Are you an only child?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Are you an only child?

There is a possibility that DH and I are "one and done". There are some health concerns that make IF treatments something I shouldn't persue. (we need IF last time).

There are financial concerns

There are space concerns.

I had a scary end to my pregnancy and some health issues long after that if they combine could prove to be dangerous. Not that it would be definite (i.e., I had pre eclampsia. If I had that again it is a high risk for a condition I developed last year that made me sick. It has resolved itself but, there is always a chance it could come)

All that together, plus the fact that we feel so full and happy right now.. we are discussing not having another. I can't even believe we are thinking that. We both come from 5 or 6 kid families. I never thought I would only have 1.

I feel okay with it now but, I am afraid that I will regret it later or that DS will feel empty because he didn't have siblings. Also, the burden that places on one child when we are older..

Then there is the thought that I yearn for a girl. Not that I would be able to make that happen for sure but still...

Anyway, the point... Do you, as an only child, feel sad you didn't have siblings? Did you have a very full and loving life or did you feel like something was missing?

Any input would be greatly appreciated. I am struggling with this choice so much.

TIA

Message edited 2012-12-21 09:18:08.627000.

Posted 12/21/12 9:16 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Are you an only child?

I hope you don't mind me jumping in- I am not an only child, but I am the mom of an only, who is 5. I never got the urge to have another one, and I had some complications that made me worry about a second pregnancy.

My DD loves being an only child. I have asked her more than once if she wants a sibling, and she always says no. (And she is crazy about her baby cousins, but even after visits with them, she still says she doesn't want another baby in the house!)

There are no guarantees that siblings will be friends- I know plenty of people who've gotten nothing but misery from their siblings. Though I also know people whose siblings are their best friends. So I do put time into making sure DD has people in her life who are there for her. My nephew, who is also an only at this point, is crazy about my DD, and she loves him, and they are very close. And she's got two nice friends in our neighborhood who she sees a lot. She is not spoiled even though we are able to give her opportunities she would not have if we had more kids.

And for the most part, all of the adult onlies I know are happy, successful and well-adjusted.

Good luck- whatever your choice, there are pluses and minuses.

Posted 12/21/12 9:26 AM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Are you an only child?

Well I will be honest. Yes there are times that I really wanted a sibling, esp bc I have a very small family and my aunt and cousins live in TX so I feel like I really don't have very much family. That is mainly when I wish I had a sibling. Now having said that....since I am an only my parents took me on amazing trips, paid for things etc that I probably wouldn't have seen if I had a sibling. Also means my girls get extra grandparent attention bc it is just them. They love taking family vacations etc. Not sure we would have done all that if I had siblings. I would say if health was an issue I would go with one and not have regrets.

Posted 12/21/12 9:33 AM
 

MrsFrizzle
<3

Member since 9/09

4628 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Are you an only child?

Not an only child either but my sisters BF is and he says he grew up pretty lonely.....HOWEVER this was because both parents worked and he was alone the majority of the time. I think had his parents been more attentive him feeling lonely would have been a non issue.

Growing my best friend was an only child and her parents got pregnant when she was 9 and then again with their 3rd when she was 11. Things can change in the blink of an eye, but I wouldn't worry about DS. My friend was fine as an only child and fine and one of three.

Posted 12/21/12 9:35 AM
 

MaZz
* Lovin my baby girl!!! *

Member since 2/09

6243 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Are you an only child?

I am an only child. I don't feel like I am missing something. Sure it would have been nice to have that bond with a sibling, but no one knows for sure if we would have even been that close kwim? I was always loved, always felt special, never needed a sibling to fill a void. I was not spoiled and was always happy with how we lived.

That being said, we too think that we may be one and done. Granted dd is still very little and a lot can change, but right now be believe we would be very content with having her, and just her. I feel like having another child would limit us financially. I don't think we'd be able to take the kids on all the vacations we love going on. I feel both kids would be missing out. Wth just one, we could swing it and take her places and do things that I always did as a child. So for us, it's also a financial concern. We have enough space for 2, but it would be crowded and we would eventually like to move to a bigger place and feel comfortable. I think having 2 children would mean that we'd end up staying in our current place for lack of extra $.

Posted 12/21/12 9:47 AM
 

Loveme
LIF Adult

Member since 6/11

3170 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Are you an only child?

I'm an only child. Growing up I had my cousins as my siblings, and we are still very close to this day. But I always longed for a sibling.
I lost both my parents suddenly and am the only one left. I swear if if wasn't for DH (my fiance at the time) I would have thrown myself off a cliff. I went into a deep depression and still struggle with the fact that it's just me.
Not saying AT ALL that will be the case with your DC, my situation is extremely rare.
You have to do what is right for your family.

