Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

That's why we sleep outside in a tent. That way, if the house burns down, we're already safe outside.... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

No matter what you decide to do, there is a scenario that will put your child in jeopardy, albeit a very, very small chance. Door is left wide open, then smoke and fire gets in the room easier. Doors and half-doors can get jammed in the heat of a fire. From DC's point of view, a gate that they can't get past is just the same as a locked door. If you don't lock the door, DC could fall down the stairs at night, fall into the toilet, leave the house, etc, etc. There is absolutely no "right" decision, so I think it's up to everyone to decide which method is best for their household.
Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/10 7:40 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

I could never lock my child in their room, HOWEVER, I live in a one story home, and my kids cannot unlock the front door - I've asked them to try to "let the dog out" but I wanted to see if they were able.

ETA: I'm TERRIFIED of kids and stairs, so if I lived in a 2-story, I cant tell you what I'd do.

Message edited 2010-02-08 08:24:59.950000.

Posted 2/8/10 8:24 AM
 

littlejoy06
Love

Member since 3/07

6944 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by eddiesmommy

there are a lot of what ifs, on both sides....what of they were locked in during an emergency, what if they got out on any night and got into trouble.

I think it's a personal comfort level and not really anyone's place to throw stones when you don't know someone's reasoning for doing so or the nature of their household/child.



ITA!!!

Posted 2/8/10 8:26 AM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

DD is gated into her room. We keep her door open. So we can hear her and she can call for us if needed.

Posted 2/8/10 8:42 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

I can certainly understand why parents do this, but I think there are safter options out there - I don't have an issue with it per se, other than the fact that it really does present a serious safety concern.

Posted 2/8/10 8:44 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

It's a fire hazard. End of story

Posted 2/8/10 9:00 AM
 

MrsDrMatt
Live and RUN like a Ninja!

Member since 5/06

3104 total posts

Name:
MrsDrMatt

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by pinkandblue

Posted by eddiesmommy


I think it's a personal comfort level and not really anyone's place to throw stones when you don't know someone's reasoning for doing so or the nature of their household/child.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon so much judement, whatever happened to live and let live Chat Icon



This is LI Families.. we read, we judge, we comment! Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/10 9:00 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by eddiesmommy

there are a lot of what ifs, on both sides....what of they were locked in during an emergency, what if they got out on any night and got into trouble.

I think it's a personal comfort level and not really anyone's place to throw stones when you don't know someone's reasoning for doing so or the nature of their household/child.



ITA-just like everything else its perceived risk. This is going to make my parents sound like nutcases b ut they used to lock me in my room with a hook and eye latch because I guess I'd wander the house.Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/10 9:14 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

If your kid can master opening/climbing over the gate - what do you suggest if the bedrooms are upstairs? If you have a sleep walker? .......The chance of the kid falling down an entire flight of stairs is signigicantly higher than the chance of a fire, or intruder -

I can completely understand why parents do this - I don't know if I will - I'll see when he's big enough I guess.

Posted 2/8/10 9:18 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by eddiesmommy

there are a lot of what ifs, on both sides....what of they were locked in during an emergency, what if they got out on any night and got into trouble.

I think it's a personal comfort level and not really anyone's place to throw stones when you don't know someone's reasoning for doing so or the nature of their household/child.



Perfectly said.

We didn't lock our children's doors.. because they slept with us in our beds until they were 3 & 5. When they transitioned to their own room they desired a certain level of comfort that came from keeping their door open. Our door is also open across the hall and we leave the bathroom light on between the 2 rooms. It works for us.. but it certainly will not work for everyone!

Posted 2/8/10 9:23 AM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

I don't have anything against parents who do this, but i'm not sure I would. I just don't think I would feel comfortable with it. I can almost guarantee my DH wouldn't.

Posted 2/8/10 9:30 AM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by My3girlsMylife

My aunt cut my cousins door in half , I almost wan't to do the same Chat Icon



I know of a few people who have done this and think its a great ideaChat Icon

Posted 2/8/10 9:44 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by KateDevine

It's a fire hazard. End of story



I know we have "debated" this before but let's go again, how is it a fire hazard, I just don't get it

if god forbid, there was a fire, I would have been able to open miki's door NO problem as there was nothing on the outside of the door preventing me from doing that. Like I said, it is a non issue for us cause now we keep her door open, all other doors in the house (front door, back door, kevin's door) have the knob covers so she cannot open those doors either....

