HOLY SH!T!!!!!!
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
|
Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!! I am the odd man out, I don't see this as "racist". |
|
Posted 2/24/11 11:09 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!! Posted by jilliibabii Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by jilliibabii Posted by TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog I saw this on the news this morning...yes, allowed your opinion (that I don't agree with) but racist to boot! ITA! I mean I'm pro-choice, but I was ready to defend the ad since everyone is entitled to freedom of speech. But there's no excuse for the racism. What is racist about this billboard? The fact that they are singling out African Americans. "The womb is the most dangerous place for an African American"? Seriously? You're okay with that? I'm sure you're about to spout off some facts and percentages, but that doesn't make it right at all IMO. Why are you getting defensive? I asked a very simple non-inflammatory question. The ad (like ALL advertisements) is targeting a specific demographic - the one that happens to be the largest. In simple terms - reach the largest market. That's a basic advertising principle. This specific group is reaching out to black women because they are historically one of the largest groups of people to get abortions. A group that is against abortion is going to target that group because they're trying to persuade the most people from having an abortion. It has nothing specifically to do with race but rather which group has the most abortions. In this case based on the statistics (I'm sorry, I like basing my opinions on FACTS and NUMBERS - I know I'm CRAZY like that!) it's black women. Ever notice back in the day when cigarette companies could have people in their ads they were all white? There's a reason for that. Same principle here. It's not racist - it's mass marketing. Message edited 2011-02-24 11:13:11.340000. |
|
Posted 2/24/11 11:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!! Posted by VanderZwang Posted by Jennie0898 But is it an area of the city that's just in general, busy? I don't recall where in lower Manhattan the billboard is but generally speaking if you're in the city there's a huge mix of people regardless of where you are - for the most part. It was specifically put up a few blocks from a planned parenthood office. Ah, gotcha! |
|
Posted 2/24/11 11:17 AM
|
|
|
Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!! Posted by Bxgell2 I don't get it - I understand the importance of free speech, but how is it that organizations like this don't understand that this kind of message only serves to DETER people from really hearing the message, and push them more and more to the pro-choice side? When will an anti-abortion group figure out a more sensible, understandable and relatable campaign that will actually DRAW people to the message? True. I was on the fence a long time ago but I decided to be Pro-Choice instead of Anti-choice, if you will. A major factor was that I grew up in a low income neighborhood. They pushed the pro-life propaganda on us a lot. We had a LOT of teen pregnancies in our school (early 90s). Their ads were at the time using the “Bag of Babies” images. I hated them. I felt like it was pushing me to be pro-life and I didn’t like that. I felt dirty for agreeing with them. So I did more soul searching and found that honestly I have no right to tell another woman what to do with their lives or bodies. What I believe is right or wrong has nothing to do with how I should or should not dictate another person’s life. There is a middle ground which both sides agree, but neither want to talk about it. No one wants to see a child hurt. A lot of pro-choice folks do agree that 3rd term abortions are wrong and should be avoided at all costs. I only wish that both sides would agree to disagree, find a common ground and fight together. I think combined their efforts would be staggering. Instead these types of shock tactics only serve to polarize the two sides even more. I am pro-choice. I am proud of that decision. I see this billboard as another example of the extremist views from a select group from ‘the other side’. Sad, disturbing and honestly not unexpected. |
|
Posted 2/24/11 11:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!! Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by jilliibabii Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by jilliibabii Posted by TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog I saw this on the news this morning...yes, allowed your opinion (that I don't agree with) but racist to boot! ITA! I mean I'm pro-choice, but I was ready to defend the ad since everyone is entitled to freedom of speech. But there's no excuse for the racism. What is racist about this billboard? The fact that they are singling out African Americans. "The womb is the most dangerous place for an African American"? Seriously? You're okay with that? I'm sure you're about to spout off some facts and percentages, but that doesn't make it right at all IMO. Why are you getting defensive? I asked a very simple non-inflammatory question. The ad (like ALL advertisements) is targeting a specific demographic - the