Re: Debate #2?
Posted 10/17/2012 10:07:55 AM by Ophelia


Posted by JennP

Everyone needs to read the transcript and look at Romney's plan for "reducing taxes to the middle class."

He stated explicitly that he plans on limiting itemized deductions. He threw out an admittedly arbitrary number of $25k but I wouldn't be surprised if it was a lot lower.

It's a safe cut for him to make because the metro areas with high taxes and home prices are not in his states anyway.

This could DEVASTATE the finances of LIers.

As a panacea, he then touts the benefit of people making under 200k not paying taxes on interest income, dividends or capital gains.

That's a f u c k ing joke and here's why:

Interest income - Have you seen your bank statements lately? It's a few dollars for most of us.

Capital gains - there is ALREADY a tax break on capital gains from home sales which is where middle class wealth is. There are requirements, but they're minimal. You have to live in the house for two years. When I sold my first house I profited 100k (those were the days) and kept every penny. ETA - also, I am pretty sure there is no income requirement for this tax break but I am not 100% on that.

Dividends - most middle class people are NOT worrying about their dividend income. It's minimal for most.

He is doing the middle class NO FAVORS here!!!!!




this stuck out to me the most.

my husband is a TAX ACCOUNTANT. that is what he does, day in and day out, in NYC, LI and NJ. I shutter to think at all the boring tax papers he looks at 10 hours a day way too many days a year Chat Icon Chat Icon

he said he has seen TWO PEOPLE. TWO PEOPLE out of the hundreds he's personally handled and the thousands that his firm handles TWO people with capital gains, and on the them they still can't figure out how she did it Chat Icon Chat Icon

that was a red herring. OH look, we are keeping the capital gains but extending it to people who will quite probably never have any and this will basically be a tax wash for the middle class while we take away their actual tax breaks so my people can still pay less overall income tax than all you shmoes.

THAT is what I see. and that is what I hate. I don't give a flying fudge if you made 20 millions dollars a year. I am sure there is some work, some scheming, some awesome thing you are good at that allows for this to happen (I am not going to classify that as hard work b/c I also think that migrant farmers work pretty damned hard and make no where near that) but don't you DARE come and talk about taxes and helping the middle class when you are out to keep you and your boys richer. when your effective tax breaks have you paying LESS than I do. I work hard too. YOU work hard too.

don't talk to me about people who pay no income tax-who are TOO POOR to pay income tax-when our tax code allows for American corporations to make BILLIONS of dollars TAX FREE b/c they keep it off shore.

don't talk to me about the proposed Medicare voucher system, which would put seniors at the mercy of PUBLICALLY TRADED (IE, people can invest and they can get rich off of the savings these insurance companies make off of the people they are supposed to serve) Health Insurance companies.

we are being BAMBOOZLED people. given the crumbs from their table. enough is enough is enough.


ETA: his tax plan is not mathematically impossible. he is being vague b/c he KNOWS who is going to end up paying after his tax break pre-election shell game is over. if people are OK with this, then that is fine. but that is what it is.
Print Post      Close Window