Maybe you have to "dumb it down" for me (your fire hazard comment) cause I just don't get it

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/10 9:51 AM
 

Salason
♥

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by MrsGmomof3
Also, DH is a firefighter and we do not even HAVE doors on our bedrooms because of some of the things he has seen. First thing he did when we moved in was remove the doors from the bedrooms. He was at a fire once where the doors got stuck and they were unable to save a baby. Chat Icon



This confuses me a little because my brother is a firefighter and is adamant about sleeping with doors closed (definitely not locked though) to prevent a fire from spreading... I guess even firefighters have differing views on this? Chat Icon

I do not see myself ever locking DS in his room for fire safety reasons. That just scares me way too much. We have a gate at the top of the stairs so he's confined to that space and we still use a monitor so we'd most likely hear him if he got him up. If I was that scared, I'd probably use the angelcare monitor again (I used it until he was 2 so I'd know if he climbed out of his crib). If he ever did manage to get downstairs, our alarm would pick him up as soon as he hit the first floor so I don't worry about him getting out of the house or even into the kitchen.

ETA: the locks are a fire hazard because even if you know how to get into your child's room quickly, in a fire it may not be YOU in the position to do so, it may be a firefighter who doesnt know there is a lock and how to open it and the extra time it takes him to get in could cost you!

Message edited 2010-02-08 10:03:12.020000.

Posted 2/8/10 9:56 AM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

I think your use of the word "horrified" is a bit much. It's not FOR you to understand- as it's not your life.

My daughter has a doorknob protector on her door so she can't open it- so she is essentially "locked in". I don't want her wandering the house, and it's not safe to sleep with doors open anyway as it's considered a fire hazard. My kid can climb gates- so not sure how that would be helpful.

There's a smoke detector in her room as well as a monitor so if she needs me I can hear her.

Posted 2/8/10 9:58 AM
 

Mkr09
.....

Member since 5/05

7550 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

We don't lock our DD's room at night but we do keep the door closed. We have a small apt and she is a pretty light sleeper and if we kept her door open the noises from us, the dog and the cats would wake her up.

We do have the monitor on and our room is literally 2 feet from hers so we can hear her perfectly.

I'm not sure if I would ever lock her door but if I thought that was the only way to keep her safe if she was a wanderer then I would do it.

Posted 2/8/10 10:00 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by Porrruss

I think your use of the word "horrified" is a bit much. It's not FOR you to understand- as it's not your life.

My daughter has a doorknob protector on her door so she can't open it- so she is essentially "locked in". I don't want her wandering the house, and it's not safe to sleep with doors open anyway as it's considered a fire hazard. My kid can climb gates- so not sure how that would be helpful.

There's a smoke detector in her room as well as a monitor so if she needs me I can hear her.




I agree with everything you wrote....I never knew that leaving the door open was a fire hazard but it make miki feel better when she can hear DH and I in the living room while she goes to sleep so we leave it open...but up until about 2 months ago, she had the doorknob protector on her door Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/10 10:02 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by Salason

Posted by MrsGmomof3
Also, DH is a firefighter and we do not even HAVE doors on our bedrooms because of some of the things he has seen. First thing he did when we moved in was remove the doors from the bedrooms. He was at a fire once where the doors got stuck and they were unable to save a baby. Chat Icon



This confuses me a little because my brother is a firefighter and is adamant about sleeping with doors closed (definitely not locked though) to prevent a fire from spreading... I guess even firefighters have differing views on this? Chat Icon

I do not see myself ever locking DS in his room for fire safety reasons. That just scares me way too much. We have a gate at the top of the stairs so he's confined to that space and we still use a monitor so we'd most likely hear him if he got him up. If I was that scared, I'd probably use the angelcare monitor again (I used it until he was 2 so I'd know if he climbed out of his crib). If he ever did manage to get downstairs, our alarm would pick him up as soon as he hit the first floor so I don't worry about him getting out of the house or even into the kitchen.



