Baby naming (sensitive topic)

Posted By Message

katiebug
I'll love you for always

Member since 2/08

4624 total posts

Name:
Katie

Baby naming (sensitive topic)

I have a friend who's husband had a brother who killed himself. If they have a son he wants to name the baby after him. She is very uncomfortable with the idea because of how he died. She doesn't know how to say no without sounding heartless.

I don't think I could do it. I have two cousins that committed suicide, and I don't think I could name a child for them. It just makes me feel uncomfortable.

Posted 2/4/11 11:15 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

Posted by katiebug

I have a friend who's husband had a brother who killed himself. If they have a son he wants to name the baby after him. She is very uncomfortable with the idea because of how he died. She doesn't know how to say no without sounding heartless.

I don't think I could do it. I have two cousins that committed suicide, and I don't think I could name a child for them. It just makes me feel uncomfortable.




I would feel the same way-what about a middle name? I would offer that as a compromise.

Posted 2/4/11 11:16 AM
 

katiebug
I'll love you for always

Member since 2/08

4624 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by katiebug

I have a friend who's husband had a brother who killed himself. If they have a son he wants to name the baby after him. She is very uncomfortable with the idea because of how he died. She doesn't know how to say no without sounding heartless.

I don't think I could do it. I have two cousins that committed suicide, and I don't think I could name a child for them. It just makes me feel uncomfortable.




I would feel the same way-what about a middle name? I would offer that as a compromise.



That is what I told her. But the brother just died a few months ago so the emotions are still very raw. I don't think she knows how to say no.

Posted 2/4/11 11:18 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

Posted by katiebug

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by katiebug

I have a friend who's husband had a brother who killed himself. If they have a son he wants to name the baby after him. She is very uncomfortable with the idea because of how he died. She doesn't know how to say no without sounding heartless.

I don't think I could do it. I have two cousins that committed suicide, and I don't think I could name a child for them. It just makes me feel uncomfortable.




I would feel the same way-what about a middle name? I would offer that as a compromise.



That is what I told her. But the brother just died a few months ago so the emotions are still very raw. I don't think she knows how to say no.



Hopefully they will have a girl first, and then in time, if they have a boy, he will be able to see it from a different angle.Chat Icon for themChat Icon

Posted 2/4/11 11:19 AM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

Is she pregnant now? Or is this just a future thing they're talking about? If it's not like an immediate thing they are dealing with, I would think the best thing is to not discuss names really until they do get pregnant. By then, more time will have passed, and it might be a little easier to separate emotions from the conversation. Such a difficult situation, I honestly don't know what I would do.

Posted 2/4/11 11:22 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

I don't see the issue at all. I think its an honor to remember the good in the brother, the love they felt.

To see a small child carry the name on and succeed in life, grow, thrive and be loved.

JMHO

Posted 2/4/11 11:22 AM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

I agree with you - I would feel very uncomfortable with that.
Maybe she can say that since this is such a new feeling to deal with, she wouldn't want those sad emotions associated with something so happy. I don't know if I'm saying that right - i hope everyone understands what I mean.
Like it might make the DH sad to hear his brother's name and be reminded of that tragedy

Posted 2/4/11 11:29 AM
 

katiebug
I'll love you for always

Member since 2/08

4624 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

Posted by JennB

I agree with you - I would feel very uncomfortable with that.
Maybe she can say that since this is such a new feeling to deal with, she wouldn't want those sad emotions associated with something so happy. I don't know if I'm saying that right - i hope everyone understands what I mean.
Like it might make the DH sad to hear his brother's name and be reminded of that tragedy



See this is the problem she is having. She doesn't know how to word it. She doesn't want to offend him, because she loved her brother in law, and she understands why he wants the name to be the same.

Posted 2/4/11 11:39 AM
 

katiebug
I'll love you for always

Member since 2/08

4624 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

Posted by wingsofsong

Is she pregnant now? Or is this just a future thing they're talking about? If it's not like an immediate thing they are dealing with, I would think the best thing is to not discuss names really until they do get pregnant. By then, more time will have passed, and it might be a little easier to separate emotions from the conversation. Such a difficult situation, I honestly don't know what I would do.



They are currently TTC. They already have one daughter.

Posted 2/4/11 11:39 AM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

My best friend's brother committed suicide when he was in HS. My bf wife is now expecting a baby and they plan on using his deceased brothers name as a middle name. I think it's a nice compromise bc it's not the baby's first name so my friend won't be reminded of his brother ever time he calls his DS's name but at the same time, it's still honoring him. I think I'd probably do the same thing if I were in a similar situation.

Posted 2/4/11 11:41 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

I wouldn't feel uncomfortable with it but I can see emotions are running high. Suicide is something only unless you had to deal with it yourself or you tried it you never fully comprehend what its like. She might see it as this horrible negative thing (which it is) but to someone who's brother is dead they see it as remembering a brother who they loved, had many pleasant memories of and wishes to honor them.

If my significant other was uncomfortable with the first name I would compromise with a middle.

Posted 2/4/11 11:43 AM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

My friends had the same situation except the wife wanted to name the baby after his brother and the husband was not sure. In the end they used the brothers name as the baby's middle name. I was all for them naming the baby after his brother. I knew hiis brother very well, he was a friend of ours also and he was an amazing guy and I thought it would be a nice tribute, but I can also understand not wanting to do that. Her DH felt it would be a constant reminder to his parents.

