Can I have some opinions?

Posted By Message

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Can I have some opinions?

DH and I are having an issue about Alex's class. He seems to think that they weighed the class more heavily towards children who are less developed, mostly because there are two children who are on the younger end of the spectrum. He thinks the other 2-3 year old class seems to have a more developed group of kids.

I spoke to the Director, who confirmed that, for all the 2-3 year old classes, the general makeup includes children closer to 2 and children closer to 3, so it's basicaly a mishmash of kids with different ages and abilities.

I have no issue with dividing classes this way, to have some kids who are more developed and some who are less developed, because this will be the general makeup of ALL Alex's classes when she gets to kindergarten. Some will be on the young side of 5, and others, like Alex, whose birthday is 3 weeks after the cutoff, will be on the older side of 5.

My DH thinks that, at this age, they should be dividing classes up by developmental abilities, so that for the two 2-3 year old classes, one should have children on the lower end of the spectrum in terms of age and abilities, and one class with children on the higher end of the spectrum, in terms of age and abilities.

He seems to think I'm nuts for thinking the way I do.

What would you prefer for your child as they go through preschool?

Message edited 2008-09-04 10:04:32.480000.

Posted 9/4/08 10:03 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: Can I have some opinions?

I agree with you; I am in favor of mixed groups. I think the younger (aka less developed) kids can learn a lot from the older--and vice versa as a matter of fact.

Posted 9/4/08 10:07 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Can I have some opinions?

I would want a combination. Age group and development abilities.

That being said, some moms like their child to be with more advanced kids so they learn.

I feel sometimes it's not beneficial to put more advanced kids in those settings. Unless you just want them to have fun. Although being with less advanced kids also teach them patience. But it usually end up in boredom.

In case somebody questions what I am saying. It was the case of ALL my younger siblings. All more advanced, and all bored in their class settings.

Posted 9/4/08 10:09 AM
 

pugmama
April already?

Member since 3/06

5297 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: Can I have some opinions?

I am having an issue with my daycare since they divide the classes strickly by chronological age. In NY the cut off is December f1st so they made up a class of kids who are 2 years old and miss the cut off. There are 7 or so kids in the class. Sydney's birthday is January so she misses the cut off and she is one of the oldest in the class. The others arent that much younger, their birthdays are february and march. My issue is that for Sydney I feel she does better with older kids as she strives to meet what they are doing.
I am not sure whether I can do anything to change this situation at her current place and DH and I have been torn for months about whether we should switch her to a different center but if we did DS would still be at this place and Sydney at another. DH wanted them at the same place, and we get a small discount for the two. We decided a few weeks ago that we will keep Sydney at this place this year and switch her next but now I am not sure.
I also am torn because Sydney seems to like her teacher but I have mixed feelings about her.
Dont know whether this helps your situation but ...Chat Icon daycare is so stressful!

Posted 9/4/08 10:25 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by pugmama

I am having an issue with my daycare since they divide the classes strickly by chronological age. In NY the cut off is December f1st so they made up a class of kids who are 2 years old and miss the cut off. There are 7 or so kids in the class. Sydney's birthday is January so she misses the cut off and she is one of the oldest in the class. The others arent that much younger, their birthdays are february and march. My issue is that for Sydney I feel she does better with older kids as she strives to meet what they are doing.
I am not sure whether I can do anything to change this situation at her current place and DH and I have been torn for months about whether we should switch her to a different center but if we did DS would still be at this place and Sydney at another. DH wanted them at the same place, and we get a small discount for the two. We decided a few weeks ago that we will keep Sydney at this place this year and switch her next but now I am not sure.
I also am torn because Sydney seems to like her teacher but I have mixed feelings about her.
Dont know whether this helps your situation but ...Chat Icon daycare is so stressful!



This is EXACTLY what we are going through, and the school goes strictly by age when dividing the kids up for classes.

I'm curious, are there even preschools that divide the kids up differently?

Posted 9/4/08 10:30 AM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Can I have some opinions?

I agree with the combo class.
I just feel like it pomotes different kinds of strengths. The children that are higher then ALex will give her educational strengths while the children that are lower then her will promote patience, responsibility and nurturing abilities. IMO its how life is set up...not everyone is on the same level. The more opportunities she gets the stroneger she will grow...JMO...

