Debate #2?

Posted By Message
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7

DumpsterBaby
My compass when I'm lost

Member since 5/11

2210 total posts

Name:
My anchor when I get tossed

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by MandJZ

The answer to gun violence is two married parents. Obviously.



If that doesn't stick, then lets blame "Fast and Furious" (which was part of "Operation Gunrunner" that began under Bush) was the cause of gun violence in the US.



a MAN AND WIFE married couple.

Posted 10/17/12 9:50 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Dani922

Posted by gdubs

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

Posted by MDF

Gas prices were not 1.85 in 2008. I can't remember the last time they were that low.



It was like 1.45 in 2002
in 2008, it was 4.10



Gas prices did go under $2.00 at some point in 2008 or 2009, I remember taking a picture at the pump and texting it to DH.



I remember this too, but I thought it was '09, but I could be wrong. Thing I'd like to point out tho is that in late 2004 I got my first car & license so I'll never forget that gas had just, for the first time, hit over $2/gallon. And it just kept going up from there. Bush was president then. Obama took office, it went down. Then started going back up again. If we're blaming the president for gas prices, at the most, Obama can be blamed for not KEEPING it down, but I can't see how to blame him for them rising in the first place? Bush would've done that. They went DOWN under Obama then no?



Gas prices skyrocketed in 2005, the day after hurricane Katrina hit. How convenient.

Gas prices have never been the same since.

Posted 10/17/12 9:55 AM
 

gdubs
This baby is awesome!

Member since 11/10

2467 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by ElizaRags35

I'm cracking up at some of these posts! Nitpicking on the pension comment when Romney flipped and flopped like a fish out of water (i.e. his comments on Pell Grants). I would love to know what some of your thoughts are on that! Also on how he still has not told us his plan? He talks about what he wants to do but he doesn't say how he wants to do it. His comments on gun control?



THANK YOU!!!!! Who cares how often he looks at HIS freakin pension. I want to know what he's going to do about everyone else's retirement. And not for anything the candidates were NOT supposed to directly address one another with questions... but I guess that rule didn't apply to Romney since he did it on more than one occasion.

Romney's answer to the gun control question was horrible. Did he really decide to alienate anyone who doesn't come from what is his views of what a family should be??? He completely avoided the question and turned it into something else. How is it the man will not answer a single question with anything of substance and there are people who refuse to admit that is what he has been doing since day one? He has NO plan. It is mathematically IMPOSSIBLE to do what he claims he will do with "teasers" of information he has dropped here and there. You can't fix the economy by cutting funding to PBS. They don't get THAT MUCH money. And I would bet my retirement that the man isn't going to cut any tax breaks that directly impact his bank account. You can't create jobs by cutting taxes for big business. It doesn't work that way. Just because a business has more money coming in that doesn't mean they are going to hire more people. If I am making $1m a year and have 10 employees and then start making $1.2m a year, if those employees are still doing the job that needs to be done I am not going to hire more people just because I'm making more because of tax cuts. Tax cuts don't equal an increase in production.

Posted 10/17/12 9:57 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by DiamondGirl


Posted by JennP

Everyone needs to read the transcript and look at Romney's plan for "reducing taxes to the middle class."

He stated explicitly that he plans on limiting itemized deductions. He threw out an admittedly arbitrary number of $25k but I wouldn't be surprised if it was a lot lower.

It's a safe cut for him to make because the metro areas with high taxes and home prices are not in his states anyway.

This could DEVASTATE the finances of LIers.

As a panacea, he then touts the benefit of people making under 200k not paying taxes on interest income, dividends or capital gains.

That's a f u c k ing joke and here's why:

Interest income - Have you seen your bank statements lately? It's a few dollars for most of us.

Capital gains - there is ALREADY a tax break on capital gains from home sales which is where middle class wealth is. There are requirements, but they're minimal. You have to live in the house for two years. When I sold my first house I profited 100k (those were the days) and kept every penny. ETA - also, I am pretty sure there is no income requirement for this tax break but I am not 100% on that.