Ive always been told (by fireman) that you should sleep with the doors closed to keep smoke from getting in, deadly heat and the actual fire. Not that it will stop it but it will give you more time. Its actually wrong (fire safety tip wise) to sleep with doors open.

Posted 2/8/10 10:06 AM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by pinkandblue

Posted by Porrruss

I think your use of the word "horrified" is a bit much. It's not FOR you to understand- as it's not your life.

My daughter has a doorknob protector on her door so she can't open it- so she is essentially "locked in". I don't want her wandering the house, and it's not safe to sleep with doors open anyway as it's considered a fire hazard. My kid can climb gates- so not sure how that would be helpful.

There's a smoke detector in her room as well as a monitor so if she needs me I can hear her.






I agree with everything you wrote....I never knew that leaving the door open was a fire hazard but it make miki feel better when she can hear DH and I in the living room while she goes to sleep so we leave it open...but up until about 2 months ago, she had the doorknob protector on her door Chat Icon



Honestly- even if it wasn't a fire hazard we'd still do it. She sleeps better with it closed. If she slept better with it opened, we'd do that and DH would have to rig something up so she couldn't get out.

It's the whole, "I would NEVER....." thing that gets me. It's so easy to pass judgement on others' parenting styles when you think yours is best I suppose.

Posted 2/8/10 10:08 AM
 

cupcakekid
LIF Infant

Member since 9/09

291 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

A child confined in a crib can't get out if there is a fire, or if he/she needs you, or is sick, so there goes that argument.

The fire safety books even say to close all bedroom doors at night. Are you saying that is incorrect? I think these fire departments have a real issue on their hands telling children and parents to shut their doors at night if it's not safe to shut doors.

Posted 2/8/10 10:10 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by cupcakekid

A child confined in a crib can't get out if there is a fire, or if he/she needs you, or is sick, so there goes that argument.

The fire safety books even say to close all bedroom doors at night. Are you saying that is incorrect? I think these fire departments have a real issue on their hands telling children and parents to shut their doors at night if it's not safe to shut doors.




It isn't so much that the child is confined to the CRIB, it is that people can't get into the room if there is a fire

That's our reasoning for not doing it, but, as always, to each their ownChat Icon

Posted 2/8/10 10:12 AM
 

Merf99
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3380 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?



Posted by eddiesmommy


I think it's a personal comfort level and not really anyone's place to throw stones when you don't know someone's reasoning for doing so or the nature of their household/child.




I totally agree!

Posted 2/8/10 10:14 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by KateDevine



It isn't so much that the child is confined to the CRIB, it is that people can't get into the room if there is a fire

That's our reasoning for not doing it, but, as always, to each their ownChat Icon



you keep saying that Kate (well, you said the same thing last time this debate was discussed) but HOW is a door knob protector on the inside of the doorknob preventing me from getting in there? It doesn't...at all, you open the door from the outside the same way you would if it did not have the protector on it, she was not able to open it from the inside, that is the only difference.

Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-02-08 10:16:22.310000.

Posted 2/8/10 10:14 AM
 

cupcakekid
LIF Infant

Member since 9/09

291 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

and people might not be able to get into an apartment in a high rise building with the door shut. But we don't keep our doors open.

I would be curious to see statistics on how many doors get jammed during a fire and how many kids die due to that. I would bet more babies die to SIDS each year than jammed doors in a fire. (jammed doors, not smoke inhalation, burning, etc.)

Message edited 2010-02-08 10:16:03.030000.

Posted 2/8/10 10:15 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Am I the only one puzzled by this?

Posted by pinkandblue

Posted by KateDevine



It isn't so much that the child is confined to the CRIB, it is that people can't get into the room if there is a fire

That's our reasoning for not doing it, but, as always, to each their ownChat Icon



you keep saying that Kate but HOW is a door knob protector on the inside of the doorknob preventing me from getting in there? It doesn't...at all




I have a doorknob protector on the inside too, and I can get in without issue.

Posted 2/8/10 10:16 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Starbuck's.. i am puzzled?? sfp0701 5/13/08 3 Families Helping Families ™
puzzled Warning : TMI MaMaTeenie 5/31/09 4 Infertility
puzzled...did I do anything wrong? Question 1/2/07 26 Families Helping Families ™
I'm either shocked, stupid or just puzzled Kate07 11/27/06 16 Home