Amanda Knox

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Amanda Knox

Did any of you guys follow this case?

____________________________________


ROME - Italy's highest criminal court has overturned the acquittal of Amanda Knox in the slaying of her British roommate and ordered a new trial.

The Court of Cassation ruled Tuesday that an appeals court in Florence must re-hear the case against the American and her Italian-ex-boyfriend for the murder of 21-year-old Meredith Kercher.

Kercher's body was found in November 2007 in her bedroom of the house she shared with Knox and other roommates in Perugia, an Italian university town where the two women were exchange students. Her throat had been slashed.

Prosecutors alleged Kercher was the victim of a drug-fueled sex game gone awry. Knox and Raffaele Sollecito denied wrongdoing. An Ivory Coast man, Rudy Guede, was convicted of the slaying in a separate proceeding and is serving a 16-year sentence.


Posted 3/26/13 5:54 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Amanda Knox

I did follow this a bit. I don't understand how someone can be convicted, have it overturned, be aquitted and now that is overturned and she is being retried. How many times can one person be tried???

Posted 3/26/13 7:23 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Amanda Knox

I don't get it either.

I know our system has it flaws, but this story makes me thankful I am here.

They were just saying on the news that it is doubtful it will go anywhere (???) but they can try you and find you guilty in Italy even if you are not present (???).

Posted 3/26/13 7:37 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

I don't get it either.

I know our system has it flaws, but this story makes me thankful I am here.

They were just saying on the news that it is doubtful it will go anywhere (???) but they can try you and find you guilty in Italy even if you are not present (???).





Well then you have one solution then. Don't travel to Italy.

Posted 3/26/13 8:03 AM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Amanda Knox

I don't understand if they have a convicted guy that is serving a 16-year sentence why are they still going after Amanda Knox and the bf?

Posted 3/26/13 8:10 AM
 

Rosie4
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/12

643 total posts

Name:

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I don't understand if they have a convicted guy that is serving a 16-year sentence why are they still going after Amanda Knox and the bf?



I don't understand this either.

Posted 3/26/13 8:17 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Amanda Knox

It's like a witchhunt, IMO.

They acquitted her and the bf.

It's seems like they're sore about it and can't accept it, even though they convicted someone else of the crime. And, when I was reading the evidence it really didn't add up that Knox did it.

I think the bf still lives in Italy though, so he will have to face the charges.

Posted 3/26/13 8:18 AM
 

Eunyboo
<3

Member since 7/12

4376 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I don't understand if they have a convicted guy that is serving a 16-year sentence why are they still going after Amanda Knox and the bf?



They believe there was a second murderer.

Posted 3/26/13 8:46 AM
 

luvmotherhood
california dreamin'

Member since 2/13

1443 total posts

Name:
love my family!

Amanda Knox

This is crazy

Posted 3/26/13 8:58 AM
 

LILady7
LIF Infant

Member since 2/13

337 total posts

Name:

Amanda Knox

so what happens now? does she have to go back to Italy? can they make her?

Posted 3/26/13 9:04 AM
 

Jennifer
Happy

Member since 5/05

4230 total posts

Name:
.

Re: Amanda Knox

I have followed it. It is crazy that the reversed the acquittal.

Granted I think Amanda is a little out there. But I do not think she killed her. It was that guy Rudy. I thought he even admitted that he had killed Meredith.

They made so many mistakes collecting crime scene evidence.


Posted 3/26/13 9:12 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by LILady7

so what happens now? does she have to go back to Italy? can they make her?



They can't make her.

Posted 3/26/13 9:17 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Amanda Knox

Sounds to me like the entire Italian judicial system is embarrassed by her conviction being overturned. They want to try and save face and seem tough but its backfiring and they just look like idiots.

You can say you're gonna try her again but she cannot be forced to go back and the US wouldn't allow it either. While this is all going on in Italy she is still a US citizen and we don't allow double jeopardy here so why would we send someone overseas for it? Italy is just blowing smoke.

Posted 3/26/13 9:37 AM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by LILady7

so what happens now? does she have to go back to Italy? can they make her?



They can't make her.

\

I think they can- if Italy requests that the US extradite her, they may- I think it might be unluckly because of the double jeopardy and how we view things here, but its still a possibility

Posted 3/26/13 9:46 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by LILady7

so what happens now? does she have to go back to Italy? can they make her?



They can't make her.



So then she is safe? I mean odds are she will never want to travel to Italy anyway, right?

Posted 3/26/13 9:47 AM
 

luvmotherhood
california dreamin'

Member since 2/13

1443 total posts

Name:
love my family!

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by LILady7

so what happens now? does she have to go back to Italy? can they make her?



They can't make her.



So then she is safe? I mean odds are she will never want to travel to Italy anyway, right?


If I were her I would NEVER go back to Italy!!!

Posted 3/26/13 9:52 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by LILady7

so what happens now? does she have to go back to Italy? can they make her?



They can't make her.

\

I think they can- if Italy requests that the US extradite her, they may- I think it might be unluckly because of the double jeopardy and how we view things here, but its still a possibility



I responded based on a news article I read, because that point stood out to me. Italy apparently cannot make her return. Not sure about extradition.

"Italian law cannot compel Knox to return to Italy and she could be tried in absentia."