Dividends - most middle class people are NOT worrying about their dividend income. It's minimal for most.

He is doing the middle class NO FAVORS here!!!!!






ALL OF THIS!

I don't know about other middle class/upper MC people but my DH and I NEED that money that we get bc of the deductions we are eligiable for. It is the difference bw us taking a vacation, making improvements on our home, getting another car. It is money that we and MOST middle class people put RIGHT BACK INTO THE ECONOMY.

Bottom line if you are wealthy then Romney serves your best interest.

If you are not (and most are NOT) then he does not.

I GET that people want to stimulate the economy and feel that Romney would be better fit to do that BUT know that that stimulation will come from hurting the majority (middle class). The healthcare/medicare/voucher program also scares the hell out of me.

I picture all the money we have saved for our children, for our vacations when we retire etc. going to my medical bills bc medicare and SS wont be there for us.

Romney is going to HURT US (by us I mean those of us who are not wealthy).

Sure I dont like that he will cut social programs, I dont like that he feels he should revoke womans medical choices (and all the other "crazy" liberal views I have, like the fact that women should have their contraception covered by insurance the same way VIAGRA IS) BUT ALL THAT ASIDE the overriding concern I have IS a selfish one, this man will make it so I have less money for my family, my son, and I cant fuckin have that!



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/17/12 9:59 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Debate #2?

Just to bring back the healthcare thing for a minute, because another thread was brought up to highlight the "problems with Obamacare", I wanted to point to this thread HEALTH INSURANCE COSTS to highlight the problems with the current system. Someone on there mentions paying over $11k a year in premiums....that is before copays etc. This, to me, is the problem with the current system. Not to mention that insurance companies can drop people at will.

Posted 10/17/12 10:01 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Debate #2?

Am I the only one wondering what Obama's plan is to cut taxes and decrease the deficit? He also has not given any examples of his "plans" so to me, that means more of the same which is NOT ok!

How will he decrease unemployment? How will he decrease the burden on the middle class? He is not proposing anything new so how will anything change? I do not remember receiving tax breaks as a middle class family the past two years?

Yes, we can all point at Romney and say "give examples, we want specifics" but HOW is Obama going to make changes to better the economy? More of the same is NOT the answer?

Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.

Last night was lame, I actually fell asleep like the dude in the first row. I will give Obama credit, he did decide to show up but no one won last night, I don't see last night swaying any non-decided votes in either direction.

Posted 10/17/12 10:03 AM
 

DumpsterBaby
My compass when I'm lost

Member since 5/11

2210 total posts

Name:
My anchor when I get tossed

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by gdubs

Posted by ElizaRags35

I'm cracking up at some of these posts! Nitpicking on the pension comment when Romney flipped and flopped like a fish out of water (i.e. his comments on Pell Grants). I would love to know what some of your thoughts are on that! Also on how he still has not told us his plan? He talks about what he wants to do but he doesn't say how he wants to do it. His comments on gun control?



THANK YOU!!!!! Who cares how often he looks at HIS freakin pension. I want to know what he's going to do about everyone else's retirement. And not for anything the candidates were NOT supposed to directly address one another with questions... but I guess that rule didn't apply to Romney since he did it on more than one occasion.

Romney's answer to the gun control question was horrible. Did he really decide to alienate anyone who doesn't come from what is his views of what a family should be??? He completely avoided the question and turned it into something else. How is it the man will not answer a single question with anything of substance and there are people who refuse to admit that is what he has been doing since day one? He has NO plan. It is mathematically IMPOSSIBLE to do what he claims he will do with "teasers" of information he has dropped here and there. You can't fix the economy by cutting funding to PBS. They don't get THAT MUCH money. And I would bet my retirement that the man isn't going to cut any tax breaks that directly impact his bank account. You can't create jobs by cutting taxes for big business. It doesn't work that way. Just because a business has more money coming in that doesn't mean they are going to hire more people. If I am making $1m a year and have 10 employees and then start making $1.2m a year, if those employees are still doing the job that needs to be done I am not going to hire more people just because I'm making more because of tax cuts. Tax cuts don't equal an increase in production.



