bf article - a different take

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

pandaworm
LIF Adult

Member since 8/08

1125 total posts

Name:
bethany

bf article - a different take

i hope this doesn't offend anyone or start a big debate or drama, but i just thought it might be something people would be interested in.

article

Posted 4/15/10 12:26 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsC614
My little angel is here <3

Member since 7/09

2851 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: bf article - a different take

Posted by pandaworm

i hope this doesn't offend anyone or start a big debate or drama, but i just thought it might be something people would be interested in.

article



wow!!! i am pregnant with my first baby, and that really makes me think!!!
And I'm a nurse too!
thanks for this!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/15/10 12:47 AM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: bf article - a different take

Each of those scenarios was definitely told with a spin, not objectively. Does a newborn really crawl its way to the mother's breast even in the best of circumstances?

Message edited 2010-04-15 01:04:55.660000.

Posted 4/15/10 1:04 AM
 

codybear
Our Family is Complete!

Member since 11/06

2064 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: bf article - a different take

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

Each of those scenarios was definitely told with a spin, not objectively. Does a newborn really crawl its way to the mother's breast even in the best of circumstances?



Actually yes, if you google breast crawl you can find a video of it, its quite amazing.

Posted 4/15/10 3:00 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: bf article - a different take

wow. the first scenario is very much like my birth experience here in the UK on the NHS with my son...except that I get a years maternity leave and its a midwife, not a doula. And no copays!!!

eta...when I had my section with Immi they ask if you want skin to skin and if you are breast feeding, they hand the baby right to you, all mucky and covered in vernix and let you have a few minutes, in recovery I sat with Immi for about an hour doing Kangaroo care (she sat inside of my hospital gown) and it was wonderful...hence the look of absolute bliss on my face here

Message edited 2010-04-15 15:06:42.200000.

Posted 4/15/10 4:16 AM
 

lorich
.

Member since 6/05

9987 total posts

Name:
Grammie says "Lora Gina"

Re: bf article - a different take

Sadly that's so true! I had a c-section. DS was brought over to me all washed up & bundled to the max.
When I got in recovery I stripped him down & he latched right on. The nurses were yelling at me through my entire stay because I kept stripping DS down for the skin to skin contact AND kept him in our room 24/7.

From the point of the recovery until the time I got him later on I found out they gave him a bottle when they took him to the nursery to clean him up & give him his vitamin K shot.

DS was crying one night & one nurse pushed & pushed for us to give him a bottle saying my milk wasn't in & I should feed him. DH & I pushed through it & he was fine. I think most of the nurses tend to take the easy way out. I hope more hospitals get good LCs. The one we had at SB was awesome. I really didn't see her during my stay because we were fine with BFing, but her class gave tons of great information and tips, which we think helped us.

Posted 4/15/10 6:58 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: bf article - a different take

Nice article. I went to the link for the baby friendly hospitals and only ONE in all of metropolitan NY? And it's in Harlem? Not one on LI? That makes me sad to see.

I wish I could have seen DD in recovery, I didn't get to see her until I was in my room. It may cause me to switch up OBs this time so I don't have to deliver at Good Sam except that I really like and trust my OB. I had one nurse who really pushed to formula feed too, even accused me of being unfit for starving my DD. I wish I had educated myself more before going in. I actually called DH at 5:30 in the AM from there begging him to come get me.

Posted 4/15/10 7:38 AM
 

tran92
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/08

732 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: bf article - a different take

ok, not to the point of the article, but there is one comment in it thats blantantly wrong! blood sugar in a newborn at 45 is NOT normal. i had a child born with severe hypoglycemic issues and it drives me nuts to see people say a blood sugar of 45 is ok in a newborn. it should be in the normal range, of 60-120. anything below that is hypoglycemic and can cause brain damage.

i'll get off my soapbox now.

Posted 4/15/10 8:32 AM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: bf article - a different take

Love this article. I was very lucky to pretty much have the 1st birth experience listed in the article (except the 80% paid maternity leave!). I absolutely agree with the skin to skin contact and having their first hour (or more) of life be bonding with you.

