Re: If you are a teacher or if your child has taken the state tests...questions for you
Posted 2/21/2016 9:40:40 AM by mosh913
Posted by itsbabytime
Posted by mosh913
Hi... Obviously don't know what your reasons are for your child taking these assessments but just a few things I wanted to add.. Opting out is a personal choice. Has nothing to do with your district. I'm a teacher and a mom to a 3rd grader and she will not be taking these tests. They are really flawed. Don't necessarily match curriculum and are developmentally inappropriate. You should check out the LI Opt out page on Facebook. You'll be able to find more information about these tests. As for your other questions, it almost sounds like you want to study or prep your child, which believe me, they are getting enough of in school. I think it's BS that schools Say they use these tests for placement. What did they do before when tests were only 4th and 8th grade? These tests are first and foremost used for teacher evaluation. There are many other ways schools progress monitor. Good luck with whatever you decide!
Not sure why you responded because you actually answered none of my questions. I'm not trying to study or prep my child. The tests are a month away - I think it's a little late in the game for that.
I am trying to make an educated decision as to how I feel about these tests. Why would I send my child into two weeks of tests that I don't know anything about and he doesn't either? I would like to know what will be expected so I can guage whether it is developmentally appropriate and matches the curriculum or not. I have personally looked at past tests and review materials and the engage NY website and I disagree with you. Also the scores on these tests In my district also conflict with what you said. However I find it is extremely difficult to find answers to my questions above which I personally consider important questions baring on whether these are appropriate and useful tests. I'm hoping someone can answer my questions but thinking i should probably take my post down. I'm actually perplexed as to how these questions wouldn't matter to you if your child was taking the test. For ex. My child has never taken a scantron test to date and I certainly wouldn't want the first time to be on two Weeks Of State tests. That is a skill in itself for an 8 yr old! I also wouldn't want him taking an exam that a large part includes topics he has never been taught. My point is here and with my original post that I would like to make my own decision based on facts and not rhetoric and I want to set the right tone and precedent for my child with my decision. Perhaps the answers to my questions would help me understand why these teats are developmentally inappropriate and don't match the curriculum as you have states but, since you didn't answer any of them I am still confused!
Eta: you misunderstood what I wrote about my district. I understand it is a personal decision that is not what I meant.
I may not have specifically answered your questions but did provide you with some other information that could help you. Wasn't trying to spark a debate. If anything, you should speak to your child's teacher. And what are you disagreeing with me over? That the tests are developmentally inappropriate?? Anyone will tell you that! They might be okay for your child b/c they might be above grade level but for the majority of children, they are not.
|