Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted By Message

bpmom
Feeling Blessed

Member since 6/07

2963 total posts

Name:

Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Did anyone here attend the workshop held tonight at Bayport-Blue Point library?

DH and I were there and are infuriated with our school district. I had no idea how much power the school board has with regards to the religious exception for avoiding vaccinations...

I haven't made my mind up yet about which vaccines DS will receive, but I want to know that it's my choice, so I'll be writing letters/making calls to Marc Alessi to show our support of his bill for NYS to have a philosophical exception t vaccinations. I want to know that IF I decide to not vaccinate Jack that I will be supported.

Just wondering if anyone from LIF was there tonight....

Posted 5/12/08 11:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

michele31
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3372 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

I think the reason that the school district has these rules is because if your child does contract a disease such as polio he/she could then infect other children in school or create a new strain that the current vaccine cannot fight.
I, for one, do not want my child in a school with children who are not vaccinated. Most who have religious exceptions actually do not send their children to public school because they want an extremely religious school environment or homeschool.

I am NOT saying that you have to vaccinate at all. But you should then home school in order to protect other children.

I do wish that these meetings would show video of children who do not have access to vaccines. I have have seen first hand (in Africa) what can happen when a simple vaccine could have saved a child from having her legs twisted like a pretzel from Polio.
again, you have every right NOT to vaccinate your child, but you should also make sure you understand what can happen if you don't.
There are risks with every choice we make as parents.

Posted 5/12/08 11:45 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by michele31

I think the reason that the school district has these rules is because if your child does contract a disease such as polio he/she could then infect other children in school or create a new strain that the current vaccine cannot fight.
I, for one, do not want my child in a school with children who are not vaccinated. Most who have religious exceptions actually do not send their children to public school because they want an extremely religious school environment or homeschool.

I am NOT saying that you have to vaccinate at all. But you should then home school in order to protect other children.

I do wish that these meetings would show video of children who do not have access to vaccines. I have have seen first hand (in Africa) what can happen when a simple vaccine could have saved a child from having her legs twisted like a pretzel from Polio.
again, you have every right NOT to vaccinate your child, but you should also make sure you understand what can happen if you don't.
There are risks with every choice we make as parents.



ITA!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/13/08 2:16 AM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by michele31

I think the reason that the school district has these rules is because if your child does contract a disease such as polio he/she could then infect other children in school or create a new strain that the current vaccine cannot fight.
I, for one, do not want my child in a school with children who are not vaccinated. Most who have religious exceptions actually do not send their children to public school because they want an extremely religious school environment or homeschool.

I am NOT saying that you have to vaccinate at all. But you should then home school in order to protect other children.

I do wish that these meetings would show video of children who do not have access to vaccines. I have have seen first hand (in Africa) what can happen when a simple vaccine could have saved a child from having her legs twisted like a pretzel from Polio.
again, you have every right NOT to vaccinate your child, but you should also make sure you understand what can happen if you don't.
There are risks with every choice we make as parents.



ITA!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Ditto Chat Icon

Posted 5/13/08 2:41 AM
 

shellybean
Love my Baby Boy!

Member since 4/07

5191 total posts

Name:
mich

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

I agree, im a teacher and it others me that some kid sin my school, maybe about 5...dont have the ,measules shot and they are in third grade and up....im scraed ill bring it home to my 4 months old....i think you should home school if your child doesnt have the shot...the reason for measles shot is to prevent ,,...if more and more dont vaccinate we will have an outbreak again....delaying the shot is another story, but these kids are older and Never getting it....

Posted 5/13/08 6:38 AM
 

partyof6
b nice like u want ur kidz 2

Member since 7/06

7752 total posts

Name:
jeannine

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

in all respect..she just wanted to know if anyone attended. She then said she was mad regardiing her situation and so on.
That workshop was in my town and I actually wanted to listen to it to see but forgot and well there was actually another reason I didn't attend, lets just say a personality confict with someone.
The woman that set it all up...is fighting the courts because apparently 2 kids are vaccinated and the third is not.
I dk what the reasons are behind it.
There are going to be topics where people disagree.
I won't even go into this subject--circumcision or anything else that potentially takesa turn for the worst.
I hate to say it...but I am sure one of your children already are in a class with religious excemptions or something.
This woman is not the only one that didn't vaccinate..I know there are others around here.
I also think a point was--if someone else does not have to do it--then everyone should be offered the right to decide for their kids..
edited for spelling

Message edited 2008-05-13 08:05:24.207000.

