Could this be a reason to call ACS?

Posted By Message

Mimi25
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/08

556 total posts

Name:

Could this be a reason to call ACS?

I have a friend and her DD went to school and told her teacher - who she's known for 3 years - she wasn't able to hand in an assignment because her and her mother got into a really big fight and her mother went crazy.

She also said she had to leave the house. The teacher was concerned and called the mother, but I'm wondering could she have called ACS if she felt the child (16yrs old) was in danger?



Posted 10/22/08 4:15 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

I am not a teacher or even in the field, but if it was the first time something like this had happened, then I think the teacher acted appropriately.

Posted 10/22/08 4:21 PM
 

Mimi25
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/08

556 total posts

Name:

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

Posted by KateDevine

I am not a teacher or even in the field, but if it was the first time something like this had happened, then I think the teacher acted appropriately.



My BFF is FLIPPING OUT. She is so upset right now and worried. I mean she spoke w/the teacher and explained the situation which was FAR from what her DD said..but WOW. I had NO words.

Posted 10/22/08 4:23 PM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

Honestly, I think the teacher did a right thing calling a mother first. Nobody knows what really happened .

Posted 10/22/08 4:26 PM
 

pmpkn087
Life is good...

Member since 9/05

18504 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

While I guess that a theacher COULD call ACS, I think that if there is no sign of a pattern of abuse, either physical or emotional or otherwise, then most teachers would do what this one did. Especially since she has known the student for 3 years.

Let's face it...16 year old girls do have a tendency of stretching the truth. Especially when it comes to bad-mouthing their parents Chat Icon

Chat Icon to your friend.

Posted 10/22/08 4:26 PM
 

sweetie101
you make me smile :o)

Member since 5/08

4419 total posts

Name:

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

Message edited 2008-10-22 16:37:12.853000.

Posted 10/22/08 4:36 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

Posted by Mimi25

Posted by KateDevine

I am not a teacher or even in the field, but if it was the first time something like this had happened, then I think the teacher acted appropriately.



My BFF is FLIPPING OUT. She is so upset right now and worried. I mean she spoke w/the teacher and explained the situation which was FAR from what her DD said..but WOW. I had NO words.





i don't know if the teacher did the "right" thing by calling the mom instead of ACS/CPS - the teacher is a mandated reporter, and if this girl said that her mother made her leave the house without making alternate arrangements for her to stay somewhere then technically that is child maltreatment. i can't really comment on the fight b/c that is a "she said/she said" situation but as i said previously, the teacher is a mandated reporter - it's not her job to "investigate," which she technically did by calling the mother - that is ACS's job.

if a child just came in and said "i didn't do my homework because my mom and i got in a fight" then yes, i would expect the teacher to just call the mom first.

however, she said that they got in a fight and her mom went crazy - that to me is cause for concern. whether it was true or not, what if the teacher called the mom, the mom denied it all,

i am NOT saying that this is what happened with your friend and her daughter - but what if this were something serious? what if this IS a pattern and it's just the first time that the teacher was made aware of this? the teacher could have gotten in a LOT of trouble for NOT calling ACS.

i work with troubled adolescents - yes, they have a tendency to lie, and sometimes they tell BIG lies, but better safe than sorry, KWIM?

Posted 10/22/08 4:37 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

If the child was 6 maybe but at 16 yrs old, I don't think they would even take a report.

Posted 10/22/08 4:40 PM
 

Mimi25
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/08

556 total posts

Name:

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by Mimi25

Posted by KateDevine

I am not a teacher or even in the field, but if it was the first time something like this had happened, then I think the teacher acted appropriately.



My BFF is FLIPPING OUT. She is so upset right now and worried. I mean she spoke w/the teacher and explained the situation which was FAR from what her DD said..but WOW. I had NO words.





i don't know if the teacher did the "right" thing by calling the mom instead of ACS/CPS - the teacher is a mandated reporter, and if this girl said that her mother made her leave the house without making alternate arrangements for her to stay somewhere then technically that is child maltreatment. i can't really comment on the fight b/c that is a "she said/she said" situation but as i said previously, the teacher is a mandated reporter - it's not her job to "investigate," which she technically did by calling the mother - that is ACS's job.

if a child just came in and said "i didn't do my homework because my mom and i got in a fight" then yes, i would expect the teacher to just call the mom first.

however, she said that they got in a fight and her mom went crazy - that to me is cause for concern. whether it was true or not, what if the teacher called the mom, the mom denied it all,

i am NOT saying that this is what happened with your friend and her daughter - but what if this were something serious? what if this IS a pattern and it's just the first time that the teacher was made aware of this? the teacher could have gotten in a LOT of trouble for NOT calling ACS.

i work with troubled adolescents - yes, they have a tendency to lie, and sometimes they tell BIG lies, but better safe than sorry, KWIM?