Link

Posted 3/26/13 9:53 AM
 

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by LILady7

so what happens now? does she have to go back to Italy? can they make her?



They can't make her.

\

I think they can- if Italy requests that the US extradite her, they may- I think it might be unluckly because of the double jeopardy and how we view things here, but its still a possibility



I responded based on a news article I read, because that point stood out to me. Italy apparently cannot make her return. Not sure about extradition.

"Italian law cannot compel Knox to return to Italy and she could be tried in absentia."



Link



Italy can petition the US to extradite her. However, since the Italian system is so vastly different then the American system, it's likely that the US would say no, based on the fact that European countries refuse to extradite people to the US in death penalty cases saying that the death penalty violates their policies.

Posted 3/26/13 10:05 AM
 

limomof2
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/13

845 total posts

Name:

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by MrsPJB2007

Sounds to me like the entire Italian judicial system is embarrassed by her conviction being overturned. They want to try and save face and seem tough but its backfiring and they just look like idiots.

You can say you're gonna try her again but she cannot be forced to go back and the US wouldn't allow it either. While this is all going on in Italy she is still a US citizen and we don't allow double jeopardy here so why would we send someone overseas for it? Italy is just blowing smoke.



You would think they would want this whole thing to go away....NOT bring it up again and again...makes them look worse.

Posted 3/26/13 10:08 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by sameinitials

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by LILady7

so what happens now? does she have to go back to Italy? can they make her?



They can't make her.

\

I think they can- if Italy requests that the US extradite her, they may- I think it might be unluckly because of the double jeopardy and how we view things here, but its still a possibility



I responded based on a news article I read, because that point stood out to me. Italy apparently cannot make her return. Not sure about extradition.

"Italian law cannot compel Knox to return to Italy and she could be tried in absentia."



Link



Italy can petition the US to extradite her. However, since the Italian system is so vastly different then the American system, it's likely that the US would say no, based on the fact that European countries refuse to extradite people to the US in death penalty cases saying that the death penalty violates their policies.



Thanks for explaining!

Posted 3/26/13 10:13 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Amanda Knox

I read a couple books about the case. One was very slanted in favor of her involvement, the other supported her innocence. I'm cynical enough to think that she might have had more to do with it than she claims (or remembers) but I also think the investigation was so botched that the truth will never be known about her role. I feel badly for Meredith's family but the person who did it IS in jail. The Italian justice system is such a disaster. The author of The Monster of Florence (I forget if it was Douglas Preston or Lincoln Child) also had a really scary run in with Italian authorities, thought I forget the specifics. But it showed how the authorities get their teeth into an idea, even a fabricated one, and refuse to let go.

Posted 3/26/13 10:32 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

I don't get it either.

I know our system has it flaws, but this story makes me thankful I am here.

They were just saying on the news that it is doubtful it will go anywhere (???) but they can try you and find you guilty in Italy even if you are not present (???).




They can try you in the US even if you're not present. Didn't they do that with Roman Polanski when he skipped town? I'm sure there are others too.

Posted 3/26/13 11:20 AM
 

MrsBurtch525
Year for change!

Member since 1/09

6017 total posts

Name:
Taryn

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by sfp0701

I did follow this a bit. I don't understand how someone can be convicted, have it overturned, be aquitted and now that is overturned and she is being retried. How many times can one person be tried???



That is what i was saying this morning. It's been 6 years at this point. DH reminded me that in Italy Double Jeopardy doesn't apply so they can try her however many times they want. It's crazy this is still going on.

Posted 3/26/13 12:32 PM
 

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

Re: Amanda Knox

Posted by MrsBurtch525

Posted by sfp0701

I did follow this a bit. I don't understand how someone can be convicted, have it overturned, be aquitted and now that is overturned and she is being retried. How many times can one person be tried???



That is what i was saying this morning. It's been 6 years at this point. DH reminded me that in Italy Double Jeopardy doesn't apply so they can try her however many times they want. It's crazy this is still going on.



It's not even a double jeopardy issue, really. In the US, the prosecution cannot appeal an acquittal (it can appeal to decisions that might have led to an acquittal, such as a judge's decision to prevent evidence from coming in, but not the actual ultimate decision itself), and on appeal the courts cannot retry the case or look at new evidence (except perhaps in some rare circumstances regarding the new evidence). In Italy, either side can appeal any part of the case, including the decision, and can retry it. So it's just getting bounced back and forth.

Posted 3/26/13 12:58 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Amanda Knox

I've read a great deal about this case and I think this is dreadful. There was no concrete evidence to connect her to the crime. Totally mishandled and botched investigation. However, it seems highly unlikely that she will ever be brought back to Italy.

Posted 3/26/13 1:23 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Did anyone see the Amanda Knox special on 20/20? DiamondGirl 10/1/11 7 Families Helping Families ™
? About amanda Knox trial sami 10/3/11 3 Families Helping Families ™
amanda knox MrsC614 10/3/11 43 Families Helping Families ™
Amanda Knox MorningCuppaCoffee 9/30/11 15 Families Helping Families ™
Amanda Knox starryeyes 3/8/11 22 Families Helping Families ™
Amanda Knox movie on Lifetime pinky 2/22/11 10 Celebrities & Entertainment