Discipline vent..

Posted By Message

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Discipline vent..

My DS is almost 16 months. My twin nephews are older by 5 months, they will be 2 in March. Today we were at my SIL's house for Thanksgiving and one of my nephews was trying to pull away a book from my DS that my DH was reading to him. My DH told him "no, you go get a book over there" and pointed, etc. His mother (my SIL) just watched. After a few minutes she echoed what my DH said and told him to go get another book. My nephew continued whining and grabbing for the book even though he wasn't getting it, and finally threw himself on the floor in a full-on tantrum. My SIL sat there and did NOTHING. She just watched. So my DH said to him, "I said NO, go get another book, etc. (My SIL is a single mom - there is no dad in the picture). So my SIL pipes up and says "oh you know, it's normal for them to throw tantrums at this age" and walks away Chat Icon Chat Icon My DH and I looked at each other and said - yea it may be normal but it doesn't mean you don't teach them to share or say no, etc. My DS is younger than the twins and knows this. I just couldn't believe she was like eh - no big deal. She never tells them no or to share, take turns etc. Never!! Chat Icon

Posted 11/25/10 9:56 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Discipline vent..

It sounds like your nephew needs some discipline, but I think ignoring a tantrum and walking away is appropriate.

Posted 11/25/10 10:20 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Discipline vent..

I'm going to play devil's advocate here and say that maybe she felt your DH handled it and didn't want to undermine him. And as far as ignoring the tantrum, I would have done the same thing. Just another point of view from the outside.

Posted 11/25/10 10:25 PM
 

lbride
Lovin' my mini man!

Member since 3/07

2475 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Discipline vent..

sounds pretty typical of two year old behavior to be honest..she could've tried to reason with him etc but it probably would have had the same end result

Message edited 2010-11-25 22:27:18.300000.

Posted 11/25/10 10:26 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Discipline vent..

Posted by BaroqueMama

I'm going to play devil's advocate here and say that maybe she felt your DH handled it and didn't want to undermine him. And as far as ignoring the tantrum, I would have done the same thing. Just another point of view from the outside.



ITA.


I'm jealous, too, that your DS knows what No means. I'm pretty sure that DD (who is 15 and a half months old) thinks that "No" means, "I need to do this fast and as often as possible." Chat Icon At least, that's what her actions translate into. Chat Icon

Posted 11/25/10 10:30 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Discipline vent..

Posted by BaroqueMama

I'm going to play devil's advocate here and say that maybe she felt your DH handled it and didn't want to undermine him. And as far as ignoring the tantrum, I would have done the same thing. Just another point of view from the outside.



This def. could be true. If Jack is acting up with someone in my family I let them handle it, and then step in if he hasn't apologized for what he did.

Or maybe she was overwhelmed with hosting. I know that I'm more laid back with the boys when I have people over because I'm dealing with the craziness of cooking, cleaning etc.

Just some thoughts! Either way - I'm sure it was really annoying!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/25/10 10:31 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: Discipline vent..

i don't know them at all, but i also wondered whether there was any chance she didn't say anything because she thought your DH was handling and wanted to respect that. if i see someone in family who i am ok with disciplining my child disciplining her, i often will stay quiet because i want my daughter to listen to and respect them as well, and I dont want to undermine.

Also- ignoring tantrums (to a certain extent) can be appropriate. and her saying it's normal--she might have been embarrassed.

again- you know her better so i could be totally off--just trying to give the benefit of the doubt

Posted 11/25/10 10:46 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Discipline vent..



Seems like your DH was handling it and her son started having a tantrum. He was told no, he didnt seem to understand that or want to stop. I probably would have ignored it as well. Sometimes you cant talk to them or rationalize with them

I dont think she did anything wrong

Posted 11/25/10 10:55 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Discipline vent..

ignoring a tantrum is the best way to handle it, at that point the kid is not going to care what you are saying. pllus they are twins and have to fight for everything, I know my nephews are twins and 2 years older than DS , the 3 of them are always fightingChat Icon I stay out of it and my DS holds his own against them Chat Icon

Posted 11/26/10 1:18 AM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: Discipline vent..