They let us have DD for 1.5 hours immediately after birth to bond/breastfeed before they took her away to do anything. She took to nursing literally 10 mins after birth and it was smooth sailing from there.

You have to speak up when you're in the hospital and know your rights.


ETA: Racheeee, that is an amazing shot! I wish I had one like that.

Message edited 2010-04-15 08:37:42.823000.

Posted 4/15/10 8:36 AM
 

OOSMommy
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/09

860 total posts

Name:
me

Re: bf article - a different take

That article just gave me flashbacks of the first few months of DD's life - some of the darkest days.

I was lucky that the hospital where I delivered (OOS) was very pro-BF'ing and never gave her a bottle or pushed formula or pacis on me. BUT she lost a ton of weight there and had a lot of trouble putting it back on. The first weeks were a blur of LC visits, pumping, weight checks, and endless crying (both of us). It was awful.

I don't even know what point I'm making except that even in the first scenario (perfect hospital), there are a lot of us who don't have that instant supply that helps them gain weight. And it's a really trying experience under any circumstances.

Posted 4/15/10 8:43 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: bf article - a different take

wow..scenario # 2 is a lot like my experience. they show you all these happy videos in childbirth class, and really..nothing can prepare you.

I didnt have a bad experience, but I did need a vacuum to get DS out; they put him on me for maybe 30 seconds..took him over to the scale, cleaned him up a bit, swaddled, etc. then when they took him to the nursery to do all their poking & prodding, they had to give him an oz of formula b/c his sugar was low. even though everyone was informed that I was going to try breastfeeding first.

The day after i asked for a nurse to come help me get him to latch and she literally spent 30 seconds trying to shove my boob into his mouth. that was it. and oddly enough, all the lactation consultants were on vacation that week from the hospital. so i was shi** out of luck.

and my breast pump got lost in the mail..long story. so even by the time i got home, i had no pump.

Posted 4/15/10 8:47 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: bf article - a different take

Posted by cookiemonster
BUT she lost a ton of weight there and had a lot of trouble putting it back on. The first weeks were a blur of LC visits, pumping, weight checks, and endless crying (both of us). It was awful.

.



I had the exact same experience

my ds was born at 9lb, 10oz and was down to 8lb,3oz when we left the hospital

I am still so traumatized over our first 4 weeks after birth

it was a NIGHTMARE Chat Icon

Posted 4/15/10 8:47 AM
 

ruby
you rang?

Member since 6/08

5573 total posts

Name:

Re: bf article - a different take

Posted by CaMacho

You have to speak up when you're in the hospital and know your rights.




Exactly! You must speak up, I didn't end up having the birth experience I wanted, nowhere close to it, but I knew that even though I had a c-section and had the baby taken away, I wanted the baby to room with me, I wanted the baby given to me unswaddled and I placed him on my chest to nurse. They wanted to take him to the nursery and I said no. They wanted to give him formula, I said no. I knew to ask for certain things as I'd done my research ahead of time and knew that I was going to BF come hell or high water. I knew it was going to be hard, I knew it was going to be painful, I knew it was going to feel like needles were shooting through my nipples those first few weeks. I knew he'd want to feed around the clock and I'd get no sleep. I knew I did not want to give him a bottle in the hospital no matter what the nurses said about him being hungry as I knew his stomach was barely the size of a pea and my colostrum was all he needed. I'm not saying I'm perfect, I'm just saying that I armed myself with all the information I could get my hands on re: BFing because that was my choice, I was determined to do it and any issues with latching, supply, pain, etc were not going to stop me. NOT saying if these issues stopped you that it is bad, this is just how I felt for ME. I think any hospital can be a "baby friendly" hospital if that's what you make it. You don't HAVE to listen to the nurses, they are not god, I was his mother and once he was born, what I said, went, and that was that. If he had an actual medical issue after birth then that's a whole different story, but I knew what they might try and tell me and/or convince me to do ahead of time, so I spoke up and we did what I wanted. You (the collective you) do whatever works for you and your baby and makes you comfortable. Happy mom= happy baby. Chat Icon

Posted 4/15/10 8:55 AM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: bf article - a different take

The first birth in that article is EXACTLY like my home birth.



Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

Each of those scenarios was definitely told with a spin, not objectively. Does a newborn really crawl its way to the mother's breast even in the best of circumstances?



Yes, Amelia wiggled herself right to my breast and started nursing within 5 minutes of being born, it was amazing!

Posted 4/15/10 9:06 AM
 

Grill
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

994 total posts

Name:
J

Re: bf article - a different take

Does a newborn really crawl its way to the mother's breast even in the best of circumstances?



Yes, absolutely. If given the opportunity within an hour or two after birth, all human babies will do this..but there is a critical window and the use of drugs may inhibit the instinctual response. My DS did this five minutes after he was born and taught me how to BF him. And then again at 2 months when we were having problems, I followed "baby-led nursing" after reading an article on this different style of latching. My son amazed me again with his instincts....and again, we relearned how to do it properly. I didn't read the article in the OP yet...but I wanted to respond to your question.

Posted 4/15/10 9:09 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: bf article - a different take

I wish I could have had an experience like #1. Unfortunately mine was #2. My babies went right to NICU since I had preeclampsia. I did not put Ronan to breast until 4 days after birth(he was on cpap) I ended up pumping and building a great supply with a pump. When they were in the NICU I was not encouraged at ALL to BF and they pushed formula-fed them even when they knew I was coming down to BF and basically ignored my requests. I was the one who talked about skin to skin, none of the nurses or LC's even mentioned it to me. I knew about it from books I had read and another friend who had preemie twins.

If I ever have another baby I am doing it at a birthing center-maybe even in water!

Posted 4/15/10 9:10 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: bf article - a different take

Posted by codybear

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

Each of those scenarios was definitely told with a spin, not objectively. Does a newborn really crawl its way to the mother's breast even in the best of circumstances?



Actually yes, if you google breast crawl you can find a video of it, its quite amazing.



yep try it, get you and your baby naked and put them on your chest, its amazing Chat Icon I did it all the time in the first week to help build milk supply and help us bond. I have no idea about this baby latching themselves part, I would love to get that right!

I had the oddest experienced DS was gaining weight just fine, but he was yellow. One ped said he's really yellow and I needed to worry, the other say ped #1 was crazy. Too bad it was 3 days later, after I had a panic attack and offered the baby formula in tears.

Message edited 2010-04-15 09:52:57.917000.

Posted 4/15/10 9:13 AM
 

FelAndJon
needs to update her avatar pic

Member since 6/05

10212 total posts

Name:
Felice (aka LuckyBride2004)

Re: bf article - a different take

Wow, that is some article! While my births were not exactly like scenario #2, they were most certainly nothing like #1 either.

DS1:
Due to developing pre-eclampsia, I was on Magnesium. After 12+ hours of labor, with no progression, I went in for a c-section. Because of the mag, I was not able to BF for the first 36 hours. He latched on immediately and we successfully nursed for 9 months (he bit me, drew blood and I called it quits!). I was not able to pump, due to various circumstances,, so I supplemented with formula once I went back to work at 4 months but nursed when we were together.

DS2:
After delivering at 33 1/2 weeks (emergency c-section), baby was whisked off to the NICU immediately. I didn't even see him until the following day Chat Icon Chat Icon. As soon as I was able, I got a pump and started to pump so the NICU nurses could give him the colostrum. I pumped and brought milk to the NICU 6 times a day until he was taken off the feeding tube. Even with the tube in, the nurses encourages kangaroo hold from the beginning. I can't remember if the tube was still in but I was nursing him by day 4. He latched on right away (even the NICU nurses and the lactation consultant were amazed by how good he was at it!) and I continued to nurse him for a little over 15 months. I was no longer working so I didn't have to worry about pumping.

