HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

This is disturbing. On so many levels. But these type of ads always are. I am sure this will stop the 16 yr old on her way to clinic, yes THIS is what will get through to her Chat Icon

Posted 2/23/11 9:15 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

PrincessVonTrockel
Trophy Wife in Training

Member since 11/09

2953 total posts

Name:
Natalie

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Chat Icon

Posted 2/23/11 9:45 PM
 

imagin916
LIF Adult

Member since 6/05

1826 total posts

Name:
Valerie

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

How offensive!!! Chat Icon

I'm pretty sure that women of every race have abortions, and this is not doing anything to help these women who are in the position to want an abortion.

How about putting up a phone number or website where women can call and speak to a counseler and obtain information for alternatives to abortion? I think that would reach out to these women more than offending them.

Posted 2/23/11 9:48 PM
 

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by Jillybean28

What I think is particularly disturbing is that this isn't even a highly populated multicultural neighborhood! The majority of people who live in the surrounding area are white and wealthy. If it is a statement directed to Planned Parenthood, the nearest location is 25 BLOCKS AWAY! Why put it where they did? Is this suppose to make white people come out on their white horses and preach to the inner city teens that are pregnant? It is disgustingly racist and inappropriate for a billboard. The money spent on this monstrosity could have been donated to a woman's shelter.

Where do they get their stats from anyway? I work in an alternative high school with pregnant teens and in my experience African American girls keep their babies, far out numbering any other population. Chat Icon



yeah, i work with a low income, minority population and very, very, very, rarely do we see anyone have an abortion- this ad is pure shock value

Message edited 2011-02-23 22:08:45.730000.

Posted 2/23/11 10:08 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Disgusting.

Posted 2/23/11 10:29 PM
 

KevinNKristin8-15-08
Welcome to the world Chase

Member since 9/08

6162 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by waterspout4

I am 100% Pro Life

But even this was done poorly.

I agree. I have no words. This is sick. It's not even anti-abortion, it's more racist than anything else!

Posted 2/23/11 10:34 PM
 

blondiebabyZ
Ohhhh yeaaahh!!

Member since 6/10

1033 total posts

Name:

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

guess they got something against blacks? im shocked at all the billboards that have been going up lately and the messages/images they are showing. i get free speech but kids viewing these ads just doesnt seem right.

Posted 2/24/11 12:14 AM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by Nifheim

good advertising (shock, gets attention, etc) but whatever. do african american's have a high rate of abortion? not sure but i am guessing they do with this ad and perhaps they should focus preventive measures.



These are the national numbers from abc:

AA make up 13% of the population and have 35% of the abortions performed.


ITA seems like prevention might be abetter way to go.

Posted 2/24/11 6:17 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

I don't get it - I understand the importance of free speech, but how is it that organizations like this don't understand that this kind of message only serves to DETER people from really hearing the message, and push them more and more to the pro-choice side? When will an anti-abortion group figure out a more sensible, understandable and relatable campaign that will actually DRAW people to the message?

Posted 2/24/11 8:28 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

There are many pro life groups that have decent campaigns that are not shocking or gross...I've witnessed them and loved the fact that it didn't take a disgusting image to get a point across.

And while this billboard is just poorly worded and not something that should have been used, i kind of understand the message...

A pro life AA group is troubled and saddened by the amount of AA babies being aborted.

The core of being pro life is the firm belief that life is sacred...we all get that. Those who are pro life feel DEEPLY that babies are being discarded and the life of the child isn't even a question anymore and the numbers are growing in this community. Maybe they think that by showing the face of a child, it hits home the point that those african americans who choose to abort are doing a horrible disservice to their culture.

I'm not saying I agree...I am trying to play devils advocate here.

Again..poorly worded and NOT a poster I would have chosen to get my message across. But maybe those who designed this ad felt it was sure to tug at heartstrings of the black community...