Posted 9/4/08 10:30 AM
 

pugmama
April already?

Member since 3/06

5297 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by pugmama

I am having an issue with my daycare since they divide the classes strickly by chronological age. In NY the cut off is December f1st so they made up a class of kids who are 2 years old and miss the cut off. There are 7 or so kids in the class. Sydney's birthday is January so she misses the cut off and she is one of the oldest in the class. The others arent that much younger, their birthdays are february and march. My issue is that for Sydney I feel she does better with older kids as she strives to meet what they are doing.
I am not sure whether I can do anything to change this situation at her current place and DH and I have been torn for months about whether we should switch her to a different center but if we did DS would still be at this place and Sydney at another. DH wanted them at the same place, and we get a small discount for the two. We decided a few weeks ago that we will keep Sydney at this place this year and switch her next but now I am not sure.
I also am torn because Sydney seems to like her teacher but I have mixed feelings about her.
Dont know whether this helps your situation but ...Chat Icon daycare is so stressful!



This is EXACTLY what we are going through, and the school goes strictly by age when dividing the kids up for classes.

I'm curious, are there even preschools that divide the kids up differently?



The place that I was going to switch her to has the kids mixed, I think the kids have to be at least 2 and 8 months to be in the 3 year old class. We have our class orientation tomorrow night and I am going to again talk with the director about moving Sydney up if we are not satisfied with her progress in the current class. If I still am not satisfied in a month or so I will look into moving her to the other place even if it is inconvenient and a little more money.

Posted 9/4/08 10:40 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by PrincessP

I agree with the combo class.
I just feel like it pomotes different kinds of strengths. The children that are higher then ALex will give her educational strengths while the children that are lower then her will promote patience, responsibility and nurturing abilities. IMO its how life is set up...not everyone is on the same level. The more opportunities she gets the stroneger she will grow...JMO...



I absolutely agree with this!

Posted 9/4/08 10:52 AM
 

paulandles912
My children are a blessing!

Member since 5/05

2598 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Andrew's preschool makes exceptions to the age cutoff based on an individual basis. When I placed Andrew there at 2 1/2 I did not want him in with the 'Toddlers' group (had to be 2 by Dec. 31st) b/c I felt that his experience at day care made him ready for more. So they asked to meet him and determined that he would fare well with the nursery school group. He was the youngest of the class but he did really well.

I will have an issue when Andrew goes to public school as they are seemingly more strict with the age cut-offs. So he'll probably have to repeat pre-K.

Posted 9/4/08 11:11 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by PrincessP

I agree with the combo class.
I just feel like it pomotes different kinds of strengths. The children that are higher then ALex will give her educational strengths while the children that are lower then her will promote patience, responsibility and nurturing abilities. IMO its how life is set up...not everyone is on the same level. The more opportunities she gets the stroneger she will grow...JMO...



I absolutely agree with this!



Well said. I think the school is correct in having a class full of kids at varying developmental stages. Not to mention, a child who is physically advanced (fine motor/gross motor) may be average or below average with speech, cognitive, etc... or vice versa. So how DO you establish what is advanced? Jordana can physcally do the same things as the 3 year olds, but her speech is delayed.

Posted 9/4/08 12:05 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by PrincessP

I agree with the combo class.
I just feel like it pomotes different kinds of strengths. The children that are higher then ALex will give her educational strengths while the children that are lower then her will promote patience, responsibility and nurturing abilities. IMO its how life is set up...not everyone is on the same level. The more opportunities she gets the stroneger she will grow...JMO...



ITA!

Posted 9/4/08 12:17 PM
 

Luv2bAmom
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1255 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by PrincessP

I agree with the combo class.
I just feel like it pomotes different kinds of strengths. The children that are higher then ALex will give her educational strengths while the children that are lower then her will promote patience, responsibility and nurturing abilities. IMO its how life is set up...not everyone is on the same level. The more opportunities she gets the stroneger she will grow...JMO...



Well saidChat Icon

Posted 9/4/08 12:20 PM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by PrincessP

I agree with the combo class.
I just feel like it pomotes different kinds of strengths. The children that are higher then ALex will give her educational strengths while the children that are lower then her will promote patience, responsibility and nurturing abilities. IMO its how life is set up...not everyone is on the same level. The more opportunities she gets the stroneger she will grow...JMO...



