Car dilemma..WWYD

Posted By Message

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Car dilemma..WWYD

So we've always lived in the city and only owned one car at a time.

Currently we have a Hyundai Elantra 2012..due to be paid off in about 2 years or so. Theoretically we can be more aggressive and pay it off in a year.

We are in contract for a house in LI and are due to close sometime in the next week or so (God willingChat Icon )

Right now DH and I will be commuting together and we pretty much are always with each other on the weekends so we don't anticipate needing two cars anytime soon. We definitely don't want to swing two car payments so we figured when we pay off this car we will reevaluate our situation and see if we really need a 2nd car.

Here is the dilemma..when we first bought our car DD was only 3 and we didn't have a 65pd dog which we do take with us when we visit family + we hope to get pregnant in the near future. The car is tight as it is and honestly not that comfortable for long rides. Before we went into contract we even debated about buying another car.

Now I'm kind of debating buying a new car (after we close of course) a more spacious car like the Subaru Outback or something to that effect with a back for the dog that leaves space in the backseat for DD and baby #2 when it comes but is good on gas and has AWD. We did get stuck in the Poconos this winter during a snow storm and it took 5 guys and like 2 hours for us to get out..not fun.

If you live on LI do you have 2 cars? Is it necessary? Do you think we should just pay off this car and then get a second car in a year or so or go bigger now? TIA

Posted 3/20/15 9:44 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

lilqtny
-Crossfit & pitbull addict

Member since 7/06

2830 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Car dilemma..WWYD

Have 2! Could NEVER have just 1 but we have crazy schedules. It's hard bc public transportation isn't as easy and mist places are driving distance. I love to walk/run o errands but some that is just not possible.

Posted 3/20/15 9:52 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Car dilemma..WWYD

Absolutely 2 cars. We couldn't live with one. It would be impossible for us to have only one.

Posted 3/20/15 10:35 PM
 

Strawberry2468
It's summatime

Member since 3/09

4739 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

I work from home and don't go out that much. Dh works basically opposite hours as me. But I still need a car for errands after work and weekends. I'd never want to be stuck home with kids and no car gfb I need to go somewhere.

Posted 3/21/15 4:18 AM
 

cheryl28
LIF Adult

Member since 2/10

4657 total posts

Name:

Car dilemma..WWYD

On LI you need 2 cars. There's no way I'd be stuck home with no car. To much of a hassle. For a little bit you can do it, but having 1 car is a pain. If you are home, either you are with out a car or driving dh to the train/work every morning. I'm in CT now but when we first moved from Boston to CT we had 1 car and I was miserable. Where I am, you can't really walk much and no cabs. I was miserable.

Posted 3/21/15 6:59 AM
 

LoveDayLove
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

1250 total posts

Name:

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

My husband and I both work in Manhattan and commuted from Ronkonkoma with one car. He would drive me to the train at 430am and then go back home to sleep. He would leave for the train at 9am and leave the car at the station. When I got home I would take the car with me and pick him up around 9. It worked for us. If there was a day that he was going to be incredibly late I would just ask someone to pick me up from the train or follow me to the station so I could leave the car there and go back home. We did this for a good year and saved a lot of money.

Posted 3/21/15 7:20 AM
 

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

I agree that you'll need two cars, but having two car payments seems rather foolish. If I were you, I'd finish paying off your current car, THEN get the Subaru in addition and use your current car as your "station" car.

Posted 3/21/15 7:50 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Car dilemma..WWYD

We did one car for a shirt but cause we both worked in the city. It was a PIA to have to go back to the station to get him. I could never do things cause I had to wait for him.

Also we have different interests and wanted to do things on the weekends and it would leave the other stuck at home.

Imo I would keep the car you have and buy a new bigger one.

Posted 3/21/15 7:57 AM
 

JandJ1224

Member since 6/06

5911 total posts

Name:
Jannette

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

I think it depends on your life style. Do you find yourself using public transportation to get around on the weekends now? If you are commuting together at the same time to from work and spending most time on weekends together I don't think you NEED 2 cars it would be nice but certainly not necessary. I like the idea of aggressively paying off the 1 and then getting a second larger car. Will be a while before baby #2 and an actual need for a larger car.