I am proof that even under the worst circumstances, you can make it work if you want to! With that said, I am in no way against formula! I was only able to make it work because I wanted to make it work for me and my familyChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/15/10 9:42 AM
 

Marbo
LOVE

Member since 7/08

2374 total posts

Name:

Re: bf article - a different take

Posted by pinkandblue

Posted by cookiemonster
BUT she lost a ton of weight there and had a lot of trouble putting it back on. The first weeks were a blur of LC visits, pumping, weight checks, and endless crying (both of us). It was awful.

.



I had the exact same experience

my ds was born at 9lb, 10oz and was down to 8lb,3oz when we left the hospital

I am still so traumatized over our first 4 weeks after birth

it was a NIGHTMARE Chat Icon



Same here...dd was 8lb4oz and went down to 7lb7oz...but I still breastfed only- until day 3 when the ped told me to supplement(which they told me earlier but I didn't listen but finally had to when I breast fed her in the office for 1/2 hour and she gained nothing at all)...but I had to go to the ped right away, go to the lab for bili rubin 2 days in a row and then my dd ended up in the NICU for 2 days at 4 days old for an unrelated issue-1st week was a nightmare.

Hopefully next time things will go better. My birth was a little bit in the middle of 1 and 2. We had the baby for about an hour before they took her and I could have breastfed her but instead I allowed our parents to come in and see her. When I finally did get to breastfeed her she latched only on one side...by the time I left the hospital she was great on both. I didn't buy the pump right away and everyone told me the baby was better than the pump-but I really think I could have increased my supply if I pumped earlier on. I will definitely do things differently next time. But I am happy that my dd got at least a little breastmilk for almost 4 months.

Posted 4/15/10 9:43 AM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: bf article - a different take

Interesting article - i agree with it. US hospitals do not assist mother in bfing neither do employers. Hospitals push FF b/c it is easier for them to just shove a bottle in a baby's mouth than go through all the other steps of assisting in bfing even though in long run it is probably healthier for the baby and mother. This country is so backwards on so many things when it comes to women - maternity, working, etc.

Posted 4/15/10 9:44 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: bf article - a different take

OMG.

now this makes me cry.

I feel like my experience birthing him contributed SO MUCH to my problems breast feeding him. I have battled SO HARD to have this relationship...that I can now feed him FROM my breast to satisfaction is a miracle.

unfortunately I've never been able to pump enough and it took my longer than my 6 pitiful weeks of maternity leave (which was actually SICK TIME I had ACCRUED over the years I've been here b/c WE HAVE NO MATERNITY BENEFITS, and NO DISABILITY INS PROGRAM) so he's the ONLY time he is EBF is on the weekends.

he was over 2 months old before I could feed him from the breast. it was Christmas week and I kept him on the breast the whole week to build the supply sufficiently. we now, at 6 months, can make it 3 hours between feedings, which I think is low for his age, but it's fine for me b/c it allows me these moments with him that I will cherish always.

the description of his birth is almost identicle, except that I DID have him all yucky and clammy on my chest for a few short moments...and he was checked IN the room with me. but *I* was in need of MANY stitches (it took almost an hour to stitch my cervix and the epi cut/tear) so my dh held him.

the hours and hours with an IV in my arm from being induced also did not help with my milk production and it came in late.

and YES, your child instinctively and absolutely roots for its mother's breast. please do not doubt it.

Rachel, I am so happy for your birthing experience. people are so ethnocentric here that they fail to realize it could be and IS being done differently to great success in other countries. our national "pride" is hurting us.

thank you for posting this. Chat Icon

ETA: my hospital DID NOT have an LC. they let her go b/c of budget cuts. but the formula freebies were so easy to find. Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-04-15 10:30:14.260000.

Posted 4/15/10 10:27 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: bf article - a different take

Posted by Ophelia


and YES, your child instinctively and absolutely roots for its mother's breast. please do not doubt it.

