Elimination Communication....

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Elimination Communication....

I came across this article yesterday.. of course I can't find it now.

It was about Blossom's Myaim Bialik (celebrity spokesmom for the holistic Mom's network) and her parenting techniques.. some were EBFing and co-sleeping.. normal stuff...

Another was "elimination communication." I had never heard of this so I looked it up. It's... interesting... to say the least.

She believes that all newborns are born potty trained and that parents need to read the signs and get the baby to the potty. She started her 1st child at 6 mos and her second at 2 days.. It is pairing sounds and signals when the baby "goes", Kind of like conditioning them, as you are rushing them to the bathroom. So her kids don't wear diapers..

HOW ON EARTH DOES SHE DO THAT? I mean, I guess it is possible to get through the daylight hours.. but, nighttime?? How?
From Wiki.."Elimination communication (EC) is a practice in which a caregiver uses timing, signals, cues, and intuition to address an infant's need to eliminate waste. Typically the goal is to partially or completely avoid the use of diapers. EC emphasizes communication between the caregiver and child, helping them both become more attuned to the child's innate rhythms and control of urination and defecation." "The terms elimination communication and natural infant hygiene were coined by Ingrid Bauer and are used interchangeably in her book, Diaper Free! The Gentle Wisdom of Natural Infant Hygiene (2001). Bauer had traveled to India and Africa, where she noticed that most mothers would carry their diaperless babies constantly, yet she saw no elimination "accidents" as would be expected in industrialized countries where babies wear diapers almost continuously from birth. Subsequently, she raised her own children with minimal use of diapers, and eventually began to share her approach with other mothers and caregivers — initially through Internet-based parenting support groups and eventually through her book and website (link missing).

Prior publications introducing Western parents to this ancient practice include the book Trickle Treat, by Laurie Boucke (1991), and a pamphlet entitled Elimination Timing, by Natec (1994). Boucke was influenced by an Indian friend who taught her how mothers in India care for babies without diapers, and she adapted it to fit her Western lifestyle."

It sounds nuts to me.. But, what do you think? Is this just pushing kids to do something they aren't ready to do.. or are we as American's missing the boat? I found on article that said it could lead to UTI's and constipation by teaching children to "hold it" when they weren't ready.

Wiki article

another link

Message edited 2009-08-29 10:51:39.570000.

Posted 8/29/09 10:47 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Elimination Communication....

I think it sounds nuts. With everything else that goes into taking care of a newborn the LAST thing I would want to bother worrying about is potty training them too! Aside from that, what's the rush? Everyone learns to use the potty eventually........you don't see adults running around pooping in their pants do you? Chat Icon Chat Icon I think everyone is entirely too concerned with forcing babies and young children to do things too early. It's sad that we spend so much time rushing our children through their childhood.

Personally, I am happy to let Emerson do everything at her own pace. Whether she uses the toilet at 2 or 4 I don't care. Whether she can read by Kindergarten or not I don't care. Whether it takes her a little longer to learn how to spell her name than other kids I don't care. Why???............because eventually she will get it and IMO there is no reason to rush her, pressure her, or frustrate her. Speaking as a teacher and a parent............everyone needs to stop rushing their kids to grow up. They will get there without us pushing them so hard at every turn. There is something to be said for letting things happen naturally when they are ready to happen.

As an side............Mayim Bialik seems like a total cuckoo weirdo. Chat Icon

Posted 8/29/09 10:56 AM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by Hofstra26

I think it sounds nuts. With everything else that goes into taking care of a newborn the LAST thing I would want to bother worrying about is potty training them too! Aside from that, what's the rush? Everyone learns to use the potty eventually........you don't see adults running around pooping in their pants do you? Chat Icon Chat Icon I think everyone is entirely too concerned with forcing babies and young children to do things too early. It's sad that we spend so much time rushing our children through their childhood.

