Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted By Message
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Smiley

What if he simply makes an argument that he cannot serve people who do not speak English because not he or his employees can take a non-English order because they don't understand...? In my opinion, that would constitute a very fair argument, no?

And, based on my observation, he is not discriminating on the basis of race, color, etc, solely whether someone speaks English or not. Is there a law that spells out that that is illegal or is that interpretive as well?


His employees should be able to fill an order so long as the customer can point to an item on the menu. Customers shouldn't be required to speak English.

Discrimination on the basis of language (English only rules) is considered national origin discrimination.

Posted 6/13/06 11:53 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MrsS2005

Discrimination on the basis of language (English only rules) is considered national origin discrimination.

considered by you maybe, that's an opinion, not the law.

Posted 6/13/06 11:57 AM
 

Smiley
LIF Infant

Member since 6/06

83 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

At the risk of being argumentative... What if the menu is text only, no pictures? In trying to play devil's advocate, again, a fair argument. How do you really just communicate by pointing and smiling... Are we cavemen again? Why not just have the menu in hyroglyphics? This way no one gets offended...

Posted 6/13/06 11:59 AM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

You could theoretically post a sign that says "only people with blue eyes" and you could say you are not discriminating on the basis of race b/c it is only eye color. However, implicitly the sign discriminates on the basis of race b/c although there are exceptions, blue eyed people tend to be predominatly of a certain race.

Now this is just an example and albeit not a perfect one nor an exact parallel.

Posted 6/13/06 11:59 AM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by MrsS2005

Discrimination on the basis of language (English only rules) is considered national origin discrimination.

considered by you maybe, that's an opinion, not the law.


Really? The courts seem to think so too.

Posted 6/13/06 11:59 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by stickydust

First, universities (even historically black ones) cannot refuse to admit someone on the basis of race. They remain predominatly one race because that is the pool of applicants but they cannot refuse admission. there have been several court cases on this.

Secondly, if a man petitions to join a woman's only gym, there have been instances and cases where he has to be allowed. In making these decisions they balance the rights of a few and te rights of many.

Thirdly, in the instance at hand it is clearly discriminatory and any public accomodation does not have the right to refuse service on the basis of race, ethinicity, or national origin. This has been a long standing law. The issue at hand is whether the display of a sign rises to the leevl of denial of service. It may be construed as such in the same way a "whites only" sign would - in that the mere presence of the sign would cause sufficient intimidation.

Sorry so long - either way if this gets that far it will be up tp the courts to decide. Someone has to sue him first...



So is he being sued, or did someone just see it and complain? Also, would someone have to have been refused service in order to bring a suit against him, or could the mere presence fo the sign & the way it is displayed with the second sign constitute a valid complaint?

Sorry for all the questions, I am just curious as to how far this could go......

Message edited 2006-06-13 12:00:51.063000.

Posted 6/13/06 12:00 PM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Smiley

At the risk of being argumentative... What if the menu is text only, no pictures? In trying to play devil's advocate, again, a fair argument. How do you really just communicate by pointing and smiling... Are we cavemen again? Why not just have the menu in hyroglyphics? This way no one gets offended...



What about someone who is deaf/mute and can only communicate using sign language (it is techniacally a universal language and not english.

Posted 6/13/06 12:01 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by MrsS2005

Discrimination on the basis of language (English only rules) is considered national origin discrimination.

considered by you maybe, that's an opinion, not the law.


Really? The courts seem to think so too.

Chat Icon

If an Hispanic person came up, and ordered in English, and he refused service, than that would be discrimination based on national origin.

and here we are again... talking about a hypothetical, since he has NOT REFUSED SERVICE!

Posted 6/13/06 12:01 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by stickydust

First, universities (even historically black ones) cannot refuse to admit someone on the basis of race. They remain predominatly one race because that is the pool of applicants but they cannot refuse admission. there have been several court cases on this.

Secondly, if a man petitions to join a woman's only gym, there have been instances and cases where he has to be allowed. In making these decisions they balance the rights of a few and te rights of many.

Thirdly, in the instance at hand it is clearly discriminatory and any public accomodation does not have the right to refuse service on the basis of race, ethinicity, or national origin. This has been a long standing law. The issue at hand is whether the display of a sign rises to the leevl of denial of service. It may be construed as such in the same way a "whites only" sign would - in that the mere presence of the sign would cause sufficient intimidation.

Sorry so long - either way if this gets that far it will be up tp the courts to decide. Someone has to sue him first...



So is he being sued, or did someone just see it and complain? Also, would someone have to have been refused service in order to bring a suit against him, or could the mere presence fo the sign & the way it is displayed with the second sign constitute a valid complaint?


A complaint was filed although I think with an agency, not with the court. Depending on state law, discrimination complaints may have to be filed with state agencies first before filing them in court.

The argument is that the sign alone is enough to constitute discrimination.

Posted 6/13/06 12:02 PM
 

Smiley
LIF Infant

Member since 6/06

83 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by stickydust

You could theoretically post a sign that says "only people with blue eyes" and you could say you are not discriminating on the basis of race b/c it is only eye color. However, implicitly the sign discriminates on the basis of race b/c although there are exceptions, blue eyed people tend to be predominatly of a certain race.

