Breast feading in public. The view protest.
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 7 >> | |
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by neeniebean86 Posted by Colleen9304 Huh? Useless? Are you honestly going to argue that women's breasts were not "made" for feeding?? The extra "benefits" are just that - benefits. can i ask you an Honest question? You say that breasts are not Sexual in anyway (or are only Such b/c of societies views). Have you NEVER been aroused by any spot on your breasts or nipples Whatsoever? im just saying that thats not their Sole purpose. Um, then we're saying the SAME thing. The PRIMARY purpose of a woman's breast is for feeding - it was made with ducts and a nipple so that a baby can feed. Secondary purposes are just that - secondary. We're going tit for tat (pardon the pun ) and it's moot. I think we both agree on the same things...we're just choosing to put more emphasis on whichever thing works for our "argument".
|
|
Posted 6/6/05 6:59 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. I have no problem with women brestfeeding in public. If I were a mom though, I wouldn't do it b/c of all the pervs who would stare. NOT b/c of anyone's comfort level - but b/c people would be staring at us like we were either freaks or gross old men might try to see some boobs |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. colleen.... why do you care sooo much ? you said you dont even have a baby. |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Colleen9304 We're going tit for tat (pardon the pun ) and it's moot. I think we both agree on the same things...we're just choosing to put more emphasis on whichever thing works for our "argument". i appreciate your use of the pun there i disagree with women whipping out their boobs anywhere. I am not crazy conservative, but i just dont agree with seeing boobs while im trying to eat. Especially when there Are, in many cases, an alternative.
|
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Lolita4Life colleen.... why do you care sooo much ? you said you dont even have a baby. I could ask the same of you... I am around enough women who have had babies who either have or are still b/f'ing who have to deal with these opinions on a daily basis. It's a struggle that they shouldn't have to deal with, IMO. |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. ok, I knew this was going to get out of control. |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. I am a breastfeeding mother. I breastfed Emma till she was 2 1/2 (which some peole view as too old) and now Jeremy. It is IMO what is 100% best for my family. There have been times Ive gone out and forgot to bring something to cover myself with, I use my shirt or my hand to cover any part of my nipple thats exposed. My son gets hungry, no matter where I am, I am going to feed him. Some people dont want to see a womans breast, no matter how small of a part, but would you rather listen to a screaming child while you are enjoying your dinner? You couldnt pay me enough to take my child into a dirty bathroom to feed them, heck you arent supposed to keep your own toothbrush closer than 6' from your toilet... IMO society should get over it, its just a boob, they were put there to feed our children. AGAIN JMO anyone that has a problem with it should REALLY look into what they would do in that situation. As a mother you find yourself doing a lot of things you swore you would never do or found uncomfortable before having a child (ie. wiping someones a$$). Message edited 2005-06-06 19:27:33.823000. |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Colleen9304 Posted by Lolita4Life colleen.... why do you care sooo much ? you said you dont even have a baby. I could ask the same of you... I am around enough women who have had babies who either have or are still b/f'ing who have to deal with these opinions on a daily basis. It's a struggle that they shouldn't have to deal with, IMO. why dont you think they should have to deal with it? i do. personally. like i have said, if its done discreetly then fine. but when its made into a big production and obvious then its like "c'mon i'm EATING here i dont need to see your nipple!" maybe theyre not doing it discreetly then. if you dont want people to be annoyed by it, dont do it. i will NEVER b/f in public. |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Diane ok, I knew this was going to get out of control. Colleen, I was saying I dont care that you are going BF in public, but cover yourself, there is a time and place for this. Whiel Im eating ata restuarant eating my chicken BREAST, I dont want to see some women's Breast. I was having the problem with th efact that she was exposed. Sorry, then move to the lobby of the rest. My opinion Just as you are enititled to yours Of course you're just as entitled to your opinion as anyone else is. Not sure why you would think otherwise.
|
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. X Message edited 2005-06-06 19:15:48.860000. |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Colleen9304 Posted by Diane ok, I knew this was going to get out of control. Colleen, I was saying I dont care that you are going BF in public, but cover yourself, there is a time and place for this. Whiel Im eating ata restuarant eating my chicken BREAST, I dont want to see some women's Breast. I was having the problem with th efact that she was exposed. Sorry, then move to the lobby of the rest. My opinion Just as you are enititled to yours Of course you're just as entitled to your opinion as anyone else is. Not sure why you would think otherwise. I wasnt trying to be rude, I didnt want to post because I was personally attacked for clearly stating my opinion on LIW. I value your opinion very much and your honesty
|
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. I just wanted to add on the MAIN topic of this post the person who was on the plane that was uncomfortable was proabably THIRLLED that the baby wasnt screaming through the entire flight. The baby was probably quiet and content. Would the "complaintant" rather have a screaming baby flight? |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Lolita4Life why dont you think they should have to deal with it? i do. personally. like i have said, if its done discreetly then fine. but when its made into a big production and obvious then its like "c'mon i'm EATING here i dont need to see your nipple!" maybe theyre not doing it discreetly then. if you dont want people to be annoyed by it, dont do it. i will NEVER b/f in public. I don't understand why you're arguing with me nor why it's such a big deal to you! No, I don't think women who choose to nurse their baby, should have to deal with people being uncomfortable and annoyed by it. I also have never seen a woman "whip out her breast" - I did, however, see a woman change her baby's dirty diaper AT the dinner table in a restaurant. THAT, I find disgusting and completely inappropriate - but FEEDING a baby at a table, not so disgusting. Sorry - that's MY opinion...I'm not saying it's LAW or RIGHT. OR that your opinion is wrong.
|
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Diane I wasnt trying to be rude, I didnt want to post because I was personally attacked for clearly stating my opinion on LIW. I value your opinion very much and your honesty I didn't think you were being rude - just defensive...and I would be too if I were previously attacked wrt this discussion.
