Re: Amanda Knox
Posted 3/26/2013 12:58:03 PM by sameinitials


Posted by MrsBurtch525


Posted by sfp0701

I did follow this a bit. I don't understand how someone can be convicted, have it overturned, be aquitted and now that is overturned and she is being retried. How many times can one person be tried???



That is what i was saying this morning. It's been 6 years at this point. DH reminded me that in Italy Double Jeopardy doesn't apply so they can try her however many times they want. It's crazy this is still going on.



It's not even a double jeopardy issue, really. In the US, the prosecution cannot appeal an acquittal (it can appeal to decisions that might have led to an acquittal, such as a judge's decision to prevent evidence from coming in, but not the actual ultimate decision itself), and on appeal the courts cannot retry the case or look at new evidence (except perhaps in some rare circumstances regarding the new evidence). In Italy, either side can appeal any part of the case, including the decision, and can retry it. So it's just getting bounced back and forth.
Print Post      Close Window