CIO and screaming

Posted By Message

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

CIO and screaming

Riley is a screamer...she is not a gentle little crier by any means. My ped is recommending CIO (with a time limit) already because her sleeping habits are so awful. I've been relieved because lately she's found her thumb and can fall asleep on her own for naps...but at night, might as well forget it. Leave her for 5 minutes and she starts to scream. I could never let her go on once she starts to do that.

Did anyone do CIO with a screamer? She could go on forever! She's done it before in the car for long trips! It doesn't seem healthy to just let her scream...and not to mention I feel HORRIBLE.

I'm just hoping the practice she's getting for naps will just transfer itself to bedtime so I'll never have to do CIO...

Anyone have stories to share? TIAChat Icon

Posted 11/9/09 8:07 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: CIO and screaming

Posted by TaraGotHutched

Riley is a screamer...she is not a gentle little crier by any means. My ped is recommending CIO (with a time limit) already because her sleeping habits are so awful. I've been relieved because lately she's found her thumb and can fall asleep on her own for naps...but at night, might as well forget it. Leave her for 5 minutes and she starts to scream. I could never let her go on once she starts to do that.

Did anyone do CIO with a screamer? She could go on forever! She's done it before in the car for long trips! It doesn't seem healthy to just let her scream...and not to mention I feel HORRIBLE.

I'm just hoping the practice she's getting for naps will just transfer itself to bedtime so I'll never have to do CIO...

Anyone have stories to share? TIAChat Icon



Both of my kids can scream. Actually I think every baby doesChat Icon How old is she? I wouldn't do CIO until after 6 mos. But I am a CIO faiilure. So I am probably not the right one to ask. With one of my sons-he needs to fuss before he falls asleep. My other son needs to be soothed a couple of times most nights. But now 90% of the time they STTN

Message edited 2009-11-09 08:13:49.673000.

Posted 11/9/09 8:13 AM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: CIO and screaming

Posted by DRMom



Both of my kids can scream. Actually I think every baby doesChat Icon How old is she? I wouldn't do CIO until after 6 mos. But I am a CIO faiilure. So I am probably not the right one to ask. With one of my sons-he needs to fuss before he falls asleep. My other son needs to be soothed a couple of times most nights. But now 90% of the time they STTN



She can scream for a loooong time...I think she'd rather scream than cry!Chat Icon She's 4 months old, and I agree- I'd rather not do CIO this early (hell, I'd rather not do it AT ALL!), but my ped felt her habits were so bad that we had to fix them before they get worse. I'm still hoping she'll get the hang of it for nighttime so we can avoid CIO, since at least she's better for her naps now that she found her thumb! Her issues really aren't sleeping through the night- it's even just getting down to sleep, she's dependent on being walked around/rocked or BFed. She'll keep waking up the first part of the night just about every half hour, screaming, and we go in and rock her and she goes back to sleep. And repeat, repeat...it's nuts!

Posted 11/9/09 9:19 AM
 

Wendy
Wheeee!

Member since 5/05

13736 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO and screaming

Riley is only a day older than Ann and I can't imagine letting her CIO yet. But I also have no advice! Chat Icon


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/9/09 9:22 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: CIO and screaming

Posted by TaraGotHutched

Posted by DRMom



Both of my kids can scream. Actually I think every baby doesChat Icon How old is she? I wouldn't do CIO until after 6 mos. But I am a CIO faiilure. So I am probably not the right one to ask. With one of my sons-he needs to fuss before he falls asleep. My other son needs to be soothed a couple of times most nights. But now 90% of the time they STTN



She can scream for a loooong time...I think she'd rather scream than cry!Chat Icon She's 4 months old, and I agree- I'd rather not do CIO this early (hell, I'd rather not do it AT ALL!), but my ped felt her habits were so bad that we had to fix them before they get worse. I'm still hoping she'll get the hang of it for nighttime so we can avoid CIO, since at least she's better for her naps now that she found her thumb! Her issues really aren't sleeping through the night- it's even just getting down to sleep, she's dependent on being walked around/rocked or BFed. She'll keep waking up the first part of the night just about every half hour, screaming, and we go in and rock her and she goes back to sleep. And repeat, repeat...it's nuts!



