For breastfeeding/pumping moms

Posted By Message

zoe282
We have our miracle!

Member since 8/08

3634 total posts

Name:
Jen

For breastfeeding/pumping moms

Hey there..I'm crashing from the pregnancy board.

Baby is almost here and I'm thinking ahead to the breast pump...

I registered for the Medela Pump in style but didn't get it...any lactation person has told me that it's TOTALLY worth the price tag. And that it's pointless to go with anything else. But at $279..I wonder is it worth buying, or if there are other pumps just as good.

My friend has a pump (not sure which one) that is much less and likes it. But should I just go with the Medela?

What do you think?

Posted 11/12/10 9:26 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

newroctransplant
LIF Infant

Member since 2/09

173 total posts

Name:

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I have been bfing/pumping for 4 months.

In the weeks before the baby was due i could not bring myself to pay for a medela double pump so I bought another brand pump.

As I got closer to going to work the pump I was using on leave was proving to be a bit bulky so I bought the medela swing pump and LOVED it! Wish I would have bought it right away.

Recently the bag I had my medela pump in was mistakenly taken from my pumping room at work (long story). I freaked out and bought the freestyle pump and honestly wish I would have bought it from the beginning! I had problems pumping early on (didnt feel like I produced enough milk) but I think it was the pump. I have even tried pumping with my old pump and I don't get anywhere near as much milk as I do with the swing or freestyle.

I bought mine from BBB and they took the 20% coupon so I saved a few bucks. HTH!

Posted 11/12/10 9:31 AM
 

diggity10
I love my little brother

Member since 6/07

1747 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I have the Medela Freestyle which is more $ but totally worth it. My SIL has the Pump in Style and loves it. IMO I would wait until after you have the baby to buy it and rent a pump for the first few weeks just to make sure you like it and BF'ing is going well. I know some LC's don't recommend pumping until after 2 weeks of BF'ing.

Posted 11/12/10 9:31 AM
 

melbalalala
Little Lady

Member since 5/07

5015 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I have nothing to compare it to but I love my Pump N Style... other than DD, it's the thing I spend most of my day with Chat Icon

And I have to disagree with Ms. Diggity above <even though she's been SO helpful to me in all of the pumping posts I write Chat Icon > I would buy it and keep the receipt and return it if BFing doesnt work for you. I wouldn't rent a pump because that's more money for you to spend that you could have put towards a high quality pump

Message edited 2010-11-12 09:44:15.277000.

Posted 11/12/10 9:41 AM
 

melbalalala
Little Lady

Member since 5/07

5015 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

Double post

Message edited 2010-11-12 09:44:06.620000.

Posted 11/12/10 9:43 AM
 

azoodie

Member since 8/05

8377 total posts

Name:
Team SEXY BACK

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

Posted by diggity10

I have the Medela Freestyle which is more $ but totally worth it. My SIL has the Pump in Style and loves it. IMO I would wait until after you have the baby to buy it and rent a pump for the first few weeks just to make sure you like it and BF'ing is going well. I know some LC's don't recommend pumping until after 2 weeks of BF'ing.



I have the freestyle too and love it! Am pumping at work as I type this Chat Icon Chat Icon

I would get the medela PIS and hold onto it. Like pp said, my midwife didn't recommend me starting to pump until about 4 weeks after DS was born. You can see how breastfeeding is going and then decide if you want to continue with pumping.

Did you check with your insurance? I got mine free through mine. There is a locked thread on the pregnancy board you can check out. Also if you go to BBB you can use the 20% coupon which also helps a bit.

Good luck!!

Posted 11/12/10 9:44 AM
 

snowprincess
My happy babies

Member since 3/06

3428 total posts

Name:

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I agree buy one now but don't open and save the recipt - i have hte freestyle and love it - my mom had to run out and get mine because my ds had latching problems the first 2 weeks so pumped mostly then

definetly cehck with insutrance too - and check after the baby is born at the hospital with the lacation specialist- see if she know a way to get from isurance

we used a 20% off coupon at Buybuy baby

Posted 11/12/10 9:52 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I agree with melbalalalalalalalalala
I spend a LOT of time with my pump

Pumping in a few minutes at work actually LOL
I would go for the Freestyle , I have the PIS and love it but the Freestyle looks so much cooler!


But definitely worth the money!

Posted 11/12/10 9:54 AM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I have the Ameda Purely Yours and I love it. I think it is defin cheaper than the Medela and better rated. The hospital where my dd was born suggested it. I think the only difference is you dont have to wash the tubes on the Ameda. It can also run on batteries and has a car charger. That has come in very handy! You cant buy the pump in stores have to order online but i have seen all the accesories and replacement parts in BRU. It might better to rent a hospital pump first instead of spending all that money. Pretty cheap to rent a pump for a few weeks and they are much better at helping establish a supply. I wonder why the lc didnt suggest that for you? FM me if you have any questions.

Posted 11/12/10 10:02 AM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I have the Pump in Style and loved it I nursed and pumped for a 2 whole years 1 year for each child! Never had a problem...kept my supply good and gave me many oz for bottles! I def recommend medela

Posted 11/12/10 10:06 AM
 

shapla79
Where Does The Time Go?

Member since 11/07

4619 total posts

Name:

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I rented a pump from the hospital first to make sure that BFing/pumping was going to work out for me. When I was sure, then I purchased a Medela (totally worth the money). I had a PISA with my first baby and then added the Freestyle with my second baby.

