Re: Do YOU see anything wrong with this?
Posted 6/13/2006 12:06:05 PM by stickydust


Posted by Smiley


Posted by stickydust

You could theoretically post a sign that says "only people with blue eyes" and you could say you are not discriminating on the basis of race b/c it is only eye color. However, implicitly the sign discriminates on the basis of race b/c although there are exceptions, blue eyed people tend to be predominatly of a certain race.

Now this is just an example and albeit not a perfect one nor an exact parallel.



With all due respect, this is not a parallel, like you stated. Assuming your hypothetical would ever occur, eye color (for all intents and purposes) is not something people change to fit it, so to speak. They are born with it and that's that... Language is a completely different idea altogether and is fundamentally what our civilization is built on... the ability to communicate with each other. Eye color is nothing of the sort.



you make a good point however, whether or not something can be changed is not the basis for determing a protected class.
Print Post      Close Window