could be controversial
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 8 | |
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by dm24angel I really think the bottom line should have NOTHING to do with finances...they can change in an instant...My BIL worked with 3 children , with a house struggling for YEARS..then they won the lottery. My sisters husband was injured in an accident, she was a SAHM for 10 years, they have 3 cars, they had to get food stamps for almost a year at one point. A situation can be changed.. The questions should be can you afford enough love and stability to provide a good life for a child. Money is not an issue, unless you need to dress them in $100 outfits with $60 sneakers and a private school. EXACTLY! If your child doesn't have your love, support and respect...if your child isn't taught to love themself, as well as others - what is money going to do for them??? (I'm talking necessities such as food, shelter and clothing - aside.) Message edited 2005-06-09 16:49:47.120000. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:49 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by dm24angel What does owning a home though have to do with having a baby? I truly would like to understand. People on welfare can feed and cloth their children? So what is it that a child should have for a happy childhood? Although Im not saying people knowingly a foot into welfare should have kids, I think that Im speaking more of the paycheck to paycheck type of people here. IT provide a sense of security. I WOULD NEVER bring a child into this world to be on welfare...Just won't And if you can barely survive living pay check to pay check YOURSELF....WHY add someone into it? |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by dm24angel Posted by Redhead Posted by CaptainCharisma424 IMO and i know it cuz i experienced it first hand money means nothing if youy have a stable family and love to give, that's all that matters imo that is VERY naive to say why?? What would the child not be getting that it absoulutly needs? eta- Im trying to see what it is about money that a child needs? A child doesn't need money. A child needs love, shelter, clothes & food... nothing more, nothing less. Everything else is superficial. I think it's naive to impose the belief to a child that they're better off if they had a bigger place, or a better car, or anything at all. A child is taught to recognize superficial items... but as long as the family is happy (starting with their parents), life is good in their eyes. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Lichi Posted by dm24angel Posted by Redhead Posted by CaptainCharisma424 IMO and i know it cuz i experienced it first hand money means nothing if youy have a stable family and love to give, that's all that matters imo that is VERY naive to say why?? What would the child not be getting that it absoulutly needs? eta- Im trying to see what it is about money that a child needs? A child doesn't need money. A child needs love, shelter, clothes & food... nothing more, nothing less. Everything else is superficial. I think it's naive to impose the belief to a child that they're better off if they had a bigger place, or a better car, or anything at all. A child is taught to recognize superficial items... but as long as the family is happy (starting with their parents), life is good in their eyes. You said it better that what I could say, and Alia also deleted what I wrote.
|
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Lichi I think it's naive to impose the belief to a child that they're better off if they had a bigger place, or a better car, or anything at all. A child is taught to recognize superficial items... but as long as the family is happy (starting with their parents), life is good in their eyes. i am not talking about going above and beyond... So you are living paycheck to paycheck Something happens to your car.YOU CAN"T PAY FOR IT..Your child needs to go to the doctors... HOW DO YOU GET THERE? |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Redhead Posted by dm24angel What does owning a home though have to do with having a baby? I truly would like to understand. People on welfare can feed and cloth their children? So what is it that a child should have for a happy childhood? Although Im not saying people knowingly a foot into welfare should have kids, I think that Im speaking more of the paycheck to paycheck type of people here. IT provide a sense of security. I WOULD NEVER bring a child into this world to be on welfare...Just won't And if you can barely survive living pay check to pay check YOURSELF....WHY add someone into it? we are talking reality though, your being dramatic jenn..... None of us ( that I know) are a step away from welfare, and I wasnt talking about welfare people, unless for example something horrible happened. And living paycheck to paycheck doesnt mean we are not surviving? also- someone else said money probelms create fights...that depends...me and DH hardly ever fight, period, and never over money because we agreed lifes too short..but I know people who are always always fighting with their wives/husbands over dumb things...personally I then feel more qualified to provide a "happy childhood" to my child then them with money in the bank.