I hear you..100%. I'm just glad it didn't go that route. This could have been so much more worse.

Posted 10/22/08 5:14 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

Posted by CkGm

If the child was 6 maybe but at 16 yrs old, I don't think they would even take a report.



At 16, the child has a better understanding of the possible consequences of their accusations. This could mean more reason to lie but it could also mean that it's a more serious situation.

Posted 10/22/08 5:23 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

I think there are plenty of times when our mothers went "crazy" in our minds as teenagers. I can think of MANY instances when I stayed home from school to avoid work I didn't complete or to avoid a test. Id give the mother the benefit of the doubt.

Message edited 2008-10-22 17:46:39.820000.

Posted 10/22/08 5:43 PM
 

Pooka
Oh Happy Day!!

Member since 11/06

5689 total posts

Name:

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

I am a social orker so I guess I am responding based on my knowledge of the field and experience.

First, a call would be placed to CPS, not ACS. CPS is Child Protective Services and ACS is the Admin. for Children Children Services. ACS would only tell the teacher to call CPS. The teachers could ALWAYS call CPS and they would tell her if the call would be accepted or not accepted based on the story. CPS won't take identifying information unless the call is accepted. So, if it's rejected there is no evidence against the mother that a call was ever placed.

A teacher is a mandated reporter. Therefore, no matter what, she has no obligation to call the parent first. With that being said, the story you describe requires more information before a call can be placed. What does "went crazy" mean? Was there violence between the girl and her mother? Did she throw thing? Hit the girl with any objects? Does the girl have any markings on her body? Did the girl leave on her own or did the mother force her to leave? If the mother forced her to leave, did she allow her to return? If not, did she make arrangments for her to stay elsewhere for the time being?

The teacher is not necessarily required to ask these questions, but a call into CPS would not be accepted based on the story you described.

Posted 10/22/08 8:02 PM
 

JenniferLMSW
LIF Infant

Member since 6/07

79 total posts

Name:

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

I am a school social worker...if a teacher came to me with this case I would suggest that they get more information, such as what exactly was crazy?? I know we are all under alot of pressure as mandated reporters but we have to be careful not to jump the gun. CPS always asks for detailed info and if you don't have it they will not take the report. Sometimes you will ask further questions and see that what really happened was far less serious than it sounded or it could be a cause to call CPS. In the past I would be the one to question further, however the laws have changed and whoever the info is reported to 1st must be the one to call cps. Also, no one can request that you ask them first if you could make a call...no limitations are supposed to be imposed such as school policy etc. I think that the teacher could have questioned the student for more information...bc if the story was true (which I know it wasn't in this case) calling the parent could have made it worse or incriminate any investigation. Parents being informed when something is really going on could give time for cover ups etc. If you question and come to find out the the student overexagerated..then I would make a call home to inform the parent.

Posted 10/23/08 9:15 PM
 

2PreciousBlessings
The Perfect Pair

Member since 5/06

19861 total posts

Name:
Best Wife & Mommy

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

Posted by Goldi0218

I think there are plenty of times when our mothers went "crazy" in our minds as teenagers. I can think of MANY instances when I stayed home from school to avoid work I didn't complete or to avoid a test. Id give the mother the benefit of the doubt.



I completely agree.

Posted 10/24/08 7:05 AM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Could this be a reason to call ACS?

Oh she could have definately called, teachers are mandate to report if they suspect anything.

Posted 10/24/08 8:28 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
is theer a reason i shouldnt give motrin? should i stick with tylenol? 04bride 11/29/07 6 Parenting
And the other reason I hate my new job.... advice please Shelly 8/2/07 3 Families Helping Families ™
Planned C section-Medical Reason for sched or NO? DEF TMI inside LuvMy2Girls 4/12/07 20 Parenting
Moms of girls...."self-discovery" at 14 months or reason to be concerned? btrflygrl 2/26/07 12 Parenting
Flowers... for no reason.. hmmmm! FRAPPALICIOUS 2/24/07 25 Families Helping Families ™
Twin mommies... a reason that being a twin is the best 4monkeys 2/12/07 6 Multiple Births