.......
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
....... Thanks! Message edited 2016-03-20 21:43:00.507000. |
|
Posted 2/20/16 8:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Hi... |
|
Posted 2/20/16 9:27 PM
|
|
|
........ . Message edited 2016-03-20 21:43:22.433000. |
|
Posted 2/20/16 9:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Okay, so I agree with the PP that you were unhappy with, but I can answer your questions: |
|
Posted 2/20/16 10:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you It's scantron plus written responses for BOTH ELA and Math. The math written response might ask your child to explain how try got their answer or to use two statements to explain why an answer is correct or not. |
|
Posted 2/21/16 3:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Posted by itsbabytime Posted by mosh913 Hi... Obviously don't know what your reasons are for your child taking these assessments but just a few things I wanted to add.. Opting out is a personal choice. Has nothing to do with your district. I'm a teacher and a mom to a 3rd grader and she will not be taking these tests. They are really flawed. Don't necessarily match curriculum and are developmentally inappropriate. You should check out the LI Opt out page on Facebook. You'll be able to find more information about these tests. As for your other questions, it almost sounds like you want to study or prep your child, which believe me, they are getting enough of in school. I think it's BS that schools Say they use these tests for placement. What did they do before when tests were only 4th and 8th grade? These tests are first and foremost used for teacher evaluation. There are many other ways schools progress monitor. Good luck with whatever you decide! Not sure why you responded because you actually answered none of my questions. I'm not trying to study or prep my child. The tests are a month away - I think it's a little late in the game for that. I am trying to make an educated decision as to how I feel about these tests. Why would I send my child into two weeks of tests that I don't know anything about and he doesn't either? I would like to know what will be expected so I can guage whether it is developmentally appropriate and matches the curriculum or not. I have personally looked at past tests and review materials and the engage NY website and I disagree with you. Also the scores on these tests In my district also conflict with what you said. However I find it is extremely difficult to find answers to my questions above which I personally consider important questions baring on whether these are appropriate and useful tests. I'm hoping someone can answer my questions but thinking i should probably take my post down. I'm actually perplexed as to how these questions wouldn't matter to you if your child was taking the test. For ex. My child has never taken a scantron test to date and I certainly wouldn't want the first time to be on two Weeks Of State tests. That is a skill in itself for an 8 yr old! I also wouldn't want him taking an exam that a large part includes topics he has never been taught. My point is here and with my original post that I would like to make my own decision based on facts and not rhetoric and I want to set the right tone and precedent for my child with my decision. Perhaps the answers to my questions would help me understand why these teats are developmentally inappropriate and don't match the curriculum as you have states but, since you didn't answer any of them I am still confused! Eta: you misunderstood what I wrote about my district. I understand it is a personal decision that is not what I meant. I may not have specifically answered your questions but did provide you with some other information that could help you. Wasn't trying to spark a debate. If anything, you should speak to your child's teacher. And what are you disagreeing with me over? That the tests are developmentally inappropriate?? Anyone will tell you that! They might be okay for your child b/c they might be above grade level but for the majority of children, they are not. Message edited 2016-02-21 09:42:36.127000. |
|
Posted 2/21/16 9:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Posted by BaysideForever Okay, so I agree with the PP that you were unhappy with, but I can answer your questions: 1. How do the kids take these tests - particularly talking about the 3rd grade tests - are they scantron? or do they answer by circling in their test booklets? SCANTRON. PLUS SOME OPEN ENDED QUESTIONS (not usually on math, just ELA) 2. The tests are a little over a month away and my DC has only covered 1/2 the math topics. Is it typical for the kids to take the tests without having learned much of the material they will be tested on? YES, THEY FOCUS SOLELY ON TEST PREP FOR A LONG TIME THOUGH. 3. How much prep has your child done for the NYS math and ELA tests at this point if they are/were in 3rd grade? WHEN TESTS WERE COMING AROUND IT WAS TEST PREP 24/7. AT LEAST 1-2 PERIODS PER DAY, IF NOT MORE. 4. If your child is a generally bright kid and always does well on tests did you feel that the state tests were the same? Did anyone have a situation where a bright child getting 100's for years did not perform well on the tests? YES OF COURSE. TESTS ARE NOT A GOOD PREDICTOR. SOME OF THE WORST KIDS SCORE VERY HIGH AND SOME OF THE BEST KIDS DO NOT DO WELL. 5. where can I find a clear list of what is covered on the 3rd grade ELA? I have looked at past tests and they are all reading comp - is there grammar, usage etc. as well? YOU CAN'T. 6. Does the 3rd grade math require written essay type responses or is it all numbers and showing work? UNLESS IT CHANGED IN THE PAST 5 YEARS, (VERY LIKELY) BUT IT WAS JUST SCANTRON FOR MATH. Everything she said!! |