Posted 5/13/08 6:49 AM
 

jgm26
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/06

583 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

There is no proof that a vaccine you rcv'd at 1 y.o grants you lifetime immunity from the diease. as a matter of fact, lots of people never get the 2nd dose of the MMR. I worked in college admissions for years and I'd say about 40% of people don't - so they are technically not immune . Just wanted to point out the emergence of these diseases isn't always from unvaccinated children. I've delayed my daughters shot- but will get them separately before she enters school. Its such a gray area for lots of peopleChat Icon

Posted 5/13/08 8:14 AM
 

bpmom
Feeling Blessed

Member since 6/07

2963 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by jgm26

Its such a gray area for lots of peopleChat Icon



I agree this is a touchy subject, and that's why I'd like to be more informed before decisions are made by DH AND ME - not by the school, not by the state, not by the pharmaceutical co.'s.

My MIL doesn't really understand why I attended the meeting either. My point to her is that when DH and I were looking for houses, we researched the school districts to be sure DC will get a good education. I was pregnant with Jack I followed all the "rules" the OB gave me about safe foods. I avoided aspartame because someone read somewhere that it could cause MS. I didn't eat cold cuts because of listeria risks. I made sure I ate enough folic acid because I read that helps decrease incidence of neural tube defects. We took a Bradley birthing class to learn about our options for childbirth. We interviewed pediatricians to find one that agrees with not giving antibiotics too quickly and has well-child visits separate from sick-child visits. And now that I'm Bfing, I look at all food ingredient labels to try to avoid foods that could be "bad": high fructose corn syrup, artificial sweeteners, caffeine, etc.

If I've taken this much effort to try to give Jack (and our future children) a good start in life, why shouldn't I learn as much as possible about the vaccinations (and the materials in them) before I simply agree with what's been done in the past. I want to have information so that I feel the choices are the best for his health and future.
I don't think the information is available to us - and I want to learn as much as I can....

I'm not trying to put other people or their children at risk by making choices for my children - I'm just trying to learn as much as I can...

Posted 5/13/08 9:40 AM
 

jgm26
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/06

583 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

There are two really good books that give you info about the vaccines.

What Your Doctor Won't Tell You About Vaccinations by Stephanie Cave

and
How to Raise a Healthy Child In Spite of Your Doctor by Robert Mendelsohn( a pedi)

ITA about not wanting to do whats been done in the past- just b/c its whats done. There are a lot of gray areas in this discussion and when you are talking about the health of your child, gray is not acceptable.
Also doctors don't know everything- at one time they didn't think smoking or drinking while pregnant was a bad thing. PLUS a lot of the 'studies' that claim vaccines are totally safe are put out by pharmaceutical companies.
Good luck with your research!

Posted 5/13/08 2:06 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by michele31

I think the reason that the school district has these rules is because if your child does contract a disease such as polio he/she could then infect other children in school or create a new strain that the current vaccine cannot fight.
I, for one, do not want my child in a school with children who are not vaccinated. Most who have religious exceptions actually do not send their children to public school because they want an extremely religious school environment or homeschool.

I am NOT saying that you have to vaccinate at all. But you should then home school in order to protect other children.

I do wish that these meetings would show video of children who do not have access to vaccines. I have have seen first hand (in Africa) what can happen when a simple vaccine could have saved a child from having her legs twisted like a pretzel from Polio.
again, you have every right NOT to vaccinate your child, but you should also make sure you understand what can happen if you don't.
There are risks with every choice we make as parents.



ITA!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Ditto!Chat Icon

Posted 5/13/08 2:12 PM
 

bella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1871 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

I never heard of this but would have been very interested in attending. I have done an ENORMOUS amount of research on this topic in the last year and am always interested in hearing more.