|
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Aliasmom Posted by Lichi A child doesn't need money. A child needs love, shelter, clothes & food... nothing more, nothing less. Everything else is superficial. I think it's naive to impose the belief to a child that they're better off if they had a bigger place, or a better car, or anything at all. A child is taught to recognize superficial items... but as long as the family is happy (starting with their parents), life is good in their eyes. You said it better that what I could say, and Alia also deleted what I wrote. She must not like drama either...
|
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Redhead Posted by Lichi I think it's naive to impose the belief to a child that they're better off if they had a bigger place, or a better car, or anything at all. A child is taught to recognize superficial items... but as long as the family is happy (starting with their parents), life is good in their eyes. i am not talking about going above and beyond... So you are living paycheck to paycheck Something happens to your car.YOU CAN"T PAY FOR IT..Your child needs to go to the doctors... HOW DO YOU GET THERE? A BUS! It cost what 1.50 Im sure someone in your family or a friend has a car! |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Lichi Posted by Aliasmom Posted by Lichi A child doesn't need money. A child needs love, shelter, clothes & food... nothing more, nothing less. Everything else is superficial. I think it's naive to impose the belief to a child that they're better off if they had a bigger place, or a better car, or anything at all. A child is taught to recognize superficial items... but as long as the family is happy (starting with their parents), life is good in their eyes. You said it better that what I could say, and Alia also deleted what I wrote. She must not like drama either... ![]() I guess not.
|
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Redhead Posted by Lichi I think it's naive to impose the belief to a child that they're better off if they had a bigger place, or a better car, or anything at all. A child is taught to recognize superficial items... but as long as the family is happy (starting with their parents), life is good in their eyes. i am not talking about going above and beyond... So you are living paycheck to paycheck Something happens to your car.YOU CAN"T PAY FOR IT..Your child needs to go to the doctors... HOW DO YOU GET THERE? Good point...something again cdepending on circumstance...ME...a paycheck to paycheck person has two cars so I wouldnt have the problem. I also have 6 sisters, a mom, a MIL, and 2 BILS's etc who could help at the drop of a hat... Still dont see your point? |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by dm24angel we are talking reality though, your being dramatic jenn..... None of us ( that I know) are a step away from welfare, and I wasnt talking about welfare people, unless for example something horrible happened. And living paycheck to paycheck doesnt mean we are not surviving? also- someone else said money probelms create fights...that depends...me and DH hardly ever fight, period, and never over money because we agreed lifes too short..but I know people who are always always fighting with their wives/husbands over dumb things...personally I then feel more qualified to provide a "happy childhood" to my child then them with money in the bank. excuse me Donna...I am NOT being dramatic... I am talking reality. I think YOU are taking this a little personally |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by dm24angel Good point...something again cdepending on circumstance...ME...a paycheck to paycheck person has two cars so I wouldnt have the problem. I also have 6 sisters, a mom, a MIL, and 2 BILS's etc who could help at the drop of a hat... Still dont see your point? YOU are personalizing this...and i am out I said how i feel so be it |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Redhead Posted by dm24angel we are talking reality though, your being dramatic jenn..... None of us ( that I know) are a step away from welfare, and I wasnt talking about welfare people, unless for example something horrible happened. And living paycheck to paycheck doesnt mean we are not surviving? also- someone else said money probelms create fights...that depends...me and DH hardly ever fight, period, and never over money because we agreed lifes too short..but I know people who are always always fighting with their wives/husbands over dumb things...personally I then feel more qualified to provide a "happy childhood" to my child then them with money in the bank. excuse me Donna...I am NOT being dramatic... I am talking reality. I think YOU are taking this a little personally not at all..Im debating you is all..I think we see it from different sides of the coin...Why would I take it personally. I'm telling you though how I would do it as someone who has less then others...trying to show those who disagree how and why it works. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Lichi A child doesn't need money. A child needs love, shelter, clothes & food... nothing more, nothing less. Everything else is superficial. I think it's naive to impose the belief to a child that they're better off if they had a bigger place, or a better car, or anything at all. A child is taught to recognize superficial items... but as long as the family is happy (starting with their parents), life is good in their eyes. Very well put |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Colleen9304 Posted by dm24angel I really dont see how a child could be less happy in an apt. then a house? Whats the difference? So long as there is a roof over their head, there is no difference. It's a personal choice and I think it's sad that people are judged for it...imo. It's an individual thing for sure... my grandparents never owned their primary residence and one of my uncles to this day will criticize my grandfather for it...would his life have been any different if my grandparents owned the house he lived in? I seriously doubt it...but he judges anyway. I grew up in apartments as well, and that created a huge desire for me to be a homeowner someday...DH on the other hand never thought for a second that he'd own a home, nor did he have any real desire to do so. That is, until he met me.