Romney's whole "explanation" is to condescend and say, "Don't worry your pretty little heads about the specifics, just trust me."

Chat Icon

Posted 10/17/12 10:07 AM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: Debate #2?

Image Attachment(s):
Posted 10/17/12 10:07 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by JennP

Everyone needs to read the transcript and look at Romney's plan for "reducing taxes to the middle class."

He stated explicitly that he plans on limiting itemized deductions. He threw out an admittedly arbitrary number of $25k but I wouldn't be surprised if it was a lot lower.

It's a safe cut for him to make because the metro areas with high taxes and home prices are not in his states anyway.

This could DEVASTATE the finances of LIers.

As a panacea, he then touts the benefit of people making under 200k not paying taxes on interest income, dividends or capital gains.

That's a f u c k ing joke and here's why:

Interest income - Have you seen your bank statements lately? It's a few dollars for most of us.

Capital gains - there is ALREADY a tax break on capital gains from home sales which is where middle class wealth is. There are requirements, but they're minimal. You have to live in the house for two years. When I sold my first house I profited 100k (those were the days) and kept every penny. ETA - also, I am pretty sure there is no income requirement for this tax break but I am not 100% on that.

Dividends - most middle class people are NOT worrying about their dividend income. It's minimal for most.

He is doing the middle class NO FAVORS here!!!!!




this stuck out to me the most.

my husband is a TAX ACCOUNTANT. that is what he does, day in and day out, in NYC, LI and NJ. I shutter to think at all the boring tax papers he looks at 10 hours a day way too many days a year Chat Icon Chat Icon

he said he has seen TWO PEOPLE. TWO PEOPLE out of the hundreds he's personally handled and the thousands that his firm handles TWO people with capital gains, and on the them they still can't figure out how she did it Chat Icon Chat Icon

that was a red herring. OH look, we are keeping the capital gains but extending it to people who will quite probably never have any and this will basically be a tax wash for the middle class while we take away their actual tax breaks so my people can still pay less overall income tax than all you shmoes.

THAT is what I see. and that is what I hate. I don't give a flying fudge if you made 20 millions dollars a year. I am sure there is some work, some scheming, some awesome thing you are good at that allows for this to happen (I am not going to classify that as hard work b/c I also think that migrant farmers work pretty damned hard and make no where near that) but don't you DARE come and talk about taxes and helping the middle class when you are out to keep you and your boys richer. when your effective tax breaks have you paying LESS than I do. I work hard too. YOU work hard too.

don't talk to me about people who pay no income tax-who are TOO POOR to pay income tax-when our tax code allows for American corporations to make BILLIONS of dollars TAX FREE b/c they keep it off shore.

don't talk to me about the proposed Medicare voucher system, which would put seniors at the mercy of PUBLICALLY TRADED (IE, people can invest and they can get rich off of the savings these insurance companies make off of the people they are supposed to serve) Health Insurance companies.

we are being BAMBOOZLED people. given the crumbs from their table. enough is enough is enough.


ETA: his tax plan is not mathematically impossible. he is being vague b/c he KNOWS who is going to end up paying after his tax break pre-election shell game is over. if people are OK with this, then that is fine. but that is what it is.

Message edited 2012-10-17 10:11:10.733000.

Posted 10/17/12 10:07 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by maymama


Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.




This is exactly the problem that DH and I face. Reform for "middle class" does nothing for us because in comparison to the country as a WHOLE, we are apparently not middle class.

Posted 10/17/12 10:08 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by maymama


Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.




This is exactly the problem that DH and I face. Reform for "middle class" does nothing for us because in comparison to the country as a WHOLE, we are apparently not middle class.