I think it really is in the best interest of parents to know exacty what is in these shots and not only because of autism. The interesting thing is and I know this is a hot topic but we certainly did not give 36 shots before the age of 6 years ago, today we do, big difference. I found it very, very, very interesting that one of the leading doctors in the country and the former NIH Director just came out in favor of more studies being done as she says a link is still a possibility. Very interesting also what she says about the fear of how the public would react if a link is proven.....makes me wonder....here is the story if anyone is interested ...you hae to actually watch the video on the page.....
vaccine link to autism cbs news

I too will show my support for Marc Alessi. I as a parent should make that decision ...no one else.

Message edited 2008-05-13 15:00:15.303000.

Posted 5/13/08 2:40 PM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by bicosi

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by michele31

I think the reason that the school district has these rules is because if your child does contract a disease such as polio he/she could then infect other children in school or create a new strain that the current vaccine cannot fight.
I, for one, do not want my child in a school with children who are not vaccinated. Most who have religious exceptions actually do not send their children to public school because they want an extremely religious school environment or homeschool.

I am NOT saying that you have to vaccinate at all. But you should then home school in order to protect other children.

I do wish that these meetings would show video of children who do not have access to vaccines. I have have seen first hand (in Africa) what can happen when a simple vaccine could have saved a child from having her legs twisted like a pretzel from Polio.
again, you have every right NOT to vaccinate your child, but you should also make sure you understand what can happen if you don't.
There are risks with every choice we make as parents.



ITA!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Ditto!Chat Icon



Me too!

Posted 5/13/08 2:50 PM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by michele31

I do wish that these meetings would show video of children who do not have access to vaccines. I have have seen first hand (in Africa) what can happen when a simple vaccine could have saved a child from having her legs twisted like a pretzel from Polio.
again, you have every right NOT to vaccinate your child, but you should also make sure you understand what can happen if you don't.
There are risks with every choice we make as parents.



While I think it's terrible that those children have to live with that, let's remember that we don't live in a 3rd world country, that polio is not a threat to our children (thanks to vaccines) and that if your children do contract a disease like the measles they have access to first class quality health-care -- those children in 3rd world countries do not.

It's not really fair to compare a child on Long Island who doesn't get the MMR to children in other parts of the world who face greater risks because of lack of quality healthcare, poor nutrition and hygiene, etc.

I think parents need access to factual information, not scare tactics.

Posted 5/13/08 2:59 PM
 

hope07
LIF Adult

Member since 12/06

1050 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by bella

I never heard of this but would have been very interested in attending. I have done an ENORMOUS amount of research on this topic in the last year and am always interested in hearing more.

I think it really is in the best interest of parents to know exacty what is in these shots and not only because of autism. The interesting thing is and I know this is a hot topic but we certainly did not give 36 shots before the age of 6 years ago, today we do, big difference. I found it very, very, very interesting that one of the leading doctors in the country and the former NIH Director just came out in favor of more studies being done as she says a link is still a possibility. Very interesting also what she says about the fear of how the public would react if a link is proven.....makes me wonder....here is the story if anyone is interested ...you hae to actually watch the video on the page.....
vaccine link to autism cbs news

I too will show my support for Marc Alessi. I as a parent should make that decision ...no one else.




Great article... thanks for posting!

Posted 5/13/08 3:40 PM
 

Foodie03
LIF Infant

Member since 1/07

293 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by bdmom

Posted by jgm26

Its such a gray area for lots of peopleChat Icon



I agree this is a touchy subject, and that's why I'd like to be more informed before decisions are made by DH AND ME - not by the school, not by the state, not by the pharmaceutical co.'s.

My MIL doesn't really understand why I attended the meeting either. My point to her is that when DH and I were looking for houses, we researched the school districts to be sure DC will get a good education. I was pregnant with Jack I followed all the "rules" the OB gave me about safe foods. I avoided aspartame because someone read somewhere that it could cause MS. I didn't eat cold cuts because of listeria risks. I made sure I ate enough folic acid because I read that helps decrease incidence of neural tube defects. We took a Bradley birthing class to learn about our options for childbirth. We interviewed pediatricians to find one that agrees with not giving antibiotics too quickly and has well-child visits separate from sick-child visits. And now that I'm Bfing, I look at all food ingredient labels to try to avoid foods that could be "bad": high fructose corn syrup, artificial sweeteners, caffeine, etc.