Personally, I am happy to let Emerson do everything at her own pace. Whether she uses the toilet at 2 or 4 I don't care. Whether she can read by Kindergarten or not I don't care. Whether it takes her a little longer to learn how to spell her name than other kids I don't care. Why???............because eventually she will get it and IMO there is no reason to rush her, pressure her, or frustrate her. Speaking as a teacher and a parent............everyone needs to stop rushing their kids to grow up. They will get there without us pushing them so hard at every turn. There is something to be said for letting things happen naturally when they are ready to happen.

As an side............Mayim Bialik seems like a total cuckoo weirdo. Chat Icon



ITA! We are in a rush to get our kids to do things.. sometimes they just need to play and be kids. My Mom searched long and hard for a pre-school for me that encouraged play over too much learning. She wanted the focus to be playing and being a kid. Guess what I'm almost 30, I have one Master's degree and I'm halfway done with my second. It didn't hurt me!

Posted 8/29/09 11:02 AM
 

Blissful
Ultimate Expression of LOVE

Member since 6/08

4985 total posts

Name:
Maria

Re: Elimination Communication....

I do selective EC...... When Alexa starts to grunt and I know she is going to poop I take her diaper off and put her on the toilet..... MUCH easier to clean up, especially since we are using cloth....

Its really more of a convenience factor for us adn we just started doing it recently since I can read her signs.

It was actually my husbands idea and he never even read the articles. I was like oh you want to try EC?? He said, no I'd rather just no scrape the poop out of the diaper Chat Icon


If you REALLY understand the theory correctly its not crazy at all and DOES NOT FORCE a child to potty train early...

Posted 8/29/09 11:04 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Elimination Communication....

As much as diapers are a lot of work, and an expense, I don't see the point in rushing a baby through potty training. Especially a newborn. To me it just seems an added stress.

If she is breastfeeding exclusively I wonder how that works out. I breastfed and though I supplemented with formula after week 1 or so, I still spent an awful lot of time with DD nursing and I am sure she pooped and peed during that time. Good thing I believed in diapers or it might have gotten messy and I don't think I would have been coordianted enough to nurse and hold her over the toilet.

Posted 8/29/09 11:05 AM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by MrsProfessor

As much as diapers are a lot of work, and an expense, I don't see the point in rushing a baby through potty training. Especially a newborn. To me it just seems an added stress.

If she is breastfeeding exclusively I wonder how that works out. I breastfed and though I supplemented with formula after week 1 or so, I still spent an awful lot of time with DD nursing and I am sure she pooped and peed during that time. Good thing I believed in diapers or it might have gotten messy and I don't think I would have been coordianted enough to nurse and hold her over the toilet.



I was thinking the same thing... how can you BF and do this. Liam poops while he is eating. I could just see me ripping him off the boob and rushing my screaming baby to the potty! I would most likely get pooped onChat Icon

Posted 8/29/09 11:08 AM
 

Dani922
Here's to new beginnings

Member since 10/07

7260 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Elimination Communication....

I've heard of it & have known of women on another forum who have done it. Personaly, I say no thank you. I am all for trying things the natural way, but that's a little too natural for me. It just seems like way too much work & I'm not sure exactly what the point is of trying to train a baby under a year. I agree with Hofstra, there is no reason to rush kids to grow up so fast.

Posted 8/29/09 11:09 AM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by Blissful

I do selective EC...... When Alexa starts to grunt and I know she is going to poop I take her diaper off and put her on the toilet..... MUCH easier to clean up, especially since we are using cloth....

Its really more of a convenience factor for us adn we just started doing it recently since I can read her signs.

It was actually my husbands idea and he never even read the articles. I was like oh you want to try EC?? He said, no I'd rather just no scrape the poop out of the diaper Chat Icon


If you REALLY understand the theory correctly its not crazy at all and DOES NOT FORCE a child to potty train early...




Not that I want to do this.. but, out of curiousity.. can you explain it a bit better for us? I am always pretty interested in hearing about "less mainstream parenting techniques".