But, if I'm not mistaken, according to what Romney keeps saying recently he is insisting he will NOT cut taxes for those who are above middle class. So...his supposed policies won't be much help either?

Posted 10/17/12 10:10 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by maymama


Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.




This is exactly the problem that DH and I face. Reform for "middle class" does nothing for us because in comparison to the country as a WHOLE, we are apparently not middle class.



don't worry sister, we are RICH! Filthy RICH I tell you! Chat Icon We are the 2%! Chat Icon I really was hoping that one of the questions last night had to do with this. This issue is not just on Long Island but in many other areas too. How come no one presses this issue?

Posted 10/17/12 10:12 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Goobster

Posted by rojerono

I don't think many - if any - undecided voters were swayed one way or the other over it.



The panel of undecided voters they showed after the debate, the focus group, majority felt Romney won.



And yet another poll shows Obama won

I guess what I'm saying is that my republican friends are crying victory all over FB & Twitter. My democratic friends are elated by Obama's performance.

And a lot of folks like me think it was a draw in most respects.

Obama DID do a lot better than the last time and I think Romney lost a bit of his momentum that he'd gained from the last debate.. but not enough for me to say there is one clear WINNER or LOSER in my own opinion.

Posted 10/17/12 10:15 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by maymama


Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.




This is exactly the problem that DH and I face. Reform for "middle class" does nothing for us because in comparison to the country as a WHOLE, we are apparently not middle class.



But, if I'm not mistaken, according to what Romney keeps saying recently he is insisting he will NOT cut taxes for those who are above middle class. So...his supposed policies won't be much help either?



RIGHT! That is my point. I live on Long Island - one of the most expensive places to live in the country. On PAPER, I am the top 2-3% (not considered middle class) but I want one of these guys to come to my home, look at my finances, my budget and tell me how I am NOT middle class! WE NEED those tax breaks on LI earning 200k per year. LI is NOT Kansas is NOT San Francisco, is NOT Wasilla, AK.

Posted 10/17/12 10:16 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by maymama

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by maymama


Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.




This is exactly the problem that DH and I face. Reform for "middle class" does nothing for us because in comparison to the country as a WHOLE, we are apparently not middle class.



But, if I'm not mistaken, according to what Romney keeps saying recently he is insisting he will NOT cut taxes for those who are above middle class. So...his supposed policies won't be much help either?



RIGHT! That is my point. I live on Long Island - one of the most expensive places to live in the country. On PAPER, I am the top 2-3% (not considered middle class) but I want one of these guys to come to my home, look at my finances, my budget and tell me how I am NOT middle class! WE NEED those tax breaks on LI earning 200k per year. LI is NOT Kansas is NOT San Francisco, is NOT Wasilla, AK.



it's the local taxes and costs that are killing you. fed govt can't help you there. they have to look national.

Posted 10/17/12 10:20 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by maymama


Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.




This is exactly the problem that DH and I face. Reform for "middle class" does nothing for us because in comparison to the country as a WHOLE, we are apparently not middle class.



But, if I'm not mistaken, according to what Romney keeps saying recently he is insisting he will NOT cut taxes for those who are above middle class. So...his supposed policies won't be much help either?



RIGHT! That is my point. I live on Long Island - one of the most expensive places to live in the country. On PAPER, I am the top 2-3% (not considered middle class) but I want one of these guys to come to my home, look at my finances, my budget and tell me how I am NOT middle class! WE NEED those tax breaks on LI earning 200k per year. LI is NOT Kansas is NOT San Francisco, is NOT Wasilla, AK.



it's the local taxes and costs that are killing you. fed govt can't help you there. they have to look national.



so because I fit into a certain mold or bracket, I am neglected (as are many, many others). There needs to be some compensation and forsight for situations like this. Looking national will hardly solve the problem.

Posted 10/17/12 10:26 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by maymama


Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.




