i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

labonnevie
sometimes 1+1= 4 <3

Member since 8/09

3869 total posts

Name:
the lucky one

i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

just want to say, i HATE the search function on here!

has anyone used this? any thoughts, opinions, or reviews? bed bath & beyond is selling it for $99.99 and i'm thinking about getting. with the coupon it's only $80 and i figure why not?

any experiences?

Posted 12/3/10 5:18 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

wanttobeamom
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

2448 total posts

Name:

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

saw it at Buy buy baby.

Posted 12/3/10 5:53 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

I don't have experience with it so I can't personally say - there are several posts on this product if you do a search I think most aren't huge fans but some liked it - but there was something on the today show a month or two back on it - they quoted experts from a number of top institutions who said it wasn't worth it - here is the clip...BTW the man who put it together doesn't have a degree in this area of learning.

Check this out - http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/39953918/ns/today-money/

Posted 12/3/10 5:55 PM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

Posted by Lillykat

I don't have experience with it so I can't personally say - there are several posts on this product if you do a search I think most aren't huge fans but some liked it - but there was something on the today show a month or two back on it - they quoted experts from a number of top institutions who said it wasn't worth it - here is the clip...BTW the man who put it together doesn't have a degree in this area of learning.

Check this out - http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/39953918/ns/today-money/



Thank you for posting this video! My husband keeps talking about wanting to get this and I keep arguing with him that it's not a natural way to learn to read! I've also told him that anything that needs an infomercial is not a quality product! Chat Icon Anyway, I'm glad I have this video to back up my arguments!

Posted 12/3/10 6:36 PM
 

kmac
Two under two!

Member since 5/07

3703 total posts

Name:
Kris

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

I read a bunch of reviews and went with www.monkisee.com. DS is getting it for Christmas so I don't know how it is yet but check it out.

Posted 12/3/10 6:36 PM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

it is what it is...

this is one of many sources that will help educate you kid in learning words/actions

DD loves these disc. She sings the songs. Some words she knows by reading them and doing the action or saying the word without them saying the word. The technique for this age is right IMO. As kids get older, obviously they are wanting to understand why you must learn.

I think people are negative about is reading at such a young age is purely memorizing.
Memorizing/remember, call it what you want but at 1 year, 16 mths, they need to keeping seeing actions/words/hearing them to understand this is what it is.

Are they are gonna read like the kid on the commercial? chances are no because every kid is different...just like every kid walks at a different age.

I recommend them as a tool. It is not going to hurt them.

Posted 12/3/10 6:55 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

I have it and am not impressed.

Posted 12/3/10 7:49 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

DS loves it.

I started putting it on for him at about 3 months, and I stand in front of the tv, and act out the words to him and talk about the babies. It was a lot of fun for us, something to do with an infant. Its very slow, so I wasn't worried about it being damaging or whatever.

at 8m, we say "Noah, want to watch babies on tv?" he goes bezerk, squeels, smiles, and jumps.

He loves it, I have no idea what about it, but he gets such a kick out of it, and I don't see any harm in it, its very slow, almost boring, and the quality of the videos leaves much to be desired.

So DS loves them, BUT

1. we got only the videos second hand from friends/in laws, I would pay that much for it

2. our niece started watching at 2 and hated it, but my theory is that she's been watching more exciting tv and it was really slow and boring for her.


here is my old post on it

If your DD has been watching yo gaba gaba or something like it and is into it, I'm afraid your baby can read will be so dull and boring for her.

Posted 12/3/10 8:23 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

Posted by wingsofsong

Posted by Lillykat

I don't have experience with it so I can't personally say - there are several posts on this product if you do a search I think most aren't huge fans but some liked it - but there was something on the today show a month or two back on it - they quoted experts from a number of top institutions who said it wasn't worth it - here is the clip...BTW the man who put it together doesn't have a degree in this area of learning.

Check this out - http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/39953918/ns/today-money/



Thank you for posting this video! My husband keeps talking about wanting to get this and I keep arguing with him that it's not a natural way to learn to read! I've also told him that anything that needs an infomercial is not a quality product! Chat Icon Anyway, I'm glad I have this video to back up my arguments!



