for those that split the holidays...

Posted By Message

jacksmom09
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/10

687 total posts

Name:

for those that split the holidays...

Sorry for this early post, but it always takes DH and I so long to figure out where we will spend the holidays each year- Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

we travel to NY and our whole family is on LI. We would really love to host a holiday here (in ct) and have Easter here every year and invite everyone, but no one comes.

Just tired of traveling (now with 2 kids) and I feel like something has to change. For xmas, my DH sibling and his whole family visit for at least a week after the holiday, but MIL always says she wants us around for the actual holiday. Last year we did not come down for Thanksgiving bc my youngest was 3 months. People aren't flexible though!

Just curious, How do you split if you travel? Is it selfish of us to want to spend xmas morning in our own home? If you made a major change like this, how did you handle the family reaction?

TIA! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2014-09-29 16:13:26.693000.

Posted 9/29/14 4:12 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

for those that split the holidays...

Our families are pretty close to us (5 mins and 30 mins), but as soon as we had kids, we made it clear that we would NOT be travelling on Christmas Day. I remember spending EVERY Christmas in the car to NJ growing up and it wasn't fair that we didn't get to enjoy the day.

We get together with one side on Xmas Eve, and the other side the weekend before/after Christmas. I'm sure they're not thrilled, but they deal with it.

And TBH, I never want to host, but the fact that you try to host a holiday and nobody comes is rude. Why should you spend your day in the car if they don't want to??

Posted 9/29/14 4:17 PM
 

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

for those that split the holidays...

We are hosting thanksgiving for the first time, for both our families. The past number of years we have gone to my in-laws' house in Maine, which is a 6 hr drive. I wanted to see my fam for thanksgiving so we decided to host as a compromise. I would just say "I am hosting this year, we would love for you to come, and I would like to rotate hosting in the future." As someone else said, why should you spend the day in the car if others are not willing to?

Posted 9/29/14 4:27 PM
 

cheryl28
LIF Adult

Member since 2/10

4657 total posts

Name:

Re: for those that split the holidays...

our whole family is on LI. We are about 1 1/2 hours away. We mostly travel for holidays. We DO NOT travel for fathers or mothers day anymore. It becomes to much. I hate this time of year b/c between the holidays, we have a ton of bdays, and parties. We travel every other weekend from now until Jan. It's so hard.

No it is not selfish of you to do Xmas morning at home. We do that now that we are closer. We were in Utah and Boston for 4 years so we would do it at my inlaws.

2 years ago, was awful. My mom likes to do a "christmas morning" at her house with my nieces and nephews. Well 2 years, we had an issue at home and couldn't make in time but they went ahead and did it without us. My little baby at the time, had to open all by herself. I was so sad for her. She was little so it didn't matter to her but it did to me. Well, anyway last year I made it clear they had to wait. So my point is make sure you have it planned out and let everyone know your plans.

We usually host Christmas Eve for my Inlaws. they we wake up do Xmas morning and head to my side XMas day, then go to his aunt's later that night (same town).

I flat out told my mom, who was very set in her ways about Xmas morning, she had to change. It wasn't fair to us and now with 2 kids, I want to enjoy Santa in my own home. She was surprisingly ok with that lol.

I completely understand no one coming to you. We are in CT too, and we joke that people from LI can't cross the bridge. They can drive 1 1/2 hours to go shopping in river head but can't drove north over a bridge lol My inlaws are pretty good about but it's still a huge plan ahead to come here. We can never just call Sat morning and say come on up.

They way I see it, our families had to adjust or they will not see us. Remind them how they felt when you were little and doing Xmas morning. It' s so hard. I gave up on inviting people. If they say hey we want to come, great come on up, but I tend to not invite, unless a party, b/c it's like a space shuttle launch. lol

Anyway, in the ramble I hope I helped you out, lol

Posted 9/29/14 4:29 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: for those that split the holidays...

Posted by Katareen

Our families are pretty close to us (5 mins and 30 mins), but as soon as we had kids, we made it clear that we would NOT be travelling on Christmas Day. I remember spending EVERY Christmas in the car to NJ growing up and it wasn't fair that we didn't get to enjoy the day.

We get together with one side on Xmas Eve, and the other side the weekend before/after Christmas. I'm sure they're not thrilled, but they deal with it.

And TBH, I never want to host, but the fact that you try to host a holiday and nobody comes is rude. Why should you spend your day in the car if they don't want to??



This is what we do - unfortunately, it means I have to host my DH's side EVERY FREAKING year - BUT, it also means I get to keep my Christmas Day free of their last minutes maybe we will/maybe we won't plans - it's also easier for me b/c DH's parents are divorced, and my hosting avoids having to split the holidays in 3!

Posted 9/29/14 4:30 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

for those that split the holidays...

We had to lay down some rules when we had kids.

Thanksgiving we spend with my MIL which will probably not happen this year since I refuse to spend any time with her. So we will probably do FIL's

Christmas we used to run between 3 sets of parents and now I refuse. We do Xmas eve at my FILs and then Christmas at our house and who ever wants to come can or not but I am not running all around the world to please others. I have my own little family now and that became my priority.

Posted 9/29/14 4:38 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: for those that split the holidays...

Posted by alli3131

We had to lay down some rules when we had kids.

Thanksgiving we spend with my MIL which will probably not happen this year since I refuse to spend any time with her. So we will probably do FIL's

Christmas we used to run between 3 sets of parents and now I refuse. We do Xmas eve at my FILs and then Christmas at our house and who ever wants to come can or not but I am not running all around the world to please others. I have my own little family now and that became my priority.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/29/14 4:47 PM
 

PatsBrat
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

2326 total posts

Name:
Ms. Brat

Re: for those that split the holidays...