Posted 8/29/09 11:11 AM
 

Blissful
Ultimate Expression of LOVE

Member since 6/08

4985 total posts

Name:
Maria

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by Blissful

I do selective EC...... When Alexa starts to grunt and I know she is going to poop I take her diaper off and put her on the toilet..... MUCH easier to clean up, especially since we are using cloth....

Its really more of a convenience factor for us adn we just started doing it recently since I can read her signs.

It was actually my husbands idea and he never even read the articles. I was like oh you want to try EC?? He said, no I'd rather just no scrape the poop out of the diaper Chat Icon


If you REALLY understand the theory correctly its not crazy at all and DOES NOT FORCE a child to potty train early...




Not that I want to do this.. but, out of curiousity.. can you explain it a bit better for us? I am always pretty interested in hearing about "less mainstream parenting techniques".




It kind of just happened. I would never try this with a newborn. We finally got our high chair, a tripp trapp chair and every time I sat Alexa in it so she was sitting upright she would grunt and poop. My husband was like why don't you put her on the toilet...

So when she starts doing this I pick her up take the diaper off and put her on the toilet and she poops... VOILA.........

I don't always do it and it doesn't always work but I would say 75% of the time she poops in the toilet and I don't have to scrape it....

Its not something I would FORCE or make her do or another kid, it just happens to work out and I don't see this as trying to train her or push her to potty train...

SHe SCREAMS after she poops cause she hates to be dirty so this actually makes her happier!

Posted 8/29/09 11:14 AM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Elimination Communication....

I heard they do this in Japan, like its more common

Posted 8/29/09 11:21 AM
 

XcalystaX
Sooo Sleep Deprived....

Member since 7/06

2742 total posts

Name:
S

Re: Elimination Communication....

Similar to Blissful, my DD poops right after breakfast in her high chair-so the pattern was easy to see. My mom had both my brother and I using a potty since 12 months old and we have been doing the same with my DD. She will even preface her popping by saying "caca potty" and we put her on the potty and she goes. Its super convenient when we are home and I am positive that I am not "damaging" her or making her miss out on her childhood ;)

Posted 8/29/09 11:53 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by XcalystaX

Similar to Blissful, my DD poops right after breakfast in her high chair-so the pattern was easy to see. My mom had both my brother and I using a potty since 12 months old and we have been doing the same with my DD. She will even preface her popping by saying "caca potty" and we put her on the potty and she goes. Its super convenient when we are home and I am positive that I am not "damaging" her or making her miss out on her childhood ;)



I think this is different than true "EC" b/c your DD is older and she can express that she has to go, to me, that is normal potty trainingChat Icon

My BFF's sister does EC though, and has since her DD was a NB. I give her credit. I love the idea of being green, but I will have to pay a pennance for disposable diapers b/c I can't handle the alternativeChat Icon

Posted 8/29/09 12:08 PM
 

Alli06
Baby #3 coming this June

Member since 8/05

6721 total posts

Name:
A

Re: Elimination Communication....

I can see you doing this as the child gets older say past 8 months, but as a newborn!! I felt like I didn't have a minute to myself when he was a newborn. He nursed constantly and for long periods of time. Another article I read said that a newborn pees every 20 minutes of so. How the heck do you get to the bathroom everytime, especially when their BF. How do you sit a 8lbs newborn on the toilet? Do you have the baby nursing and pooing at the same time. I don't get it! I'm also very interested in this.

I have heard from many people that kids potty train a lot older these days, because majority don't use cloth diapers. The cloth makes them uncomfortable when wet or soiled so they are more inclined to start going on the toilet earlier. Also, that pull-ups are not good to use. That you should go straight to underwear.

Posted 8/29/09 12:22 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Elimination Communication....

while i understand the concept, i would not want to have to drop everything and rush a child to the potty because i saw the "signs" that they were going to poop. and they still have to wear a diaper for pee. i just don't see the point.

i don't use cloth diapers - i don't know if that would have changed my mind - but for me it's easier to throw away a diaper than worry about where the closest bathroom is.

Posted 8/29/09 12:54 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Elimination Communication....

