Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Message edited 2008-03-24 09:25:31.033000.

Posted 10/9/07 9:21 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

This is a hard one!

I agree with you about being nervous about her driving her around (heck, I don't even like my DH driving Jack around Chat Icon )

I just don't know - I would MAYBE want her to have a car seat in case of an emergency. This is a hard one. IF you think she'll be taking her out and about - and really just doing it for socializing reasons - well then I don't know. But, it is good for her to have in case on an emergency!

No help at all. Sorry! Chat Icon

Posted 10/9/07 9:24 AM
 

MrsR
My love.

Member since 5/05

6247 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

although I agree with your hesitations about your MIL driving the baby around (I have the same fears) I ALWAYS make sure whomever is watching my daughter has a car seat.

Sometimes the emergency isn't at her house. What happens if g-d forbid you and DH can't get there to pick her up and she needs to take the baby to you - or something like that.

I would make it really clear to her that you don't want her driving all around town and that it is for emergencies only.

Posted 10/9/07 9:25 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

DW and I are the same way with DC and other people driving. DS is 4.5, and has never had anyone drive him except for DW and myself. However, the twist for you is that MIL babysits a lot. We don't have that, so for us it's an easy answer. I would try and maintain that you don't want her to drive DC anywhere, without turning it into a battle. Unfortunately, an "emergency" is a grey area. If MIL "needs" milk, is that an emergency? Does a nice day constitute and "emergency" trip to a park?

Posted 10/9/07 9:27 AM
 

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Oh boy, I know how you feel! I'm like you--very laid back, but other people driving my girls freaks me out!

I had family watching DD 5 FT while I worked. My cousin watched her on Fridays and put her in the car every week since she had to pick up her kids from school--I was very uneasy about it, but what could I do? Honestly, I just had to let it go. I knew she had never been in an accident. Also, one day DD will have to get in the car with someone else--a school bus or whatever.

It's up to you of course and if you are absolutely uncomfortable, don't allow her to do it. Did you discuss her concerns with her? Based on the swing convesation, she'd probably think you were being silly, but it's worth a shot. Play it off like you're a "neurotic new mom," like it's you with the problem--nothing to do with her driving skills, etc.

Message edited 2007-10-09 09:28:59.410000.

Posted 10/9/07 9:28 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

I absolutely think that she should have a car seat in case of emergency. Its more of a hazard for her to NOT have one than it is to have one.
Personally, I think its unreasonable to be nervous about someone else (especially the person who you trust with your child on a regular basis) driving around your child, you are at the exact same amount of risk to be in an accident as she is.
If there was to be an emergency, she would have to take the child without a car seat, which is worse???

Posted 10/9/07 9:28 AM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Sorry....but I agree with your MIL.

In case of an emergency, she really should have the car seat. As someone else mentioed, you might not be able to get there - because you might be the emergency. Or something could happen in her house, causing her to have to leave quickly.

In addition, just because she's watching your baby doesn't mean she should have to be locked in her house. Just think how you would feel if you were cooped up all day long with a baby. It's not really fair to her.

Posted 10/9/07 9:29 AM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Posted by MrsR

although I agree with your hesitations about your MIL driving the baby around (I have the same fears) I ALWAYS make sure whomever is watching my daughter has a car seat.

Sometimes the emergency isn't at her house. What happens if g-d forbid you and DH can't get there to pick her up and she needs to take the baby to you - or something like that.

I would make it really clear to her that you don't want her driving all around town and that it is for emergencies only.




ITA: I just said to my mother yesterday that DH and I should get another car seat and leave it with my inlaws for emergencies. My FIL watches DS a lot.
Im nervous, but, I would make sure they know its for emergencies only and I would hope they would "listen" to us.
My mother already has an extra car seat for DS as well.

Posted 10/9/07 9:31 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Posted by MrsR

although I agree with your hesitations about your MIL driving the baby around (I have the same fears) I ALWAYS make sure whomever is watching my daughter has a car seat.

Sometimes the emergency isn't at her house. What happens if g-d forbid you and DH can't get there to pick her up and she needs to take the baby to you - or something like that.

I would make it really clear to her that you don't want her driving all around town and that it is for emergencies only.



ITA with this.

Posted 10/9/07 9:36 AM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Posted by Palebride

Sorry....but I agree with your MIL.

In case of an emergency, she really should have the car seat. As someone else mentioed, you might not be able to get there - because you might be the emergency. Or something could happen in her house, causing her to have to leave quickly.

