considering a dog

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Naturalmama
Love my boys!!

Member since 1/12

3548 total posts

Name:
Christine

considering a dog

We are moving out of our co-op and into our first house in August. DS will be 15 months at the time, and we are seriously talking about getting a dog. What would be a good breed? I grew up with labs, but we are also considering a golden or a collie. I am just nervous with DS now being a very active toddler, he will want to rough house with the dog and the dog will get upset and nip him. We are looking for a 8-9 month old puppy, so we can skip the house training. Chat Icon Also, we are talking about TTC # 2 this fall/winter. How did your dog react to a new baby? TIA! Chat Icon

Posted 6/3/12 2:13 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

bettybcafe
Big brother in the making

Member since 7/07

8611 total posts

Name:
M

Re: considering a dog

I have a Yorkie and toy poodle and I was actually shocked on how they each reacted. My toy poodle was PERFECT and I thought he would be the trouble since he is sooo attached to me. It was amazing, he actually protects the baby from my yorkie. When my yorkie comes around the baby the toy poodle goes to attack him lol. The yorkie (who I thought would be the good one) was the one that gave me a bit of a headache. He didnt want to hurt the baby but he was VERY curious and in an agressive kind of way. He kept barking at him and wanting to jump on him. After about 2-3 days though he stopped. It was like a day to night transformation..he just didnt care about him anymore and now almost 5 weeks later, he still doesnt. Now, those are small dogs and it seems you want to get a big dog. If I were you I would go with a Golden. I work for a vet. and I have never seen a problem with goldens and children. GL Chat Icon

Posted 6/3/12 2:49 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: considering a dog

Odds are any dog, even 8-9 mths old, will need to be trained. They go into a new environment and will need to be trained. So don't base your choice on that thought.

Also...puppies do nip. This can't be avoided. They are teething. My dogs lost their baby teeth. It amazed me as it never had occured to me I would find their baby teeth all around.Chat Icon And toddlers don't always listen, so it can be a LOT LOT LOT of work. I have a 3.5 year old and it was lot of work when she was a toddler. My dogs ARE big time nippers (some dogs don't grow out of this), and only now that my DD is older and smarter is my life easier. She knows how to handle the dogs, avoid them if they are cranky or tired, etc. KWIM?

I have to be honest and say that I think it's a very very bad idea to get a dog, even if an older pup, now, if you plan to ttc #2. Dogs are a lot lot lot of work, and so would be baby #2. Odds are the dog would be the last one to get his needs met if another child came along. Stufff like this happens all the time. We see it all the time on the pet board. People have another child and all of a sudden the load is too much to bear and the dog either gets neglected, acts out b/c he has pent up energy or they look to rehome the dog. It really does happen. Also the dog often suffers b/c the older your child gets, the more you go out and do things, etc, and the more the dog gets left alone. Just wanted to throw all this out there.

I had my 2 dogs before DD came, for years. And there are days I am exhausted and I only have one child. But they are my babies so I have to give them what they need (ALOT OF ATTENTION, care, vet visits, medications, etc).

I guess my point is you have to be really reallly dedicated to making a lifelong committment. Since you plan to have another baby, it's a LOT of adjusting for a dog, to come into a new house, with a toddler, then add a baby. I generally say to wait to get a dog until you are done having kids and your youngest is around 2 or 3 at the least.

This way the dog comes in and your kids are large enough and not going through the crawling, falling stages with a pup or dog in the mix. And the pup can get sole attention as the "baby" or newcomer in the house. And they enter the house with all the "kids" being there already, so it's easy for them to get used to their new life without any major changes happening. Dogs do react to changes and it's just a bad idea to add a dog into the mix with a toddler and the thought of having another baby shortly.

JMO, not trying to be a downer, just want to put the truth out there. Congrats on the first house btw!

Message edited 2012-06-03 19:19:45.780000.

Posted 6/3/12 7:18 PM
 

drwifettc
LIF Adult

Member since 6/10

2348 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

I have a lab who is 2 years old (almost 3) and a 1 year old. We have had the puppy since she was 8 weeks old.

Here is the good my lab is amazing amazing with the baby, best friends. They are the first thing they look for in the morning and will happily play with each other during the day. The dog adjusted really well to having a baby in the house, but honestly she still gets alot of attention. I don't think her life changed all that much besides for getting some more table scraps, haha. I think the relationship between a dog and kids are great and it really is an awesome addition to some families. Don't regret getting a dog before I had the baby at all.

