Re: Yay or Nah: Your Baby Can Read
Posted 8/15/2010 9:54:40 PM by Goldi0218

There is a natural developmental progression to acquiring academic skills. Reading is an academic skill. Not one educator that I can think of would dispute that. There may be no harm, but I cannot think of one advantage unless your child's destiny and the G-d's above have predetermined that the child is Harvard bound. In which case, there are plenty of Harvard grads who read at the same pace as the rest of us.

I will say this, from the time I student taught MANY years ago until now, I have met many children in both the general education and special education settings whose parents' expectations exceed their capabilities. These children often feel as if they have disappointed their parents, appear anxious and yes are socially awkward. That is my experience alone so I won't comment on the population at large, but, IMO, I think programs like this, could start a parent and child down a road like this. I'm sure I'll get flamed for this, but I've been teaching long enough to form this opinion.

Id rather see my kids play with developmental toys. There are plenty of children who recognize symbols and letters through life experience and are fluent readers (age appropriate of course) at kindergarten. I was one of them. How did I learn to read? Well since we did not have cable TV much less VCR's, DVD players and whatnot, in the olden days of the 70s, we relied on good old fashioned reading to and with your children. ANY parent who asks me tips on how to help their child learn to read, will ALWAYS get this answer from me.

And as an educator, we are ALWAYS first in the line of fire when a child does not meet expectations. Frankly, I am tired of it. If a parent thinks this is the end-all be-all, I would like a refund for my degree so I can go into a different line of work. I'll be damned if I am going to invest money in a program like this when I know for a fact that parents can teach children how to read all by themselves with a bit of time and effort.

(And no it is not PG hormones getting to meChat Icon )
Print Post      Close Window