Posted 3/21/15 8:26 AM
 

Sweetlax22
LIF Adult

Member since 5/10

1904 total posts

Name:

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

Posted by Eireann

I agree that you'll need two cars, but having two car payments seems rather foolish. If I were you, I'd finish paying off your current car, THEN get the Subaru in addition and use your current car as your "station" car.



This is what I think too.

Posted 3/21/15 9:19 AM
 

Lara&Aidansmommy
For mom i miss u ETC ILOVEU

Member since 3/07

13921 total posts

Name:
ETC I LOVE YOU

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

Posted by ElizaRags35

Absolutely 2 cars. We couldn't live with one. It would be impossible for us to have only one.




Agree!

Posted 3/21/15 11:03 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

Posted by Eireann

I agree that you'll need two cars, but having two car payments seems rather foolish. If I were you, I'd finish paying off your current car, THEN get the Subaru in addition and use your current car as your "station" car.



This.. I hate car payments. I had 3 cars at once in Long Island but NEVER more than one car payment. Even here we had 3 for a bit but still only one car payment. To me its an issue of affordable spending. If you are 2yrs to paying it off, I'd hold out.

Posted 3/21/15 11:14 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

If you can afford it, I would probably buy a used car for no more then $6,000 so that no one is without a car when you both need it. I can't even imagine us sharing one car.

Posted 3/21/15 12:54 PM
 

LuckyStar
LIF Adult

Member since 7/14

7274 total posts

Name:

Car dilemma..WWYD

DH and I both work in the city and only have 1 car (no kids). It's terrible and we keep saying we'll get another one but never do.

Posted 3/21/15 1:39 PM
 

BlackJack96
LIF Infant

Member since 6/08

245 total posts

Name:

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

I think the answers are really based on your own living situation and your financial situation.

Based on your post it seems like most of the time you can deal with 1 car (you both commute together) and the scenarios where your current care is suboptimal is long drives with severe weather conditions. In theory you could keep your current car and rent a car when you go on vacation for more space and better winter driving.

Another option is to sell your current car (assuming you don't owe too much) and get a bigger car that's either new or CPO with the money left.



Posted 3/21/15 2:23 PM
 

KarenK122
The Journey is the Destination

Member since 5/05

4431 total posts

Name:
Karen

Car dilemma..WWYD

I would definitely get two cars. Even if you have to get a cheap "station" car to drive to the train and then have a nicer car for your family time. My parents just tried to go down to one car, they are both retired, and it was awful for them. My mom felt trapped if my dad went out and when the car had to go in for service they had to rent a car for the week. If you can swing it, definitely 2 cars.

Posted 3/21/15 7:30 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Car dilemma..WWYD

DH and I decided we are going to upgrade the Elantra to something bigger and then search Craigslist and pay cash for a spare car to have around just in case. Thanks for all the advice and insight it's really appreciated.

Posted 3/21/15 10:56 PM
 

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

I think it also depends where you bought your house, if its in a "walkable" town then I would wait on the 2nd car until you paid off your first. When we lived in great neck, we had one car but it didn't matter bc I could walk to everything if dh is out.

Posted 3/23/15 8:13 AM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

We were in a similar situation. We had a crossover when we lived in the city that we would use on weekends. No kids at that point and no big dog.

When we moved to LI our car lease was up so we ended up Lessing two new cars. There is no way dh and I could just have one car.

I would lease a bigger car for your dd, dog and potential new baby. The freedom will make life so much easier as will the space.

Posted 3/23/15 8:18 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Car dilemma..WWYD

Definitely two cars for LI. Could you get by with one? Sure but it's extremely inconvenient with public transportation that runs hourly in some parts.

Posted 3/23/15 8:55 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
WWYD - car seat/infant seat related Charly 1/2/09 12 Parenting
WWYD: Car Question statusquoscreenname 6/25/08 7 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD - car trip related pinkandblue 5/15/08 13 Parenting
WWYD - Car Seat Related cgdg61606 5/9/08 4 Parenting
wwyd...car related? dcl08 4/30/08 11 Parenting
WWYD - Car related Rycois 2/14/08 15 Families Helping Families ™