|
Posted 2/21/16 9:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you I am a third grade teacher on LI. It appears that other posters have mostly answered your questions, however, I just wanted to add that I am only halfway through module 3 in math, and there are 7 modules, putting my class at the halfway mark as well. |
|
Posted 2/21/16 12:52 PM
|
|
|
If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you 1. How do the kids take these tests - particularly talking about the 3rd grade tests - are they scantron? or do they answer by circling in their test booklets? Scantron and written response in booklets and the best part is how many times I have seen students bubble 1 question wrong and the rest of the test is then wrong. It is against the law as a test administrator to tell the students to go back and fix their bubbling. Message edited 2016-02-21 16:24:04.850000. |
|
Posted 2/21/16 4:17 PM
|
|
|
...... . Message edited 2016-03-20 21:43:53.017000. |
|
Posted 2/21/16 6:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Posted by CurlyQ 1. How do the kids take these tests - particularly talking about the 3rd grade tests - are they scantron? or do they answer by circling in their test booklets? Scantron and written response in booklets and the best part is how many times I have seen students bubble 1 question wrong and the rest of the test is then wrong. It is against the law as a test administrator to tell the students to go back and fix their bubbling. 2. The tests are a little over a month away and my DC has only covered 1/2 the math topics. Is it typical for the kids to take the tests without having learned much of the material they will be tested on? Much of the tests are on material that has not been taught, and is developmentally inappropriate. 3. How much prep has your child done for the NYS math and ELA tests at this point if they are/were in 3rd grade? Generally the real push is 4 weeks before. However, all of those test workbooks, computer based programs are year long. 4. If your child is a generally bright kid and always does well on tests did you feel that the state tests were the same? Did anyone have a situation where a bright child getting 100's for years did not perform well on the tests? I have had many STRONG students score 1's and 2's. Sometimes, the brightest students over think these poorly constructed tests, run out of time, testing anxiety etc. Students that you would have thought to be the highest scorers often are not. 5. where can I find a clear list of what is covered on the 3rd grade ELA? I have looked at past tests and they are all reading comp - is there grammar, usage etc. as well? There is no clear list. That's what puts both students and teachers at a disadvantage. These are not the tests prior to common core from 5 years ago that were better constructed, predictable, and were more student friendly and achievable. 6. Does the 3rd grade math require written essay type responses or is it all numbers and showing work? Yes, they have to explain how they got their answers, and there are constructed response. Just an FYI- it is against the law to use these NYS assessments in 3-8 as a SOLE measure for placement. A bunch of measures have to be used. So for example, if you opt out of these assessments, other measures will be used instead. Some principals and superintendents were/are using scare tactics. NYSAPE.org is a great resource to look over. ALSO engageNY does not publish most of what the students are being tested on. Teachers have to sign off on wavers saying they will not talk about what is on the test. You will never see what your child was tested on, and neither will the teacher once the tests are over. These tests in no way shape or form are ever used again to inform instruction. Such a great response! Thank you as this was even informative to me. I truly believe that these tests are used for the teacher evaluation system and ties into a political agenda that goes way beyond progress monitoring and tracking. It infuriates me, really. |
|
Posted 2/21/16 9:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you To the OP: Can I ask what the reasons may be that you think your DC should take these tests? |
|
Posted 2/22/16 9:58 PM
|
|
|
If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you My mom is a former principal and hugely supports these tests... She is completely against opting out but after reading some if the responses, i could understand why people dont want to participate. |
|
Posted 2/23/16 6:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you My son is in 5th grade and took the tests he past 2 years and I have a son in 3rd grade who will be taking the tests for the first time this year. From what I understand from my son the ELA is a combo scantron, short answers and essays. The Math is scantron and showing work and explaining work. My son in 5th grade finds the tests to be easy and doesn't stress them. He always says day 1-2 are the easiest for ELA and day 3 is the hardest. He hates to write but does well. He is a very good student and does well year round and scored 4's both years on both parts. He follows direction well so the training he gets thru the year he follows up with on the tests. Message edited 2016-02-23 07:22:50.473000. |