In addition, just because she's watching your baby doesn't mean she should have to be locked in her house. Just think how you would feel if you were cooped up all day long with a baby. It's not really fair to her.



I agree with this. My parents will be watching DD 2 days/week and will have a base in their car (and a convertible carseat when the time comes). Personally, I *want* them to take her places (but I understand you not wanting that) but in terms of an emergency or just "freedom" of mind (she's not held hostage in her home) - I think you should do it.

Posted 10/9/07 9:41 AM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

No, I don't think you are being unreasonable. We have one car seat for us and we are getting the extra base for my car but that's it. I can imagine my MIL doing the same thing.

My parents don't even have a car seat for my nephew, they watch him on the weekends for a few hours. They don't take him anywhere. I don't see the need for an "in case of emergency" car seat. I can only imagine the "emergencys" my MIL would come up with.

Posted 10/9/07 9:50 AM
 

luvsun27
Check out my cool glasses

Member since 5/05

8135 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

I'm sorry....I think your MIL should be able to leave the house if she wants to, even if it's not an emergency. Being couped up all day with a baby is not fun (for me anyway). I always go out at least once a day with DD and I can't stand to be home all day.

Your MIL is doing you a favor and babysitting for DD 3 days a week (I'm assuming she is not getting paid). She should be able to go out of the house!

Posted 10/9/07 9:52 AM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

My MIL also watches DD 2-3 days a week. She has had a car seat since day 1 and I fell so much better that she has it. I agree with the previous post, I don't want MIL to feel trapped in her house all day. She is doing ME a favor by watching her (for free) so I feel like I can't tell her that she has to stay home.
MIL is always out with DD. And belive me, there are times where I found the car seat was not "properly" buckled. I just try to take a step back and know that "it could be worse". I know that you might be like Chat Icon but think about when we were kids. The car seats were not as good and the cars were not as safe. I just Chat Icon that she is in good hands (and I don't mean me or MIL Chat Icon )

Posted 10/9/07 9:54 AM
 

LuvMy2Girls
@>---------

Member since 5/05

11165 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Honestly, I think you should give her the carseat. You just never know. You trust your DD with her during the day, I don't understand why you wouldn't trust her to abide by your wishes. JMHO.
Please don't take your MIL for granted, she's giving you guys a big gift to watch your DD.
Chat Icon

Posted 10/9/07 9:57 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Posted by Palebride

Sorry....but I agree with your MIL.

In case of an emergency, she really should have the car seat. As someone else mentioed, you might not be able to get there - because you might be the emergency. Or something could happen in her house, causing her to have to leave quickly.

In addition, just because she's watching your baby doesn't mean she should have to be locked in her house. Just think how you would feel if you were cooped up all day long with a baby. It's not really fair to her.



I agree with Lori.

I know that we would all like our kids to be in a bubble where only ourselves or our spouses drive our child around, but in most situations it just isn't a reality.

Unless she has some type of medical condition that should keep her from driving and she still does (don't get me started on my great aunt) then I think you need to trust her....or look elsewhere for care. Unfortunately, with family, you can make the rules, but at the same time, they are going to feel entitled to break them.

Before we moved, my SMIL was going to watch DS and I actually registerd for the extra snugride base for her to keep in her car b/c I knew she'd be taking DS to a whole b unch of places everyday.

Posted 10/9/07 9:58 AM
 

DJJ914
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/07

715 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

I'm sorry....I think your MIL should be able to leave the house if she wants to, even if it's not an emergency. Being couped up all day with a baby is not fun (for me anyway). I always go out at least once a day with DD and I can't stand to be home all day.

Your MIL is doing you a favor and babysitting for DD 3 days a week (I'm assuming she is not getting paid). She should be able to go out of the house!



I agree. My MIL watches my DD, she has her own car seat and I totally trust her driving. Maybe you can go for a drive with your MIL and see how she drives, maybe you be more comfortable with it.

Posted 10/9/07 9:58 AM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

In addition, just because she's watching your baby doesn't mean she should have to be locked in her house. Just think how you would feel if you were cooped up all day long with a baby. It's not really fair to her.




Sorry, but I totally agree with this! My mom actually went out and bought her own car seat before I even thought about it. I was nervous at first but I showed her how to put him in and strap him in and have had no problems.

Message edited 2007-10-09 10:03:36.267000.

