.

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

.









Message edited 2010-03-30 18:32:44.113000.

Posted 3/30/10 10:07 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: how would you handle the situation?

I would not speak to her, I would call the cops.

Posted 3/30/10 10:08 AM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: how would you handle the situation?

honestly, i would mind my own business if i wasn't going to speak directly to the neighbor.

i would not call the cops unless i thought the kids were being beaten or abused. it's not against the law to fight with your family, regardless of how annoying it is.

Posted 3/30/10 10:12 AM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation?

Posted by browneyedgirl

honestly, i would mind my own business if i wasn't going to speak directly to the neighbor.

i would not call the cops unless i thought the kids were being beaten or abused. it's not against the law to fight with your family, regardless of how annoying it is.

If you read my last post about the same issue I'm sure you would change your mind. Trust me , I am the kind of person who ALWAYS minds her own business , unless it really is too much, unfortunately in this case I don't think I can mind my own business Chat Icon

maybe I'll find the old post, I think it was on parenting

Message edited 2010-03-30 10:26:00.700000.

Posted 3/30/10 10:18 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation?

Posted by browneyedgirl

honestly, i would mind my own business if i wasn't going to speak directly to the neighbor.

i would not call the cops unless i thought the kids were being beaten or abused. it's not against the law to fight with your family, regardless of how annoying it is.



I tend to agree. Unless she is constantly cussing them out and the words she is using is belittling and cruel, I wouldn't call the cops.

I come from a family of yellers. I don't know if people would consider us the "normal" amount of yelling. But we were loud and whenever we had an issue- we would air it out immediately- and loudly (at home). I grew up in a nurturing lovign home, but when someone got mad, we got loud. Every screaming match ended up with us hugging- but we did scream.

My husband's family never yelled. They also never spoke and dealt with their emotions.

People have different ways of communicating. It may not be the "right" way, but if the volume is what is bothering you, I'd say something to the neighbor. If the content is the issue- then that is something else.

Posted 3/30/10 10:19 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: how would you handle the situation?

Posted by browneyedgirl

honestly, i would mind my own business if i wasn't going to speak directly to the neighbor.

i would not call the cops unless i thought the kids were being beaten or abused. it's not against the law to fight with your family, regardless of how annoying it is.



I agree 100%

eta - I read your other link and now I am torn. while I think, as said in the other thread, that it is a form of abuse to yell and scream at your kids all day I wonder where do you draw the line....

how much yelling is too much? How much warrants a call to the cops?

I think the hubby and wife fighting, that is none of your business but the kids, I really don't knowChat Icon

Message edited 2010-03-30 10:26:01.727000.

Posted 3/30/10 10:20 AM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Message edited 2010-03-30 18:33:08.130000.

Posted 3/30/10 10:23 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

From your old post, I would call CPS. I would explain that you're not sure if they're the right people to call but you suspect your neighber is dealing with PPD & are concerned about the children. I would ask if they have any suggestions if they can't help.

While she's a screaming lunatic now, she is clearly overwhelmed & may need that push to see medical help.

I realize this is extreme but it's not normal. I come from a family of screamers too but given she just had a baby a week or two ago, it sounds like post partum.

Posted 3/30/10 10:33 AM
 

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by tatuka

Posted by browneyedgirl

honestly, i would mind my own business if i wasn't going to speak directly to the neighbor.

i would not call the cops unless i thought the kids were being beaten or abused. it's not against the law to fight with your family, regardless of how annoying it is.

If you read my last post about the same issue I'm sure you would change your mind. Trust me , I am the kind of person who ALWAYS minds her own business , unless it really is too much, unfortunately in this case I don't think I can mind my own business Chat Icon

maybe I'll find the old post, I think it was on parenting



i just read the old post. while i feel for you, and especially those kids, i still don't think calling the cops is appropriate. there is nothing they can actually do.

i don't think what that woman is doing is right and i'm not defending her. i think it's terrible!!!! but unless you speak with the family, there's really nothing else you can do. like i said, it's not against the law to yell and scream (as horrible as it is)Chat Icon

i'm so sorry you're dealing with thisChat Icon

Posted 3/30/10 10:35 AM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by nrthshgrl

From your old post, I would call CPS. I would explain that you're not sure if they're the right people to call but you suspect your neighber is dealing with PPD & are concerned about the children. I would ask if they have any suggestions if they can't help.

While she's a screaming lunatic now, she is clearly overwhelmed & may need that push to see medical help.

I realize this is extreme but it's not normal. I come from a family of screamers too but given she just had a baby a week or two ago, it sounds like post partum.



I remember that post and also responded that it sounds like she is dealing with some severe PPD. I'd be inclined to say it's NOT abuse given the circumstances (new baby, other children at home, etc....) having dealt with PPD myself, I really think this woman needs medical help and quick.