|
Posted 2/23/16 7:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Posted by my3bugs My son is in 5th grade and took the tests he past 2 years and I have a son in 3rd grade who will be taking the tests for the first time this year. From what I understand from my son the ELA is a combo scantron, short answers and essays. The Math is scantron and showing work and explaining work. My son in 5th grade finds the tests to be easy and doesn't stress them. He always says day 1-2 are the easiest for ELA and day 3 is the hardest. He hates to write but does well. He is a very good student and does well year round and scored 4's both years on both parts. He follows direction well so the training he gets thru the year he follows up with on the tests. I think a lot of what my son is doing in 3rd grade so far is preparing for the tests. The Math homework is all showing work and short answer/explanation type questions. He has weekly writing assignments where he reads passages and either answers short answers for essays each week. She is definitely grading them as they are state test questions. Not sure if they took any sample tests yet - think it may be early. I do remember after winter break it kicks in more from my older son. This son does well in school as well and I Will have him take the test. Not sure how he will do as he is very smart but very different than my other son but so far I think he do well enough to at least get 3's based on what I have seen from him so far. Thank you so much for posting this is very helpful and reassuring! |
|
Posted 2/23/16 10:13 AM
|
|
|
If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you When my daughter took the tests in seventh grade, she scored below average (1's and 2's) after being in high honors her entire school career. The next year, we refused the tests. |
|
Posted 2/23/16 11:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Sent u a FM Chatham chick :) Message edited 2016-02-23 17:11:03.033000. |
|
Posted 2/23/16 11:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you This article was written by Michael Hynes, Superintendent of Pat-Med. It's a very good article for anyone that is on the fence. |
|
Posted 2/23/16 5:40 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Posted by busymomonli When my daughter took the tests in seventh grade, she scored below average (1's and 2's) after being in high honors her entire school career. The next year, we refused the tests. As a sophomore in high school right now, she is ranked 6th in her high school class of 425! Does that sound like someone who is below average to you? She's already getting offers from colleges. These tests are flawed. My kids will never take another one. Wow. Really goes to show you what a piece of crap those tests are. |
Posted 2/25/16 10:44 AM
|
|
|
If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you My DD will not be taking the test. There is no reason to take them. Why subject kids to taking week long tests for nothing. The scores mean nothing, they can not do placement on these scores alone, they do not show a true potential in a student. they do not factor into class averages. Remedial services can be obtained without these test scores and getting into to honors can also be done without the test scores. I'd rather they use these two weeks to add some fun learning into the curriculum which is now lacking due to common core. |
|
Posted 2/25/16 11:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Posted by KarenK122 My DD will not be taking the test. There is no reason to take them. Why subject kids to taking week long tests for nothing. The scores mean nothing, they can not do placement on these scores alone, they do not show a true potential in a student. they do not factor into class averages. Remedial services can be obtained without these test scores and getting into to honors can also be done without the test scores. I'd rather they use these two weeks to add some fun learning into the curriculum which is now lacking due to common core. Agreed. |
|
Posted 3/6/16 6:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Here's my personal experience. Both DH and I were on the same page that DS would be taking the tests, if and only if they passed his 504, which they did the Friday before tests began. My DS is ADD Inattentive and I knew he would need extra time to do his best. He wasn't stressed about the test, as our district doesn't make kids feel it's the end-all be-all. I told him to take just take his time and do his best. That's it. It turns out he did exceptionally well. Does that mean anything in the grand scheme? No, of course not. But we felt it was important for him to get used to the idea of testing, as that's something he will deal with all throughout school. The pressure and time management lessons were more important to us then the results. |
|
Posted 3/7/16 9:55 AM
|
|
|
If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you I have a random question. When I was in elementary school I remember taking CAT tests. From what I recall, they had some really ridiculous questions and reading passages. They were timed as well. To this day, I have no clue what they were for, but everyone took them. There was no "opting out." |
|