I sympathize with youChat Icon My nephew is a hand full (he's 5 1/2) and is NEVER disciplined. He gets away with everything(always has since he was a baby). He is so mean to my DS (and everyone else-but mostly him) and my SIL and BIL just stand thereChat Icon When he throws screaming/crying temper tantrums, they just say your a baby, look how your cousin (my DS) is a big boy and how good he is. Yea that's really going to make him be nicer to my DS Chat Icon They feel b/c he acts immature, its OK for him to be like that. My DH's whole family is fed up with they lack of discipline this kid has had. Maybe if they started teaching him when he was 1-2 yrs, he wouldn't be so mean. I know people are saying well if someone else is disciplining, it's OK for the parents to be hands off and sometimes it is. BUT honestly, your SIL could have atleast said no we dont do that. I dont care what age they are, you can still try to teach your DC whats right and whats wrong. If my DS acted up even if someone else says something to him, me and my DH would always get involved, both to help the other person and also my child (what if someone is disciplining them in a way we are not comfortable with?) I dont rely on others to teach my kid whats acceptable behavior of not. Good luckChat Icon Glad your DH atleast tried to say something to your nephew
ETA- I do agree with walking away and ignoring a temper tantrum, but your SIL could have been a little bit more pro-active before he got to that point

Message edited 2010-11-26 01:48:48.700000.

Posted 11/26/10 1:47 AM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Discipline vent..

Posted by bayla

I sympathize with youChat Icon My nephew is a hand full (he's 5 1/2) and is NEVER disciplined. He gets away with everything(always has since he was a baby). He is so mean to my DS (and everyone else-but mostly him) and my SIL and BIL just stand thereChat Icon When he throws screaming/crying temper tantrums, they just say your a baby, look how your cousin (my DS) is a big boy and how good he is. Yea that's really going to make him be nicer to my DS Chat Icon They feel b/c he acts immature, its OK for him to be like that. My DH's whole family is fed up with they lack of discipline this kid has had. Maybe if they started teaching him when he was 1-2 yrs, he wouldn't be so mean. I know people are saying well if someone else is disciplining, it's OK for the parents to be hands off and sometimes it is. BUT honestly, your SIL could have atleast said no we dont do that. I dont care what age they are, you can still try to teach your DC whats right and whats wrong. If my DS acted up even if someone else says something to him, me and my DH would always get involved, both to help the other person and also my child (what if someone is disciplining them in a way we are not comfortable with?) I dont rely on others to teach my kid whats acceptable behavior of not. Good luckChat Icon Glad your DH atleast tried to say something to your nephew
ETA- I do agree with walking away and ignoring a temper tantrum, but your SIL could have been a little bit more pro-active before he got to that point



ITA 100000%

Posted 11/26/10 5:34 AM
 

MrsPowers
So blessed!

Member since 11/06

10348 total posts

Name:
Ivelysse

Re: Discipline vent..

Oh Jen I am so sorry about this. I totally understand your point. Tommy understands "no" because he is taught it. Your nephews may not. It is so frustrating and I do understand because I know how your SIL is. Chat Icon

Posted 11/26/10 6:39 AM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Discipline vent..

Posted by bayla


ETA- I do agree with walking away and ignoring a temper tantrum, but your SIL could have been a little bit more pro-active before he got to that point



I agree with this!

I'm on the fence since I know how your SIL is first hand! Samantha is the same age as your nephews (a month older), but as you saw last week, she is the same way. And there were many times at our GTG that I just sat and watched her temper tantrum away. We DO discipline and she has consequenses for her actions. While I do think your SIL saw that DH was handling the situation, she took that as yet another excuse NOT to look after her boys.

And I wish Tommy would teach Samantha what NO really means!

Posted 11/26/10 8:48 AM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: Discipline vent..