|
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by KPtoys I just wanted to add on the MAIN topic of this post the person who was on the plane that was uncomfortable was proabably THIRLLED that the baby wasnt screaming through the entire flight. The baby was probably quiet and content. Would the "complaintant" rather have a screaming baby flight? Uh-oh - you opened a whole other can of worms!! LOL I used to be one of those people who would get so annoyed by babies screaming - and why weren't the parents doing anything about it, etc......UNTIL I spent weeks with my sister and helped her tend to her (now) 13 month old. It isn't easy and I don't think people should be so quick to pass judgement until they've been in the shoes of those they are judging. IMO. |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Colleen9304 Posted by KPtoys I just wanted to add on the MAIN topic of this post the person who was on the plane that was uncomfortable was proabably THIRLLED that the baby wasnt screaming through the entire flight. The baby was probably quiet and content. Would the "complaintant" rather have a screaming baby flight? Uh-oh - you opened a whole other can of worms!! LOL I used to be one of those people who would get so annoyed by babies screaming - and why weren't the parents doing anything about it, etc......UNTIL I spent weeks with my sister and helped her tend to her (now) 13 month old. It isn't easy and I don't think people should be so quick to pass judgement until they've been in the shoes of those they are judging. IMO. AMEN! |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. I actually don't mind when babys scream or cry. I get annoyed when teenagers act like animals though |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. I dont think anyones OPINIONS means they are passing judgement. I personally DO not want to see a womans breast, brestfeeding or not. If I were breastfeeding my child, I would make sure I never left the house without something, simple as that. I see a breast as a sexual thing, no-one has to agree with me, its only my opinion. I thought we could give opinions. |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Colleen9304 Posted by KPtoys I just wanted to add on the MAIN topic of this post the person who was on the plane that was uncomfortable was proabably THIRLLED that the baby wasnt screaming through the entire flight. The baby was probably quiet and content. Would the "complaintant" rather have a screaming baby flight? It isn't easy and I don't think people should be so quick to pass judgement until they've been in the shoes of those they are judging. IMO. KP- i agree that i would rather have a child be fed, then Scream during a whole plane ride (when there really is no place to take the screaming baby). BUT i think something thats getting tossed aside here is that most people (myself included) said that their issue was NOT about breast feeding in public, but about NOT being discreet about it or covering it up. Both of my SILs have twins (5 months and 7 months), so theres ALOT of breast feeding around me. i have Never seen their boobs. and thats all i'm saying (as i think the majority is as well). Do what you have to do for your child- but it shouldnt be flashed in other people's faces (and i agree... i would NEVER breast feed my child on a toilet.... i think the poster who originally said that may have meant a bathroom that has a seating area, but i dont know). |
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by neeniebean86 Posted by Colleen9304 Posted by KPtoys I just wanted to add on the MAIN topic of this post the person who was on the plane that was uncomfortable was proabably THIRLLED that the baby wasnt screaming through the entire flight. The baby was probably quiet and content. Would the "complaintant" rather have a screaming baby flight? It isn't easy and I don't think people should be so quick to pass judgement until they've been in the shoes of those they are judging. IMO. KP- i agree that i would rather have a child be fed, then Scream during a whole plane ride (when there really is no place to take the screaming baby). BUT i think something thats getting tossed aside here is that most people (myself included) said that their issue was NOT about breast feeding in public, but about NOT being discreet about it or covering it up. Both of my SILs have twins (5 months and 7 months), so theres ALOT of breast feeding around me. i have Never seen their boobs. and thats all i'm saying (as i think the majority is as well). Do what you have to do for your child- but it shouldnt be flashed in other people's faces (and i agree... i would NEVER breast feed my child on a toilet.... i think the poster who originally said that may have meant a bathroom that has a seating area, but i dont know). I GUESS im just such a pro at discretness... I walked around Old Navy, did some shopping while Emma ate and no one knew, they thought she was asleep
|
|
Posted 6/6/05 7:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by Colleen9304 OK, I'm going to agree to disagree with you. I don't have a baby but I'm around a lot of babies and there is just NO WAY to plan your life around a nursing baby. I just don't think a lot of people are understanding that it's just not as simple to do as it is to say. I'm a mother of 2...breastfed both my babies..and I do not feel it is appropriate to bf blatantly in public...there are very discreet ways to nurse your child WITHOUT having to expose your entire breast!! I bf my Sofia once so discreetly, my friend thought I was just sitting there holding her. Sometimes, IT IS that simple! |
|
Posted 6/6/05 10:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. Posted by KPtoys I GUESS im just such a pro at discretness... I walked around Old Navy, did some shopping while Emma ate and no one knew, they thought she was asleep YES you are....at the shower i had no idea at first! |
|
Posted 6/6/05 10:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest.
|
|
Posted 6/6/05 10:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. BRAVO to Colleen! Well said in all your posts. I knew I liked you |
|
Posted 6/6/05 10:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Breast feading in public. The view protest. I have no problem with bf in public, but I DO think they should cover up. Message edited 2005-06-06 22:47:53.560000. |
|
Posted 6/6/05 10:47 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 7 >> | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IBC - Inflammatory breast cancer awareness | mskimmy98 | 8/16/06 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Mommy GTG NY Cancer Society Breast Cancer Walk | MrsBumbleb | 8/16/06 | 7 | Parenting |
| Public Bathroom Dilemma for women | Crismicka | 8/16/06 | 6 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| CandleLight Vigil to Protest Breed Specific Legislation | Gertyrae | 8/16/06 | 4 | Pets |



) and it's moot. I think we both agree on the same things...we're just choosing to put more emphasis on whichever thing works for our "argument". 









