Bjorn or sling?

Posted By Message

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Bjorn or sling?

Ryan wants to be on me at all times so I want to try a sling or bjorn so I can move around more. I don't want to waste $$ so I wonder if any of you have an opinion on which is better. TIA

Posted 4/20/08 6:55 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Gatsbygirl
Please St. Therese....

Member since 10/07

8494 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I had a sling that was very uncomfortable. I felt DS was too low and it hurt my back.

He loves the Bjorn. He liked to feel close to me and still falls asleep in it sometimes. It was comfortable on my shoulders. I loved it- one of the best baby things I have!

Posted 4/20/08 7:10 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I think you should try both. I used both of them. The sling was very awkward for me at first and it took me a few months to warm up to it with my first, but it soon became one of my most favorite items. My husband tried the sling a few times but HATED it and loved the Bjorn.

Posted 4/20/08 7:22 PM
 

DC HJJ M

Member since 8/07

3732 total posts

Name:
Crystal

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I have the bjorn but DD is still a little too small for it. She isnt sitting in it as comfortably as I would like but I really think I am going to like it. I got the one with the back support too. GL!!

Posted 4/20/08 7:27 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I would get the Bjorn. You may not be able to use it the first few weeks (the head support isn't really enough), but it lasts longer if you are looking to save money.

Never had a sling, and I can't say I wished I bought one.

Posted 4/20/08 9:12 PM
 

KPtoys
I'm getting old

Member since 5/05

8688 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I hate hate hate hate hate the Bjorn. Slings actually last longer because you can use them for 2-3 year olds not just infants. Slings put less stress on your neck/back because the weight is mostly on your shoulder. You have to get the right size. If you don't the baby can sit too low and be uncomfortable. If you want test them both out with a 10lbs baby and a 25lb baby. Walk around for 20 minutes with each and I bet you anything you would want a sling.

Message edited 2008-04-20 21:26:10.107000.

Posted 4/20/08 9:25 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I loved the Bjorn.

Posted 4/20/08 9:27 PM
 

SweetT
LIF Adult

Member since 4/06

1305 total posts

Name:
Ali

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I love my bjorn and saw it at BJ's recently for I think under 50$!

Message edited 2008-04-20 21:33:14.587000.

Posted 4/20/08 9:32 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

Sounds almost like a diaper thing...what works for one baby does not for another, same with the sling and the Bjorn.

Probably a good idea to try out both and put something in each with a little weight. I don't care for slings at all myself, and I doubt DS would like it now--he hates being in the chest facing position on the Bjorn, but everyone is different. So you may love a sling, try each out.

Posted 4/20/08 9:40 PM
 

thiadora
Happy Little Girl

Member since 5/05

3830 total posts

Name:
Thia (Cynthia)

Re: Bjorn or sling?

Posted by cjik

Sounds almost like a diaper thing...what works for one baby does not for another, same with the sling and the Bjorn.




Very true. And some of it also comes down to what is comfortable for you.

My personal favorites were the Moby when he was a newborn. (I only stopped using it because it's not as convenient when you're out and about-- but it's great at home when you have the space to do the wrapping.) And now I love my Ergo. I've been using it since he was about 4 months old and it goes up to 40 lbs. (I think that the Bjorn only goes up to 25 lbs.) My DS was 25 lbs. 3 oz. at his 9-1/2 month appointment- so the Bjorn wouldn't even have lasted a year for me.

I have a couple of slings, but I have never found them as comfortable as the Moby and Ergo.

Posted 4/20/08 10:20 PM
 

nadia
My two Girls=)

Member since 7/07

1421 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

Posted by KateDevine

I loved the Bjorn.


Me too!

Posted 4/20/08 10:23 PM
 

jodi714
Love my little girl!

Member since 2/06

3621 total posts

Name:
Jodi

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I have both and would recommend both although we haven't used the sling a lot. I have the peanut shell but I may get a moby wrap because I hear great things about it. lately she is not so into the sling so I have been using the bjorn and I love it. It works really well for my DD who likes to be held upright. I use it mainly around the house to get things done, eat dinner, etc. DD falls asleep after a few minutes of me moving around.

Posted 4/20/08 10:24 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Bjorn or sling?

We don't use either one a lot but we have both and I plan to use them more now that Spring is here and i can walk with DS. I think that the Bjorn gives more freedom. DS seems more stable in it so I am not afraid to just let him hang there. With the sling, I still hold onto him a little bit. Do some research online. I met a girl who was wearing something like a Bjorn but it was a different brand and it looked great. She said it gets reviews as the easiest one on the back. It may have been the Ergo but I am not sure.

Posted 4/20/08 10:28 PM
 

my3boys
I love these boys

Member since 7/07

2711 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I never used the sling but I loved my Bjorn. My middle guy lived in it for the first few months since he wouldn't let me put him down.

Posted 4/21/08 12:03 AM
 

KangaMom
...

Member since 1/06

4593 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I didn't care for the Bjorn, DH liked it though. I used a Ring Sling from birth up and then started using a Mei Tei after a few months as well.

Posted 4/21/08 8:34 AM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I've used both. I think the Bjorn is easier to use at first, but there are a number of things I don't like about it:
--it puts strain on back
--you can't breastfeed in it
--there is some concern that it is bad for baby's development because of the way the baby hangs by it's crotch
--your baby will grow out of it after a few months

You won't have any of those problems with a sling, but a sling can be challanging to learn at first. There is a Babywearing meeting this Thursday in Brentwood where people can show you how to use a sling -- that's the best way to learn. FM me if you want details.