I don't think there is a right or wrong, but if she feels that strongly against it she should talk to her DH and explain why. Maybe they can work out a compromise.

eta: I agree with waiting til they actually need to make the decision. Time may make one or both of them feel differently.

Message edited 2011-02-04 12:26:16.243000.

Posted 2/4/11 11:50 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

honestly, she doesn't not even need to broach this subject until she becomes pregnant with a boy.

there is no reason to upset him or cause an issue just yet.

my cousin had an issue with this when she got pregnant the first time around. her dh was adamant that he wanted to name the baby after his mom is if was a girl. my cousin HATED the name and they fought about it. she told me they may end up divorced in the delivery room. but all that fighting and discomfort ended up to be for naught b/c she had a boy.

not worth it to me to potentially hurt his feelings until it becomes an issue manifested. Chat Icon

that must be so hard though. Chat Icon

Posted 2/4/11 11:55 AM
 

piggy007
Mommy of 2!!

Member since 11/08

1742 total posts

Name:

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

Honestly I couldn;t do it. My mom was named after her sister that died at 6 months...when i think about it, it just freaks me out!

Posted 2/4/11 12:00 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

is she pregnant? or expecting and not know the gender? if either, then I would just not worry about it until she knows for sure that she is having a boy.. Chat Icon

Posted 2/4/11 12:18 PM
 

Mrs-Boop
My Babies

Member since 5/05

4956 total posts

Name:
Jaime

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

We almost had an issue. DH nephew died in September and the first thing out of people's mouths were, now you have to name the baby after him.
While we loved him, I would never have named the baby after him. I do not want people thinking of him and his death every time they say my sons name, specially with it being so new. I don't want to explain where he got his name when people ask. It is one thing to use it as a middle name. We are using my brothers name as our soon to be DS's middle name, because he was my bro. I would never even have thought to give him my brothers name as a first name. That was my brother, not my son!!

Posted 2/4/11 12:51 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

i dont know, i really think it depends on your relationship with the deceased.

if i were very close to a sibling who commited suicide, i would have no reservations about naming my child after that person.

if the relationship was ehh, i would not.

for me, naming a baby after someone deceased is a way to honor that person. your memories of that person. i always try to remember the goods times and not reflect on the bad after a death.

we named my son after my father who passed (a victim of hospital medical malpractice) and it doesnt bring up bad memories for me. those memories would be there regardless of whether or not we named my son after my father or not. it makes me happy to think that we honored my dad in such a way.

i also think it will help my son to feel more connected to my father though he never met him. again depends upon your relationship with the deceased.

Message edited 2011-02-04 12:59:39.670000.

Posted 2/4/11 12:59 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

In the Jewish faith we name after the deceased. If you want to name after somene who had a short life you also name after someone who had a long life to balance it out.

Or if his name was Daniel, maybe they can name him Neil... or David... something that starts with the same letter.

OR - look up the meaning of his name, and use a different name w/ the same meaning. Or a different origin... Jaque/Jack...

ETA: are there any other men that she'd want to name after and say, I thiought if we had aboy we could name him after my uncle/grandfather?

Message edited 2011-02-04 13:02:28.037000.

Posted 2/4/11 1:01 PM
 

sj-girl
Happy Family of 4

Member since 5/08

5654 total posts

Name:

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

I would feel the same way. Maybe she can compromise and use it as a middle name.

Posted 2/4/11 1:08 PM
 

labonnevie
sometimes 1+1= 4 <3

Member since 8/09

3869 total posts

Name:
the lucky one

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

I think it's too sore of a subject to discuss now. I think she should simply say, let's discuss this when we become pregnant and find out we're having a boy (if that happens).

I personally wouldn't want to name the first name after someone who died(especially after someone who committed suicide- that is emotional), but the middle name definitely.

Kerry- BAM2009 named her DS after her father or brother who had passed but calls her DS by his middle name because it's too difficult for her mom, DS's grandmother, to say the name.

I know in the jewish religion they choose the first initial of a person who has passed and they name the next born with a name that starts with that initial to honor the person who has passed.

Posted 2/4/11 1:22 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

Posted by Xelindrya

I don't see the issue at all. I think its an honor to remember the good in the brother, the love they felt.

To see a small child carry the name on and succeed in life, grow, thrive and be loved.

JMHO



ITA!

Posted 2/4/11 1:26 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Baby naming (sensitive topic)

In the Jewish faith we name after those in our family that have passed on. What we do in my family is use the first initial of the relative. It honors the other person. You say that you hope they have the same good attributes as the person who passed.

Posted 2/4/11 1:41 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
*Sensitive subject* post-baby intimacy.. Mom2010 9/25/10 4 Parenting
Anyone's Baby on Similac Sensitive RS? mrswask 2/24/10 22 Parenting
Sensitive Skin on Baby - PSA Angel321 12/30/09 0 Parenting
baby sensitive skin wants2bmommy 9/18/09 9 Parenting
Spinoff to baby items: those with sensitive skin: kerrycec03 3/4/09 2 Parenting
Best lotion for very sensitive baby skin?? johnsae 9/10/07 10 Parenting