I can say though that being an onl child has made me incrediby independent, which I think is a great quality to have. Plus the love and attention I got from my parents and grandparents was incredible! GL ! Chat Icon

Posted 12/21/12 9:49 AM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Are you an only child?

I am an only child and never, ever felt like I missed out on anything. I come from a small family, but it felt cozy, never lacking.

I would never have a second child just to "give them a sibling". Just in my immediate family, here are the dynamics:
- My mom only recently reconciled with her brother after a 20 yr estrangement
- My dad does not speak to his sister
- My DH does not speak to his sister

Not to mention many friends who have strained, if any, relationship with a sibling.

I guess I'm saying there is no guarantee that siblings are going to be in each others' lives. I have two children myself, and I can only hope they'll be there for each other throughout the years but honestly you never know.

Posted 12/21/12 9:51 AM
 

MrsDiamondgrlie
Bailey

Member since 5/05

12810 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Are you an only child?

I am not an only child, I have 1 sister who is 4 years younger than I am and we were like 2 peas in a pod all our lives and still are.

DH has a sister 6 years younger than him and even though they truly love each other like a brother and sister, they never had that "special" bond because of their age and sex.

DH's cousin is an only child and DH remembers him having more friends than anyone ever! He was never lonely.

DS will be an only child and its by choice. I was lucky, no complications (besides GD) and financially we definitely could but DH and I just arent "baby people" and openly admit we love that DS in now in school and we are get back to "us" time.

Ok, I am rambling... sorry.

My bottom line is, and my mom is the one who gave me this advice, that you shouldnt have another child for your kids. Its a good reason but shouldnt be the ONLY reason. YOU have to raise them, not their siblings.

Good luck in whatever you decide!

Posted 12/21/12 10:00 AM
 

Straightarrow
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

3534 total posts

Name:

Re: Are you an only child?

Posted by jkfris09

Not an only child either but my sisters BF is and he says he grew up pretty lonely.....HOWEVER this was because both parents worked and he was alone the majority of the time. I think had his parents been more attentive him feeling lonely would have been a non issue.

.




That sucks. Most parents have to work in this day and age and it doesn't mean that they aren't attentive to their child

Posted 12/21/12 10:05 AM
 

Frenchy49
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/10

707 total posts

Name:

Are you an only child?

I am an only child. I'm not going to lie I always wanted a sibling when i was younger because at the time i only had a few cousins but they were all older than me so I didn't really have any playmates. For health reasons my mom could never have another child not to mention my parents divorced before my fifth birthday. Luckily I ended up being in a great neighborhood with tons of kids my age so that filled that void of a sibling.

Now as an adult I enjoy being an only child because I get all of my parents attention lol.

Posted 12/21/12 10:08 AM
 

BellyBlessings
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/08

574 total posts

Name:

Re: Are you an only child?

I am an only child... and I NEVER felt like I was missing out on anything!

My Dh and I have a son... and we are 99% sure he is going to be our one and only... and I really don't feel like I "jipping" (SP? Chat Icon) him out of anything by not having another baby.

I will say this - now that I am 30 and my parents are in their 60s.. I do worry about what is going to happen if GOD FORBID they get sick... or worse.

Overall, I loved and still love being an only child. I like social time - but I also value my alone time. I wouldn't change it for anything!

Posted 12/21/12 10:19 AM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Are you an only child?

I am and have never had any issues with it. I think it helped make me pretty independent and self sufficient actually.

I had plenty of friends growing up, had a small family but never found myself wanting a sibling. I liked being the center of my parents attention and i know that we were able to do many things that would not have been possible if there was another child. I traveled Europe with my parents as a child, they took me to museums and hiking and we explored the countryside. I learned a lot in my childhood and i'm pretty sure if i had a sibling, we wouldn't have traveled nearly as much.

As another poster said, you can't have kids just to make a companion for your first kid - you have to WANT another one.

it's a decision that is different for everyone. Some people will say they were lonely as an only child and some will say they were perfectly fine

I know for myself, i have one child and i'm done. I love our little family unit and feel like we can do so much together. If we were to have another, everything would change (financially especially) and i'm not sure i want that.

good luck with your decision!

Posted 12/21/12 10:20 AM
 

MrsFrizzle
<3

Member since 9/09

4628 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Are you an only child?