Here is the bad/hard, it took a ton of training, and even now a ton of work. The amount of training I did with her when she was young would be near impossible with two kids at home. I knew we'd have kids eventually so I really worked on food aggression, nipping, jumping, etc. That's in addition to the basic crate, socialization, and potty training. We don't have a backyard and my dog is co-dependent so wouldn't handle playing outside alone anyways. That means that rain, shine, sleet, snow, 40 weeks pregnant, etc, the dog and I (and now baby) go out for a walk. I think that you have to take that into consideration even with a backyard. Dogs like labs and goldens need a ton of walking if you don't want them to destroy your house.

Also keep in mind, that 8-9 months is still very very much a puppy when it comes to those breeds. Honestly, at 2 my dog is still a puppy.

I also hate to be a downer because I looooove my dog, but If I were in your situation I would wait until you were done having children and your youngest was at least walking. They will be so excited to get a dog and they'll have great memories of growing up with a dog.

ETA: I hope this didn't come across as too negative!
Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-06-03 21:18:39.470000.

Posted 6/3/12 9:14 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: considering a dog

I have a pit mix. We have had him since he was 10 weeks and made sure he was always around kids.

He is great around DS. Never even really bothers too much around the baby.

We had a BBQ this weekend and our friends son was following him around all day and pulling his tail. The dog didnt even growl or anything...he just played along. I now know our dog will put up with anything.

Posted 6/3/12 9:18 PM
 

Naturalmama
Love my boys!!

Member since 1/12

3548 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: considering a dog

Thank you for your honest opinions. Chat Icon I understand what everyone is saying. If we start to TTC in the fall, and we are successful, we will have a June/July 2013 baby. Which would mean a just turned 2 year old and a newborn. Life will be hectic enough without the dog. But I was hoping for people to tell me it was a piece of cake. Chat Icon DH and I are still considering it, but we will definitely consider all of your points. Either way, we know we want a dog. It's just a matter of when.

Posted 6/3/12 9:39 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: considering a dog

Posted by Naturalmama

Thank you for your honest opinions. Chat Icon I understand what everyone is saying. If we start to TTC in the fall, and we are successful, we will have a June/July 2013 baby. Which would mean a just turned 2 year old and a newborn. Life will be hectic enough without the dog. But I was hoping for people to tell me it was a piece of cake. Chat Icon DH and I are still considering it, but we will definitely consider all of your points. Either way, we know we want a dog. It's just a matter of when.



I am glad you understood. I have to tell you with 2 dogs who came before a baby, it is exhausting. Dogs require sooo much attention, they really do, esp with active kids in the house. The dog would be another high energy small being running around, kwim? It really truly is alot of work, not exaggerating. Today alone so much time was spent taking our dogs out due to the rain, feeding them, cleaning up after them, playing with them, giving them love, etc.

You will definitely get a dog, sounds like you love t hem alot. But I truly would suggest waiting until baby #2 is about 3. That way your child is old enough to be helpful and cooperative, kwim? Plus both kids get the joy of seeing a small puppy grow up into a big doggie. hthChat Icon

Posted 6/3/12 10:16 PM
 

PumpkinGirl
:o)

Member since 10/08

1838 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

I adopted my dog when she was a year and a half. Best thing was getting to meet her & see her personality right off the bat. We got to see she was great with kids.. no mystery like with a puppy. The dog I had before her I had gotten as a puppy & he had aggression issues his whole life.. I'm not saying that will happen with every dog, but I feel like adopting a dog out of the puppy stage is better to be sure of personality & of course saving a life (vs. buying a puppy). Good luck!

Posted 6/3/12 10:18 PM
 

Alli06
Baby #3 coming this June

Member since 8/05

6721 total posts

Name:
A

Re: considering a dog

I have a Cavalier King Charles Spaniel. It is such a wonderful breed. She is great with the kids and is such a mush of a dog. I got her as a puppy and it was like having a newborn. We had to set our alarm clocks every three hours to let her out to pee/poo. She would cry in her crate at night. She would nip, chew on things. We had her before having kids. Getting a 8-9 month old dog would be much easier, but I'm sure you will still need to train them. Especially big dogs like a golden who has a ton of energy and likes to jump on people. My DH grew up with a Golden and he didn't calm down till about 3 years old. They are a wonderful breed though.
If you want my honest opinion, I would wait to get a dog. The are alot of work and with a young child at home and TTC for #2. The last thing you are going to be wanting to do is take care of a new dog. Plus, I might be alone here, but with such a young kid at home who is not used to being around a dog, I would be really worried about bringing a 8-9 month old large breed dog into the house. At that age, they are just ruff with the dogs. You just don't know how the dog will react. I just had my second DS. I'm trying to juggle so many things already, the last thing I need is to deal with a crazy puppy, or worry about leaving the room and something happening if my DS pulls his or her tail. My dog is 4 years old and just lays around most of the day.
I would wait until the kids are older to get a dog.