Posted 2/24/11 9:46 AM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

the billboard was meant to be provocative and stir discussion and debate - i'd say it's done it's job.

i don't understand how this ad is racist - can someone explain their point of view on this?

i think the ad is far fetched in terms of comparing an abortion to genocide but that's the drama of the ad campaign. it's meant to be far fetched to make people talk.

i don't agree with the sentiment in the least bit as i'm very pro-choice but i get it from a advertising stand point.

Posted 2/24/11 10:11 AM
 

VanderZwang
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/11

740 total posts

Name:
Gail

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by Erica

Posted by Nifheim

good advertising (shock, gets attention, etc) but whatever. do african american's have a high rate of abortion? not sure but i am guessing they do with this ad and perhaps they should focus preventive measures.



These are the national numbers from abc:

AA make up 13% of the population and have 35% of the abortions performed.


ITA seems like prevention might be abetter way to go.



Adding to this, in NYC the abortion rate is 50% AA. So of all abortions done, 50% are AA.

I am 100% pro choice and this bilboard sickens me. It puts a stigma on black women who seek out abortion (for their own reasons). NO ONE should be shamed because of a decision based on a bilboard.

Posted 2/24/11 10:14 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by VanderZwang

Posted by Erica

Posted by Nifheim

good advertising (shock, gets attention, etc) but whatever. do african american's have a high rate of abortion? not sure but i am guessing they do with this ad and perhaps they should focus preventive measures.



These are the national numbers from abc:

AA make up 13% of the population and have 35% of the abortions performed.


ITA seems like prevention might be abetter way to go.



Adding to this, in NYC the abortion rate is 50% AA. So of all abortions done, 50% are AA.

I am 100% pro choice and this bilboard sickens me. It puts a stigma on black women who seek out abortion (for their own reasons). NO ONE should be shamed because of a decision based on a bilboard.




I get what you're saying on the stigma against black women..

But what if the ad were a general pro life ad without bringing race into it? Should billboards from the pro-life community not be allowed to run because women who have an abortion might feel shamed?

Honestly, and I say this because I am pro-life...but I think similar type ads SHOULD run because many women (not all) disconnect themselves completely from what abortion actually is.

There are many young girls who don't "get it". Sure, many many women understand what an abortion is. But for others who aren't educated...and are ignorant of how far along they are, what the process does etc...maybe these ads do once in a while make a woman stop and think completely about what they are doing.

In the eyes of the pro life community, if you can show just ONE person that there are alternatives to abortion and a life is saved, then the message is worth it.

I wouldn't have gone with the approach they used here..and i would have indeed added information about alternatives to abortion, but the message is still a message.

Posted 2/24/11 10:29 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

As a african american women and reading the article I understand what this is trying to say. I wouldn't have gotten that by just seeing the billboard alone. If people don't get the meaning behind it, which from this thread many don't, it serves no pupose. Putting up the statistics instead of what they currently have would better reach the point they are trying to convey. We are having this discussion here, but how many of those whom this poster is aimed toward is having the same discussion. This was a missed opportunity to educate people.

Posted 2/24/11 10:33 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by Jennie0898

the billboard was meant to be provocative and stir discussion and debate - i'd say it's done it's job.

i don't understand how this ad is racist - can someone explain their point of view on this?

i think the ad is far fetched in terms of comparing an abortion to genocide but that's the drama of the ad campaign. it's meant to be far fetched to make people talk.

i don't agree with the sentiment in the least bit as i'm very pro-choice but i get it from a advertising stand point.




It is racist b/c people assume anything that is RACIAL is RACIST. Which is not the case with this poster.

I think the poster makes sense, although most people won't get it but will just be offended because

a. they think it is somehow racist

b. they are pro choice anyway -- and no poster is going to change that

Posted 2/24/11 10:38 AM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Jennie0898

the billboard was meant to be provocative and stir discussion and debate - i'd say it's done it's job.

i don't understand how this ad is racist - can someone explain their point of view on this?

i think the ad is far fetched in terms of comparing an abortion to genocide but that's the drama of the ad campaign. it's meant to be far fetched to make people talk.

i don't agree with the sentiment in the least bit as i'm very pro-choice but i get it from a advertising stand point.




