English vs Spanish language

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

whatalife24
LIF Infant

Member since 5/10

151 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

English vs Spanish language

Why do you think it is that there is such an issue with Spanish being offered as another language option in places?

My thinking is that it is more a problem with those that come to this country with no intention of learning English at all or melt into that 'melting pot' and need a Spanish option because they can't speak a sentence of English after decades in this country.

I don't think there's as much issue with those who are just more comfortable in their native language.

Thoughts?

Posted 2/16/12 9:25 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: English vs Spanish language

Honestly it's racism at it's best. People will come up with a million excuses on why everyone should speak English, but what it boils down to is pure racism.

Posted 2/16/12 9:40 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: English vs Spanish language

I agree with the melting pot idea. You come to this country and decades later you haven't attempted to learn the language? Really? Most other countries don't bow down as much as we do.

My father and mother both hispanic and come from long lines of spanish speaking families. Everyone in the family speaks Spanish first. With the exception of two. Me and my brother. Why? "Because we didn't want you to have that spanish accent and be a second class citizen" Ironic since now I won't speak it because I feel uncomfortable with it.

My uncle (my aunt's husband) is from Mexico. He used to constantly tell me I *need* to speak spanish. He said it to me all the time when I moved back to Texas. I would brush it off, small talk or laught it away but finally I had enough.

"Why should I speak Spanish? I'm American and English is my language. Why don't YOU speak English?"

He pushed me some more and I pushed back. He's lived in this country for nearly 30yrs and yet hasn't become a citizen because he's afraid of the english language on the test. Well buddy, suck it up or shut up. He's been here LONG enough in my opinion. He's now waiting for a 'grandfather' type act that allows him to take the test in Spanish. Chat Icon So much for acclimating and becoming part of this country, huh?

Otherwise, I do think this man is a prime example of how it should work. He came to this country with nothing but came here legally. He has worked his butt to the bone. He's 50yrs old and still works 6 days out of 7 and 5 of those days he works two jobs. He is more physically fit than any 50yr old man *I* know and he hasn't ever taken any assistance in anyway. He pride prevents it. He's careful with his money and always pays cash for things. He lives within his means and believes that most of the Mexicans here are cry babies.

He has been my biggest eye opener to the whole issue. Though I may not agree with everything. Even HE thinks you must learn English. He knows it, he speaks it and writes it (very little).

He finally stopped harassing me about Spanish and I won't harass him about English.

Sorry got carried away. Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-02-16 10:33:45.720000.

Posted 2/16/12 9:55 AM
 

JoesWife628
Our family is complete :)

Member since 8/08

3934 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: English vs Spanish language

I don't think it's racism at all. I believe it's a combination of things. For example, the fact that our society still have an existing generation of first generation European Americans. I know my grandparents came from Italy and had to learn English. And they wanted to. In their eyes, it made them "true Americans," which is what they wanted, thus the reason they immigrated. And it wasn't a Second, we are a generation of speed and convenience. It is time consuming. Examples: being on an autommated phone call and hearing options in both English and Spanish, reading signs or directions that are written in both languages, even the language barrier I've experienced most recently: being in DD and having to repeat myself four times to get an iced coffee with skim, yet still received regular milk. I do realize it is a huge help for those who do speak Spanish, but what about those who came to America fron other places? Wht aren't signs and autommated messages in Chinese as well? A melting pot is a beautiful thing, however it does have its shortcomings in regards to language/communication.

Message edited 2012-02-16 09:58:43.877000.

Posted 2/16/12 9:56 AM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: English vs Spanish language

Are you talking about another language option or the only language option. I don't have a problem with it being another option, but if it is the only option, I won't be shopping there because I won't know what is being said. I don't think that is racist though.

Posted 2/16/12 9:56 AM
 

whatalife24
LIF Infant

Member since 5/10

151 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: English vs Spanish language

Posted by SlurpeeDad

Are you talking about another language option or the only language option. I don't have a problem with it being another option, but if it is the only option, I won't be shopping there because I won't know what is being said. I don't think that is racist though.