I think there was a better report on this on 20/20 I think, or cbs, one of those other ones, nbc does such a cheesy report.

but I wonder, half kidding,
If a video could teach babies to read, what would all the reading experts and teacher do for money?

Posted 12/3/10 8:35 PM
 

gabbie83
2 girls <3

Member since 6/08

3037 total posts

Name:
gabbie

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

we have it
i think the amount of money that is spent on all other crap that lays around in her playroom, this $80 is worth it

ofcourse JMO opinion
i dont expect DD to learn how to read from this, that would be stupid of me.
But as a pp mentioned, its a TOOL , and i think if the tv should be on and some spongebob be on, id rather her watch this..

Posted 12/3/10 10:11 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

Someone gave it to me when I had my son. I never even opened it...

My question to inventors of those type of "products" is always: WHY? WHY should babies read?

At least all those baby Mozart/Beethoven videos were cute and didn't promise to teach them some ridiculous skills that shouldn't poses for another 5 years...

Posted 12/3/10 11:34 PM
 

karenchad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/09

518 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

We have it and some of it is still in the box. I wouldn't spend the money on it.

Posted 12/4/10 6:58 AM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

This article about summed it up for me. I am not buying it.
link to article

Posted 12/4/10 7:32 AM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

just saw it on sale at walmart I believe it was $69

Posted 12/4/10 8:18 AM
 

labonnevie
sometimes 1+1= 4 <3

Member since 8/09

3869 total posts

Name:
the lucky one

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

Posted by wingsofsong

Posted by Lillykat

I don't have experience with it so I can't personally say - there are several posts on this product if you do a search I think most aren't huge fans but some liked it - but there was something on the today show a month or two back on it - they quoted experts from a number of top institutions who said it wasn't worth it - here is the clip...BTW the man who put it together doesn't have a degree in this area of learning.

Check this out - http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/39953918/ns/today-money/



Thank you for posting this video! My husband keeps talking about wanting to get this and I keep arguing with him that it's not a natural way to learn to read! I've also told him that anything that needs an infomercial is not a quality product! Chat Icon Anyway, I'm glad I have this video to back up my arguments!



i just started watching the video, and so far i don't agree. memorization can be a good thing, a child is supposed to have over 220 sight words (sight words are the most common words found everywhere- I, am, all, of, are, at, etc) in their vocabulary for school, 52 of those to be known (or should be known or worked on) by or in kindergarten. sight words help develop fluency in reading. although memorization may not help with comprehension, fluency and comprehension must go hand in hand at some point.

to continue on, and i don't know so those who have it can chime in here, but it seems along with learning the word they are learning the picture of the word as well. so if the word is giraffe and they associate the picture of a giraffe with the word, they now know what a giraffe looks like. the only thing left to learn is that a giraffe is an animal but everything comes with time.

with that being said, i am going to continue to watch this video and see what else it has to say, but thus far, i don't fully agree with what is being said.

eta: watched the rest of the video and although the guy may seem like a weirdo with that, i'm not saying that it would be the defining process to teach my DD to read, but i think it could definitely help!

Message edited 2010-12-04 08:36:41.090000.

Posted 12/4/10 8:23 AM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

So, for those that don't agree with this tool, how do you "teach/educate" your DC about new actions/words?

Posted 12/4/10 8:41 AM
 

MrsRivera
2 under 2...whew!!

Member since 2/07

9876 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

DD absolutely LOVES it. As a teacher (and a literacy specialist at that), it went against everything that I believed in. But all *I* knew was, every. single. time. those commercials came on, she would be entranced (or would come running into the room from clear across the house). We figured, one-month trial for $14.95, we may as well see if she likes it.

She started them at just over a year. Almost a full year later, she still grabs the remote and starts the videos every day.

And I don't care what anyone says...these videos have been amazing. At 1 year and 51 weeks old, she knows most of her colors, a plethora of new songs...oh, and about 100 sight words that she can consistently identify. And not just on flash cards--she knows them if I write them on her Magna Doodle.