Posted by Straightarrow

Posted by jkfris09

Not an only child either but my sisters BF is and he says he grew up pretty lonely.....HOWEVER this was because both parents worked and he was alone the majority of the time. I think had his parents been more attentive him feeling lonely would have been a non issue.

.




That sucks. Most parents have to work in this day and age and it doesn't mean that they aren't attentive to their child



It does suck and unfortunately for him he says this was the exact case. He would spend countless hours by himself everyday. It does not have to be that way even if both parents have to work.

Posted 12/21/12 10:25 AM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Are you an only child?

I'm not an only child; however, my brothers are significantly older than I am. They are 38 & 36, and I am 26. We grew up in different times, and they were teenagers when I was little. I never thought anything of not having a sibling close in age...I had plenty of friends and did plenty of things with my parents.

As an adult, I'm a bit jealous of people who have siblings who are close in age. Then again, I also have no first cousins....so I don't really have the opportunity to be close with any family member who is the same age and gender as me. You try to make family out of friends...but people don't always respond to that in the way you'd hope.

However, I never EVER EVER have thought that my parents should have had another child just to appease me. I especially would never think that my mother should've risked her health to give me a sibling.

Posted 12/21/12 10:25 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Are you an only child?

I am one and done and PROUD of it!

I’ll flip it though. I am one of 10 total. 1 full blooded brother, 1 half sister, 3 step sisters, 1 step brother, 2 adopted brothers (twins) and an adopted sister. I have at one point of my life been the youngest, middle, only and oldest. I loved being an only child the most.

My husband is the oldest of 3.

He wanted 3 kids, I wanted 2. Idealistically hahaha then reality when AJ was born was that we were both very content with one and one. We decided to revisit the issue when I was 36. I’m now 37 and we are both more than happy with what we’ve decided.

Our reasons:
Having a child for the sake of the current child just doesn’t compute in our minds. You can’t miss what you don’t’ have.
Being an only child won’t make you lonely, having friends and other family can and will suffice.
We both grew up with parents who sacrificed so much to manage our families. We don’t want her to see that struggle, feel that pressure. Because both of us as children saw the pain our parents went through no matter how much they tried to hide it. We both admit we had feelings of anger and/or our own struggles to live that life of barely scrapping by. I don’t want that for AJ. I don’t expect to spoil her but I also won’t have another to make HER happy or make myself feel better in a social world at the price of stretching us so thin. Things are LOT more expensive these days (daycare/school/college).
Having AJ nearly killed me. Literally. My blood pressure after she was born was seriously insane. Like, took a year of meds and monitoring to come back to somewhat normal. I am not sure my body could handle that again.

Finally to us, there is no benefit to having another child than just that, having another child. If I were to accidentally get pregnant on my IUD (which would have its own problems) I wouldn’t regret it but I’m not hoping for a pregnancy.


ETA: Confession: I am VERY happy to have only one child. I often say "thank god we only have one" for so many different reasons an scenarios. I look at others with more kids and think "oh thank god that's not me" sure its cute to see the dad carrying his two kids in a park but I love that we share her equally with two sets of eyes, ears and hands.

Its hard to describe. I feel LUCKY to be able to give her so much because she's our one and only. She won't have to suffer because we're still paying tuition for daycare when she's in grade school. We can put all we can into her college fund without splitting it. We want to push her out to the world and explore. I think having one will let us be able to focus more on her and her goals and her desires and help her see them through without having to juggle another. One regret from my childhood was the chance to go to Australia to study marine biology in HS unrealized. I know without a doubt that it was because of the three kids at home (adopted) I dont hate them for it, and yes I accepted it.... but I wonder what my life would have been if I could have gone. I want her to have that ability. I wanted to go farther away for college but they couldn't afford it because of the kids. I wanted to take College classes in HS but couldn't because the kids' costs outweighed mine. So much that even my job at McDonald's paid for their clothes and school needs.

I'm not saying a financial explosion WON'T happen because we only have one child. I'm just saying I feel a little less fear that if something were to happen i won't have to stretch it even FARTHER.

Message edited 2012-12-21 11:47:47.633000.

Posted 12/21/12 10:30 AM
 

AScottWolf
I <3 our squish!

Member since 11/10

2237 total posts

Name:
Adriana

Re: Are you an only child?

I am an only child.

Do I wish I had a sibling growing up? Yes. I'm adopted and asked my parents when I was younger, "When we go back to Mexico can you get me a brother or sister?" They looked into it for years but then the adoption laws changed there and they explained that too me. I was quite happy with the explanation and never thought much about it again.