Well said. and then you will have to "draw the line" at what qualifies for going into which class, and schools/teachers have enough parental requests (and competition) as it is.


Posted 9/4/08 12:23 PM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by PrincessP

I agree with the combo class.
I just feel like it pomotes different kinds of strengths. The children that are higher then ALex will give her educational strengths while the children that are lower then her will promote patience, responsibility and nurturing abilities. IMO its how life is set up...not everyone is on the same level. The more opportunities she gets the stroneger she will grow...JMO...



I agree. I also think that at this young an age one has to be careful with creating an "advanced" class and a "not so advanced" class. I think it is too early for that stigma to develop. I think grouping them by age is the fairest (is that a word?) way to do it.Chat Icon

Posted 9/4/08 12:33 PM
 

hope07
LIF Adult

Member since 12/06

1050 total posts

Name:

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Classes thoughout his school career will be "mixed" as you called it. Im an elementary teacher and this definitely is typical and there are benefits to it!

Posted 9/4/08 12:36 PM
 

-DonnaMarie-
<3

Member since 5/05

6079 total posts

Name:

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by PrincessP

I agree with the combo class.
I just feel like it pomotes different kinds of strengths. The children that are higher then ALex will give her educational strengths while the children that are lower then her will promote patience, responsibility and nurturing abilities. IMO its how life is set up...not everyone is on the same level. The more opportunities she gets the stroneger she will grow...JMO...



totally agree with this.

And DS's preschool actually does have a class for "older" 4's the cut off is a July 1st birthday.
DS qualifies AND already is proficient for some time now in many of things listed on this years curriculum for the regular 4's class and I still kept him in with the regular class. They way I see it, his school works closely with the school district to ready the children for kindergarten, other than that preschool is a time for social skills, patience, team work, tolerance and perfecting fine motor skills.

Posted 9/4/08 12:43 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Can I have some opinions?

I think having the groups split by developmental ability would unfair. Children often learn from their peers more than from the adults around them at that age. You will be surprised by the changes in all these children by the end of the year.

Posted 9/4/08 8:29 PM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Can I have some opinions?

Posted by Shelly

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by PrincessP

I agree with the combo class.
I just feel like it pomotes different kinds of strengths. The children that are higher then ALex will give her educational strengths while the children that are lower then her will promote patience, responsibility and nurturing abilities. IMO its how life is set up...not everyone is on the same level. The more opportunities she gets the stroneger she will grow...JMO...



I absolutely agree with this!



Well said. I think the school is correct in having a class full of kids at varying developmental stages. Not to mention, a child who is physically advanced (fine motor/gross motor) may be average or below average with speech, cognitive, etc... or vice versa. So how DO you establish what is advanced? Jordana can physcally do the same things as the 3 year olds, but her speech is delayed.



Totally agree with this! At that age, how would you divide them up - physical, emotional, maturity milestones? And how would you measure it? And what if a child reaches a measurement during the school year, do they get moved?

Plus, imagine if they did and parents got wind that their child was not in the "advanced" class. It would be a nightmare for all involved!

Message edited 2008-09-04 20:36:57.880000.

Posted 9/4/08 8:36 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Can I have some opinions?

If you go to a good school, the teachers will differentiate based on the children's learning style, ability, etc. and then it does not matter who is stronger or weaker in areas, etc. So really, you need to find out if they are providing ample chances for ALL of the children, regardless of their level, to challenge themselves. This is coming from a teacher who strives to differentiate in her own classroom based on the various levels of knowledge and understanding the kids have. HTH.

Posted 9/4/08 8:37 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I need some opinions regarding SAHM vs. going back to work btrflygrl 1/31/06 18 Parenting
OK, I need honest opinions. Am I wrong? (VERY long) Scotty-CassidysMom 1/8/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
So my Dh just left he went out AGAIN! Opinions advice needed BADLY 04bride 11/22/05 20 Families Helping Families ™
what ipod to get for a guy for xmas?? need opinions ggt08 11/9/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
Changed post DH will not move to coram so I need opinions about what suffolk towns are good , safe and have a good school district. MommyofG 9/22/05 51 Home
My swing is broken... dilemma.. looking for opinions. -Laurie- 9/22/05 5 Parenting