The way I figure it...since Kindergarteners are expected to be READING by the middle of the school year...a bit of an advantage can't hurt, even if that's not the reason we let her watch the videos.

Posted 12/4/10 8:51 AM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

Posted by BabyBoy

So, for those that don't agree with this tool, how do you "teach/educate" your DC about new actions/words?



The same way we learned new words and people years and years ago learned to read I suppose! I don't know, my son is just 4 and he's recognizing certain words just from me reading to him every night and the exposure he gets at preschool.

Don't get me wrong...if a baby loves this video i don't see the harm. It's fine. But i just don't like the concept..I HATE seeing the commercials. The main reason being is that its one more thing for other parents to question themselves over "Oh wow that 18 month old is reading, and my baby isn't..should i buy this DVD?" The answer is NO. Its not important or necessary for an 18 month old to be memorizing words. I guess it doesn't hurt..but I like babies being babies. That is just my feeling. To each their own. If a fellow mom loves the system and their child does as well, great. For me i think i'll pass...they will all learn to read when they are ready.

Posted 12/4/10 9:05 AM
 

DBJ808
LIF Adult

Member since 6/09

1039 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

The way I figure it...since Kindergarteners are expected to be READING by the middle of the school year...a bit of an advantage can't hurt, even if that's not the reason we let her watch the videos.

As a kindergarten teacher (and a literacy specialist not teaching reading lol), I totally agree with this! I have been reluctant to buy it as well though! It definitely goes against the "Fountas and Pinnell" reading system. However, I do think from looking at the material, it is a great resource to have at home for parents who want a head start! The bottom line is this.... the fundamentals to teaching children to read are letter recognition, sound recognition, phonemic awareness, using picture clues, and learning how to actually use a book (turn pages, read from left to right, sweeping, pointing to the words, etc.). Some might argue that this program is a long shot from that but I feel like anything you can do to prepare your child is great. Is it necessary... absolutely not. Although, it is not a program a school would ever consider, it is fine for extra reinforcement or exposure in the home. The key is EXPOSURE!!! However, it can be a big price tag for some people and many of these things you can do on your own for FREE! You can go to your local library and take out the monthly Kindergarten Teachers Helper and Mailbox magazines. There are wonderful preschool age activities in these magazines that address all subject areas. Lots of fun activities too! You could also subscribe to these magazines or buy them from a teachers store. I have been using them for years in my classroom. At home, I would work on having your child identify the top 100 high frequency words (it, and, I, me, etc.). Put them on flashcards and keep them in your car. Make them your driving activity!!! Label everything in your home with index cards (do maybe 5 things a week). Start with the colors and shapes of the items then work up to the actual words. If you are teaching colors, write the word RED in the color RED etc. Get the alphabet magnets in upper and lowercase. Start with only uppercase and have your child work towards identifying the letters then eventually put the letters in order. The kids eventually memorize the alphabet so you want to mix it up and do it out of order once you sense this so the really KNOW it. Then move on to lowercase. You can also make fun books at home. Everything is repetition and pictures. So maybe the name of the book is Blue if you are teaching about colors and the letter B (I would focus on 1 letter a week and 1 word a week). The words would read something like this. The blue sky (with a picture of the sky). The blue water (with a picture of water). The blue shirt (with a picture of a shirt). The key is constant repetition, picture clues, and building their self esteem to make them think they are really reading. Spend a whole week on 1 book, have them color the pictures in (obviously blue haha), highlight the letter of the week you are working on, talk about the pictures, etc. Although it starts as repetition, this develops into a recognition of all of the things I wrote above in their long term memory. I hope this was helpful! If anyone has any questions feel free to FM me. Just wanted to post some additional ideas if you want to start exposing your child but don't want to fork out $100 on a program you are uncertain of. I do think it could be helpful but you can also do some things at home without it with a little extra preparation on your part (if you have the time). Sorry if I rambled a little...

Message edited 2010-12-04 09:31:01.220000.

Posted 12/4/10 9:22 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

lots of good info in there, thanks Dana! Im going to try some of that here.

