Am I wrong? Advice please

Posted By Message

04bride
I'm a big sister!!!

Member since 5/05

6707 total posts

Name:
Noel

Am I wrong? Advice please

Ok so give me your opinion on this...I had a wooden toy box that my sil gave me when i was pregnant with my dd. I did not register for it, i did not ask for it, it ddint even match teh whole theme for her room but it was cute. It was wooden and while I used it i didnt need it, i have a huge closet in her room and i didnt need it ,it stored stuffed animals that she didnt use. Anyway back in october my son fell and hot his head on the toybox and got 14 stitches. I was never a big fan of wodoen toyboxes and NEVER would have gotten this one( why it wasnt on my registry).Anyway we are redoing dd room to a princess theme so i bought a plastic storage bin with princess on it. i was offf from work yesterday and got rid of a bunch of stuff including the toybox. i gave it to my cousin for her friend who is recently divorced and needed it for his girls room at his house. I warned her that i didnt like wooden toyboxes but she said it was fine. So I tell Dh and he flips out saying its rude and insulting to do that to my sil.To be honest i doubt she will even notice and if she does I can just say my mom neededit for her house. What annoys me is i feel if onepf my friends gave it to us and i got rid of it he wouldnt care but bc its his Bro and sil its a big dela wto him. What do you think?

Posted 12/15/09 7:35 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Heres whats important here....
Do you and SIL get along in the first place? BC if you dont then I would understand your dh thinking you did it out of spite. If you both get along and you did it as an honest move to help someone else out, then I am all for helping out. TBH, its done, the person has it anyway, right? I'd probably let it go Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 7:44 AM
 

04bride
I'm a big sister!!!

Member since 5/05

6707 total posts

Name:
Noel

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

We get along but we are not close if that makes sense. We are nice to each other never had a fight but we have very differnt parenting styles and while its never caused an issue with us Dh and I have fought about it. If i was doing it out fo spite i would have done it a LONG time ago. It was a legit reason. i am redoing her room, it didnt fit the theme( although it never fit the theme) and i ddint really use it and i knew saomeone who could. I knew it was going to cause an issue but i wanted it OUT!!
Thanks for your response. You brought upa good point and he may think it was oput of spite buit it wasnt

Posted 12/15/09 7:49 AM
 

Kate
*****

Member since 5/05

7557 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Your son fell on it and needed stitches? That is reason enough alone to get rid of it, no matter who gave it to you.

Posted 12/15/09 8:24 AM
 

04bride
I'm a big sister!!!

Member since 5/05

6707 total posts

Name:
Noel

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Posted by Kate

Your son fell on it and needed stitches? That is reason enough alone to get rid of it, no matter who gave it to you.



yep was walking tripped head into the top of the toy box which has a scalloped edge and got 14 stitsches in his forehead

Posted 12/15/09 9:36 AM
 

MrsDrMatt
Live and RUN like a Ninja!

Member since 5/06

3104 total posts

Name:
MrsDrMatt

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

From the way your wrote this, it sounds like you are more annoyed that she gave you something not on your list (you mention it several times) Perhaps your husband thinks you are using the stitches as an "excuse" to get rid of it. Sorry, I side with your husband.

I hope that your son healed just fine and does not have any further injuries!

Posted 12/15/09 9:42 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

I don't think you're wrong - I would have gotten rid of it when my son got stitches - perfect excuse right there IMO -

Maybe it's in the way you're presenting your 'case' ??? -

Posted 12/15/09 9:45 AM
 

mtnmama

Member since 5/06

4794 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

I wouldn't give away a gift that was from SIL until talking to DH about it, b/c it is his sister. I probably would have just stuck it in the basement or something to save any hurt feelings, but that is just how I am!

Posted 12/15/09 9:47 AM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

In this situation I would have gotten DHs opinion before giving it away, especially since it was from a family member. We have toys that I never would have thought twice about donating but DH has asked me to hang onto them because he finds them to be special.

Posted 12/15/09 9:47 AM
 

04bride
I'm a big sister!!!

Member since 5/05

6707 total posts

Name:
Noel

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

it was his sister in law his brothers wife.

Maybe it was the way i was presenting it but in all hoesty i was giving it away bc its hardly used and i am redoing her room.

Posted 12/15/09 10:48 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Posted by PrincessP

Heres whats important here....
Do you and SIL get along in the first place? BC if you dont then I would understand your dh thinking you did it out of spite. If you both get along and you did it as an honest move to help someone else out, then I am all for helping out. TBH, its done, the person has it anyway, right? I'd probably let it go Chat Icon



I was thinking along the same lines.

If DH was privy to grumbling about the toy box, I could see why he would think the intentions weren't completely clear.

If the toybox was a handcrafted thing that she went to alot of trouble to get or it was meant to be passed down, I'd say it warranted a phone call to SIL saying you're redoing the room & ds got hurt, so you didn't need the toybox anymore...did she want it.

Posted 12/15/09 11:21 AM
 

04bride
I'm a big sister!!!

Member since 5/05

6707 total posts

Name:
Noel

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

No she gave it to me as a gift, like it was brand new had to be put together and all when she gave it to me, she most certainly didnt want it back.