Posted 3/7/16 10:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you Posted by ohbaby08 I have a random question. When I was in elementary school I remember taking CAT tests. From what I recall, they had some really ridiculous questions and reading passages. They were timed as well. To this day, I have no clue what they were for, but everyone took them. There was no "opting out." How were those tests different from the ones they are giving today? My son is in 2nd grade now, so I haven't had to make a decision yet for him. These tests are totally different from those tests. Those tests were norm- referenced standardized (meaning they were given to large test groups and the scores were based on how they tested as a representation of the total population. It was already known that if you scored a certain number.. you would get an assigned score.) The current tests are not given to test groups. After the tests are scored, the "cut" score is determined. So they just choose.. ok all the kids who scored from here and up get a 4". There is no rhyme or reason to where the numbers are assigned". There is nothing to support " 70% of the kids failed". 70% failed because they decided that 70% would fail. The past tests were available then. In fact, much like the Regents, they were used for practice. These tests are sealed and are never looked at again. In fact, teachers are directed not to read the tests as the students take them. They are very secretive. Those tests were not used to assess teachers. They were used as measures of the student's ability. They were developmentally appropriate. The reading level was on par with the grade level. Those tests are what we should be going back to. Message edited 2016-03-20 08:17:28.053000. |
|
Posted 3/20/16 8:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: ....... Posted by mosh913 Posted by CurlyQ 1. How do the kids take these tests - particularly talking about the 3rd grade tests - are they scantron? or do they answer by circling in their test booklets? Scantron and written response in booklets and the best part is how many times I have seen students bubble 1 question wrong and the rest of the test is then wrong. It is against the law as a test administrator to tell the students to go back and fix their bubbling. 2. The tests are a little over a month away and my DC has only covered 1/2 the math topics. Is it typical for the kids to take the tests without having learned much of the material they will be tested on? Much of the tests are on material that has not been taught, and is developmentally inappropriate. 3. How much prep has your child done for the NYS math and ELA tests at this point if they are/were in 3rd grade? Generally the real push is 4 weeks before. However, all of those test workbooks, computer based programs are year long. 4. If your child is a generally bright kid and always does well on tests did you feel that the state tests were the same? Did anyone have a situation where a bright child getting 100's for years did not perform well on the tests? I have had many STRONG students score 1's and 2's. Sometimes, the brightest students over think these poorly constructed tests, run out of time, testing anxiety etc. Students that you would have thought to be the highest scorers often are not. 5. where can I find a clear list of what is covered on the 3rd grade ELA? I have looked at past tests and they are all reading comp - is there grammar, usage etc. as well? There is no clear list. That's what puts both students and teachers at a disadvantage. These are not the tests prior to common core from 5 years ago that were better constructed, predictable, and were more student friendly and achievable. 6. Does the 3rd grade math require written essay type responses or is it all numbers and showing work? Yes, they have to explain how they got their answers, and there are constructed response. Just an FYI- it is against the law to use these NYS assessments in 3-8 as a SOLE measure for placement. A bunch of measures have to be used. So for example, if you opt out of these assessments, other measures will be used instead. Some principals and superintendents were/are using scare tactics. NYSAPE.org is a great resource to look over. ALSO engageNY does not publish most of what the students are being tested on. Teachers have to sign off on wavers saying they will not talk about what is on the test. You will never see what your child was tested on, and neither will the teacher once the tests are over. These tests in no way shape or form are ever used again to inform instruction. Such a great response! Thank you as this was even informative to me. I truly believe that these tests are used for the teacher evaluation system and ties into a political agenda that goes way beyond progress monitoring and tracking. It infuriates me, really. Thank you for so much information. I have one more question maybe you can help with - how does the state, if it does, use these test for data mining on our children which is then used by companies, like Pearson, to develop curriculum that is then sold to NYSDofEd? |
|
Posted 3/23/16 8:45 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| child bullied; teacher asks uncomfortable questions | ayesha86 | 1/31/16 | 32 | Parents of School-Aged Children |
| New to LIF...Question about tests taken..... | babymill13 | 1/19/13 | 8 | TTC |
| (TAKEN) FREE - HPT's, CBEFM Test Sticks, Fertility Tests | Hofstra26 | 10/8/12 | 2 | TTC |
| taken....ClearBlue Easy digital ovulation tests | Lucky2008 | 7/14/11 | 2 | TTC |
| TAKEN - Dollar Tree Ovulation tests up for grabs - FREE | MrsSteflily | 4/18/10 | 0 | TTC |
| Teacher Cert. Tests in April | want2beamom | 5/10/07 | 1 | Teachers |