ETA: I see someone else mentioned the Ergo -- definately check that out. It's as easy and stable as a Bjorn, but you won't have the problmes I listed above with it (although I don't think you can breastfeed in it). I think BuyBuyBaby is selling them now. I also loved my moby for a younger baby. Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-04-21 09:03:25.387000.

Posted 4/21/08 8:51 AM
 

08BabySurprise
My Life. My Everything.

Member since 10/07

9151 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I never used a Bjorn but I love my sling. And I think my Chat Icon enjoys it too - he sleeps so soundly every time he is in it - curled up next to me. He is 6 weeks old. I will try the Bjorn in a few weeks when he gets better control of his little head/neck.

Posted 4/21/08 9:27 AM
 

Belladonna219
HOT MAMA

Member since 2/07

2642 total posts

Name:
Belladonna219

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I had both and thought the bjorn was more comfortable.

Posted 4/21/08 9:30 AM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Bjorn or sling?

Does BBB have them out for you to try? How do you test them without making the purchase?

Posted 4/21/08 8:09 PM
 

thiadora
Happy Little Girl

Member since 5/05

3830 total posts

Name:
Thia (Cynthia)

Re: Bjorn or sling?

Posted by Dragonfly75

I've used both. I think the Bjorn is easier to use at first, but there are a number of things I don't like about it:
--it puts strain on back
--you can't breastfeed in it
--there is some concern that it is bad for baby's development because of the way the baby hangs by it's crotch
--your baby will grow out of it after a few months

You won't have any of those problems with a sling, but a sling can be challanging to learn at first. There is a Babywearing meeting this Thursday in Brentwood where people can show you how to use a sling -- that's the best way to learn. FM me if you want details.

ETA: I see someone else mentioned the Ergo -- definately check that out. It's as easy and stable as a Bjorn, but you won't have the problmes I listed above with it (although I don't think you can breastfeed in it). I think BuyBuyBaby is selling them now. I also loved my moby for a younger baby. Chat Icon



I was never successful at it-- but you can BF in the Ergo. I watched their demos and they show how you can BF in it. (You loosen the straps so the baby moves down a bit and then put the hood over them for privacy. I just couldn't figure out how to loosen the strap while my DS was actually in it.)

Posted 4/21/08 10:16 PM
 

thiadora
Happy Little Girl

Member since 5/05

3830 total posts

Name:
Thia (Cynthia)

Re: Bjorn or sling?

Posted by SweetCaroline

Does BBB have them out for you to try? How do you test them without making the purchase?



I know of a store in the City that lets you try them out. But mostly it seems like you're relying on the rec's of other moms. Too bad we can't get together and let each other try the carriers we have. I feel like the whole thing is such an individual preference.

Posted 4/21/08 10:21 PM
 

heidla
Me and the guys

Member since 5/05

4024 total posts

Name:
Heidi

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I hated the Bjorn. DH liked it. I preferred the Ergo when it comes to carries. Much easier on my back and shoulders and I love that I can use it three different ways (actually, I have placed my DS in it facing out and he was fine). Now that DS is almost a year he likes to ride on my back in it. I also love my slings. I have a Maya wrap and a Peanut Shell. DH loves both. I know that some places in the city have sling/carrier seminars you might want to see if something like that goes on near you.

ETA: you can BF in the Ergo with a little practice.

Message edited 2008-04-21 23:18:54.163000.

Posted 4/21/08 11:17 PM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

Here's a link the NYC store's website:

Slingzilla

There is also a Long Island Babywearing Group. They have meetings all across the island. There's one this Thursday morning in Brentwood.

Here's their website:

LI Babywearing

You can try out different baby carriers and get tips at either of these places.

Posted 4/22/08 8:44 AM
 

NewlyMrs
Laugh-Live-Love LIFE!

Member since 10/06

14432 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Bjorn or sling?

I just got the Moby this weekend. I never thought I would because it looked too intimidating, but it is actually very easy. I put it on in seconds and did not need assistance. I had my daughter in it sleeping for 2.5 hours yesturday while I prepared dinner.

Posted 4/22/08 8:44 AM
 

luvnlife
LIF Adult

Member since 7/07

981 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn or sling?

Posted by Dragonfly75

Here's a link the NYC store's website:

Slingzilla

There is also a Long Island Babywearing Group. They have meetings all across the island. There's one this Thursday morning in Brentwood.

Here's their website:

LI Babywearing

You can try out different baby carriers and get tips at either of these places.




This sounds great. I've been debating getting a sling but didn't want to buy one without trying it. If DS cooperates I think I might go.

Posted 4/22/08 9:06 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
sling and bjorn??? jodi714 1/13/08 7 Pregnancy
Bjorn vs. sling LUCY 8/19/07 3 Parenting
Baby Bjorn/Snugli/sling..... btrflygrl 7/5/07 12 Parenting
Does your DH use the same baby carrier/sling as you do? And what do you think he might like? thiadora 6/11/07 5 Parenting
shoe Q....how far into "winter" or cold weather do you wear sling backs or d'orsay style pumps Ophelia 9/26/06 4 Fashion & Beauty!
Baby Bjorn Ali 3/14/06 5 Parenting