Now this is just an example and albeit not a perfect one nor an exact parallel.



With all due respect, this is not a parallel, like you stated. Assuming your hypothetical would ever occur, eye color (for all intents and purposes) is not something people change to fit it, so to speak. They are born with it and that's that... Language is a completely different idea altogether and is fundamentally what our civilization is built on... the ability to communicate with each other. Eye color is nothing of the sort.

Posted 6/13/06 12:02 PM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by stickydust

First, universities (even historically black ones) cannot refuse to admit someone on the basis of race. They remain predominatly one race because that is the pool of applicants but they cannot refuse admission. there have been several court cases on this.

Secondly, if a man petitions to join a woman's only gym, there have been instances and cases where he has to be allowed. In making these decisions they balance the rights of a few and te rights of many.

Thirdly, in the instance at hand it is clearly discriminatory and any public accomodation does not have the right to refuse service on the basis of race, ethinicity, or national origin. This has been a long standing law. The issue at hand is whether the display of a sign rises to the leevl of denial of service. It may be construed as such in the same way a "whites only" sign would - in that the mere presence of the sign would cause sufficient intimidation.

Sorry so long - either way if this gets that far it will be up tp the courts to decide. Someone has to sue him first...



So is he being sued, or did someone just see it and complain? Also, would someone have to have been refused service in order to bring a suit against him, or could the mere presence fo the sign & the way it is displayed with the second sign constitute a valid complaint?

Sorry for all the questions, I am just curious as to how far this could go......



In order to bring a suit you have to have "standing" which means it has to have affected you or the potential to affect you in some way. So, supposedly the mere presence of the sign may be enough. But it is such a gray area as to standing that it will be an issue in and of itself in the courts. (unless the person was actually refused service - then it is clear they have standing)

Posted 6/13/06 12:04 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by MrsS2005

Discrimination on the basis of language (English only rules) is considered national origin discrimination.

considered by you maybe, that's an opinion, not the law.


Really? The courts seem to think so too.

Chat Icon

If an Hispanic person came up, and ordered in English, and he refused service, than that would be discrimination based on national origin.

and here we are again... talking about a hypothetical, since he has NOT REFUSED SERVICE!


National origin discrimination can be based on language or someone's place of birth. If the Hispanic person was refused service b/c he was Hispanic, it's national origin discrimination. If he's refused service b/c he doesn't speak English, this is also national origin discrimination.

Posted 6/13/06 12:04 PM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Smiley

Posted by stickydust

You could theoretically post a sign that says "only people with blue eyes" and you could say you are not discriminating on the basis of race b/c it is only eye color. However, implicitly the sign discriminates on the basis of race b/c although there are exceptions, blue eyed people tend to be predominatly of a certain race.

Now this is just an example and albeit not a perfect one nor an exact parallel.



With all due respect, this is not a parallel, like you stated. Assuming your hypothetical would ever occur, eye color (for all intents and purposes) is not something people change to fit it, so to speak. They are born with it and that's that... Language is a completely different idea altogether and is fundamentally what our civilization is built on... the ability to communicate with each other. Eye color is nothing of the sort.



you make a good point however, whether or not something can be changed is not the basis for determing a protected class.

Posted 6/13/06 12:06 PM
 

Smiley
LIF Infant

Member since 6/06

83 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

xx

Message edited 2006-06-13 12:10:26.090000.

Posted 6/13/06 12:08 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by MrsS2005

Discrimination on the basis of language (English only rules) is considered national origin discrimination.

considered by you maybe, that's an opinion, not the law.


Really? The courts seem to think so too.

Chat Icon

If an Hispanic person came up, and ordered in English, and he refused service, than that would be discrimination based on national origin.

and here we are again... talking about a hypothetical, since he has NOT REFUSED SERVICE!


National origin discrimination can be based on language or someone's place of birth. If the Hispanic person was refused service b/c he was Hispanic, it's national origin discrimination. If he's refused service b/c he doesn't speak English, this is also national origin discrimination.

it is not discrimination for a business to refuse service. every business has that right. sure, they have to have a good reason (like what if you aren’t dressed right or start cursing? They can throw you out)

why do you keep arguing this point when he has not refused service to anyone? If the sign said “we will only serve whites/blacks/etc” THAT is discrimination! Not “speak English when ordering”

it is clear you disagree with the sign, so do I. but until he actually DOES discriminate, it's moot point to continue this.

Message edited 2006-06-13 12:10:55.510000.

Posted 6/13/06 12:10 PM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

My entire family came from Italy (parents included). They learned the language and YES they have accents. Having accents or not knowing the english language doesnt make a person less smarter than the person who does speak english. My father made a great career for himself and supported my family very well. Huge accomplishment for someone who came to US not knowing one word of english!
My grandparents speak very little english, BUT they get by when necessary. They have the same rights that I do...I t would break my heart if they were refused as a customer....

Message edited 2006-06-13 12:17:45.223000.

