Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

What do you think is the difference b/w being a person who is cheap vs being a person who is frugal?

Just curious people's thoughts on this.

For ex, someone who you know has $ and is not on a budget who would reuse something like tinfoil, instead of using a new sheet of tinfoil to wrap something. (They are not environmentally conscious so it's not that). So is this frugal or cheap in your opinion?

Posted 9/28/11 8:23 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

I would call your example frugal, not cheap.

"Cheap" is word I have always believed to have a negative connotation so as long as the action isn't unethical or hurtful in some way I won't call it cheap.

I will occasionally reuse foil because I feel like we empty the kitchen garbage every 10 minutes but that is not what you are talking about.Chat Icon

Posted 9/28/11 8:31 AM
 

PeasandCarrots
♥

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

To me frugal is having an understanding of money and knowing when and where to cut cornors. Cheap is not caring about what is right or having to argue with people over a check or money or the smallest things. Like figuring out how much each slice of pizza costs so you only pay for what you ate instead of splitting the whole pizza with someone. Or trying to get a good deal on a car, but once you get a good deal trying for an even better deal. Cheap boarders on rude IMHO.

Posted 9/28/11 8:35 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by medic6809

To me frugal is having an understanding of money and knowing when and where to cut cornors. Cheap is not caring about what is right or having to argue with people over a check or money or the smallest things. Like figuring out how much each slice of pizza costs so you only pay for what you ate instead of splitting the whole pizza with someone. Or trying to get a good deal on a car, but once you get a good deal trying for an even better deal. Cheap boarders on rude IMHO.



Good examples! I also think cheap can be used when it may be a health or safety hazard to do such and such, but the person only cares about saving $$$ (when again, they are not on a budget or short on $$).

Message edited 2011-09-28 09:00:21.613000.

Posted 9/28/11 8:39 AM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by medic6809

To me frugal is having an understanding of money and knowing when and where to cut cornors. Cheap is not caring about what is right or having to argue with people over a check or money or the smallest things. Like figuring out how much each slice of pizza costs so you only pay for what you ate instead of splitting the whole pizza with someone. Or trying to get a good deal on a car, but once you get a good deal trying for an even better deal. Cheap boarders on rude IMHO.



Well put! I agree with this.

Posted 9/28/11 8:41 AM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

I tend to think of frugal as the way people make careful decisions about their own money and how purchases will affect them, while being cheap usually means cutting corners in a way that is rude to others.

I know my definition isn't all encompassing, but it's at least part of the way I think of the difference.

Posted 9/28/11 8:44 AM
 

NASP09
...

Member since 6/05

6030 total posts

Name:

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by medic6809

To me frugal is having an understanding of money and knowing when and where to cut cornors. Cheap is not caring about what is right or having to argue with people over a check or money or the smallest things. Like figuring out how much each slice of pizza costs so you only pay for what you ate instead of splitting the whole pizza with someone. Or trying to get a good deal on a car, but once you get a good deal trying for an even better deal. Cheap boarders on rude IMHO.



Chat Icon

I was trying to think of a way to word this same idea, but you said it perfectly

Posted 9/28/11 8:58 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

My mother is NOT cheap by any means. She has the money to spend as she wishes but she is frugal, it is just her way. We went for pizza yesterday and she ordered a tap water. She does not see the point in paying $3 for a bottle of Poland Spring. But she is the same person who will treat whoever she is with to lunch and not think twice about it (granted she has the means to be generous).

Cheap to me somehow implies tacky, rude, it is off putting.

Frugal to me is thrifty & as I get older something I aspire to be! (as a teen I would have been embarrassed by being seen as frugal bc I did not differentiate bc cheap and frugal. )

Posted 9/28/11 9:19 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

I think frugal people watch how they spend dollars. Cheap people watch how they spend pennies.

Posted 9/28/11 9:19 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by DiamondGirl

Cheap to me somehow implies tacky, rude, it is off putting.




When I think of cheap, I am not really thinking rude b/c the things I think of aren't necessarily something that might effect others.

I think more so of foolish, unsafe, unsanitary, etc. Things that someone might do to save money but can have harmful consequences. Such as...you have the $$$ to get your car professionally fixed if something is wrong, but you try to find a way to do it yourself even though you really don't have expertise and it can compromise the safety of the car.

Or someone who eats coldcuts or food that's in the fridge that are ages old, just b/c they don't want it to go to waste. They risk their own health to save $$$ they aren't in dire need to save. That's more along the lines I see cheap as. Unless there is another word for this that I can't think of?

I guess I am thinking of cheap in regards to how someone spends their own money on themself, not so much in interacting with others.

Message edited 2011-09-28 09:29:40.143000.

Posted 9/28/11 9:28 AM
 

FirstMate
My lil cowboy

Member since 10/10

7790 total posts

Name:

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by medic6809

To me frugal is having an understanding of money and knowing when and where to cut cornors. Cheap is not caring about what is right or having to argue with people over a check or money or the smallest things. Like figuring out how much each slice of pizza costs so you only pay for what you ate instead of splitting the whole pizza with someone. Or trying to get a good deal on a car, but once you get a good deal trying for an even better deal. Cheap boarders on rude IMHO.