|
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Redhead Posted by dm24angel Good point...something again cdepending on circumstance...ME...a paycheck to paycheck person has two cars so I wouldnt have the problem. I also have 6 sisters, a mom, a MIL, and 2 BILS's etc who could help at the drop of a hat... Still dont see your point? YOU are personalizing this...and i am out I said how i feel so be it jenn, I like to understand all sides of the story, like you DO...so Im asking you...I'm telling you how I see it, and I dont want you getting all upset when Im asking you to prove your point, or explain better how you feel..THATS ALL. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Redhead Posted by Lichi I think it's naive to impose the belief to a child that they're better off if they had a bigger place, or a better car, or anything at all. A child is taught to recognize superficial items... but as long as the family is happy (starting with their parents), life is good in their eyes. i am not talking about going above and beyond... So you are living paycheck to paycheck Something happens to your car.YOU CAN"T PAY FOR IT..Your child needs to go to the doctors... HOW DO YOU GET THERE? Some people can't even afford a car though... and they make ends meet. I live in Queens, and though I have a car, I don't need it. I can take any bus, train, or even call a cab to take my kids to the doctor. Personally, I don't & wouldn't live paycheck to paycheck, and would love to have all the things in the world, but I'm well in tune with reality... I'm not Trump or Bill Gate's kid, I'm responsible for my own money, and what I do with it. And if I have a kid, and still live in an apt, as long as they're not mal-nutrititioned, and feel the love that we have for them, that extra cash (or nothing at all) doesn't hold a candle to how happy I'd be. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial The reality of the situation is that many people may never achieve better then living paycheck to paycheck. So, they should not have children no matter how much they want them? That is IMO unrealistic. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 4:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by dm24angel also- someone else said money probelms create fights...that depends...me and DH hardly ever fight, period, and never over money because we agreed lifes too short..but I know people who are always always fighting with their wives/husbands over dumb things...personally I then feel more qualified to provide a "happy childhood" to my child then them with money in the bank. I mentioned the fights... I know that varies from situation to situation, but I know from experience that money has led to a lot of fights with my parents. My dad lives in a house he can't afford, in a neighborhood where almost every driveway has a mercedes, bmw, lexus, etc. in the driveway. So, of course, my siblings want that. And sometimes they give in (mostly my step-mom) and that has led to a lot of fights. In this situation, they are just living above their means... But I know a majority of their fights have been about money. A few years ago my parents (mom and dad) got in a huge fight over who was going to claim me on their taxes - I felt awful - like all I was was a financial burden - I had to hear it from both sides, and seriously it made me, the child, feel like crap. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 5:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial I think one of the problems is that we're talking different levels of financial difficulty. There are people who live paycheck to paycheck but can provide a child with a secure, stable home life. They can't afford luxuries, and that's fine. I personally would not want to have a child until DH and I could provide more for them, but that's my own personal preference. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 5:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Redhead Posted by dm24angel What does owning a home though have to do with having a baby? I truly would like to understand. People on welfare can feed and cloth their children? So what is it that a child should have for a happy childhood? Although Im not saying people knowingly a foot into welfare should have kids, I think that Im speaking more of the paycheck to paycheck type of people here. IT provide a sense of security. I WOULD NEVER bring a child into this world to be on welfare...Just won't And if you can barely survive living pay check to pay check YOURSELF....WHY add someone into it? I think a home in general - whether rented or owned - provides a sense of security (however false it may be). I don't think every person who WANTS a child, NEEDS to OWN a home first. There are plenty of people who - for whatever reason - just flat out do not want to own a home. This doesn't make them any less worthy to be a perent nor does it make them less responsible. I don't think anyone here is talking about welfare... I remember the days of living paycheck to paycheck - NOT fun. I wouldn't say I was "barely surviving"...but it left me feeling really nervous and uneasy - something *I* definetly don't want to pass on to a child. