Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read I saw an article on the Your Baby Can Read program...does it really work? I am a definate skeptic on this one. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 1:41 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read I am sure it "could" work, but in all honesty, I do not get it. What is the point of them reading sooo early. In my opinion, they will all level out for the most part in the end anyway. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 1:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read No, I don't think it works. Reading is a developmental skill. I think it's just memorization and I don't see the point in it. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 1:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Nay (or in this case Nah) |
|
Posted 8/15/10 1:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read IDK I just feel like those babies are not developmentally ready to read. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 2:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Nay |
|
Posted 8/15/10 2:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Reading is so much more than just "saying" the word. It's comprehension. Those kids you see on the commercial might be "reading" but 1) they're an exception and 2) they're not comprehending a thing, so what's the point? |
|
Posted 8/15/10 3:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Yah...It was handed down so not a big deal for me. Would i pay for it, kinda |
|
Posted 8/15/10 3:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Posted by BaroqueMama No, I don't think it works. Reading is a developmental skill. I think it's just memorization and I don't see the point in it. ITA |
|
Posted 8/15/10 3:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read As an educator with 15 years behind her,I find programs like this unnecessary. I am dead set against them and think the time used to work the program could be better used. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 3:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Imho, as an educator too, I say skip it, there are so many other skills they should be learning and mastering first....I'm a big believer in letting them be kids and not pushing them to do things.... |
|
Posted 8/15/10 4:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read As a teacher of literarcy, i dont personally believe that any one program is perfect. i believe children need different strategies and exposures to lterature and words. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 4:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Nah. Memorizing site words is not reading. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 6:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Its a yay for us. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 9:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read nay - its memorization, not reading. children need to read through phonics - sounding words out |
|
Posted 8/15/10 9:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Posted by BaroqueMama No, I don't think it works. Reading is a developmental skill. I think it's just memorization and I don't see the point in it. I agree. Its just teaches them to memorize, not to read. I cant see the harm in it, but I dont believe it teaches them read in the traditional sense. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 9:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Personally, I wouldn't bother with it. I don't want my baby to read. My child will read when she's ready...I see no need to push it on her. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 9:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read I am also a teacher- and I think time is better spent reading quality books to your child, and talking about them. That does more than just reading words. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 9:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Posted by iluvmynutty Nah. Memorizing site words is not reading. ditto. IMO, it should be called Your Baby Can Memorize. Cause thats all it is. Also, I'm a firm believer that a baby SHOULDNT be reading. this is the only time in their lives when they can just play all day and not have a care in the world. Why put pressure on them now when you know theres going to be nothing but pressure as they get older, kwim? i want DS to enjoy every moment of being a baby and not constantly be force fed only educational toys. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 9:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Posted by BaroqueMama No, I don't think it works. Reading is a developmental skill. I think it's just memorization and I don't see the point in it. I agree. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 9:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Posted by MrsBurtch525 I saw an article on the Your Baby Can Read program...does it really work? I am a definate skeptic on this one. Did you even want opinions from people who have never seen the program, or know at all what it is about? I'm sorry, I really don't want to cause drama, and I have upmost respect for educators, but I think the opinions are based on watching the cheesy commercials and not really understanding what the system entails. If you can get a hold of the workshop DVD, he gives a lot of insight on how to talk, play and read to your baby. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 9:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read There is a natural developmental progression to acquiring academic skills. Reading is an academic skill. Not one educator that I can think of would dispute that. There may be no harm, but I cannot think of one advantage unless your child's destiny and the G-d's above have predetermined that the child is Harvard bound. In which case, there are plenty of Harvard grads who read at the same pace as the rest of us. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 9:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Posted by Goldi0218 There is a natural developmental progression to acquiring academic skills. Reading is an academic skill. Not one educator that I can think of would dispute that. There may be no harm, but I cannot think of one advantage unless your child's destiny and the G-d's above have predetermined that the child is Harvard bound. In which case, there are plenty of Harvard grads who read at the same pace as the rest of us. I will say this, from the time I student taught MANY years ago until now, I have met many children in both the general education and special education settings whose parents' expectations exceed their capabilities. These children often feel as if they have disappointed their parents, appear anxious and yes are socially awkward. That is my experience alone so I won't comment on the population at large, but, IMO, I think programs like this, could start a parent and child down a road like this. I'm sure I'll get flamed for this, but I've been teaching long enough to form this opinion. Id rather see my kids play with developmental toys. There are plenty of children who recognize symbols and letters through life experience and are fluent readers (age appropriate of course) at kindergarten. I was one of them. How did I learn to read? Well since we did not have cable TV much less VCR's, DVD players and whatnot, in the olden days of the 70s, we relied on good old fashioned reading to and with your children. ANY parent who asks me tips on how to help their child learn to read, will ALWAYS get this answer from me. And as an educator, we are ALWAYS first in the line of fire when a child does not meet expectations. Frankly, I am tired of it. If a parent thinks this is the end-all be-all, I would like a refund for my degree so I can go into a different line of work. I'll be damned if I am going to invest money in a program like this when I know for a fact that parents can teach children how to read all by themselves with a bit of time and effort. (And no it is not PG hormones getting to me )Great point! No flames from me! I completely agree with you on many points, but why can't a dvd be a deveopmental toy? I'm not an child educator, I barely know anything about child develpment ... but I would really like an understanding. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 10:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read Posted by mommyIam Posted by Goldi0218 There is a natural developmental progression to acquiring academic skills. Reading is an academic skill. Not one educator that I can think of would dispute that. There may be no harm, but I cannot think of one advantage unless your child's destiny and the G-d's above have predetermined that the child is Harvard bound. In which case, there are plenty of Harvard grads who read at the same pace as the rest of us. I will say this, from the time I student taught MANY years ago until now, I have met many children in both the general education and special education settings whose parents' expectations exceed their capabilities. These children often feel as if they have disappointed their parents, appear anxious and yes are socially awkward. That is my experience alone so I won't comment on the population at large, but, IMO, I think programs like this, could start a parent and child down a road like this. I'm sure I'll get flamed for this, but I've been teaching long enough to form this opinion. Id rather see my kids play with developmental toys. There are plenty of children who recognize symbols and letters through life experience and are fluent readers (age appropriate of course) at kindergarten. I was one of them. How did I learn to read? Well since we did not have cable TV much less VCR's, DVD players and whatnot, in the olden days of the 70s, we relied on good old fashioned reading to and with your children. ANY parent who asks me tips on how to help their child learn to read, will ALWAYS get this answer from me. And as an educator, we are ALWAYS first in the line of fire when a child does not meet expectations. Frankly, I am tired of it. If a parent thinks this is the end-all be-all, I would like a refund for my degree so I can go into a different line of work. I'll be damned if I am going to invest money in a program like this when I know for a fact that parents can teach children how to read all by themselves with a bit of time and effort. (And no it is not PG hormones getting to me )Great point! No flames from me! I completely agree with you on many points, but why can't a dvd be a deveopmental toy? I'm not an child educator, I barely know anything about child develpment ... but I would really like an understanding. I don't think anyone (that I could see) was saying it can't be fun for your child or used as a developmental toy, but to think that it's going to make a baby a reader is far-fetched. I'm not saying that to you, because clearly you have a realistic understanding of what the videos do and seem to have fun using them with your child. But that's not how they're marketed. Think about it: a baby can barely speak, but they're going to read? I mean, their brains cannot even process reason, so it's hard for me to believe that they'll have any comprehension of what they're reading. So, that being said, I think it's a waste if someone is looking to try to get their baby to read. Like I said before, reading is a developmental skill, just like walking or talking or sitting up. You can't force those things, they happen when the child is ready, but it sure doesn't hurt at all to have fun practicing. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 10:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read It could be, but a DVD can also "zombify" a kid too. Why not read a book? I read a handful of the same books over and over again to Abby and she recognizes a handful of the words already. She loves books. She babbles and makes up her own stories with intonation and inflection - all precursors to decoding. I say "decoding" because it is easier to determine decoding than comprehension skills IMO. Message edited 2010-08-15 22:30:08.267000. |
|
Posted 8/15/10 10:23 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yay, just won a tv for baby's room | butterfly20 | 12/18/08 | 1 | Pregnancy |
| baby shower games - Yay or Nay? | jambalady | 1/13/08 | 12 | Pregnancy |
| YAY - my cousin had a baby boy this morning | HarleyGirlFLA | 6/13/07 | 22 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Baby Doll tops yay or nay? | Tumbalina | 3/12/07 | 43 | Fashion & Beauty! |
| oh yay baby who needs a man for anything..lol | Michi | 12/26/06 | 14 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| doing my first wash of baby clothes YAY | 04bride | 8/10/06 | 5 | Pregnancy |



















)