ITA

Posted 9/28/11 9:28 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by Goobster

Posted by DiamondGirl

Cheap to me somehow implies tacky, rude, it is off putting.




When I think of cheap, I am not really thinking rude b/c the things I think of aren't necessarily something that might effect others.

I think more so of foolish, unsafe, unsanitary, etc. Things that someone might do to save money but can have harmful consequences. Such as...you have the $$$ to get your car professionally fixed if something is wrong, but you try to find a way to do it yourself even though you really don't have expertise and it can compromise the safety of the car.

Or someone who eats coldcuts or food that's in the fridge that are ages old, just b/c they don't want it to go to waste. They risk their own health to save $$$ they aren't in dire need to save. That's more along the lines I see cheap as. Unless there is another word for this that I can't think of?

I guess I am thinking of cheap in regards to how someone spends their own money on themself, not so much in interacting with others.



YES! I agree with everything you said, very good points. Where I see it as rude is when you are with someone like this and they nickel and dime everything. Like if we went to McDonalds and ordered together and my meal was $4.99 and yours was $5.30 and you haggled me for the 31 cents....comes off as rude,kwim?

Message edited 2011-09-28 09:41:46.287000.

Posted 9/28/11 9:41 AM
 

MrsFrizzle
<3

Member since 9/09

4628 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by medic6809

To me frugal is having an understanding of money and knowing when and where to cut cornors. Cheap is not caring about what is right or having to argue with people over a check or money or the smallest things. Like figuring out how much each slice of pizza costs so you only pay for what you ate instead of splitting the whole pizza with someone. Or trying to get a good deal on a car, but once you get a good deal trying for an even better deal. Cheap boarders on rude IMHO.




I think that's worded perfectly.

Also for me frugal is when I try not to spend money that I don't have and be conservative and live within my means. Cheap to me can mean you have it but refuse to spend it for reasons other than you just not wanting to spend money.

Case in point for cheap - I have two cousins who once argued over who was going to drive to a family breakfast (they were siblings) because each didn't want to waste their gas (one is a broke college student the other has a very good career and makes good $$) what ended up happening??

My freaking grandma who has no money had to drive and use her gas bc they both refused to go and use their gas. They were going to drive a total of 5 miles each way, the situation still makes me mad. Chat Icon

Posted 9/28/11 10:05 AM
 

MySunshine
In love with my Baby Boy

Member since 3/11

2783 total posts

Name:

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by medic6809

To me frugal is having an understanding of money and knowing when and where to cut cornors. Cheap is not caring about what is right or having to argue with people over a check or money or the smallest things. Like figuring out how much each slice of pizza costs so you only pay for what you ate instead of splitting the whole pizza with someone. Or trying to get a good deal on a car, but once you get a good deal trying for an even better deal. Cheap boarders on rude IMHO.



Chat Icon

To the OP- in your example I call that cheap. It's tin foil you can use a different piece.

Posted 9/28/11 10:13 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by jkfris09

Case in point for cheap - I have two cousins who once argued over who was going to drive to a family breakfast (they were siblings) because each didn't want to waste their gas (one is a broke college student the other has a very good career and makes good $$) what ended up happening??

My freaking grandma who has no money had to drive and use her gas bc they both refused to go and use their gas. They were going to drive a total of 5 miles each way, the situation still makes me mad. Chat Icon



I would be mad for your grandma too.

I HAD a friend like that. And key word...had. I can't stand that kind of cheapness.

Message edited 2011-09-28 10:21:01.307000.

Posted 9/28/11 10:20 AM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

I agree that "cheap" implies either tacky/rude (like arguing over who drives the 5 miles to a breakfast) or potentially dangerous/foolish (like eating food that might be spoiled rather than toss it). Any other choices fall into the "frugal" category.

But I do have a pet peeve related to this. I hate when people comment negatively on a person who "has money" but is doing something frugal. Duh, why do you think they "have money" in the first place? Because they were frugal!

Posted 9/28/11 10:31 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

I look at frugal as making smart choices about spending. Using coupons. Using Store brands. Buying clothes in target- etc.

I look at cheap as being not generous- giving cheap gifts even if you could afford to give more, leaving bad tips when you can afford to leave more, etc.

Posted 9/28/11 10:36 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by computergirl

But I do have a pet peeve related to this. I hate when people comment negatively on a person who "has money" but is doing something frugal. Duh, why do you think they "have money" in the first place? Because they were frugal!



I agree with this. But there is a line that sometimes gets crossed when someone gets crazy over saving $$$ all the time.

Posted 9/28/11 10:37 AM
 

MrsFrizzle
<3

Member since 9/09

4628 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by Goobster

Posted by computergirl

But I do have a pet peeve related to this. I hate when people comment negatively on a person who "has money" but is doing something frugal. Duh, why do you think they "have money" in the first place? Because they were frugal!



I agree with this. But there is a line that sometimes gets crossed when someone gets crazy over saving $$$ all the time.



