DC's room- carpet or wood?

Posted By Message

RSB34
LIF Toddler

Member since 9/11

453 total posts

Name:

DC's room- carpet or wood?

We are having a second DC and moving DD out of the nursery and into the spare room. There is currently carpet in there but we never changed it or cleaned it since moving in. Should we put carpet in or wood? The nursery is wood, which is great but this will be dd's room for a long time. Carpet is more "homey" imo but maybe wood is still better? We can always get an area rug? What do you have??

Message edited 2011-12-30 09:45:30.820000.

Posted 12/30/11 9:44 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

I prefer carpet

Posted 12/30/11 9:44 AM
 

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

I'm having the same issue. We are moving DS1 to a big boy room soon. It has wood floors, but not 100% finished.

DH doesn't want carpet b/c he's still young and can get sick on them. I love carpet b/c it's soft and warms the room.

I think we're getting carpet.

Can you rip it up and get new carpet?

Posted 12/30/11 10:01 AM
 

Kim7706
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

1233 total posts

Name:
Kimberly

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

We have hard wood floors in DS room....and an area rug.

Posted 12/30/11 10:16 AM
 

RSB34
LIF Toddler

Member since 9/11

453 total posts

Name:

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

Posted by EricaAlt

I'm having the same issue. We are moving DS1 to a big boy room soon. It has wood floors, but not 100% finished.

DH doesn't want carpet b/c he's still young and can get sick on them. I love carpet b/c it's soft and warms the room.

I think we're getting carpet.

Can you rip it up and get new carpet?



We have to rip it up either way- the carpet in there is gross- so once we rip it up we don't know if we should put a new carpet down or fix the wood underneath (that is gross too)! cost wise I don't think it makes a huge difference. I prefer carpet, DH prefers wood, but DD will still be young and I'm afraid with vomit or an explosion while potty training or something Chat Icon that said, I love carpet

Posted 12/30/11 10:28 AM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

Wood. Carpet (especially new) is one of the most toxic items in your house, it off-gasses for years.

Posted 12/30/11 10:32 AM
 

JoesWife628
Our family is complete :)

Member since 8/08

3934 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

Wood with an area rug

Posted 12/30/11 11:10 AM
 

Lauren82
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

4580 total posts

Name:
L

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

We have wood in our entire house...I have several area rugs in their room, but I like the hardwood since my girls both have allergies that are aggravated by the dust and fibers in the carpet.

Posted 12/30/11 11:13 AM
 

hotsauce345
my love, my life, my son

Member since 1/09

4169 total posts

Name:
Melody

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

Wood floors with an area rug. I love this bc I don't like carpets but it gives DS an area to play on thats soft. It's also cheap enough to replace.

Posted 12/30/11 11:20 AM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

Posted by Kim7706

We have hard wood floors in DS room....and an area rug.



this... can't stand WW carpet, make a room feel very dirty

Posted 12/30/11 11:22 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

Posted by OrganicMama

Wood. Carpet (especially new) is one of the most toxic items in your house, it off-gasses for years.



The Mohawk brand of SmartStrand carpet is corn-based, and has less toxic off-gassing than a lot of wood floors. It's also inherently stain resistant because of the way it is made. I saw a demo where they put wall-to-wall SmartStrand carpet in a rhino's pen for 2 weeks. After that time, they steam-cleaned it, and it was as good as new.

It all depends on the brands, installation method, finishing methods, etc. There is no black and white (carpet is better/worse than wood) answer.

Posted 12/30/11 1:54 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

Posted by Lauren82

We have wood in our entire house...I have several area rugs in their room, but I like the hardwood since my girls both have allergies that are aggravated by the dust and fibers in the carpet.



Studies surprisingly contradict this common idea.

http://www.canadiancarpet.org/carpet_and_health/air_quality/scientific_studies.php
A study commissioned by the DAAB (die Deutscher Allergie- und Asthmabund e.V. - the German Allergy and Asthma Society) in 2005 shows that using smooth flooring markedly increases the risk of finding an increased fine dust load in indoor rooms, while using "fitted" (wall-to-wall) carpets minimizes this risk. The results of this study were presented to the public in Düsseldorf at the DAAB Conference in June 2005.

The study has shown that the average fine dust concentration in indoor rooms equipped with smooth flooring material much higher than in indoor rooms covered with wall-to-wall carpets, and thus exceeds the limit value.

Posted 12/30/11 1:56 PM
 

Lauren82
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

4580 total posts

Name:
L

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Lauren82

We have wood in our entire house...I have several area rugs in their room, but I like the hardwood since my girls both have allergies that are aggravated by the dust and fibers in the carpet.



Studies surprisingly contradict this common idea.

http://www.canadiancarpet.org/carpet_and_health/air_quality/scientific_studies.php
A study commissioned by the DAAB (die Deutscher Allergie- und Asthmabund e.V. - the German Allergy and Asthma Society) in 2005 shows that using smooth flooring markedly increases the risk of finding an increased fine dust load in indoor rooms, while using "fitted" (wall-to-wall) carpets minimizes this risk. The results of this study were presented to the public in Düsseldorf at the DAAB Conference in June 2005.

The study has shown that the average fine dust concentration in indoor rooms equipped with smooth flooring material much higher than in indoor rooms covered with wall-to-wall carpets, and thus exceeds the limit value.




All I know is that my husband doesn't need his daily allergy medication since we replaced all our carpeting with hardwood flooring and my girls aren't sneezing and stuffed up nearly as much...I am a slave to it since I vacuum constantly because I can actually see the dust and debris but it seems to be better for us.

Posted 12/30/11 2:09 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by OrganicMama

Wood. Carpet (especially new) is one of the most toxic items in your house, it off-gasses for years.



The Mohawk brand of SmartStrand carpet is corn-based, and has less toxic off-gassing than a lot of wood floors. It's also inherently stain resistant because of the way it is made. I saw a demo where they put wall-to-wall SmartStrand carpet in a rhino's pen for 2 weeks. After that time, they steam-cleaned it, and it was as good as new.

It all depends on the brands, installation method, finishing methods, etc. There is no black and white (carpet is better/worse than wood) answer.



Thanks for the info! I didn't know they had a greener option (but I still prefer wood for sanitary purposes).

Posted 12/31/11 11:04 PM
 

Kissy331
My two miracles!

Member since 5/06

17826 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: DC's room- carpet or wood?

We have hard wood with an area rug....I prefer it bc there are less allergens with the hardwood

Posted 12/31/11 11:10 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Using Pledge on your wood dining room table mlny 4/13/10 16 Home
Does anyone have wood floors in their dining room and Jen2999 4/14/07 24 Home
Dining Room in solid wood....PIC leighdvm 10/9/06 13 Home
anyone have a room that is part tile/part carpet lbride 12/1/08 9 Home
Spinoff to carpet in baby's room Chica 11/8/07 3 Pregnancy
Carpet in baby's room?? BunnyBaby 11/8/07 10 Pregnancy