She doesn't know how to soothe herself to sleep. What I would do is a modified CIO. I would do very small increments. So rock her for a few minutes, say its night night time, put her in her crib. Let her cry for 1 minute. Then go in and soothe her after 3 minutes. Then do 5. I wouldn't go longer than 5 with a baby her age. Do you have a bedtime routine? Is she swaddled. Does she have a binky?

Posted 11/9/09 9:24 AM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: CIO and screaming

DS's sleeping got messed up last week because he was sick Monday night. He started waking up every night after at the same time, so we had to do CIO all over again. Fri. night he screamed bloody murder for an hour. I have no idea how 1) he was able to keep it up that long and 2) he didn't wake DD up (she sleeps RIGHT next to him). It was so hard to listen to, but then Sat. night he screamed for only a few minutes and last night he didn't wake up at all.
However, he is 10.5 months.
The first time we tried modified CIO he was 5.5 months. I wouldn't do it any earlier than that.

Posted 11/9/09 9:27 AM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: CIO and screaming

Posted by DRMom


She doesn't know how to soothe herself to sleep. What I would do is a modified CIO. I would do very small increments. So rock her for a few minutes, say its night night time, put her in her crib. Let her cry for 1 minute. Then go in and soothe her after 3 minutes. Then do 5. I wouldn't go longer than 5 with a baby her age. Do you have a bedtime routine? Is she swaddled. Does she have a binky?



That's exactly what my ped said- she doesn't know how to soothe herself yet- though she's making HUGE progress since she found her thumb and can get herself to sleep for naps. She just can't soothe herself BACK to sleep. Even some of her naps only last a half hour. My ped said to let her CIO for a half hour but I thought that was nuts. I tried a little modified CIO by waiting like a couple minutes and going back in- but she just got more upset that way. Chat Icon

We have a nap AND bedtime routine. She came off the swaddle a few weeks ago and is doing great without it. The binky has been off and on- mostly off- but lately when it's REALLY late she'll take it. She actually fell asleep in our bed the last two nights with the binky in her mouth- it was a miracle! She usually will only sleep when we walk her around!!

Posted 11/9/09 9:30 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: CIO and screaming

Posted by TaraGotHutched

Posted by DRMom


She doesn't know how to soothe herself to sleep. What I would do is a modified CIO. I would do very small increments. So rock her for a few minutes, say its night night time, put her in her crib. Let her cry for 1 minute. Then go in and soothe her after 3 minutes. Then do 5. I wouldn't go longer than 5 with a baby her age. Do you have a bedtime routine? Is she swaddled. Does she have a binky?



That's exactly what my ped said- she doesn't know how to soothe herself yet- though she's making HUGE progress since she found her thumb and can get herself to sleep for naps. She just can't soothe herself BACK to sleep. Even some of her naps only last a half hour. My ped said to let her CIO for a half hour but I thought that was nuts. I tried a little modified CIO by waiting like a couple minutes and going back in- but she just got more upset that way. Chat Icon

We have a nap AND bedtime routine. She came off the swaddle a few weeks ago and is doing great without it. The binky has been off and on- mostly off- but lately when it's REALLY late she'll take it. She actually fell asleep in our bed the last two nights with the binky in her mouth- it was a miracle! She usually will only sleep when we walk her around!!



I think 1/2 hr is WAY too long. Many people call the first 3 months of life the "fourth trimester" Imagine a one month old baby just crying for 1/2 hr. I am all for trusting my Dr's but I trust my Mommy instinct first. You know what will work for you and your family, ask his advice, take it into consideration and then do what you think will work. My kids did not go to bed easily or STTN til around 9 months. I think 6 months is a reasonable time to expect it.

Posted 11/9/09 9:34 AM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: CIO and screaming

Posted by DRMom



I think 1/2 hr is WAY too long. Many people call the first 3 months of life the "fourth trimester" Imagine a one month old baby just crying for 1/2 hr. I am all for trusting my Dr's but I trust my Mommy instinct first. You know what will work for you and your family, ask his advice, take it into consideration and then do what you think will work. My kids did not go to bed easily or STTN til around 9 months. I think 6 months is a reasonable time to expect it.