My thought was with Spanish as a second option

Posted 2/16/12 10:07 AM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: English vs Spanish language

I don't care if signs are in both languages or if I have to press 1 for English. But if you are in the service industry and deal with the public, know English backwards and forwards and speak it clear, and don't get frustrated with ME if you don't, and I kindly ask you 3 times to repeat yourself.

Posted 2/16/12 10:07 AM
 

springchick
make a wish

Member since 5/08

3566 total posts

Name:
justask

Re: English vs Spanish language

I think is a combination of things;
I feel like hispanic have it "easy" in some way because they come here and have the option everywhere to get service in spanish, so why learn english? For example if an Italian or French speaking person immigrate to this country they have to learn the language because they dont have a choice. By offering Spanish option I feel that they are enabling latinos to no wanting to learn.

2nd for a Hispanic person language is a big part of their culture as religion so is kind of giving away your culture in some sense.

3rd a lot of people that immigrate are older generations that they are either stuborn to learn new things and/or is harder to learn a second language.

4th. The hispanic community is sooo big and when someone come to this country most likely move to a town or community full of other hispanics so they work and live with other people talking to them in spanish

Regarding americans learning spanish.. I feel that everyone should learn a second and third language speacially americans this is a country that do business with the world and people from all over the world come to this country and is nice to have the option to talk to and learn about other cultures.

Sign- The Latina that immigrate to this country already knowing the language and plan to raise my kids with both languages.

Posted 2/16/12 10:23 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: English vs Spanish language

It doesn't bother me that so many places offer a second language option. I DO think that we should have an official language, but more for unity and ease of communication than because I don't like having to press "1" for English.

But, I think that this is a two way street. I think most Americans are so wrapped up in themselves that even when visiting other countries, we expect them to cater to us and speak English. I'm not saying ALL Americans are this way, but I feel like we are worse than most countries/cultures in that respect.

Posted 2/16/12 10:27 AM
 

july4mrsO
Happy boy!

Member since 5/10

2867 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: English vs Spanish language

Posted by LeShellem

Honestly it's racism at it's best. People will come up with a million excuses on why everyone should speak English, but what it boils down to is pure racism.




Chat Icon ITA

Posted 2/16/12 10:31 AM
 

whatalife24
LIF Infant

Member since 5/10

151 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: English vs Spanish language

From my point of view, I just couldnt imagine moving to another country with no intention of learning their language and being able to communicate with the general population. I couldnt live somewhere else hoping that they will have a way tofigure out what I'm saying

Posted 2/16/12 10:57 AM
 

KaKa2323
Got my miracle

Member since 9/11

1465 total posts

Name:
K

Re: English vs Spanish language

I'm not sure how that could be considered racist? The language of American is English. I think it is nice that there are options for spanish for people who maybe just moved here and are trying to establish a life here, but on the other hand people come to America from all over the world, yet we are only catering to one language. So if we are racist against anyone it would be people who speak other languages besides English or Spanish. If I moved to another country I would absolutely learn their language and not expect people to cater to me

Posted 2/16/12 11:08 AM
 

ModDot
PUMPKIN ALL THE THINGS

Member since 8/11

2196 total posts

Name:
Trissy

Re: English vs Spanish language

Posted by cncforever

I don't care if signs are in both languages or if I have to press 1 for English. But if you are in the service industry and deal with the public, know English backwards and forwards and speak it clear, and don't get frustrated with ME if you don't, and I kindly ask you 3 times to repeat yourself.



Chat Icon

This bugs me to no end with the service type industries where you have to call on the phone. It's either farmed out over seas (in that case it's not really their fault) Or it's here, and they can't speak clearly. This is also not a Spanish thing, there are also those people who talk like they have marbles in their mouth. WHY WOULD YOU PUT SOMEONE LIKE THAT ON THE PHONE!!!

sorry, it just annoys me and them when I have to say "can you repeat that, I'm sorry I didn't understand"

Posted 2/16/12 11:18 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: English vs Spanish language

Didn't we do this yesterday?I do think it comes down to racism. (the original poster yesterday was asking a question because she wasn't originally from the US so in her case, I don't think it the racism label applies).