one that happens to be the largest. In simple terms - reach the largest market. That's a basic advertising principle. This specific group is reaching out to black women because they are historically one of the largest groups of people to get abortions. A group that is against abortion is going to target that group because they're trying to persuade the most people from having an abortion. It has nothing specifically to do with race but rather which group has the most abortions. In this case based on the statistics (I'm sorry, I like basing my opinions on FACTS and NUMBERS - I know I'm CRAZY like that!) it's black women. Ever notice back in the day when cigarette companies could have people in their ads they were all white? There's a reason for that. Same principle here. It's not racist - it's mass marketing. Like I said, singling out African American women and that's not okay with me. Sorry, I didn't mean for it to sound defensive, I was just typing a quick response. It also annoyed me a little that so many people on this thread had the same opinion as me but you singled out my response. |
|
Posted 2/24/11 11:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!! Posted by jilliibabii Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by jilliibabii Posted by Jennie0898 Posted by jilliibabii Posted by TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog I saw this on the news this morning...yes, allowed your opinion (that I don't agree with) but racist to boot! ITA! I mean I'm pro-choice, but I was ready to defend the ad since everyone is entitled to freedom of speech. But there's no excuse for the racism. What is racist about this billboard? The fact that they are singling out African Americans. "The womb is the most dangerous place for an African American"? Seriously? You're okay with that? I'm sure you're about to spout off some facts and percentages, but that doesn't make it right at all IMO. Why are you getting defensive? I asked a very simple non-inflammatory question. The ad (like ALL advertisements) is targeting a specific demographic - the one that happens to be the largest. In simple terms - reach the largest market. That's a basic advertising principle. This specific group is reaching out to black women because they are historically one of the largest groups of people to get abortions. A group that is against abortion is going to target that group because they're trying to persuade the most people from having an abortion. It has nothing specifically to do with race but rather which group has the most abortions. In this case based on the statistics (I'm sorry, I like basing my opinions on FACTS and NUMBERS - I know I'm CRAZY like that!) it's black women. Ever notice back in the day when cigarette companies could have people in their ads they were all white? There's a reason for that. Same principle here. It's not racist - it's mass marketing. Like I said, singling out African American women and that's not okay with me. Sorry, I didn't mean for it to sound defensive, I was just typing a quick response. It also annoyed me a little that so many people on this thread had the same opinion as me but you singled out my response. Would it be not racist if there was a white kid on this ad instead of a black kid? FWIW I wasn't "singling" you out. I actually quoted you and someone else and the reason I did so was because both your responses were strong. So it seemed to me you had a very real reason for feeling this way but yet neither of you mentioned why - whereas others did. I was asking for your opinion, that's all. My apologies, I was just trying understand your feelings on the issue. |
|
Posted 2/24/11 12:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!! Posted by LeShellem As a african american women and reading the article I understand what this is trying to say. I wouldn't have gotten that by just seeing the billboard alone. If people don't get the meaning behind it, which from this thread many don't, it serves no pupose. Putting up the statistics instead of what they currently have would better reach the point they are trying to convey. We are having this discussion here, but how many of those whom this poster is aimed toward is having the same discussion. This was a missed opportunity to educate people. ITA with this. Reading the statistics made me very sad and I am truly shocked. There definitely needs to be more education and information made available so that women who are forced to make this decision are fully informed about what their options are. This ad does nothing to bring light to subject and it is not aimed at the audience it is seeking to sway. |
|
Posted 2/24/11 12:38 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HOLY COW!! WOW...You are NEVER going to believe this!! | btrflygrl | 6/17/06 | 25 | Parenting |
| holy psyhco coworker!!! W T F? | raken40 | 12/9/05 | 7 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Holy Cr*p! could I BE anymore BORED!!! | BikerGrl | 11/6/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Holy c r a p! I think I am ovulating! | NS1976 | 10/29/05 | 6 | TTC |
| HOLY FOLLICLES!!!!!! UPDATE...... | Diane | 9/7/05 | 19 | Infertility |
| holy crap! I just called an oil company for a delivery | raken40 | 8/31/05 | 2 | Home |