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 5:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by heidla The reality of the situation is that many people may never achieve better then living paycheck to paycheck. So, they should not have children no matter how much they want them? That is IMO unrealistic. Very true. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 5:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by VirginiaDeb Posted by dm24angel also- someone else said money probelms create fights...that depends...me and DH hardly ever fight, period, and never over money because we agreed lifes too short..but I know people who are always always fighting with their wives/husbands over dumb things...personally I then feel more qualified to provide a "happy childhood" to my child then them with money in the bank. I mentioned the fights... I know that varies from situation to situation, but I know from experience that money has led to a lot of fights with my parents. My dad lives in a house he can't afford, in a neighborhood where almost every driveway has a mercedes, bmw, lexus, etc. in the driveway. So, of course, my siblings want that. And sometimes they give in (mostly my step-mom) and that has led to a lot of fights. In this situation, they are just living above their means... But I know a majority of their fights have been about money. A few years ago my parents (mom and dad) got in a huge fight over who was going to claim me on their taxes - I felt awful - like all I was was a financial burden - I had to hear it from both sides, and seriously it made me, the child, feel like crap. I completly understand! |
|
Posted 6/9/05 5:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Jax430 I think one of the problems is that we're talking different levels of financial difficulty. There are people who live paycheck to paycheck but can provide a child with a secure, stable home life. They can't afford luxuries, and that's fine. I personally would not want to have a child until DH and I could provide more for them, but that's my own personal preference. Then there are the people who become involved in the social service agencies who keep having children. They are living in public housing, getting their food from food banks and using food stamps and getting donations of clothing. They live in terrible neighborhoods filled with crime. I do not and cannot understand why people in these situations continue to have children. That I have to agree with. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 5:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: could be controversial Posted by Aliasmom Posted by Jax430 I think one of the problems is that we're talking different levels of financial difficulty. There are people who live paycheck to paycheck but can provide a child with a secure, stable home life. They can't afford luxuries, and that's fine. I personally would not want to have a child until DH and I could provide more for them, but that's my own personal preference. Then there are the people who become involved in the social service agencies who keep having children. They are living in public housing, getting their food from food banks and using food stamps and getting donations of clothing. They live in terrible neighborhoods filled with crime. I do not and cannot understand why people in these situations continue to have children. That I have to agree with. I agree too. |
|
Posted 6/9/05 5:07 PM
|
|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 8 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Major controversial issue... | 05mommy09 | 1/6/06 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Might turn controversial | unknown1 | 11/16/05 | 48 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| I just heard a disturbing new trend....(this may turn into a controversial topic) | MamaNDaddyof3 | 9/28/05 | 22 | Parenting |
| This could be controversial, but I have a ??? | Scotty-CassidysMom | 7/28/05 | 27 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| May be controversial, but . . . | Bri | 5/23/05 | 3 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| So first controversial topic for LIF | Redhead | 5/11/05 | 31 | Families Helping Families ™ |