This is exactly the problem that DH and I face. Reform for "middle class" does nothing for us because in comparison to the country as a WHOLE, we are apparently not middle class.



But, if I'm not mistaken, according to what Romney keeps saying recently he is insisting he will NOT cut taxes for those who are above middle class. So...his supposed policies won't be much help either?



That is what I took away from it, yes. However, while it may not help me, his plan wouldn't raise my taxes either. He was very clear that above-middle class would stay the same.

Posted 10/17/12 10:28 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by maymama

so because I fit into a certain mold or bracket, I am neglected (as are many, many others). There needs to be some compensation and forsight for situations like this. Looking national will hardly solve the problem.



you have your federal tax breaks but then you have to look locally. you just championed states rights in a post above mine, well that is where you have to look.

I think the cost just to own a piece of land on LI is ridiculous. I think the taxes are ridiculous. over priced. I think if people looked more for tax reform on the localized level, your playing field would be similar to those in other areas of the country.

it's not b/c you fit into a certain mold or bracket, it's b/c of where you choose to make your home. in an over taxed over priced area.

Posted 10/17/12 10:31 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by maymama


Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.




This is exactly the problem that DH and I face. Reform for "middle class" does nothing for us because in comparison to the country as a WHOLE, we are apparently not middle class.



But, if I'm not mistaken, according to what Romney keeps saying recently he is insisting he will NOT cut taxes for those who are above middle class. So...his supposed policies won't be much help either?



That is what I took away from it, yes. However, while it may not help me, his plan wouldn't raise my taxes either. He was very clear that above-middle class would stay the same.



he wouldn't change income tax rates.

but he did allude to tax breaks changing and THAT is the kicker.

does anyone on LI really want to say goodbye to the mortgage interest deduction? the dependent care dd?

those will mose assuredly be on the chopping block. he is going to change middle class deductions. it is not going to be pretty.

Posted 10/17/12 10:33 AM
 

nraboni
Uggh...

Member since 10/09

6905 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by DiamondGirl


Posted by JennP

Everyone needs to read the transcript and look at Romney's plan for "reducing taxes to the middle class."

He stated explicitly that he plans on limiting itemized deductions. He threw out an admittedly arbitrary number of $25k but I wouldn't be surprised if it was a lot lower.

It's a safe cut for him to make because the metro areas with high taxes and home prices are not in his states anyway.

This could DEVASTATE the finances of LIers.

As a panacea, he then touts the benefit of people making under 200k not paying taxes on interest income, dividends or capital gains.

That's a f u c k ing joke and here's why:

Interest income - Have you seen your bank statements lately? It's a few dollars for most of us.

Capital gains - there is ALREADY a tax break on capital gains from home sales which is where middle class wealth is. There are requirements, but they're minimal. You have to live in the house for two years. When I sold my first house I profited 100k (those were the days) and kept every penny. ETA - also, I am pretty sure there is no income requirement for this tax break but I am not 100% on that.

Dividends - most middle class people are NOT worrying about their dividend income. It's minimal for most.

He is doing the middle class NO FAVORS here!!!!!






ALL OF THIS!

I don't know about other middle class/upper MC people but my DH and I NEED that money that we get bc of the deductions we are eligiable for. It is the difference bw us taking a vacation, making improvements on our home, getting another car. It is money that we and MOST middle class people put RIGHT BACK INTO THE ECONOMY.

Bottom line if you are wealthy then Romney serves your best interest.

If you are not (and most are NOT) then he does not.

I GET that people want to stimulate the economy and feel that Romney would be better fit to do that BUT know that that stimulation will come from hurting the majority (middle class). The healthcare/medicare/voucher program also scares the hell out of me.

I picture all the money we have saved for our children, for our vacations when we retire etc. going to my medical bills bc medicare and SS wont be there for us.

Romney is going to HURT US (by us I mean those of us who are not wealthy).