:



ABSOLUTELY...I learned in BFing class that fluid from your nipples smell just like amniotic fluid and that draws the baby to them

awesome, isn't it Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/15/10 10:35 AM
 

DoctorK1219
LIF Infant

Member since 7/08

346 total posts

Name:
Debra

Re: bf article - a different take

I EBF my daughter and my experience was much more like #2. The nurses even gave her formula in the nursery because they said her blood sugar was low (she was premature). When I told my ped that, he looked at her chart and said her sugar levels were fine and to stop giving her formula if I planned on breast feeding. I'm glad I listened to him and not the people at the hospital!

Posted 4/15/10 10:51 AM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: bf article - a different take

Posted by CaMacho


You have to speak up when you're in the hospital and know your rights.



I think a big thing is knowing what to ask. I took a breastfeeding class and a birthing class and none of this was brought up. We were told to write out a birth plan, but not really given any idea what that could include. Going in for the first time, how are you supposed to know what you can ask for? My birth plan was no formula for DS and he was to stay in the room with us, I didn't know I could ask to have him placed on my chest immediately following the section - I wish I had! There should be more guidance from the hospital and OBs.

My birth was very much like #2, I had an emergency C-section and didn't even see DS until 15 minutes after his birth, I didn't hold him for nearly an hour. I did have a pro BFing hospital, so he was never given formula and they did stress nursing him within 3 hours, but by the time I was able to hold him he was sleeping and he wouldn't latch.

I had so much trouble trying to get him to nurse, he lost so much weight they were not going to let us leave the hospital, but at the same time this pro BFing hospital only had 1 LC and I didn't see her until the day we left.

Thankfully my PED is pro BFing, she said to nurse more and supplement with BM. We went out and bought the top of the line pump (and like the article said neither INS or FLEX would cover it ...and yes Thank God for the gift cards). My breasts would not respond to the pump, I never got more than 1/2 an ounce. So I ended up having to supplement with formula and felt like a failure. I would cry as I gave him the bottle, as people questioned me why he was getting a bottle, and while I continued to struggle to BF him.

Thankfully after 6-8 weeks of HELL, BFing became normal and 4 weeks after that he no longer got any formula.

I also didn't find out until later that the meds I was on after the section can suppress milk production, had I known that I would have just dealt with the pain from the surgery and skipped the meds.

We don't instinctively know what to ask for, and you can't really research something without knowing what you are looking for. If we have a 2nd child I think I'll be printing out part 1 and calling it my "birth plan"

Posted 4/15/10 11:03 AM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: bf article - a different take

Posted by NinaLemon

I think a big thing is knowing what to ask. I took a breastfeeding class and a birthing class and none of this was brought up. We were told to write out a birth plan, but not really given any idea what that could include. Going in for the first time, how are you supposed to know what you can ask for?



You're correct, you need to know what to ask and what your rights are in the hospital. What I did was research research research!

We took a birthing class that was extremely informative, pro BFing, pro natural birth and actually had an experienced doula and a doctor who sat in class with us too to answer questions. Then I would go home and google everything about natural birth, breastfeeding, first hours of life, etc. We rented the Business of Being Born as well which was a real eye opener for me.

I think it's also a lot of luck with who your dr is and nurses are in the hospital that day. I was lucky to have an amazing dr. who sat with me from the minute she got to my room when I was in labor until DD was born and had nurses who encouraged skin to skin and immediate breastfeeding.

Posted 4/15/10 11:16 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Article on avoiding Soy MrsR 6/22/05 8 TTC
Article: Home Buyer Mistakes to Avoid HarleyGirlFLA 6/21/05 5 Home
Interesting Article on Home Ownsership karacg 6/13/05 1 Home
Daily News Article on Bad Vets baghag 5/29/05 2 Pets
This is a great article It so explains my MIL june262004 5/20/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
There is an article about Jergens tanner TAD 5/17/05 23 Families Helping Families ™