It is racist b/c people assume anything that is RACIAL is RACIST. Which is not the case with this poster.

I think the poster makes sense, although most people won't get it but will just be offended because

a. they think it is somehow racist

b. they are pro choice anyway -- and no poster is going to change that




I agree.

And you're right about the billboard. I'm pro-choice regardless of this billboard or any other.

I'm sure it goes the same way for someone who's pro-life.

Posted 2/24/11 10:46 AM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

This is purely for shock value and media attention. This not going to help any young girl who is deciding whether or not to keep her baby.

Posted 2/24/11 10:46 AM
 

Jillybean28
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

1018 total posts

Name:
Jill

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Jennie0898

the billboard was meant to be provocative and stir discussion and debate - i'd say it's done it's job.

i don't understand how this ad is racist - can someone explain their point of view on this?

i think the ad is far fetched in terms of comparing an abortion to genocide but that's the drama of the ad campaign. it's meant to be far fetched to make people talk.

i don't agree with the sentiment in the least bit as i'm very pro-choice but i get it from a advertising stand point.





It is racist b/c people assume anything that is RACIAL is RACIST. Which is not the case with this poster.

I think the poster makes sense, although most people won't get it but will just be offended because

a. they think it is somehow racist

b. they are pro choice anyway -- and no poster is going to change that




You make a good point. For me I believe the "racist" undertones are simply about WHERE they put this. To put this in perspective, it would be like putting this ad up in West Islip when the demographic you are trying to reach is in Wyandach. I feel like they purposely misplaced this ad. There is availability for billboards in multicultural areas, where arguably this ad would be more thought provoking.
* for the record I know that the city is a melting pot, but A.A. traffic is low in this area. It also has a HUGE gay population, who don't own a uterus. Chat Icon

Posted 2/24/11 10:51 AM
 

VanderZwang
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/11

740 total posts

Name:
Gail

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by maybebaby

..

But what if the ad were a general pro life ad without bringing race into it? Should billboards from the pro-life community not be allowed to run because women who have an abortion might feel shamed?

Honestly, and I say this because I am pro-life...but I think similar type ads SHOULD run because many women (not all) disconnect themselves completely from what abortion actually is.

There are many young girls who don't "get it". Sure, many many women understand what an abortion is. But for others who aren't educated...and are ignorant of how far along they are, what the process does etc...maybe these ads do once in a while make a woman stop and think completely about what they are doing.

In the eyes of the pro life community, if you can show just ONE person that there are alternatives to abortion and a life is saved, then the message is worth it.

I wouldn't have gone with the approach they used here..and i would have indeed added information about alternatives to abortion, but the message is still a message.



This is a good point and well said. This is the first REAL explination like this I have seen. I dont disagree that women should be told about options they have.

My personal belief is that abortion MUST stay legal so women dont die. Women MUST be able to have access to clean and safe abortions so the women dont die. No matter what happens women will always seek out abortion. I see it as my job to make sure it stays legal and SAFE. I ahve no comment on the moral issue, or religous issue. I just want abortion to always be a SAFE option.

I think this message, of this bilboard, is in the most poor taste and attacks AA women. Its telling them how wrong they are for doing what is a very personal choice. The anti-abortion community that put up this add should be ashamed.

Are we talking about it? Yes. But things like this solidify my position that women MUST be protected. I am offended for the AA community this targets.

Posted 2/24/11 10:57 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog

I saw this on the news this morning...yes, allowed your opinion (that I don't agree with) but racist to boot!



ITA! I mean I'm pro-choice, but I was ready to defend the ad since everyone is entitled to freedom of speech. But there's no excuse for the racism.