If you can, get the Medela Freestyle. It's very convenient. The pump fit in my handbag and nobody knew I had it when I was out in the city. The digital display makes life easier since you don't have to watch a clock when pumping. Mindy, an LC in Texas, sold me a brand new Freestyle for about the same price as a pump in style and I didn't have to pay taxes. It saved us sooo much! She's an authorized Medela dealer:

Link

You have to call or e-mail her to place the order because she's not allowed to post her price on the site. I had no problems working with her and she's really nice!

Posted 11/12/10 10:09 AM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I have the Ameda Purely Yours and I love it. I think it is defin cheaper than the Medela and better rated. The hospital where my dd was born suggested it. I think the only difference is you dont have to wash the tubes on the Ameda. It can also run on batteries and has a car charger. That has come in very handy! You cant buy the pump in stores have to order online but i have seen all the accesories and replacement parts in BRU. It might better to rent a hospital pump first instead of spending all that money. Pretty cheap to rent a pump for a few weeks and they are much better at helping establish a supply. I wonder why the lc didnt suggest that for you? FM me if you have any questions.

Posted 11/12/10 11:50 AM
 

alisha
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

1199 total posts

Name:

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I have the Avent ISIS Duo (about the same price as the PIS) and I love it. The suction is terrific and I never get milk in the tubes.

I also have the Medela Freestyle for when I travel for work b/c it is tiny (off Craigslist NIB $200) and while I love how portable it is, I am dissapointed with the suction. My breasts always feel full even after I pump. I also am very busty (DDD) so if you aren't very busty, it may work better for you.

Message edited 2010-11-12 12:41:14.127000.

Posted 11/12/10 12:26 PM
 

mommyin09
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1007 total posts

Name:

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I have the Medela in style and I liked it a lot. It is very convenient to take with you anywhere.

Posted 11/12/10 12:30 PM
 

Babylove10
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/10

814 total posts

Name:
Doreen

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

i have the first years pump (electric) it was only 60 bucks and it does the job. It comes with alittle brown and blue bag and its very portable. The only down side is you have to hold it i'm not sure if its the same with every pump.

Message edited 2010-11-12 12:36:34.503000.

Posted 11/12/10 12:34 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

Posted by MrsB0118

I have the Ameda Purely Yours and I love it. I think it is defin cheaper than the Medela and better rated. The hospital where my dd was born suggested it. I think the only difference is you dont have to wash the tubes on the Ameda. It can also run on batteries and has a car charger. That has come in very handy! You cant buy the pump in stores have to order online but i have seen all the accesories and replacement parts in BRU. It might better to rent a hospital pump first instead of spending all that money. Pretty cheap to rent a pump for a few weeks and they are much better at helping establish a supply. I wonder why the lc didnt suggest that for you? FM me if you have any questions.



ditto, word for word. not having to wash the tubes is huge.

Posted 11/12/10 1:17 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

I am supposed to be washing the tubes of my Medela? Chat Icon

Posted 11/12/10 1:21 PM
 

LML
Twins!

Member since 10/09

1320 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

Posted by Cpt2007

Posted by MrsB0118

I have the Ameda Purely Yours and I love it. I think it is defin cheaper than the Medela and better rated. The hospital where my dd was born suggested it. I think the only difference is you dont have to wash the tubes on the Ameda. It can also run on batteries and has a car charger. That has come in very handy! You cant buy the pump in stores have to order online but i have seen all the accesories and replacement parts in BRU. It might better to rent a hospital pump first instead of spending all that money. Pretty cheap to rent a pump for a few weeks and they are much better at helping establish a supply. I wonder why the lc didnt suggest that for you? FM me if you have any questions.



ditto, word for word. not having to wash the tubes is huge.



I've never had to wash the tubes on my pump in style. You'd only need to do that if milk got in them and I can't imagine how that would happen. The one benefit of the medela is that the parts are easier to find than ameda. This was a big plus when I went away for 4 days and realized that I forgot the pump parts after I got there.

Posted 11/12/10 1:33 PM
 

jerseychick
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3923 total posts

Name:

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

Posted by Tilde

I am supposed to be washing the tubes of my Medela? Chat Icon



I don't think so! I don't. Not sure why you would...milk doesn't go through them. I thought they were just for suction Chat Icon

ETA: To answer your question...I am a fan of the Pump In Style. I have one that is 5 years old, and has gone through 3 kids, and it still gets the job done quickly. However, its hard to compare because this is the only pump I've ever had.

Message edited 2010-11-12 13:49:52.490000.

Posted 11/12/10 1:37 PM
 

shapla79
Where Does The Time Go?

Member since 11/07

4619 total posts

Name:

Re: For breastfeeding/pumping moms

Posted by jerseychick

Posted by Tilde

I am supposed to be washing the tubes of my Medela? Chat Icon



I don't think so! I don't. Not sure why you would...milk doesn't go through them. I thought they were just for suction Chat Icon



With my PISA, my milk overshot and got in the tubes. It rarely happened, and I always kept an extra set of tubes in my backpack just in case. I never had that issue with my Freestyle though. The tubes were never washed, simply replaced if anything happened to them.

Posted 11/12/10 1:48 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Breastfeeding/pumping moms? janedoe 8/9/10 5 Parenting
Breastfeeding/Pumping moms - help smiles 11/27/07 8 Parenting
best bottle for breastfeeding moms? Ali 11/11/05 5 Parenting
Pumping moms - jcndd 10/21/05 6 Parenting
Pumping Moms-How do you warm your breastmilk? monkeybride 10/20/05 10 Parenting
? for breastfeeding moms MrsBumbleb 9/6/05 10 Parenting