One day I just decided I had enough. I sent out an email (and followed up with phone calls) saying we had decided to stay home for Christmas and that they were all welcome to join us. Some people came and some didn't, but it was their choice. We stay home every year now. Sometimes we have a big crowd and sometimes it's just us, but we ALWAYS enjoy the day.

PS we ignore all guilt trippers and whiners. Chat Icon

Message edited 2014-09-29 18:29:52.617000.

Posted 9/29/14 6:29 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

for those that split the holidays...

If I were you, I would drive to NY for Thanksgiving, spend CT as just your dh and kids, and drive to NY the following weekend... No way would I would that big drive for Christmas.

Posted 9/29/14 6:54 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: for those that split the holidays...

My upstate family comes to us and stays a few days since DS was born.

My ILs do Italian Christmas eve a few towns over, I do brunch in the am on Christmas for whoever wants to join and dinner for my family and close friends who have drama with their family.

Thanksgiving is generally at my parents house and the three of us go.

Posted 9/29/14 7:29 PM
 

PitterPatter11
Baby Boy is Here!

Member since 5/11

7635 total posts

Name:
Momma <3

for those that split the holidays...

We do Thanksgiving at my ILs and Christmas at my parents. Since DS is young, we'll probably do this for a few more years and then reevaluate. We stay over for 3-4 days.

Posted 9/29/14 7:53 PM
 

PregowithTwins
My boys turned 8

Member since 5/11

2451 total posts

Name:

for those that split the holidays...

I agree. I want to be home for Christmas. The family needs to get over it. They will adjust, tell them to come to you.

Posted 9/29/14 8:53 PM
 

JSDB
<3

Member since 1/13

1329 total posts

Name:

Re: for those that split the holidays...

We have it somewhat easier bc I am Jewish and dh is not but ILs live OOS which adds a wrinkle. We spend every thanksgiving with my family - it's my moms big holiday to host. We fly OOS to spend Xmas with my inlaws every year (except this year, we will have an appx 10 week old). We invited people to come to us but they aren't coming for Xmas, a few are planning visits other times. We host a small Chanukah at our house. If I was you I would want the no travel on Xmas rule, or at least no travel until noon.

Posted 9/29/14 9:05 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: for those that split the holidays...

We host Thanksgiving and both families come here. Christmas Eve is with DH family. Christmas morning we open presents and relax in the morning and then go to my moms for lunch. Oh, and did I mention that my mom is Jewish.Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/29/14 9:51 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: for those that split the holidays...

DH and I (no kids) have recently cut down on going to visit family for holidays. Every other year we were flying to Australia or NY (we are in Germany) and it got to be too much. We would fly there, then I would wind up cooking at my mom's or MIL's.

One year we decided to do a safari vacation and it was really relaxing. From then on, we decided to just do our own thing for Xmas and visit at other times of the year when it was less hectic. Or they could come visit us. After 8 years of traveling and holidays, I got really sick of people not even making an effort to visit us, let alone call us. I know Germany is far, but a phone call would be nice...

Posted 9/30/14 5:17 AM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: for those that split the holidays...

My in laws are in NJ and refuse, I mean REFUSE to come to NY. So I refuse to do Christmas with them. They usually get either Easter or Thanksgiving. My in laws are divorced. My FIL gets mad that he "only gets one holiday." But, my MIL gets the other. So DH's family gets two holidays IMO. Don't get divorced if you are going to complain about the holiday splits.

Sorry... I get worked up about this. Chat Icon

Posted 9/30/14 8:14 AM
 

Mrs&MrsK
i need sleep ;-)

Member since 2/14

2008 total posts

Name:
L

for those that split the holidays...

we are on LI and so are our families but decided after we got married (last year) to alternate holidays instead of breaking up the actual day and driving between houses because that was NOT working out--

Thanksgiving & Easter - switch off each family. 30 - 40 mins away
Christmas Eve- my mom does this holiday so we do this every year -45 mins away
Christmas Day- DW's family has kids so we do this @ their house. it's only 10-15 mins away

We are definitely going to have our own christmas morning once LO is born!!

Message edited 2014-09-30 09:13:10.757000.

Posted 9/30/14 9:12 AM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

for those that split the holidays...

We host christmas eve. We spend Christmas in the car though. It is ridiculous. His family is out east (and Jewish?) my family is in Western Nassau and Brooklyn.

7am wake up and get ready
8am drive out east
9am-12am Bagels at his cousin's house and their kids open presents
12-1pm drive back west
1pm - 3pm - appetizers at his aunt's house
3:pm-3:30pm - Drive south to my mom's side
3:30-6:30pm - Dinner, presents
6:30-7:30 - Drive to brooklyn
7:30-9:00pm Dessert, presents at my dad's side
9:00-10:00pm Head home

Im PG this year and I told my DH from the get-go once I get pg, Jewish Christmas ends. His family is more than welcome to come to our house or my mother's house though!


Posted 9/30/14 9:19 AM
 

jams92

Member since 1/12

6105 total posts

Name:

for those that split the holidays...

you have to do what is best for you
we used to go to Dh family that was 1.5 hours away from us for Christmas eve. it got too much last year as we had one child and one on the way. we decided to host and if people came, great. if not, their loss.
I would tell your family it is too much for you to do and offer to host. hopefully people join you, but if not, just enjoy the time with your kids

Posted 9/30/14 9:28 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How do you split up the holidays with family? NoStressMom 10/18/11 33 Parenting
We really need to figure out how to split these holidays. Shorty 11/23/06 21 Families Helping Families ™
Holidays with family how do you split it? Lillykat 10/19/09 8 Parenting
How do you split holidays?? GoingNutty 11/9/06 36 Families Helping Families ™
With whose side do you celebrate holidays more? aimerliny 5/12/05 35 Families Helping Families ™