If I've taken this much effort to try to give Jack (and our future children) a good start in life, why shouldn't I learn as much as possible about the vaccinations (and the materials in them) before I simply agree with what's been done in the past. I want to have information so that I feel the choices are the best for his health and future.
I don't think the information is available to us - and I want to learn as much as I can....

I'm not trying to put other people or their children at risk by making choices for my children - I'm just trying to learn as much as I can...




I just finished reading The Vaccine Book by Dr. Robert Sears and it was very informative. He is not anti-vaccine by any means in fact probably the opposite,but he does suggest an alternate vaccination schedule that only allows 1 vaccination a visit that contains aluminum (another controversial ingredient in vaccines). The book was pretty informative as far as describing the disease, the making of the vaccinations, the ingredients and the side effects. It doesn't tell you what to do, just helps you to be more informed in order to make decisions for your children. Highly reccommended!

Posted 5/13/08 4:15 PM
 

bpmom
Feeling Blessed

Member since 6/07

2963 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by Dragonfly75

[
It's not really fair to compare a child on Long Island who doesn't get the MMR to children in other parts of the world who face greater risks because of lack of quality healthcare, poor nutrition and hygiene, etc.

I think parents need access to factual information, not scare tactics.



One of the peds last night discussed a chart which showed the decline of polio in the US versus time. Interestingly, polio began to decline BEFORE the vaccines were implemented so some people attribute the decline to the introduction of the polio vaccine but this might not be true.

I think we should promote healthier living in addition to vaccines but not just vaccines alone...

Here's a link to some of the other information they gave last night:
Mykidsmychoice.com

Posted 5/13/08 5:01 PM
 

jules
Changing everyday

Member since 1/08

2281 total posts

Name:
julia

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by Dragonfly75

While I think it's terrible that those children have to live with that, let's remember that we don't live in a 3rd world country, that polio is not a threat to our children (thanks to vaccines) and that if your children do contract a disease like the measles they have access to first class quality health-care -- those children in 3rd world countries do not.

It's not really fair to compare a child on Long Island who doesn't get the MMR to children in other parts of the world who face greater risks because of lack of quality healthcare, poor nutrition and hygiene, etc.

I think parents need access to factual information, not scare tactics.


the facts actually are that this year, according to the CDC

biggest U.S. outbreak of measles since 2001 is unfolding in 10 states, with at least 72 people ranging from infants to the elderly becoming ill -- most of them unvaccinated, U.S. health officials said Thursday.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said said none of those who caught the highly contagious viral illness has died, but at least 14 people have been hospitalized, most with pneumonia triggered by measles.

There were 116 cases in 2001, and the last major U.S. outbreak occurred from 1989 to 1991, when 55,000 people got measles and 123 died.

Anne Schuchat, who heads the CDC's National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases, said she expects "many more cases this year than we had in 2001 based on what's going on today."

Public health officials have been stressing the importance of immunizing children in the face of increasingly vocal groups who object to vaccines for religious reasons or because they think the shots may cause autism or other problems.

CDC officials said overwhelming scientific evidence points to the safety of the combined measles-mumps-rubella, or MMR, shot and other childhood vaccines.

"We are concerned ... about the population of people who are choosing not to be vaccinated, and whether we may be on the verge of facing larger-scale outbreaks in the United States," said Jane Seward of the CDC's division of viral diseases.

The CDC said most of the measles cases can be traced to 10 people who picked up the disease overseas and then traveled back to the United States, where others became infected. The ages of those sickened ranged from 5 months to 71 years.

Posted 5/13/08 6:36 PM
 

partyof6
b nice like u want ur kidz 2

Member since 7/06

7752 total posts

Name:
jeannine

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

vaccinations do not last forever...
I was curious how many parents are up to date on all their vaccinations?
We tend to put ourselves last...
I am sure school teachers probably are but what about the rest of us?
I for one am not.

Posted 5/13/08 7:51 PM
 

jules
Changing everyday

Member since 1/08

2281 total posts

Name:
julia

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by lastchance1222

vaccinations do not last forever...
I was curious how many parents are up to date on all their vaccinations?
We tend to put ourselves last...
I am sure school teachers probably are but what about the rest of us?
I for one am not.



SOOO TRUE

Most vaccinations need titers. And that some def need repeating when adults. Just the other day i was talking to a physician who told me that ALL adults should be getting the DTap again!