My mom did this to me starting at 8 months and she also had me say caca or something along those lines ....DD actually just turned 8 months and my mom bought her a potty, I have yet to use it, but will try to start soon...I'm not forcing her, but I don't mind starting sooner rather than later...I was potty trained by 12 months. I honestly don't think it hurts, you just look for the cues...as a NB there is no way in he** I can see myself doing that...

Posted 8/29/09 1:33 PM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by Hofstra26

I think it sounds nuts. With everything else that goes into taking care of a newborn the LAST thing I would want to bother worrying about is potty training them too! Aside from that, what's the rush? Everyone learns to use the potty eventually........you don't see adults running around pooping in their pants do you? Chat Icon Chat Icon I think everyone is entirely too concerned with forcing babies and young children to do things too early. It's sad that we spend so much time rushing our children through their childhood.

Personally, I am happy to let Emerson do everything at her own pace. Whether she uses the toilet at 2 or 4 I don't care. Whether she can read by Kindergarten or not I don't care. Whether it takes her a little longer to learn how to spell her name than other kids I don't care. Why???............because eventually she will get it and IMO there is no reason to rush her, pressure her, or frustrate her. Speaking as a teacher and a parent............everyone needs to stop rushing their kids to grow up. They will get there without us pushing them so hard at every turn. There is something to be said for letting things happen naturally when they are ready to happen.

As an side............Mayim Bialik seems like a total cuckoo weirdo. Chat Icon



i agree 100% on EVERYTHING you wrote!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/29/09 2:39 PM
 

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Re: Elimination Communication....

who has the time when the baby is a newborn... maybe that was why she was on tlcs what not to wear

Posted 8/29/09 2:40 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by Hofstra26

I think it sounds nuts. With everything else that goes into taking care of a newborn the LAST thing I would want to bother worrying about is potty training them too! Aside from that, what's the rush? Everyone learns to use the potty eventually........you don't see adults running around pooping in their pants do you? Chat Icon Chat Icon I think everyone is entirely too concerned with forcing babies and young children to do things too early. It's sad that we spend so much time rushing our children through their childhood.

Personally, I am happy to let Emerson do everything at her own pace. Whether she uses the toilet at 2 or 4 I don't care. Whether she can read by Kindergarten or not I don't care. Whether it takes her a little longer to learn how to spell her name than other kids I don't care. Why???............because eventually she will get it and IMO there is no reason to rush her, pressure her, or frustrate her. Speaking as a teacher and a parent............everyone needs to stop rushing their kids to grow up. They will get there without us pushing them so hard at every turn. There is something to be said for letting things happen naturally when they are ready to happen.

As an side............Mayim Bialik seems like a total cuckoo weirdo. Chat Icon



i agree 100% on EVERYTHING you wrote!Chat Icon Chat Icon



Me too! 100%!

I just don't get it. Ryan poops around the clock..I must change 8 poop diapers/day. I would go NUTS trying to race to the toilet when I hear him grunt. I would spend half the day there...

I just don't understand the rush some parents have for these things.

Posted 8/29/09 3:03 PM
 

bonitachyc
big sister status may 2012!!

Member since 5/08

3242 total posts

Name:
Lupe

Re: Elimination Communication....

i'm gonna do it with allison as soon as i read up on the methods and techniques. will probably start at 8 months. i see no harm in it. i can already read her signs, the sooner she gets trained, the easier it'll be on all of us...

Posted 8/29/09 3:14 PM
 

bonitachyc
big sister status may 2012!!

Member since 5/08

3242 total posts

Name:
Lupe

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by Blissful

I do selective EC...... When Alexa starts to grunt and I know she is going to poop I take her diaper off and put her on the toilet..... MUCH easier to clean up, especially since we are using cloth....

Its really more of a convenience factor for us adn we just started doing it recently since I can read her signs.

It was actually my husbands idea and he never even read the articles. I was like oh you want to try EC?? He said, no I'd rather just no scrape the poop out of the diaper Chat Icon


If you REALLY understand the theory correctly its not crazy at all and DOES NOT FORCE a child to potty train early...