Message edited 2012-06-03 23:32:20.533000.

Posted 6/3/12 11:24 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

i have recently brought a golden into my house and it's been a breeze.

The puppy was so easy to train and she was potty trained in a couple of weeks. a little nipping but it's already toned down. I think I got lucky because she is pretty calm for a puppy.

I think it's all how you look at it. if you look at it as a daunting chore that's exhausting, it will be. if you look at it as another loving creature in your home, it will be good.

You know yourself and your family. If you have time and the effort to want to add love to your family and have energy to train, u will be rewarded with a loyal and behaved dog.

Posted 6/4/12 6:18 AM
 

thinkinglikemommy
LIF Infant

Member since 5/10

373 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

Posted by Goobster

I have to be honest and say that I think it's a very very bad idea to get a dog, even if an older pup, now, if you plan to ttc #2. Dogs are a lot lot lot of work, and so would be baby #2. Odds are the dog would be the last one to get his needs met if another child came along. Stufff like this happens all the time. We see it all the time on the pet board. People have another child and all of a sudden the load is too much to bear and the dog either gets neglected, acts out b/c he has pent up energy or they look to rehome the dog. It really does happen. Also the dog often suffers b/c the older your child gets, the more you go out and do things, etc, and the more the dog gets left alone. Just wanted to throw all this out there.

JMO, not trying to be a downer, just want to put the truth out there. Congrats on the first house btw!



Excellent advice, Goobster! Best of luck to the OP!

Posted 6/4/12 6:46 AM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: considering a dog

My brother and SIL just got a boxer / bulldog mix. The puppy is the cutest and sweetest thing. She has such a calm temperment - just lays in your arms. And she loves the kids. When I'm holding DD she just sits by my feet. They were told she will have the body of a boxer and the temperment of a bulldog.

Posted 6/4/12 8:29 AM
 

snowprincess
My happy babies

Member since 3/06

3428 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

there are a lot of breeders who won't sell you a golden or a lab because as puppies they nip and as they get big they are not aware of their size.

we have a 3 year old golden and he is amazing. i got him while pregnant with my oldest. so he was pretty well trained by the time my son came

he is amazing with my kids, the crawl on him, poke them, whatever - hus response to stop them is to lick them. they all adore him.

but i do know a 3 year old child who was bit my a glden puppy because they can be so rampuctuous.

I honestly would try and finrd a 2 year old rescue - this way they have calmed down a touch but out of the puppy teething stage

Posted 6/4/12 9:04 AM
 

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

Posted by bettybcafe

If I were you I would go with a Golden. I work for a vet. and I have never seen a problem with goldens and children. GL Chat Icon



Not trying to Chat Icon AT ALL but just wanted to say I had a friend's "harmless" golden retriever try to bite me as a child when I went to pet it. I was around 8 or 9 years old and I've hated that breed since.

Posted 6/4/12 9:19 AM
 

three4us
LIF Infant

Member since 12/09

97 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

Posted by Alli06

I have a Cavalier King Charles Spaniel. It is such a wonderful breed. She is great with the kids and is such a mush of a dog..



We have a Cavalier King Charles Spaniel as well. We got her at 8 weeks. She is amazing. Great with the kids, even my three year old who tends to play a little rough with her. (he gets spoken too, and she likes that!!) She is such a part of the family. She has always slept through the night from about 10pm-7am (first few weeks home it was 5am because her breeders sleep schedule was 8pm-5am). Now she sleeps exactly how our schedule is. She sleeps in a kennel in our bedroom. She is the true meaning of a companion dog. All she wants is to please you and snuggle with you. She's amazing, have I said that already!!!

Posted 6/4/12 10:19 AM
 

Ann456
LIF Infant

Member since 8/11

309 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

We got our beagle at 8 months old and she still needed some house training. Think of it .. new environment / people a dog needs to get used to. Yes, it is a little easier than a very young pup. Beagles are for the most part great with kids. The advantage that we had is that we had her about 2 years before we had DS so we were familiar with her behavior. Our son has put his face near the dog food bowl while the dog was eating and did not care nor growl at him. We think because she A. has no competition with another dog and B. has never had to fight for food You need to do your homework on the breed. Our DD is due in July and we thought about getting a second dog but with the craziness of an active two year old and a newborn it would be too hectic. Also our dog needed surgery last year so I am trying to keep her activity to a minimum. Perhaps you are better waiting 2-3 years or at least until baby #2 is a year old. Also get a dog that is almost a year or about a year old so you have a sense of history/behavior of the dog around kids.

