Re: i know someone posted about this recently- but i can't find it... RE: Your Baby Can Read
Posted 12/4/2010 8:23:54 AM by labonnevie


Posted by wingsofsong


Posted by Lillykat

I don't have experience with it so I can't personally say - there are several posts on this product if you do a search I think most aren't huge fans but some liked it - but there was something on the today show a month or two back on it - they quoted experts from a number of top institutions who said it wasn't worth it - here is the clip...BTW the man who put it together doesn't have a degree in this area of learning.

Check this out - http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/39953918/ns/today-money/



Thank you for posting this video! My husband keeps talking about wanting to get this and I keep arguing with him that it's not a natural way to learn to read! I've also told him that anything that needs an infomercial is not a quality product! Chat Icon Anyway, I'm glad I have this video to back up my arguments!



i just started watching the video, and so far i don't agree. memorization can be a good thing, a child is supposed to have over 220 sight words (sight words are the most common words found everywhere- I, am, all, of, are, at, etc) in their vocabulary for school, 52 of those to be known (or should be known or worked on) by or in kindergarten. sight words help develop fluency in reading. although memorization may not help with comprehension, fluency and comprehension must go hand in hand at some point.

to continue on, and i don't know so those who have it can chime in here, but it seems along with learning the word they are learning the picture of the word as well. so if the word is giraffe and they associate the picture of a giraffe with the word, they now know what a giraffe looks like. the only thing left to learn is that a giraffe is an animal but everything comes with time.

with that being said, i am going to continue to watch this video and see what else it has to say, but thus far, i don't fully agree with what is being said.

eta: watched the rest of the video and although the guy may seem like a weirdo with that, i'm not saying that it would be the defining process to teach my DD to read, but i think it could definitely help!
Print Post      Close Window