Re: CIO and screaming
Posted 11/9/2009 9:52:04 AM by Hofstra26


Posted by TaraGotHutched


Posted by DRMom



I think 1/2 hr is WAY too long. Many people call the first 3 months of life the "fourth trimester" Imagine a one month old baby just crying for 1/2 hr. I am all for trusting my Dr's but I trust my Mommy instinct first. You know what will work for you and your family, ask his advice, take it into consideration and then do what you think will work. My kids did not go to bed easily or STTN til around 9 months. I think 6 months is a reasonable time to expect it.



It's interesting cuz my ped based the half hour on her age (4 months). She felt that was the most a baby her age should withstand. Go figure! I just want to avoid it at all costs....still praying this thumb sucking will help her at night because it really is working wonders for naps!



Hey Tara............I wasn't one who needed to do CIO but that being said, I would never have let Emerson cry for a half an hour at 4 months old. Heck......... I wouldn't let her cry that long now and she's almost 14 months old. (I think my heart would break) Also, at 4 months old they are just learning how to soothe themselves and to let a baby cry for that long is just not right IMO. I know what your ped. said but I 100% disagree. Everything I have ever read on babies and sleep habits say that 6 months is the minimum age to let them CIO an even then I don't think they recommend letting them scream and cry for a full half hour.

I know it's frustrating but Riley just seems to need a lot of comforting and help to get to sleep and stay asleep but those things tend to change too as they get older. Just because at 4 months old she's like this doesn't mean she will be like this next month, the month after, or even next week. Emerson needed to fall asleep and us ALL THE TIME for months and months and months and then one day........she didn't need us anymore and she was fine on her own. Now we just put her in the crib for naps and bedtime and she puts herself to sleep within minutes if not right away. I just think it takes babies some time to figure out the whole sleeping thing, especially when it comes to falling asleep and staying asleep.

IMO, doctors are great but as with anything, you need to take their advice sometimes with a grain of salt. Lots of doctors have differing opinions on the same thing but in the end you need to trust your own instinct when it comes to your baby. If you don't feel right about letting her cry that long then don't do it. Just because your ped. recommends something doesn't mean you have to do it. It's just a recommendation.............you need to decide what is best for your child. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window