Was I lonely growing up? At times yes but I fee like even children who have 5 siblings could feel like that. I had no first cousins my age and come from a pretty small immediate family. I did have plenty of friends growing and there are a few who I still talk to and am close too.

Was I spoiled? Yes. But I think every child is spoiled a little bit and don't always think of it as a negative term. My parents gave me things, and took me places that might not have been possible if there were other children in the home.

My dad passed away when I was 12 and it's been just my mom and I since then until I got married. Finances were a major struggle at times but I know that if there were other children to care for things would have gone from bad to worse.

Since it is just my mom and I I do worry about taking care of her when the time comes. But don't all children? Even if you come from a family of 5 who says that anyone else is going to take any interest in caring for an aging parent.

I've seen siblings who are very close, and I see siblings who act as if they are only children.

I'm in an odd situation in the fact that I'm now able to experience what it's like to have a sibling. I think I identify with being an only child so much that it's odd for me to call someone brother or sister at this point. Like another poster said, you can't miss what you never had.

I think you need to do what's best for you and your family and realize whatever decision you make is being made for a reason.

HTH

Posted 12/21/12 10:46 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Are you an only child?

My DH is an only. He said there was a time he wanted a sibling, but specifically an OLDER sister Chat Icon, so short of adoption, that wasn't going to happen.

He is not spoiled at all, which is the sterotype of only children, although he did have some advantages as the above poster mentioned. He went to private school, traveled to Europe, had help with college loans, etc, but he doesn't take that for granted.

My mom felt bad for him, when I told her he was an only, but he doens't feel bad for himself.

Yes, we will be the only ones to care for his parents, but I have a brother and I still will be the only one to care for my parents.

My brother was a difficult teen and there were times I wished I was an only.

There are some issies that arise, being the wife of an only child (especially a boy child) but a lot of that has to do with his mother, so you do have control over that with how you chose to handle things as he is older.

For me, I feel like she never really wanted to let go. She cried when he moved out
(less than an hour away) at 23 and said she didn't see him enough, even though he went there for dinner once a week.

We don't have children, so there is some tension there, because he was her only hope for having grandchildren. But my parnts have 2 kids & they don't have grandkids either--so you never really know what you are going to get.

Now that his cousins have moved away & his grandparents passed away, there is starting to be the slight problem that we have to spend all holidays with them so they aren't alone, but if you come from a bigger family (your own brothers & sisters) that isn't as much of an issue.

On the plus side, my husband is very skilled at entertaining himself. He can find something to read absolutely anywhere. He will go to movies alone, wander museums and explore cities while I am working if he travels with me on business trips.

He is not the most social, but part of that is just his personality. He is a loyal friend though, his two closest friends he has known for 22 years, so they are like his brothers. One of them is also an only.



Message edited 2012-12-21 11:03:12.853000.

Posted 12/21/12 10:59 AM
 

EclecticEsq10810
Bored Esq.

Member since 10/10

2156 total posts

Name:
L.

Re: Are you an only child?

I am an only child and so is DH (technically he has a half sister but she is 20 years his senior and lives in Ohio, she was adopted by a foster family). No regrets at all. I had a huge group of friends growing up and many cousins so was never alone as a child. Now as a grown up, the only regret is not being an aunt because DH and I plan to remain kid-free. So we just play auntie/uncle to our friends' kids but we love not having any family drama in our life.

Posted 12/21/12 12:17 PM
 

PennyCat
Just call me mommy :)

Member since 7/08

19084 total posts

Name:
Jib

Re: Are you an only child?

Well, I have a different perspective. I'm not an only child, but I have absolutely 1000000000% NO relationship with my brother Chat Icon It's very sad, but he has lots of problems he's dealing with and we have not spoken in I wanna say 20 years. It's horrible and weird, I know. I used to be humiliated by it, but I've learned to accept the situation for what it is and I know that none of this was my fault.

Anyway, my point here is having siblings is no guarantee they would have a close relationship. Of course that would be wonderful and ideal, but you just never know!

Posted 12/21/12 12:39 PM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Are you an only child?

I am an only child and love it! Have loved it for as long as I can remember. I remember wanting a sibling bc so many other kids had one but that was a short-lived phase. I quickly realized how good I had it. Honestly though, I have no complaints. I have an amazing relationship with my parents, always had friends and was able to enjoy and have many things I might not have had if I had siblings. Vacations were always fun bc my parents always invited one of my close friends along and took care of all their costs. I had cousins I was close to growing up. DH is an only child too and was perfectly content. I contemplated my DS being an only child for a long time. We ultimately decided to try for another but honestly, a part of that was bc BOTH DH and I are onlies so my DS has no aunts or cousins, etc. If DH had siblings and thus DS had a larger family, I'm pretty sure that I would have only had one.