Posted by MrsRbk

Posted by bayla


ETA- I do agree with walking away and ignoring a temper tantrum, but your SIL could have been a little bit more pro-active before he got to that point



I agree with this!

I'm on the fence since I know how your SIL is first hand! Samantha is the same age as your nephews (a month older), but as you saw last week, she is the same way. And there were many times at our GTG that I just sat and watched her temper tantrum away. We DO discipline and she has consequenses for her actions. While I do think your SIL saw that DH was handling the situation, she took that as yet another excuse NOT to look after her boys.

And I wish Tommy would teach Samantha what NO really means!



I was telling Brett yesterday how cute Tommy was telling Riley NO when she went for Brett's rock band guitars!Chat Icon What a good boy!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Knowing your SIL from the stories you've told me, she seems to have a lackadaisical approach to discipline and parenting in general. Hopefully they'll learn it somewhere!Chat Icon

Posted 11/26/10 9:15 AM
 

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Re: Discipline vent..

Thanks for the feedback..what bothered me was her response, not that she ignored the tantrum. I ignore my DS's tantrums too sometimes. But i wouldn't completely ignore him if he was pulling a book out of another child's hands..gotta start somewhere to try and teach them right from wrong, and to share.

Posted 11/26/10 9:51 PM
 

Karma
LIF Infant

Member since 9/10

201 total posts

Name:

Re: Discipline vent..

Posted by BaroqueMama

I'm going to play devil's advocate here and say that maybe she felt your DH handled it and didn't want to undermine him. And as far as ignoring the tantrum, I would have done the same thing. Just another point of view from the outside.



I agree with this. Tantrums are very normal for a 21 month old and ignoring it is really the best thing to do. She did exactly what I would have done.

Posted 11/26/10 10:27 PM
 

Karma
LIF Infant

Member since 9/10

201 total posts

Name:

Re: Discipline vent..

Posted by CaseyGirl

Thanks for the feedback..what bothered me was her response, not that she ignored the tantrum. I ignore my DS's tantrums too sometimes. But i wouldn't completely ignore him if he was pulling a book out of another child's hands..gotta start somewhere to try and teach them right from wrong, and to share.



But wasn't your DH already doing that? Like BaroqueMama pointed out, maybe he said something before she could and she didn't want to undermine him. Plus, she did repeat what he said a few minutes later, and kids that age respond well to consistency.

ETA: From reading the other posts it seems that this is an ongoing issue with your SIL. Maybe next time you and your DH could take a different approach and see if that works, something like "Here DS, let's read this book instead because Cousin hasn't learned how to share/play nicely yet." Put the onus on her.

Message edited 2010-11-26 22:32:51.663000.

Posted 11/26/10 10:29 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Discipline vent..

At 2, ignoring the tantrum is really the best thing. Trying to discipline him or talking about what he didn't do right while he's losing his mind just doesn't work, so I don't think she did the wrong thing here. Trying to teach him how to share while he's having a tantrum is even more futile. Most kids don't get sharing at that age. Not that she shouldn't talk about it with him later, but in the moment, it's pretty useless.

As far as not saying something before the tantrum, I agree with others--she may have felt your DH handled it and why step in at that point? She may have been busy hosting also--I know I pay less attention to DS when I'm hosting.

I'd cut her some slack--none of this is terrible one time. I guess if she never steps in, then she may not be doing her part as a parent, but on a holiday, things get wacky with a 2 year old.

Message edited 2010-11-27 09:40:18.413000.

Posted 11/27/10 9:38 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
MY American Idol Vent Redhead 5/26/05 41 Families Helping Families ™
I need to vent alittle Tany 5/24/05 16 Families Helping Families ™
vent! janet 5/23/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
MIni-Vent----Nobody ever comes out here!!!!!!! Holly 5/20/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
peasant skirts - mini vent! Jax430 5/15/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
I have to vent...... MsMBV 5/13/05 7 Families Helping Families ™