It's interesting cuz my ped based the half hour on her age (4 months). She felt that was the most a baby her age should withstand. Go figure! I just want to avoid it at all costs....still praying this thumb sucking will help her at night because it really is working wonders for naps!

Posted 11/9/09 9:36 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO and screaming

Posted by TaraGotHutched

Posted by DRMom



I think 1/2 hr is WAY too long. Many people call the first 3 months of life the "fourth trimester" Imagine a one month old baby just crying for 1/2 hr. I am all for trusting my Dr's but I trust my Mommy instinct first. You know what will work for you and your family, ask his advice, take it into consideration and then do what you think will work. My kids did not go to bed easily or STTN til around 9 months. I think 6 months is a reasonable time to expect it.



It's interesting cuz my ped based the half hour on her age (4 months). She felt that was the most a baby her age should withstand. Go figure! I just want to avoid it at all costs....still praying this thumb sucking will help her at night because it really is working wonders for naps!



Hey Tara............I wasn't one who needed to do CIO but that being said, I would never have let Emerson cry for a half an hour at 4 months old. Heck......... I wouldn't let her cry that long now and she's almost 14 months old. (I think my heart would break) Also, at 4 months old they are just learning how to soothe themselves and to let a baby cry for that long is just not right IMO. I know what your ped. said but I 100% disagree. Everything I have ever read on babies and sleep habits say that 6 months is the minimum age to let them CIO an even then I don't think they recommend letting them scream and cry for a full half hour.

I know it's frustrating but Riley just seems to need a lot of comforting and help to get to sleep and stay asleep but those things tend to change too as they get older. Just because at 4 months old she's like this doesn't mean she will be like this next month, the month after, or even next week. Emerson needed to fall asleep and us ALL THE TIME for months and months and months and then one day........she didn't need us anymore and she was fine on her own. Now we just put her in the crib for naps and bedtime and she puts herself to sleep within minutes if not right away. I just think it takes babies some time to figure out the whole sleeping thing, especially when it comes to falling asleep and staying asleep.

IMO, doctors are great but as with anything, you need to take their advice sometimes with a grain of salt. Lots of doctors have differing opinions on the same thing but in the end you need to trust your own instinct when it comes to your baby. If you don't feel right about letting her cry that long then don't do it. Just because your ped. recommends something doesn't mean you have to do it. It's just a recommendation.............you need to decide what is best for your child. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-11-09 09:54:28.153000.

Posted 11/9/09 9:52 AM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: CIO and screaming

Thanks Kris.Chat Icon It's so frustrating when everyone has an opinion, but no one has an answer. And I guess I just have to stop looking for answers when there aren't any! Chat Icon I just Chat Icon Chat Icon that this thumb discovery will help in the long run, because like I said I want to avoid CIO at all costs. I was just wondering what people do with screamers and I guess no one's been in that boat before.Chat Icon

Believe me, I want to do everything in my power to help soothe her...but my ped's philosophy was that if you don't give her the opportunity to figure it out for herself, you end up with big problems in the long run. She was definitely alarmed that Riley wakes up every half hour all night long until she's finally out and she didn't want her to have a dependency on us to fall back asleep. I've read so many differing accounts on what is the correct age...the Healthy Sleep Habits book starts them early. Ferber says 5 months old. Who freaking knows. Chat Icon

Good thing is...she seems to be 'starting' to figure it out - thanks to the thumb!Chat Icon

Posted 11/9/09 12:42 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO and screaming

Posted by TaraGotHutched

Thanks Kris.Chat Icon It's so frustrating when everyone has an opinion, but no one has an answer. And I guess I just have to stop looking for answers when there aren't any! Chat Icon I just Chat Icon Chat Icon that this thumb discovery will help in the long run, because like I said I want to avoid CIO at all costs. I was just wondering what people do with screamers and I guess no one's been in that boat before.Chat Icon

Believe me, I want to do everything in my power to help soothe her...but my ped's philosophy was that if you don't give her the opportunity to figure it out for herself, you end up with big problems in the long run. She was definitely alarmed that Riley wakes up every half hour all night long until she's finally out and she didn't want her to have a dependency on us to fall back asleep. I've read so many differing accounts on what is the correct age...the Healthy Sleep Habits book starts them early. Ferber says 5 months old. Who freaking knows. Chat Icon