Not that I want to do this.. but, out of curiousity.. can you explain it a bit better for us? I am always pretty interested in hearing about "less mainstream parenting techniques".



Here's a fabulous article I just read recently in Chicago Parent magazine regarding EC -
linky

Posted 8/29/09 3:17 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Elimination Communication....

See.. I think the part that is a bit nuts is doing it at 2 days. Nothing wrong with 8 months or even 6 months.. BUT 2 DAYS OLD!!! My god. I couldn't even see straight yet at 2 days old. Liam only opened his eyes for 2-3 hours a day at this point.

Posted 8/29/09 4:21 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by bonitachyc

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by Blissful

I do selective EC...... When Alexa starts to grunt and I know she is going to poop I take her diaper off and put her on the toilet..... MUCH easier to clean up, especially since we are using cloth....

Its really more of a convenience factor for us adn we just started doing it recently since I can read her signs.

It was actually my husbands idea and he never even read the articles. I was like oh you want to try EC?? He said, no I'd rather just no scrape the poop out of the diaper Chat Icon


If you REALLY understand the theory correctly its not crazy at all and DOES NOT FORCE a child to potty train early...




Not that I want to do this.. but, out of curiousity.. can you explain it a bit better for us? I am always pretty interested in hearing about "less mainstream parenting techniques".



Here's a fabulous article I just read recently in Chicago Parent magazine regarding EC -
linky



That was really interesting. But, a lot more work than I am able to do right now. Chat Icon

Posted 8/29/09 4:26 PM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: Elimination Communication....

Posted by Blissful

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by Blissful

I do selective EC...... When Alexa starts to grunt and I know she is going to poop I take her diaper off and put her on the toilet..... MUCH easier to clean up, especially since we are using cloth....

Its really more of a convenience factor for us adn we just started doing it recently since I can read her signs.

It was actually my husbands idea and he never even read the articles. I was like oh you want to try EC?? He said, no I'd rather just no scrape the poop out of the diaper Chat Icon


If you REALLY understand the theory correctly its not crazy at all and DOES NOT FORCE a child to potty train early...




Not that I want to do this.. but, out of curiousity.. can you explain it a bit better for us? I am always pretty interested in hearing about "less mainstream parenting techniques".




It kind of just happened. I would never try this with a newborn. We finally got our high chair, a tripp trapp chair and every time I sat Alexa in it so she was sitting upright she would grunt and poop. My husband was like why don't you put her on the toilet...

So when she starts doing this I pick her up take the diaper off and put her on the toilet and she poops... VOILA.........

I don't always do it and it doesn't always work but I would say 75% of the time she poops in the toilet and I don't have to scrape it....

Its not something I would FORCE or make her do or another kid, it just happens to work out and I don't see this as trying to train her or push her to potty train...

SHe SCREAMS after she poops cause she hates to be dirty so this actually makes her happier!



Very clever Maria! I never heard of this before today, but it does sound interesting. I don't think I could ever do this with a newborn, but an older infant-if you know, why not save the diaper and stink?

Posted 8/29/09 4:55 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Elimination Communication....

I live in a very crunchy area and know moms who have the patience to do it and it works. It's not for me but to each his own.

Posted 8/29/09 5:05 PM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Elimination Communication....

I couldn't do it from a newborn, but I, personally think it is better to start earlier, and I plan to start after DS 1st birthday. Every one of my siblings (and I) were trained well before 2. I think it was more common to do it "back then" possibly because of the cloth diapers.I see nothing wrong with it. To each his own.

Posted 8/29/09 6:28 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Elimination Communication (infant potty training)? dandr10199 4/20/06 1 Pregnancy
Texting/Communication devises out of hand MrsBumbleb 10/25/06 4 Families Helping Families ™
can there be "too much" communication in a relationship? Michi 11/14/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
BFing Moms....Elimination diet?? dree 11/1/05 4 Parenting