How many of us had that lately? Chat Icon

Posted 5/13/08 9:09 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

As a teacher, I get sick VERY frequently from my students and they ARE vaccinated. (Easy for me to personally check their records due to the nature of my setting). I can only imagine if they did not receive such vaccinations. I often contract serious colds and end up transferring them to my DH. I can only imagine what is going to happen when there is a baby in our home.

Frankly, I'd be simply be pleased if the parents of my students just kept them home when they are sick. Im tired of the colds, cold sores and fever blisters.

Posted 5/13/08 9:24 PM
 

partyof6
b nice like u want ur kidz 2

Member since 7/06

7752 total posts

Name:
jeannine

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by Goldi0218

As a teacher, I get sick VERY frequently from my students and they ARE vaccinated. (Easy for me to personally check their records due to the nature of my setting). I can only imagine if they did not receive such vaccinations. I often contract serious colds and end up transferring them to my DH. I can only imagine what is going to happen when there is a baby in our home.

Frankly, I'd be simply be pleased if the parents of my students just kept them home when they are sick. Im tired of the colds, cold sores and fever blisters.




holy cow---a total peeve of mine....i was going to bring it up but choose not to-now I will...
my mom has a bad immune system...she catches everything.
She gets kids tht come to school---thts right come to school puking---high fevers....diseases...you name it,..
she getsit everytime.
She is sick every holiday it seems.
All because they have to go to school.
I am more concerned with my kid sitting next to a sick kid then a unvaccinated kid.
if your kid is sick---has the runs, green **** from their nose...whatever...be responsible and stay home with them.

Posted 5/14/08 7:24 AM
 

LisaI
Momma's Little Beans

Member since 1/06

3923 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

Posted by Dragonfly75

Posted by michele31

I do wish that these meetings would show video of children who do not have access to vaccines. I have have seen first hand (in Africa) what can happen when a simple vaccine could have saved a child from having her legs twisted like a pretzel from Polio.
again, you have every right NOT to vaccinate your child, but you should also make sure you understand what can happen if you don't.
There are risks with every choice we make as parents.



While I think it's terrible that those children have to live with that, let's remember that we don't live in a 3rd world country, that polio is not a threat to our children (thanks to vaccines) and that if your children do contract a disease like the measles they have access to first class quality health-care -- those children in 3rd world countries do not.

It's not really fair to compare a child on Long Island who doesn't get the MMR to children in other parts of the world who face greater risks because of lack of quality healthcare, poor nutrition and hygiene, etc.

I think parents need access to factual information, not scare tactics.


I was going to echo this. We don't live in a 3rd world country. It's different here. I do support the bill!

Message edited 2008-05-14 08:12:08.083000.

Posted 5/14/08 8:07 AM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

I came up not immune to measles when I did my pregnancy testing - imagine how many kids I came in contact with as a teacher (and when I was in NYC 300+ students a year in just my classroom) - we had a lot of immigrants, who visited other countriesor had families visiting, it's a possible breeding ground - I see the reasoning for the school board's policies.


I'm pro-vaccine, but I am also pro-educating yourself on vaccines.

Message edited 2008-05-14 08:11:24.350000.

Posted 5/14/08 8:09 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Education before Vaccination Workshop...

DS has been sick so many times from people who can't take off work and just bring their child sick with no regards to other kids (sometimes just a few weeks old!) and teachers.

I work with people with a cold with NO REGARDS to me.

I can only imagine if it was completely up to parents to decide on vaccinations and bringing them to school.

I don't think we need another vaccinations vs non vaccinations thread.

I have no problem with children not vaccinated. This is indeed a parent's choice but I do not agree with imposing that decision and endangering other children in a school environment. Home schooling seems more appropriate in my opinion.

I have adapted DS' schedule a bit (we will split the MMR, etc..) but he is in daycare and I am also responsible to make sure my child does not infect other children.

The stats of the CDC are clear. A lot of disease are resurfacing.

The main reason those diseases almost disappeared is because of vaccination. There are no reappearing because people are not vaccinating their children and we have move open borders. Traveling overseas with or without children, people from overseas visiting the US.

Posted 5/14/08 8:24 AM