Posted 12/21/12 1:24 PM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Are you an only child?

I am an only child.

I never knew how to answer when people asked me how it felt because I didn't know anything else.

Honestly, being an only child probably made it easier for my parents to provide me with certain things, especially after my dad passed away when I was 15 and funds were limited for some time.

Now that my mom is getting on in years it would be nice to have someone to help me help her with certain things. However, I think that is more a factor of who my mom is than anything else. We are very close so I hate to say this...but in many ways she is not the independent type. Also, there is no guarantee another sibling would be any help at all.

I would NEVER have a second child FOR the first child. The decision about whether or not to create a child is - or should be - one of the unique privileges of adulthood and coupledom and as such is really about what you and DH want for your family.

Posted 12/21/12 1:33 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Are you an only child?

Thanks for the honest responses.

Ds has some first cousins. They live in NJ though. One is a one year old and two are in high school. So he won't be close to them.

That's the other part of the problem. His family that he sees all the time is my family. My siblings will not have kids for a LOOONG time. They just aren't there. My SB will probably have a baby soon so maybe we will be closer to them once they have a child then we are now.

But, for now he really is the only child in his immediate family. I am the first grandchild by a lot. My closest cousins are in their 20's. I used to babysit for them but, now we are very close. So I guess a 10 year age difference in cousins might be a big difference now but, not so much later..

I just think we have a lot of soul searching to do. A lot.

I really appreciate the responses on both sides. We do both work but, I have school hours so we are home together in the summer and evenings so that's not an issue.

Posted 12/21/12 5:27 PM
 

frosty
LIF Toddler

Member since 5/05

462 total posts

Name:

Re: Are you an only child?

I'm an only child. I did want a sibling when I was a kid, but for a variety of reasons, my parents decided not to have any more children. I know that it was a difficult decision for them to make because they both wanted more children (my mom was 1 of 9 and my dad was 1 of 4).

I wasn't lonely growing up. I had a lot of cousins the same age and we were close then and are still close now. I may not see them often, but when we get together, it is like no time has passed.

I'm comfortable spending time alone, in fact I crave it. My DH is one of 5 kids and he doesn't understand it. I'm a fairly independent person, and I think that is partially a result of being an only child.

My mom is still fairly young and in good health. My MIL is much older and lives with us. And despite having 3 siblings capable of helping us out, none of them do.

My dad passed away when I was 15 and it crushed me. Would it have been nice to have a sibling to go through it with? Maybe. But it brought my mom and I closer together, so much so that she is my best friend.

Good luck with your decision.

Posted 12/21/12 5:48 PM
 

MaZz
* Lovin my baby girl!!! *

Member since 2/09

6243 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Are you an only child?

Posted by JennP

Also, there is no guarantee another sibling would be any help at all.




Agreed... my mom is going through this right now... Taking care of my grandmother because she lives the closest to her... My uncle barely even talks to my grandmother so its all on my mom and she is very stressed... So essentially she is an only child and this is prob what Im going to have to deal with later on in life since im an only child... but what can ya do... there are positives and negatives to anything

Posted 12/21/12 6:12 PM
 

KwaaksNest
Love my boys!

Member since 6/10

2825 total posts

Name:
Samantha

Are you an only child?

Im not an only child but my DH is an only child, and he said he always wished he had a sibling. Growing up was lonely, he got a step sibling later on in life when he was around 10 but he said it didnt matter much by then. The holidays and stuff were sad cause it was always just him and his mom most of time

Posted 12/21/12 8:28 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Am I One Of The Only Considerate Moms Left These Days? RE: children in your child's daycare class being invited to your child's birthday party and not responding BabyLove08 9/13/11 24 Parenting
Was your first child extremely jealous when the second child was born? How bad was the sibling rivalry? Bridex100 12/2/10 11 Parenting
Do you think it's ok for your child or any child to be allowed to stay on a school team (sports) if they are failing 2 classes? mitabtrfly 11/8/07 17 Parenting
for all of us who ever have a family memebr on a trip - child or adult, this is good to read... pschica 6/11/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Could you adopt a child of below average intellect? DebG 5/27/05 20 Families Helping Families ™
security item what does or doesnt your child use? TAD 5/24/05 8 Parenting