Posted 6/13/06 12:13 PM
 

Pebbles
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/05

531 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Regardless of whether it is right or wrong he is getting a whole lot of free advertising!

Posted 6/13/06 12:17 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by MrsS2005

Discrimination on the basis of language (English only rules) is considered national origin discrimination.

considered by you maybe, that's an opinion, not the law.


Really? The courts seem to think so too.

Chat Icon

If an Hispanic person came up, and ordered in English, and he refused service, than that would be discrimination based on national origin.

and here we are again... talking about a hypothetical, since he has NOT REFUSED SERVICE!


National origin discrimination can be based on language or someone's place of birth. If the Hispanic person was refused service b/c he was Hispanic, it's national origin discrimination. If he's refused service b/c he doesn't speak English, this is also national origin discrimination.

it is not discrimination for a business to refuse service. every business has that right. sure, they have to have a good reason (like what if you aren’t dressed right or start cursing? They can throw you out)

why do you keep arguing this point when he has not refused service to anyone? If the sign said “we will only serve whites/blacks/etc” THAT is discrimination! Not “speak English when ordering”

it is clear you disagree with the sign, so do I. but until he actually DOES discriminate, it's moot point to continue this.


My comments were directed at yours and since you used the example of refusing service, I discussed that.

It is discrimination to refuse service on the basis of sex, race, national origin, etc. You believe the sign is not discrimination, but I do. IMO, this sign is enough to constitute discrimination. He doesn't actually have to refuse service in order to discriminate. The sign turns away business.

Posted 6/13/06 12:19 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Pebbles

Regardless of whether it is right or wrong he is getting a whole lot of free advertising!

Chat Icon that's what I'm thinking too!
so much for him losing business b/c of the sign

Message edited 2006-06-13 12:23:07.860000.

Posted 6/13/06 12:22 PM
 

Pebbles
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/05

531 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by Pebbles

Regardless of whether it is right or wrong he is getting a whole lot of free advertising!

Chat Icon that's what I'm thinking too!
so much for him losing business b/c of the sign



He's not that stupid now, is he?

Posted 6/13/06 12:24 PM
 

Eva Luna
Be kind...life's hard!

Member since 8/05

4750 total posts

Name:
God, bless & heal my DH, JenG's DH Rob & DebG

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Bella11

My entire family came from Italy (parents included). They learned the language and YES they have accents. Having accents or not knowing the english language doesnt make a person less smarter than the person who does speak english. My father made a great career for himself and supported my family very well. Huge accomplishment for someone who came to US not knowing one word of english!
My grandparents speak very little english, BUT they get by when necessary. They have the same rights that I do...I t would break my heart if they were refused as a customer....


Thank you for posting from a non-Hispanics POV. Sadly though, it seems that this is more one sided than not. But yes, will those who have thick accents be refused service as well? Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/13/06 12:24 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

To go back to a few pages ago...if someone postss a whites only sign, but says they will still serve to people of other races, the effect is the same. the sign is there

Posted 6/13/06 12:26 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

i think the owner is a jackass for putting up that sign. will he lose business? most likely, no, my boycott would do no good, i'm in ny and have never been to philly.

he's within his rights, imo. stupid, but within his rights

Posted 6/13/06 12:26 PM
 

MrsPornStar
Partners in crime

Member since 10/05

14656 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by DMcK

Posted by girlygrl33

Did this come after President Bushes speech on immigration where he said all imigrants have to learn English this is America. I wonder if he is using this- difference is they are working here Chat Icon

Its freakin FOOD- how low can someone be so low! My grandmother is an American Citizen, she is Puerto Rican and her English is broken so if my grandma was hungry and had American money and she couldnt pronounce or order her food correctly they wont serve her?
He should def be closed down!



Totally hear you! When my grandparents immigrated here, they were in their late 30s and had never even studied English. They speak very broken English but are US citizens. What happens to all the people like them? They are as American as you or I.



I completely agree. My grandmother to this day still tries to learn English. She is now a US citizen and is proud to be one. She speaks with an accent and in broken English but is proud to be an American now. Her English is not great but she tried to speak it everywhere, especially in stores.

Posted 6/13/06 12:27 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

has it been posted that english is the hardest language to learn? i thing that if you live here, you should try, but i've lived here my whole life and i'd probably fail a english grammar test

Posted 6/13/06 12:29 PM
 
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
YUMMY WW 2 PT SNACK ALERT!! Repost..cause I posted on the wrong board... Cookiegobbler 1/23/06 10 Diet & Fitness
OK, I need honest opinions. Am I wrong? (VERY long) Scotty-CassidysMom 1/8/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Am I feeding Kevin Wrong? Veggies? Maximum amount of formula per day? MM2004 12/6/05 1 Parenting
I have a number that is a wrong number but it is restricted how can i call this person back luvsbob4603 11/15/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
i knw i am sensitive b/c i just had a DNc but this is whast so wrong with twh worlkd sometimes... 04bride 11/9/05 11 Pregnancy
i want ask you all something and let me know if you agree or am i wrong luvsbob4603 8/24/05 8 Families Helping Families ™