Re: .......
Posted 3/23/2016 8:45:37 AM by mommyagain3
Posted by mosh913
Posted by CurlyQ
1. How do the kids take these tests - particularly talking about the 3rd grade tests - are they scantron? or do they answer by circling in their test booklets? Scantron and written response in booklets and the best part is how many times I have seen students bubble 1 question wrong and the rest of the test is then wrong. It is against the law as a test administrator to tell the students to go back and fix their bubbling.
2. The tests are a little over a month away and my DC has only covered 1/2 the math topics. Is it typical for the kids to take the tests without having learned much of the material they will be tested on? Much of the tests are on material that has not been taught, and is developmentally inappropriate.
3. How much prep has your child done for the NYS math and ELA tests at this point if they are/were in 3rd grade? Generally the real push is 4 weeks before. However, all of those test workbooks, computer based programs are year long.
4. If your child is a generally bright kid and always does well on tests did you feel that the state tests were the same? Did anyone have a situation where a bright child getting 100's for years did not perform well on the tests? I have had many STRONG students score 1's and 2's. Sometimes, the brightest students over think these poorly constructed tests, run out of time, testing anxiety etc. Students that you would have thought to be the highest scorers often are not.
5. where can I find a clear list of what is covered on the 3rd grade ELA? I have looked at past tests and they are all reading comp - is there grammar, usage etc. as well? There is no clear list. That's what puts both students and teachers at a disadvantage. These are not the tests prior to common core from 5 years ago that were better constructed, predictable, and were more student friendly and achievable.
6. Does the 3rd grade math require written essay type responses or is it all numbers and showing work? Yes, they have to explain how they got their answers, and there are constructed response.
Just an FYI- it is against the law to use these NYS assessments in 3-8 as a SOLE measure for placement. A bunch of measures have to be used. So for example, if you opt out of these assessments, other measures will be used instead. Some principals and superintendents were/are using scare tactics. NYSAPE.org is a great resource to look over.
ALSO engageNY does not publish most of what the students are being tested on. Teachers have to sign off on wavers saying they will not talk about what is on the test. You will never see what your child was tested on, and neither will the teacher once the tests are over. These tests in no way shape or form are ever used again to inform instruction.
Such a great response! Thank you as this was even informative to me. I truly believe that these tests are used for the teacher evaluation system and ties into a political agenda that goes way beyond progress monitoring and tracking. It infuriates me, really.
Thank you for so much information. I have one more question maybe you can help with - how does the state, if it does, use these test for data mining on our children which is then used by companies, like Pearson, to develop curriculum that is then sold to NYSDofEd?
|