Posted 10/9/07 10:01 AM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Posted by luvsun27

I'm sorry....I think your MIL should be able to leave the house if she wants to, even if it's not an emergency. Being couped up all day with a baby is not fun (for me anyway). I always go out at least once a day with DD and I can't stand to be home all day.

Your MIL is doing you a favor and babysitting for DD 3 days a week (I'm assuming she is not getting paid). She should be able to go out of the house!



Although I don't really want anyone else driving DD, I agree with Kim and other posters. If she is watching her that often, she NEEDS to get out of the house. Maybe you can take her to a car seat safety course (BRU gives them for FREE) beforehand, and go over what constitutes as an "emergency". Also practive WITH her putting DD in and out of the car seat. Have the base installed professionally, and pay to get MIL's car checked out for safety (brakes, etc).

After a little time you may see that it is good for them both to get out of the house (I know it is for DD and me!) and you might want to sign them up for some kind of class that is nearby - gymboree, music, whatever. This way you will know where they are going and also I am sure they would both love it...

Posted 10/9/07 10:02 AM
 

Calla
My girls

Member since 7/05

4303 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Sorry, I also think you are being unreasonable -- unless your MIL has a really bad driving history. Assuming she hasn't been in lots of accidents, there is no reason to think she should stay home even one day a week with your child. She and your baby will go insane. They need to leave the house and not just for emergencies.

If she doesn't have a cell phone buy her one so you know you can contact her wherever she is. Feel free to annoy her with reminders about proper buckling. Get the seat professionally installed and make her show you that she knows how to do the straps.

Going to the park, stores, to visit friends, will be a good thing for both of them!

Posted 10/9/07 10:20 AM
 

MrsBlueSash
Love my sailor

Member since 6/05

5793 total posts

Name:
Christian

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

If it wasn't your MIL and you were paying someone then I would definitely feel you can dictate to the T everything. But since this is more of a favor that she is providing care, she's the grandmother, and is a good driver, I'd have to say she has a good point if she'd like to leave the house with your DC. To ask her to wait until you come home from a long day away is a little unrealistic IMO. I'd want to know where they go, etc. but I'd let my MIL take my DD to the park, to the grocery store etc. I'd just be sure to show her how to use the seat properly.

Message edited 2007-10-09 10:32:04.227000.

Posted 10/9/07 10:31 AM
 

Dragonfly75
I love Hypnobabies

Member since 3/06

2333 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

I have to agree with MIL. I think she definately needs it in case of an emergency. Show her how to use it (it's not hard).

I also think she just might need to get out of the house now and then. I know I go nuts on my days off if I just sit around the house. Just make sure she's only taking short trips.

Posted 10/9/07 10:35 AM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Message edited 2008-03-24 09:26:04.953000.

Posted 10/9/07 11:11 AM
 

lullabella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2246 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Posted by luvsun27

I'm sorry....I think your MIL should be able to leave the house if she wants to, even if it's not an emergency. Being couped up all day with a baby is not fun (for me anyway). I always go out at least once a day with DD and I can't stand to be home all day.

Your MIL is doing you a favor and babysitting for DD 3 days a week (I'm assuming she is not getting paid). She should be able to go out of the house!



I totally agree!

Posted 10/9/07 11:16 AM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

Posted by Palebride

Sorry....but I agree with your MIL.

In case of an emergency, she really should have the car seat. As someone else mentioed, you might not be able to get there - because you might be the emergency. Or something could happen in her house, causing her to have to leave quickly.

In addition, just because she's watching your baby doesn't mean she should have to be locked in her house. Just think how you would feel if you were cooped up all day long with a baby. It's not really fair to her.



I agree with Lori.

Posted 10/9/07 11:16 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being Unreasonable?- long

With all due respect, and not trying to be nasty. If you have some control issues with her and you don’t want her to treat the baby as if she was her baby…don’t leave your child with her alone. I think its wonderful that she treat the baby like her own if she is watching her for you. I would be thrilled if I had someone watching my son who treated him like their own child.

Posted 10/9/07 11:18 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Am I being unreasonable? (More of an explanation at bottom) waterspout4 6/7/07 20 Pregnancy
Am I being unreasonable ? or is this the norm ? nywebchic 9/9/05 11 Pregnancy
Why does DH have to be so unreasonable? Laura1976 8/9/06 13 Pregnancy
Grrrr..... Am I being unreasonable... 05mommy09 5/6/06 9 Parenting
am I being overly moody and unreasonable? momAGAIN 2/8/06 15 Families Helping Families ™
Is it unreasonable DebG 1/11/06 24 Parenting