Posted 12/15/09 11:23 AM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by PrincessP

Heres whats important here....
Do you and SIL get along in the first place? BC if you dont then I would understand your dh thinking you did it out of spite. If you both get along and you did it as an honest move to help someone else out, then I am all for helping out. TBH, its done, the person has it anyway, right? I'd probably let it go Chat Icon



I was thinking along the same lines.

If DH was privy to grumbling about the toy box, I could see why he would think the intentions weren't completely clear.

If the toybox was a handcrafted thing that she went to alot of trouble to get or it was meant to be passed down, I'd say it warranted a phone call to SIL saying you're redoing the room & ds got hurt, so you didn't need the toybox anymore...did she want it.




I agree with this....

but I would totally get rid of it because you don't like it AND because of the injury...but I could see how your DH would be mad when you didn't talk to him about it first

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 11:24 AM
 

Salason
♥

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Posted by MrsDrMatt

From the way your wrote this, it sounds like you are more annoyed that she gave you something not on your list (you mention it several times) Perhaps your husband thinks you are using the stitches as an "excuse" to get rid of it. Sorry, I side with your husband.

I hope that your son healed just fine and does not have any further injuries!




This is what I thought when reading it too. I also think a toddler and can trip and fall and hit ANYTHING (coffee tables etc) but I dont think it makes a wooden toybox a horrible gift.

I do think a gift from a brother versus a friend is different and I would have consulted with DH before giving it away. That said, just because someone gives you something doesnt mean you have to keep it forever!

Posted 12/15/09 11:26 AM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Honestly, I would have put those safety corner things on the corners and kept it. I would be upset if DH just got rid of something that my sister bought.

Posted 12/15/09 11:38 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

A good question to ask yourself is...if it was a toybox that you LOVED and you were redoing the room & DS got hurt on it, would you get rid of it?

Posted 12/15/09 11:50 AM
 

04bride
I'm a big sister!!!

Member since 5/05

6707 total posts

Name:
Noel

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Posted by babybug631

Honestly, I would have put those safety corner things on the corners and kept it. I would be upset if DH just got rid of something that my sister bought.



Cant the top is scalloped and that is where he cut his head. Yes i agree a kid can hurt himself on anything BUT sicne its wheer toys are usually kept they are more likely to be near it than say his dresser.

Posted 12/15/09 11:52 AM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

If my DD hurt herself on something, I would get rid of it. If whoever gave it to me was insulted, I would say DD hurt herself on it and I don't trust it, Im sorry. If anyone thinks im overreacting, I have no shame in saying I'm a little neurotic and wont take any chances at all on my daughter's safety.

Posted 12/15/09 12:31 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Posted by Salason

Posted by MrsDrMatt

From the way your wrote this, it sounds like you are more annoyed that she gave you something not on your list (you mention it several times) Perhaps your husband thinks you are using the stitches as an "excuse" to get rid of it. Sorry, I side with your husband.

I hope that your son healed just fine and does not have any further injuries!




This is what I thought when reading it too. I also think a toddler and can trip and fall and hit ANYTHING (coffee tables etc) but I dont think it makes a wooden toybox a horrible gift.

I do think a gift from a brother versus a friend is different and I would have consulted with DH before giving it away. That said, just because someone gives you something doesnt mean you have to keep it forever!



I agree with this. A friend is not the same as brother. It was thoughtful of them to splurge on your dd.

Posted 12/15/09 9:37 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

Posted by Kate

Your son fell on it and needed stitches? That is reason enough alone to get rid of it, no matter who gave it to you.



ITA

Posted 12/15/09 10:04 PM
 

clwp
Love my girls!

Member since 10/06

2114 total posts

Name:
mommy

Re: Am I wrong? Advice please

I can't stomach my SIL (also my DH's brother's wife), but if one of my kids got hurt or I suspected a gift she offered was dangerous or even just something I don't want for them... I don't care who would have thought I was spiteful, it would have gone in the garbage or if a safe, item into a donation bin. I personally do not like wooden toy boxes either. I have a padded one and yes, toddlers get hurt, but there are some items I agree, I'm not as comfortable with for safety reasons and we are all entitled to our feelings on that. Toddlers can get hurt on a lot of things, but items meant for their rooms or playrooms should be held to the highest standards of safety, legitimately as well as in the eyes of the mother (father's don't always get the whole safety thing, they mean well, but I think mom's think about that kind of stuff more). Gifts are just that, sometimes you get things that are great, sometimes you get lemons. Sometimes lemons come from well intentioned family, and if you aren't close and just "play nice" she may not have known what you wanted or honestly, didn't really put much thought into it. Not that she meant to hurt your child, but I agree with the pp who said you child getting injured was good enough reason to get rid of it. I've gotten rid of items that were given by family but I didn't like. I don't think twice about it.

Posted 12/15/09 10:25 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Need some advice with my schedule..somethings wrong pixie 2/19/09 10 Parenting
Something is seriously wrong with me, advice please! avamamma 2/22/08 20 Parenting
BFing moms- something is wrong-need advice 2girls4now 7/26/07 4 Parenting
Please no one take this the wrong way...but some advice from a BTDT maybebaby 3/14/07 7 Pregnancy
Starting to think something might be wrong - NEED ADVICE - Update Michelle1123 3/10/07 18 Parenting
Am I wrong...please give your honest advice! Eva Luna 6/5/06 25 Families Helping Families ™