Posted 12/4/10 9:28 AM
 

DBJ808
LIF Adult

Member since 6/09

1039 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

No problem Mel!!! If you want to borrow some material (I have all of the magazines) you are more than welcome to them as long as you photocopy the pages. The are AWESOME and so many fun activities too! I also have the repetition books if you want to start Eddie with them!

Posted 12/4/10 9:36 AM
 

DBJ808
LIF Adult

Member since 6/09

1039 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

Great high frquency word website!!!

Posted 12/4/10 9:37 AM
 

DBJ808
LIF Adult

Member since 6/09

1039 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

This is a FABULOUS website! My school actually subscribes to it and this is where we print out all of the weekly kindergarten books. It is based on the Fountas and Pinnell benchmarking system, which most schools have adopted. To become a member it is $90 and I honestly think this is FAR more beneficial than this other program. This is how your child will learn to read in school. You can also preview all of the books without becoming a member if you would like to try and duplicate them on your own at home. The books coincide with all of the high frequency words that I posted above. By the end of kindergarten, my goal was to have each child reading at a C but mostly D's to give you an idea. As for the word list, we try to have the children master word list 1 before the spring and learning some words on list 2 by the end of the year. That is not an expectation just *my goal* of what I would like to try to have my students work towards and achieve! Repetition Books

Message edited 2010-12-04 09:52:39.423000.

Posted 12/4/10 9:47 AM
 

sarahbelle
Little drummer boy

Member since 5/05

2377 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

My problem with the videos and the website is that they make claims about a window of opportunity for language acquisition in the early years of life. This window does not apply to learning how to read...there is no such window. We teach English Language Learners to read at 10+ years old, so no one should be concerned about missing out on the time to teach their preschooler how to read.

The only "window" that exists is the window for learning language. The brain is only receptive to learning language for a short while, so we have to take advantage of that time and speak to our children as much as possible. So I spend time with my DS talking to him, asking him questions, singing to him and with him and reading to him.

This is not a judgment on those parents who adore the videos....if your kids love them, great! But I don't really believe children without the videos are at any type of disadvantage so long as they have a parent who reads and talks to them.

BTW - If anyone has independently conducted research, aside from blogs and personal experiences, about this program, I'd love to read it.

Posted 12/4/10 9:47 AM
 

alisonggg
Cutie

Member since 3/06

4749 total posts

Name:
a

Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read

Posted by BabyBoy

it is what it is...

this is one of many sources that will help educate you kid in learning words/actions

DD loves these disc. She sings the songs. Some words she knows by reading them and doing the action or saying the word without them saying the word. The technique for this age is right IMO. As kids get older, obviously they are wanting to understand why you must learn.

I think people are negative about is reading at such a young age is purely memorizing.
Memorizing/remember, call it what you want but at 1 year, 16 mths, they need to keeping seeing actions/words/hearing them to understand this is what it is.

Are they are gonna read like the kid on the commercial? chances are no because every kid is different...just like every kid walks at a different age.

I recommend them as a tool. It is not going to hurt them.



ITA with this... DD LOVES the books, videos and the flashcards. She enjoys it and it honestly taught her so much. She knew many of her body parts very early on bc of all of the flash cards. I didn't purchase it to get her to "read", I purchased it bc I wanted a tool to begin working on some words with her. She loves it, if she didn't I wouldn't have pushed it. I used a GC for it at buy buy baby and to me it was way more worth it than buying another toy that was just going to sit around and not get played with.

Posted 12/4/10 9:52 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I know this has been posted before-fyling with baby, packing ?'s munchkinfacemama 5/18/10 2 Parenting
I know this has been posted before-Freezing meals for when baby comes munchkinfacemama 12/18/09 6 Pregnancy
I know I posted this awhile ago but Teresa Strassers Baby Blog...is so Farkin funny 4PsInaPod 7/22/09 3 Pregnancy
Don't know if this has been posted before, but a nice read.... BaroqueMama 8/3/06 6 Parenting
Anybody use/read/know anything about Secrets of the Baby Whisperer by Tracy Hogg? LuvMy2Girls 3/9/07 8 Parenting
I know this has been posted before but bear with me - dog and new baby ? pinkandblue 12/13/06 9 Pets