Posted 6/4/12 10:39 AM
 

Ann456
LIF Infant

Member since 8/11

309 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

Posted by bettybcafe

I have a Yorkie and toy poodle and I was actually shocked on how they each reacted. My toy poodle was PERFECT and I thought he would be the trouble since he is sooo attached to me. It was amazing, he actually protects the baby from my yorkie. When my yorkie comes around the baby the toy poodle goes to attack him lol. The yorkie (who I thought would be the good one) was the one that gave me a bit of a headache. He didnt want to hurt the baby but he was VERY curious and in an agressive kind of way. He kept barking at him and wanting to jump on him. After about 2-3 days though he stopped. It was like a day to night transformation..he just didnt care about him anymore and now almost 5 weeks later, he still doesnt. Now, those are small dogs and it seems you want to get a big dog. If I were you I would go with a Golden. I work for a vet. and I have never seen a problem with goldens and children. GL Chat Icon



Many terriers can be that way. They can be territorial. I had a Silky Terrier when living with my parents .... not strongly recommended with small kids.

Posted 6/4/12 10:42 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: considering a dog

Posted by Naturalmama

Thank you for your honest opinions. Chat Icon I understand what everyone is saying. If we start to TTC in the fall, and we are successful, we will have a June/July 2013 baby. Which would mean a just turned 2 year old and a newborn. Life will be hectic enough without the dog. But I was hoping for people to tell me it was a piece of cake. Chat Icon DH and I are still considering it, but we will definitely consider all of your points. Either way, we know we want a dog. It's just a matter of when.



Well here is the piece of cake opinion.

We got our dog in march of 2010. HE was 10 weeks and by the time the baby was born our "puppy" was about to turn 2. And whe I say puppy he is 82lbs of mush!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Our dog is very laid back and is low maintenance. We feed him 2 times a day. Was very well train for letting us know if he needs to go out. Never messes in the house. I would have done it the same way in a heartbeat. If we waited for the baby and then gotten a dog I never would have done it. Trainign a dog when you have a baby is a bad idea but training him before the baby was easy and now they are beginnign to be buddies! love it!

Posted 6/4/12 10:45 AM
 

patti08
Happy

Member since 5/05

3893 total posts

Name:
Patti

Re: considering a dog

Posted by drwifettc

I have a lab who is 2 years old (almost 3) and a 1 year old. We have had the puppy since she was 8 weeks old.

Here is the good my lab is amazing amazing with the baby, best friends. They are the first thing they look for in the morning and will happily play with each other during the day. The dog adjusted really well to having a baby in the house, but honestly she still gets alot of attention. I don't think her life changed all that much besides for getting some more table scraps, haha. I think the relationship between a dog and kids are great and it really is an awesome addition to some families. Don't regret getting a dog before I had the baby at all.

Here is the bad/hard, it took a ton of training, and even now a ton of work. The amount of training I did with her when she was young would be near impossible with two kids at home. I knew we'd have kids eventually so I really worked on food aggression, nipping, jumping, etc. That's in addition to the basic crate, socialization, and potty training. We don't have a backyard and my dog is co-dependent so wouldn't handle playing outside alone anyways. That means that rain, shine, sleet, snow, 40 weeks pregnant, etc, the dog and I (and now baby) go out for a walk. I think that you have to take that into consideration even with a backyard. Dogs like labs and goldens need a ton of walking if you don't want them to destroy your house.

Also keep in mind, that 8-9 months is still very very much a puppy when it comes to those breeds. Honestly, at 2 my dog is still a puppy.

I also hate to be a downer because I looooove my dog, but If I were in your situation I would wait until you were done having children and your youngest was at least walking. They will be so excited to get a dog and they'll have great memories of growing up with a dog.

ETA: I hope this didn't come across as too negative!
Chat Icon



I think this answer says it well. I'd wait until your child is walking, with complete stability and understands rules and ways to treat the dog. Many breeders won't let puppies go to houses with kids under 5. If you still want to go ahead with it now, maybe look for an older dog that has been around small children.

Posted 6/4/12 11:10 AM
 

three4us
LIF Infant

Member since 12/09

97 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

Posted by Naturalmama

Thank you for your honest opinions. Chat Icon I understand what everyone is saying. If we start to TTC in the fall, and we are successful, we will have a June/July 2013 baby. Which would mean a just turned 2 year old and a newborn. Life will be hectic enough without the dog. But I was hoping for people to tell me it was a piece of cake. Chat Icon DH and I are still considering it, but we will definitely consider all of your points. Either way, we know we want a dog. It's just a matter of when.