ENGLISH IS NOT THE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE OF THE US.

The government offers forms in multiple languages. We are a melting pot & if we are to remain a melting pot, we accept other cultures & languages in the US.

I think people being irked by language options other than English is ridiculous. English is always press #1, it's not like you have to listen to the automated voice count through every language & English is last.



Posted 2/16/12 11:21 AM
 

ModDot
PUMPKIN ALL THE THINGS

Member since 8/11

2196 total posts

Name:
Trissy

Re: English vs Spanish language

Posted by nrthshgrl

Didn't we do this yesterday?I do think it comes down to racism. (the original poster yesterday was asking a question because she wasn't originally from the US so in her case, I don't think it the racism label applies).

ENGLISH IS NOT THE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE OF THE US.

The government offers forms in multiple languages. We are a melting pot & if we are to remain a melting pot, we accept other cultures & languages in the US.

I think people being irked by language options other than English is ridiculous. English is always press #1, it's not like you have to listen to the automated voice count through every language & English is last.






We're NOT a melting pot if we become individuals and don't form one country. Haven't you heard the term "Salad Bowl", this is the term they are using to refer to America now, because we are still separate. If we were a melting pot as we used to be, everyone would assimilate.

Posted 2/16/12 11:27 AM
 

LotsaLuv
Us

Member since 6/10

4094 total posts

Name:
F

Re: English vs Spanish language

I don't have a problem with the language at all, I think it's great to be able to speak multiple languanges

BUT when the predominant language of the country is English and there is a huge communication barrier whether you speak only spanish or only hungarian, it's an issue.

In most careers, you have to be able to speak English to get by, not all, but most, so what do you do if you can't? Work a minimum wage job, and struggle to support your family?

I think for the benefit of everyone the USA should mandate a predominant language like most other countries do, this way equal opportunity is greater.

Posted 2/16/12 11:27 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: English vs Spanish language

Posted by retrochick

Posted by nrthshgrl

Didn't we do this yesterday?I do think it comes down to racism. (the original poster yesterday was asking a question because she wasn't originally from the US so in her case, I don't think it the racism label applies).

ENGLISH IS NOT THE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE OF THE US.

The government offers forms in multiple languages. We are a melting pot & if we are to remain a melting pot, we accept other cultures & languages in the US.

I think people being irked by language options other than English is ridiculous. English is always press #1, it's not like you have to listen to the automated voice count through every language & English is last.






We're NOT a melting pot if we become individuals and don't form one country. Haven't you heard the term "Salad Bowl", this is the term they are using to refer to America now, because we are still separate. If we were a melting pot as we used to be, everyone would assimilate.



I haven't heard the term Salad, I have heard of tossing salad though. But I agree that salad is better terminology.

Posted 2/16/12 12:15 PM
 

AScottWolf
I <3 our squish!

Member since 11/10

2237 total posts

Name:
Adriana

Re: English vs Spanish language

Gotta be honest, I think down the road English will no longer be the primary language in America, Spanish will.

Just like at some point the majority of Americans will be of mixed race.

I have very mixed feelings about this. One one hand yes, I think that having things translated into other language is a great help for many. There are immigrants who are trying there best to learn English because as in the past, it's still an accomplishment for them. But not everyone has that mentality anymore. One the other hand, I do think that all of these translations enable people and give them reasons to not learn English.

It's the same thing as public assistance. It's there to help people. I think it's a great thing and does help a lot of good families. But, it shouldn't be a permanent form of income for people and it is for many.

All I know is that most, if not all of our children (and future children in my case), are going to need to be bilingual in order to compete with everyone else.

Posted 2/16/12 2:03 PM
 

emilylives
biking

Member since 12/09

2163 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: English vs Spanish language

As English speakers, we can travel almost anywhere in the world and be okay, because most places people speak English and there are English options for the vast majority of things (menus, signs, call-in numbers, etc.). So considering how much we benefit from these options in other countries I can't really see how we can complain about offering another language option in our country.