Posted 2/24/11 10:59 AM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by Jillybean28

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Jennie0898

the billboard was meant to be provocative and stir discussion and debate - i'd say it's done it's job.

i don't understand how this ad is racist - can someone explain their point of view on this?

i think the ad is far fetched in terms of comparing an abortion to genocide but that's the drama of the ad campaign. it's meant to be far fetched to make people talk.

i don't agree with the sentiment in the least bit as i'm very pro-choice but i get it from a advertising stand point.





It is racist b/c people assume anything that is RACIAL is RACIST. Which is not the case with this poster.

I think the poster makes sense, although most people won't get it but will just be offended because

a. they think it is somehow racist

b. they are pro choice anyway -- and no poster is going to change that




You make a good point. For me I believe the "racist" undertones are simply about WHERE they put this. To put this in perspective, it would be like putting this ad up in West Islip when the demographic you are trying to reach is in Wyandach. I feel like they purposely misplaced this ad. There is availability for billboards in multicultural areas, where arguably this ad would be more thought provoking.
* for the record I know that the city is a melting pot, but A.A. traffic is low in this area. It also has a HUGE gay population, who don't own a uterus. Chat Icon



But is it an area of the city that's just in general, busy?

I don't recall where in lower Manhattan the billboard is but generally speaking if you're in the city there's a huge mix of people regardless of where you are - for the most part.

To compare putting up a billboard like this in WI (which is where I grew up and currently live, so I'm familiar with the area) vs. Wyandanch I think is just not a fair comparison. WI nor Wyandanch doesn't ever have the diversity that the city has. KWIM?

Posted 2/24/11 11:00 AM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog

I saw this on the news this morning...yes, allowed your opinion (that I don't agree with) but racist to boot!



ITA! I mean I'm pro-choice, but I was ready to defend the ad since everyone is entitled to freedom of speech. But there's no excuse for the racism.



What is racist about this billboard?

Posted 2/24/11 11:01 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by Jennie0898

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog

I saw this on the news this morning...yes, allowed your opinion (that I don't agree with) but racist to boot!



ITA! I mean I'm pro-choice, but I was ready to defend the ad since everyone is entitled to freedom of speech. But there's no excuse for the racism.



What is racist about this billboard?



The fact that they are singling out African Americans. "The womb is the most dangerous place for an African American"? Seriously? You're okay with that?

I'm sure you're about to spout off some facts and percentages, but that doesn't make it right at all IMO.

Posted 2/24/11 11:03 AM
 

apples99
love my sunshine..

Member since 11/08

1535 total posts

Name:
me

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

I get what they are trying to say.. . Its shocking.. yes, just like the picture of fat on top of soda but it gets your attention and it makes you think. Unfortunately, its worded in such a way that people can take it out of context.

Message edited 2011-02-24 11:06:55.293000.

Posted 2/24/11 11:04 AM
 

VanderZwang
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/11

740 total posts

Name:
Gail

Re: HOLY SH!T!!!!!!

Posted by Jennie0898


But is it an area of the city that's just in general, busy?

I don't recall where in lower Manhattan the billboard is but generally speaking if you're in the city there's a huge mix of people regardless of where you are - for the most part.




It was specifically put up a few blocks from a planned parenthood office.

Message edited 2011-02-24 11:06:28.400000.

Posted 2/24/11 11:06 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
HOLY COW!! WOW...You are NEVER going to believe this!! btrflygrl 6/17/06 25 Parenting
holy psyhco coworker!!! W T F? raken40 12/9/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
Holy Cr*p! could I BE anymore BORED!!! BikerGrl 11/6/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Holy c r a p! I think I am ovulating! NS1976 10/29/05 6 TTC
HOLY FOLLICLES!!!!!! UPDATE...... Diane 9/7/05 19 Infertility
holy crap! I just called an oil company for a delivery raken40 8/31/05 2 Home