I probably should have added this to my previous answer!

I am due with my third in mid August and our puppy will be a year old end of July. My only concern is having to take her out when I first come home and am recovering, but DH and family will be around. I am looking into an invisible fence since we are not fenced in to just let her out. But other than that. It should all go smoothly. Plus I'm huge believer that the baby should adjust to our schedule rather than us adjusting to the baby(and I'm not saying I wouldn't feed, change, hold baby on her demand/needs) But if the dog has to go out, the baby can wait two minutes! So can my 6 and 3(almost 4) yr old!

I guess if you are thinking of getting a dog, I'd do it as soon as you can before you try to conceive. This way the dog has adjusted to your family schedule as well. And it might very well help your oldest adjust to change/adding a member to the family But I think the breed you choose would make a huge difference.

Posted 6/4/12 11:23 AM
 

Liz-LIFamilies
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/07

605 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: considering a dog

We had a golden when our children were little and he was a bit to active and large for the kids. Nocked them over a few times. Im thinking smaller may be better for you. Let us know what you decide

Posted 6/4/12 12:26 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

We had our dog first and she is wonderful with DS. She's a Jack Russell Terrier.
DS, who will be 3 in October is not good with her at all. He gets too excited and I can't tell you how many times he gets too rough with her. She has never reacted aggressively, TG. He is disciplined each time but I feel really bad for the dog.
If I had to do it over again I would not get a dog until DC was older, for the dog's sake.

Posted 6/4/12 12:31 PM
 

cutie
LIF Adult

Member since 2/06

1893 total posts

Name:
Janine

Re: considering a dog

One other thing to consider that I don't think anyone else has mentioned - all of the breeds you listed shed - a LOT.

During shedding season you will have to vacuum daily, otherwise you will end up with a crawling baby covered in dog hair Chat Icon

Something you might not want to add to your daily to do list with a newborn and a toddler. I wish I had realized how much my lab mix would shed before we got her - love her to death, but I could definitely deal without the shedding! And collies are worse - we had one growing up and my mom would have to vacuum 1-2 times a day. Worst part with her is that she was black and white, so the black hair showed up on all the light surfaces and the white hair showed on everything dark (especially black pants!).

Good luck with whatever your decision is!

Posted 6/4/12 11:20 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

I have a cocker spaniel (and had another cocker before the one I have now) and she is the sweetest, most loving dog. She tolerates everything and everything from my DD and she has been great with her since day one. (My DD is 3.5 now). They are best buddies, Emerson adores our dog and the dog loves Emerson. Cocker spaniels are awesome but if you're interested in the breed, make sure you get a purebred from a respectable breeder, that is so important with this breed. I've seen some puppy store cockers that are just insane in every way.

I will say, puppies are a lot of work. I was very happy that by the time my DD was born our dog Sophie was already a little over 2 yrs old and completely trained. It defintely makes it easier when you add a baby to the mix to have a dog that is already established in your home and family. If you are Up for the challenge I say go for it but just know, it will be a ton of work initially.

Posted 6/5/12 12:14 AM
 

nycgirl
Angels!

Member since 3/09

7721 total posts

Name:

Re: considering a dog

Posted by Naturalmama

Thank you for your honest opinions. Chat Icon I understand what everyone is saying. If we start to TTC in the fall, and we are successful, we will have a June/July 2013 baby. Which would mean a just turned 2 year old and a newborn. Life will be hectic enough without the dog. But I was hoping for people to tell me it was a piece of cake. Chat Icon DH and I are still considering it, but we will definitely consider all of your points. Either way, we know we want a dog. It's just a matter of when.



Just wanted to add my 2 cents coming from someone who has kids CLOSE together:

DS is a VERY active toddler at 22 months.
DD is a very LAID back baby at 5 months.

NO WAY could I take care of a houseplant, never mind a puppy.

There are many days that I didn't shower... especially in the beginning... even with an excellent DH.

Have the baby first & then think about the dog. You'll have plenty time to add a dog on when kids are a little older.

Posted 6/5/12 8:23 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Considering getting a dog in the next year or so and starting my research, please help lol 2boys4me 1/9/12 5 Pets
Does anyone know someone who wants a dog? MDF 5/18/05 11 Pets
Does anyone know someone who wants a dog? MDF 5/18/05 0 Pets
My Dog Is Going Blind! Susan 5/17/05 13 Pets
Van-Based Dog Groomer? MsG 5/14/05 2 Pets
If You Got Another Dog ...... Jesaroo 5/12/05 28 Pets