Sure I dont like that he will cut social programs, I dont like that he feels he should revoke womans medical choices (and all the other "crazy" liberal views I have, like the fact that women should have their contraception covered by insurance the same way VIAGRA IS) BUT ALL THAT ASIDE the overriding concern I have IS a selfish one, this man will make it so I have less money for my family, my son, and I cant fuckin have that!



I Chat Icon both of the above posters statements. I was yelling at the TV...YELLING! And if I have to hear "5 point plan" one more time I think I may lose my shit.

Let's also not forget about his "Equal Opportunity" answer because he in so many words stated that we still live in the 50's where women need to be home to cook, clean and take care of their children and that is why they need a flexible schedule. Are you kidding me?!?!?! So a Woman's role in the workplace is to make sure she can have a flexible schedule to be Susie Homemaker? That's just as bad as his 47% comment.

Don't forget about his solution to Gun Control---Parents! But not just Parents, MARRIED Parents. He said that in order to have a child the parents should be married first.

This guy scares the crap out of me.

Posted 10/17/12 10:38 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

so because I fit into a certain mold or bracket, I am neglected (as are many, many others). There needs to be some compensation and forsight for situations like this. Looking national will hardly solve the problem.



you have your federal tax breaks but then you have to look locally. you just championed states rights in a post above mine, well that is where you have to look.

I think the cost just to own a piece of land on LI is ridiculous. I think the taxes are ridiculous. over priced. I think if people looked more for tax reform on the localized level, your playing field would be similar to those in other areas of the country.

it's not b/c you fit into a certain mold or bracket, it's b/c of where you choose to make your home. in an over taxed over priced area.



that was my whole point above. there is not a one size fits all solution. Why can't individual states have more say when it comes to fed taxes? I am middle class in NY, but maybe not in KS. How about tax breaks on middle class by state - lets look at the breakdown of earning BY STATE! This way, each individual state can better control the needs and spending on the state level.

Posted 10/17/12 10:39 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by maymama

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

so because I fit into a certain mold or bracket, I am neglected (as are many, many others). There needs to be some compensation and forsight for situations like this. Looking national will hardly solve the problem.



you have your federal tax breaks but then you have to look locally. you just championed states rights in a post above mine, well that is where you have to look.

I think the cost just to own a piece of land on LI is ridiculous. I think the taxes are ridiculous. over priced. I think if people looked more for tax reform on the localized level, your playing field would be similar to those in other areas of the country.

it's not b/c you fit into a certain mold or bracket, it's b/c of where you choose to make your home. in an over taxed over priced area.



that was my whole point above. there is not a one size fits all solution. Why can't individual states have more say when it comes to fed taxes? I am middle class in NY, but maybe not in KS. How about tax breaks on middle class by state - lets look at the breakdown of earning BY STATE! This way, each individual state can better control the needs and spending on the state level.



b/c the federal and state govts are separate entities as guided by the constitution.

there are some states that don't have a state income tax...Arizona and Florida are two that I can think of. so states DO have a say in the taxes you pay, just not the federal ones.

Posted 10/17/12 10:41 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

so because I fit into a certain mold or bracket, I am neglected (as are many, many others). There needs to be some compensation and forsight for situations like this. Looking national will hardly solve the problem.



you have your federal tax breaks but then you have to look locally. you just championed states rights in a post above mine, well that is where you have to look.

I think the cost just to own a piece of land on LI is ridiculous. I think the taxes are ridiculous. over priced. I think if people looked more for tax reform on the localized level, your playing field would be similar to those in other areas of the country.

it's not b/c you fit into a certain mold or bracket, it's b/c of where you choose to make your home. in an over taxed over priced area.



that was my whole point above. there is not a one size fits all solution. Why can't individual states have more say when it comes to fed taxes? I am middle class in NY, but maybe not in KS. How about tax breaks on middle class by state - lets look at the breakdown of earning BY STATE! This way, each individual state can better control the needs and spending on the state level.



b/c the federal and state govts are separate entities as guided by the constitution.

there are some states that don't have a state income tax...Arizona and Florida are two that I can think of. so states DO have a say in the taxes you pay, just not the federal ones.



maybe I am not making this clear, maybe I am not understanding. I just do not understand why the federal govenment does not take into account the cost of living when deciding income vs. tax bracket.