Posted 2/16/12 2:16 PM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: English vs Spanish language

I just don't understand when bilingualism, multilingualism, or the option of them at the very least, became a bad thing.

My ILs are South American immigrants, both citizens now for more than 30 years. They speak English completely fluently, however when provided with the option still prefer to speak in Spanish if it is available to them. MILs mother (so DH's grandmother) is also a citizen, however she moved here later in life, during an era when women did not really work outside the home, and did not have as many opportunities to learn English as well as her husband or children. It is embarrassing for her and she benefits from a Spanish language option to ease her discomfort with her own difficulties with the nuances of the English language.

In my own (vast) experience with the immigration system in this country, as well as numerous other government agencies, multiple language options are often provided to assist people who may be learning English or may be more comfortable conducting important, official business in their first language regardless of their comfort with English. I have NO idea why or how this is considered a bad thing.

Posted 2/16/12 2:36 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: English vs Spanish language

I missed yesterday's argument, but I do think it's important to repeat that the US does not have an official language.


I'm not sure that racism is the exact right word, but the concept is correct. DH is ESL but you would NEVER know it. He only speaks Spanish to his mother/family. While he is technically caucasian (why I can't label this racism, maybe ethnocentrism?), he has had some downright NASTY things said to him when he is in public and talking on the phone with his mother in Spanish. It has never happened when he is on the phone speaking English.

Posted 2/16/12 3:27 PM
 

TripletMom
My crazy Trio

Member since 3/09

2246 total posts

Name:
Paula

Re: English vs Spanish language

Posted by cncforever

I don't care if signs are in both languages or if I have to press 1 for English. But if you are in the service industry and deal with the public, know English backwards and forwards and speak it clear, and don't get frustrated with ME if you don't, and I kindly ask you 3 times to repeat yourself.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/16/12 3:35 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Re: English vs Spanish language

honestly, my grandmother came here from Europe at 16 because she refused to get married there. She went to work as a nanny/housekeeper and learned how to speak
English by picking up an object in the house and asking them what it was.....

She came to American knowing that while there wasn't an "official" language, English was the language spoken. I still don't understand why it hasn't been made an official language as it would help make the country more unified and less "salad" like.

an another think I don't understand. If you press 1 for English, 2 for Spanish... Why draw the line there? Why not 3 for German, 4 for French, 5 for Italian, 6 for Czechoslovakian( the only language my grandmother knew when she came to America)

Message edited 2012-02-16 20:32:41.203000.

Posted 2/16/12 8:29 PM
 

MrsM429
Mama x2 <3

Member since 12/10

4946 total posts

Name:

Re: English vs Spanish language

Posted by whatalife24

From my point of view, I just couldnt imagine moving to another country with no intention of learning their language and being able to communicate with the general population. I couldnt live somewhere else hoping that they will have a way tofigure out what I'm saying



Chat Icon

Posted 2/16/12 8:38 PM
 

maybemommy10
Big Brothers to Be !

Member since 2/10

3868 total posts

Name:

Re: English vs Spanish language

It may not be official, but 80+% speak English in the USA. Soooo my thinking is if they want a JOB or equal opportunity they would WANT to speak the most used language.Chat Icon

Posted 2/16/12 8:40 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
wish me luck..I'm taking a phone recorded spanish language assessment in eight minutes... Jessica 11/10/08 1 Families Helping Families ™
can I get an spanish to english translation please? TIA Janice 8/30/07 8 Families Helping Families ™
GOT IT THANKS!!! Can someone FM me who can translate english into spanish? AnthonysWife 6/21/07 0 Families Helping Families ™
When did "Foreign language" become "Languages other then English"? FreeButterfly 6/9/11 4 Parents of School-Aged Children
if you speak a language other then english at home .. transition to Daycare? gabbie83 3/29/11 7 Parenting
If your DC speaks another language BETTER than English... 08BabySurprise 3/22/10 13 Parenting