dilemma

Posted By Message

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

dilemma

I am having a baby naming for my daughter. Heres the problem...we want to have godparents...however...my brother and sister n law have been awesome to my daughter. DHs sister has yet to ask about her, came in and left without seeing her, and now responded no to the baby naming. Ummm...hello...this is your neice!?! well anyhow, if we make my bro and sisnlaw godparents we will be pissing off his family and I also dont want ANY of my future kids to have her as their godparents to them since she lacks interest in my child. She has been VERY jealous of her bro and lacks any commitment in her own life. I keep thinking which one is more important...what the right thing to do for my child is or how to keep peace. Has anyone been in this situation? If so how did you handle it? TIA

Posted 1/13/07 7:45 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JTK
my 4 boys!

Member since 6/06

7396 total posts

Name:
Kristi

Re: dilemma

in my opinion, who cares what's right for the family or who you might piss off! what's right for your DD and for you and your husband. pick the ones you feel most suited for the job!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/13/07 8:15 PM
 

NJmom
.

Member since 8/05

4987 total posts

Name:

Re: dilemma

that's a tough situation, but personally, i'm for doing what's best for your child and not what will make others happy. certain of our family members are not happy with some of the decisons that we've made, but i'm happy that we've done what is right for us and our family. i also would never want someone to be a godparent to one of my children if they showed no interest in my child and didn't come to see him/her. and to not even come to the baby naming, how could you expect to be involved?

Posted 1/13/07 8:21 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: dilemma

I think it's an honor to be named a godparent - and because of that you honor who you feel best would guide your child in the religion you choose. For that reason alone, go with brother & SIL over sister. If it was really important to be a godparent, she should have acted liked one. I wouldn't rule her out for the future because you never know what place she was in, but for DD opt for the ones that you know will be there for her.

HTH.Chat Icon

Posted 1/13/07 8:53 PM
 

Samlove

Member since 5/05

4729 total posts

Name:
Shari

Re: dilemma

I would not ask anyone not interested or that shows lack of interest. You might want to check with the Rabbi anyway because Iknow with my daughter there were no godparents . We only had godparents with my son at his bris

Posted 1/13/07 8:55 PM
 

Ladybugz
LIF Toddler

Member since 12/06

451 total posts

Name:
Laurie

Re: dilemma

Posted by nrthshgrl

I think it's an honor to be named a godparent - and because of that you honor who you feel best would guide your child in the religion you choose. For that reason alone, go with brother & SIL over sister. If it was really important to be a godparent, she should have acted liked one. I wouldn't rule her out for the future because you never know what place she was in, but for DD opt for the ones that you know will be there for her.

Amen!

Posted 1/13/07 9:37 PM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: dilemma

Pick who you want. I choose my cousin as the godfather and my SIL as the godmother. I have 3 bothers and 1 sister. My sister I felt is to young (15) and I couldnt choose between my two brothers (the 3rd one is 10). They were a little upset but they got over it. I wouldnt worry about his family. If he is fine with it then that is enough.

Posted 1/14/07 9:42 AM
 

MommyofG
just the girls

Member since 5/05

9461 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: dilemma

we too had a lil dilema but you know what, we picked who we felt would be great godparents and that was my brother and stepsister. I know it must have hurt DH's sister but for now this is what we chose. For the next one we will see. Go with your gut and heart NOT out of obligation. Good luck as I know its tuff. Chat Icon

Posted 1/14/07 12:18 PM
 

michele31
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3372 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: dilemma

I would not feel bad at all. I would just not offer the information. Also, I don't think most baby namings have godparents....is that correct? If so, then doubt anyon will even wonder. If someone asks you just say "Yes, we have asked my brother and his wife" period. don't offer reasons or justify your decision.

Here is my thinking...someone's feelings will get hurt over godparent selection. I decide to do what is best for my child and let the adults worry about their own feelings.

Posted 1/14/07 12:53 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: dilemma

Posted by nrthshgrl

I think it's an honor to be named a godparent - and because of that you honor who you feel best would guide your child in the religion you choose. For that reason alone, go with brother & SIL over sister. If it was really important to be a godparent, she should have acted liked one. I wouldn't rule her out for the future because you never know what place she was in, but for DD opt for the ones that you know will be there for her.

HTH.Chat Icon



Agreed!!

Posted 1/14/07 1:03 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
My swing is broken... dilemma.. looking for opinions. -Laurie- 9/22/05 5 Parenting
A Dilemma...help! UPDATE below - more help needed 9/15 CaseyGirl 9/14/05 20 TTC
Dilemma! I need help quick! Dog related CaseyGirl 6/24/05 15 Families Helping Families ™
Dilemma, need your opinions. bee 3/21/06 8 Pregnancy
Ava's 1st birthday party - DILEMMA Please help! Denisemang 3/20/06 3 Parenting