Posted 10/17/12 10:47 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by maymama


Also - someone needs to bring up the point that the US is NOT a one size fits all family. Take Long Island for instance. According to politicians, my husband and I are in the top 3% of income earners (some years, top 2% depending on my commision) yet we are constantly worried about how we will pay for daycare for child #2 when she arrives. We are NOT living large, we ALSO need tax breaks and help where help is given. We do NOT need tax increases. In a country where there is SO much diversity (i mean economical diversity) how can we have a one solution? This is where individual states rights are so important.




This is exactly the problem that DH and I face. Reform for "middle class" does nothing for us because in comparison to the country as a WHOLE, we are apparently not middle class.



But, if I'm not mistaken, according to what Romney keeps saying recently he is insisting he will NOT cut taxes for those who are above middle class. So...his supposed policies won't be much help either?



That is what I took away from it, yes. However, while it may not help me, his plan wouldn't raise my taxes either. He was very clear that above-middle class would stay the same.



he wouldn't change income tax rates.

but he did allude to tax breaks changing and THAT is the kicker.

does anyone on LI really want to say goodbye to the mortgage interest deduction? the dependent care dd?

those will mose assuredly be on the chopping block. he is going to change middle class deductions. it is not going to be pretty.



I don't think the outcome for us as a country is going to be pretty in the short-term, regardless of who is elected. I think things need to be done, sacrifices need to be made, to get us back on track as a nation for the betterment of not only our future, but that of future generations.

Posted 10/17/12 10:51 AM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Debate #2?

Posted by maymama

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

so because I fit into a certain mold or bracket, I am neglected (as are many, many others). There needs to be some compensation and forsight for situations like this. Looking national will hardly solve the problem.



you have your federal tax breaks but then you have to look locally. you just championed states rights in a post above mine, well that is where you have to look.

I think the cost just to own a piece of land on LI is ridiculous. I think the taxes are ridiculous. over priced. I think if people looked more for tax reform on the localized level, your playing field would be similar to those in other areas of the country.

it's not b/c you fit into a certain mold or bracket, it's b/c of where you choose to make your home. in an over taxed over priced area.



that was my whole point above. there is not a one size fits all solution. Why can't individual states have more say when it comes to fed taxes? I am middle class in NY, but maybe not in KS. How about tax breaks on middle class by state - lets look at the breakdown of earning BY STATE! This way, each individual state can better control the needs and spending on the state level.



b/c the federal and state govts are separate entities as guided by the constitution.

there are some states that don't have a state income tax...Arizona and Florida are two that I can think of. so states DO have a say in the taxes you pay, just not the federal ones.



maybe I am not making this clear, maybe I am not understanding. I just do not understand why the federal govenment does not take into account the cost of living when deciding income vs. tax bracket.



What I'm understanding from Ophelia's explanation is that the federal government ONLY determines federal taxes, which are the same for everyone (because people move around, etc. they can't factor in cost of living). The states determine other taxes and those ARE supposed to factor in cost of living - but the federal government has very little to do with that.

Posted 10/17/12 10:51 AM
 
Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Settle the debate: What is the difference between ignorance and stupidity? BigB 12/1/06 20 Families Helping Families ™
The great name debate. What do you think? snuggleupagus 11/26/06 3 Pregnancy
steroid question-DH and I are in a heated debate! apb17 11/14/06 3 Pregnancy
I dont want to start a debate but I want to survey the Girls on this board juju 8/7/06 17 Infertility
Clothes under copyright? Another knockoff debate. baghag 3/30/06 16 Families Helping Families ™
Should be on recipes, but DH and I are having a debate! MissJones 3/16/06 7 Families Helping Families ™