Good thing is...she seems to be 'starting' to figure it out - thanks to the thumb!Chat Icon



There are never definitive answers because everyone has their own opinion and every baby is different. I know it's hard but just go with your gut on this one. I understand where your ped is coming from but as with any developmental milestone or benchmark kids are going to reach them at their own pace when they are ready. I'm sure your ped wouldn't think it was a good idea for me to hold Emme until she fell asleep every night but it's what worked for us and in the long run she learned to put herself to sleep with no help. She just did it in her own time.

It's a good sign that she is using her thumb because it means she is learning ways to soothe herself but it takes time. Honestly, I can't fathom CIO at her age. I couldn't do it. I don't think you need to, she's still so little. She will become a better sleeper at some point. As my ped always says when I worry that Emerson isn't doing something........"You never see an adult who can't crawl, walk, STTN, feed themselves, etc. etc. etc.........". Chat Icon

Posted 11/9/09 4:27 PM
 

ME75

Member since 10/06

4563 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO and screaming

it is a little early for the CIO but if you have to do it in a few weeks don't feel guilty about it.
sorry this is just my opinion.
it is your job to teach your child eventually how to fall asleep on her own and stay asleep for a healthy amount of time. there are people/adults who do never develop this and who are poor sleepers as a result. being a sleep deprived teen/adult is not a good thing. so you have time to teach your DD but when the time is right (or you have to do it) remember you are doing it for her own good. if the CIO works and it takes a short time to train her then you will be happy you did it and i assure you, she won't hate you or ever remember it, or suffer long term effects from it.Chat Icon
i guess it's easy for me to say this b/c CIO worked so well with my DD who became and is still an amazing sleeper. as far as i can tell i am not a bad mom for doing it and she is no worse for it.

Posted 11/9/09 4:34 PM
 

bonitachyc
big sister status may 2012!!

Member since 5/08

3242 total posts

Name:
Lupe

Re: CIO and screaming

summer posted a great CIO thread once, i'll have to bump it for you tara!

Posted 11/9/09 4:36 PM
 

bonitachyc
big sister status may 2012!!

Member since 5/08

3242 total posts

Name:
Lupe

Re: CIO and screaming

okay, bumped it for ya Chat Icon my DD was more of a screamer than crier but i didn't care, i was a mean mommy Chat Icon once i knew she was waking up out of habit rather than hunger i made sure to fill up her tummy during the day and run for my life at night Chat Icon it took 3 days with hardcore CIO and it forever changed my life Chat Icon i closed the door at 8 and didn't go back in until the AM. i'm sure with the gradual CIO you'll have just as much luck, if not more! you have to remember whatever you do, consistency is KEY!! Chat Icon

Posted 11/9/09 4:41 PM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: CIO and screaming

Posted by bonitachyc

okay, bumped it for ya Chat Icon my DD was more of a screamer than crier but i didn't care, i was a mean mommy Chat Icon once i knew she was waking up out of habit rather than hunger i made sure to fill up her tummy during the day and run for my life at night Chat Icon it took 3 days with hardcore CIO and it forever changed my life Chat Icon i closed the door at 8 and didn't go back in until the AM. i'm sure with the gradual CIO you'll have just as much luck, if not more! you have to remember whatever you do, consistency is KEY!! Chat Icon



thanks LupeChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/9/09 5:26 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
**2nd UPDATE-- He woke up and is crying again, what do I do??** DS is SCREAMING his head off right now (my first nap CIO attempt) ruby 8/24/09 18 Parenting
CIO at 2 1/2 years???? Help she won't stop screaming Charly 7/21/09 5 Parenting
So after last nights CIO, vomit, Screaming, Snoring adventure... jerseypanda 12/10/08 8 Parenting
CIO...30 minutes of Screaming! But Now What do i do???? dree 3/1/06 13 Parenting
Need advice from BTDT moms re: Sleeping/CIO and shrill screaming in almost one year old itsbabytime 8/26/08 14 Parenting
CIO moms Bxgell2 2/22/06 10 Parenting