This bothers me too. I dont like when people judge how I spend my own money. If I choose to or not to buy clothes or shoes that's MY choice and not for anyone to judge. I think a line can get crossed over into cheap when it affects other people too like going out to dinner or doing something as a group.

Posted 9/28/11 10:52 AM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

IMO, your friend was being frugal. Frugal is not wasting $ and finding ways to be conservative with your $.

Cheap is stiffing someone on a gift when you have the means to give more, or being stingy for selfish reasons.

I have on numerous occasions watched my two aunts figure out exactly how many slices each person was going to eat before ordering pizza, and then figuring out how much each person owes... Down to the penny with tax & tip! It gets loud and takes 45 minutes! This is CHEAP. It's not lobster, it's pizza... Just split the cost evenly!

Posted 9/28/11 12:08 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by medic6809

To me frugal is having an understanding of money and knowing when and where to cut cornors. Cheap is not caring about what is right or having to argue with people over a check or money or the smallest things. Like figuring out how much each slice of pizza costs so you only pay for what you ate instead of splitting the whole pizza with someone. Or trying to get a good deal on a car, but once you get a good deal trying for an even better deal. Cheap boarders on rude IMHO.



So I am cheap because I don't want to pay for someone who ate more than me? I call the other person rude for taking advantage of me.

Frugal to me is having a budget, sticking to it, having priorities and not get diverted by impulse buys that would jeopardize that budget and/or financial goals.

Cheap to me is excessive behavior. In this instance, not everyone will agree. What someone sees as cheap might be normal behavior and being smart. It all depends!

Posted 9/28/11 12:09 PM
 

PeasandCarrots
&hearts;

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by smdl

Posted by medic6809

To me frugal is having an understanding of money and knowing when and where to cut cornors. Cheap is not caring about what is right or having to argue with people over a check or money or the smallest things. Like figuring out how much each slice of pizza costs so you only pay for what you ate instead of splitting the whole pizza with someone. Or trying to get a good deal on a car, but once you get a good deal trying for an even better deal. Cheap boarders on rude IMHO.



So I am cheap because I don't want to pay for someone who ate more than me? I call the other person rude for taking advantage of me.

Frugal to me is having a budget, sticking to it, having priorities and not get diverted by impulse buys that would jeopardize that budget and/or financial goals.

Cheap to me is excessive behavior. In this instance, not everyone will agree. What someone sees as cheap might be normal behavior and being smart. It all depends!



No i'm not implying you're cheap if you don't want to be taken advantage of, but in the pizza example I was being general. If we go out to dinner and you order a salad and I order a T-Bone I don't expect you to pay what I pay, but if we go out to have a pizza that we get with the intention of sharing and you calculate how much each slice is worth as to not pay more then you ate...that, IMHO, is cheap AND rude. I used that example because my uncle does that. There is a difference between being frugal, cheap, rude, and taking advantage of somebody and my example was not to bring anymore into it then the difference, IMHO of being cheap vs frugal.

Posted 9/28/11 1:21 PM
 

PeasandCarrots
&hearts;

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

To answer you OP some would say cheap some would say frugal. My Aunt and Uncle reuse plastic plates, plastic silverware, ziplock baggies, tinfoil, and whatever else they can wash and use again. I find it annoying not cheapor frugal, but they have millions and I have shitt so maybe I should follow their lead. Well that and calculate how much a slice of pizza isChat Icon

Posted 9/28/11 1:24 PM
 

Sheena
LIF Infant

Member since 3/07

264 total posts

Name:
queen of the jungle

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

Posted by Christine

I think frugal people watch how they spend dollars. Cheap people watch how they spend pennies.


This I really like.

Cheap to me is someone who nickels and dimes with friends and family. When wedine out regularly with 2 other couples, and we can eat and drink--appetizers, dessets, coffees, margaritas, cosmos, drinks, the works. We always just split the bill 3 ways. We'll NEVER say to each other, "You had the steak, and I had the pasta dish with chicken," because their company makes up for whatever extra we have to throw in. Some weeks we eat more than them, sometimes not.

But, one time we went to London Lennie's in Queens, and the other couple had lobsters. They automatically threw in extra because that's freaking expensive.

Ruining a friendship over a few dollars is not worth it. I hate people like that and we don't go out with them.

Posted 9/28/11 4:00 PM
 

babybeluga
LIF Adult

Member since 4/11

1148 total posts

Name:

Re: Difference between being frugal vs being cheap

so weird.... this EXACT topic came up in one of my classes today & I was trying to explain the difference to my students! what a coincidence! lol

Posted 9/28/11 4:02 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
The Difference Between Men & Women LadyMaravilla 6/29/05 12 Families Helping Families ™
What is the difference DebG 6/21/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
where can i buy a dehumidifier for cheap? raken40 6/21/05 1 Home
Cheap house in Seaford danielleandscott 6/16/05 21 Home
I dont know so Im asking whats the difference between TAD 6/3/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
Can someone help me understand the difference between.... maybride2004 5/22/05 4 TTC