I agree with Barbara's suggestion above.

Posted 3/30/10 10:40 AM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

We wake up to her screaming every weekend, we can't sleep past 6 am bc of her. She wakes up screaming and she goes to sleep screaming, she wakes us up in the middle of the night screaming, she has so much anger and rage .....

I feel bad for her, really bad , but I feel even worse for her children and for us.

We have a right not to hear her yell and especially curse , it's not right, especially when I have a 2.5 YO myself and she is constantly asking me"who is that mama?" "what's that noise mama?" No child should have to hear someone scream so muchChat Icon

I'm just trying to figure out the way to resolve this issue .
And believe me there is NO WAY anyone would put up with this .

Posted 3/30/10 10:49 AM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by browneyedgirl

Posted by tatuka

Posted by browneyedgirl

honestly, i would mind my own business if i wasn't going to speak directly to the neighbor.

i would not call the cops unless i thought the kids were being beaten or abused. it's not against the law to fight with your family, regardless of how annoying it is.

If you read my last post about the same issue I'm sure you would change your mind. Trust me , I am the kind of person who ALWAYS minds her own business , unless it really is too much, unfortunately in this case I don't think I can mind my own business Chat Icon

maybe I'll find the old post, I think it was on parenting



i just read the old post. while i feel for you, and especially those kids, i still don't think calling the cops is appropriate. there is nothing they can actually do.

i don't think what that woman is doing is right and i'm not defending her. i think it's terrible!!!! but unless you speak with the family, there's really nothing else you can do. like i said, it's not against the law to yell and scream (as horrible as it is)Chat Icon

i'm so sorry you're dealing with thisChat Icon

Thank you for your opinion . The problem is that I don't know any of her family, just her and her DH. I never see anyone else, I just know about her mom and MIL and helping bc her DH mentioned it when we first moved here. They live upstairs , I only see her in the laundry room once in a while and we don't talk,we just say hi.

Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-03-30 10:55:19.260000.

Posted 3/30/10 10:54 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by nrthshgrl

From your old post, I would call CPS. I would explain that you're not sure if they're the right people to call but you suspect your neighber is dealing with PPD & are concerned about the children. I would ask if they have any suggestions if they can't help.

While she's a screaming lunatic now, she is clearly overwhelmed & may need that push to see medical help.

I realize this is extreme but it's not normal. I come from a family of screamers too but given she just had a baby a week or two ago, it sounds like post partum.



I agree with this.

There is no harm in calling someone.
You're concerned for the kids. Since neither you or I are professionals in dealing with this, I would let them determine if she being abusive.

I know I would feel better if they are being investigated. Because god for bid something happened to one of those kids and I didn't callChat Icon

Chat Icon
Good Luck...I'm sure it's not easy

Posted 3/30/10 11:02 AM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by Mssissy

Posted by nrthshgrl

From your old post, I would call CPS. I would explain that you're not sure if they're the right people to call but you suspect your neighber is dealing with PPD & are concerned about the children. I would ask if they have any suggestions if they can't help.

While she's a screaming lunatic now, she is clearly overwhelmed & may need that push to see medical help.

I realize this is extreme but it's not normal. I come from a family of screamers too but given she just had a baby a week or two ago, it sounds like post partum.



I agree with this.

There is no harm in calling someone.
You're concerned for the kids. Since neither you or I are professionals in dealing with this, I would let them determine if she being abusive.

I know I would feel better if they are being investigated. Because god for bid something happened to one of those kids and I didn't callChat Icon

Chat Icon
Good Luck...I'm sure it's not easy



T, OMG I am so sorry you're going through this!Chat Icon And those poor kids...my goshChat Icon I would definitely call CPS and talk to them anonymously about what can be done...how they can help her!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-03-30 11:07:31.060000.

Posted 3/30/10 11:07 AM
 

SusiBee
. . . . .

Member since 3/09

8268 total posts

Name:
S

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by tatuka

We wake up to her screaming every weekend, we can't sleep past 6 am bc of her. She wakes up screaming and she goes to sleep screaming, she wakes us up in the middle of the night screaming, she has so much anger and rage .....

I feel bad for her, really bad , but I feel even worse for her children and for us.

We have a right not to hear her yell and especially curse , it's not right, especially when I have a 2.5 YO myself and she is constantly asking me"who is that mama?" "what's that noise mama?" No child should have to hear someone scream so muchChat Icon

I'm just trying to figure out the way to resolve this issue .
And believe me there is NO WAY anyone would put up with this .



If she is screaming so loudly at 2am that she wakes your family up, then you can call the cops and let them know that there are children involved. They will come and investigate and take any necessary action, such as calling CPS if they feel the children are in danger.

(eta : if you want to do something now, call the local police precinct, explain the situation, and ask them what you can do, instead of waiting until the next middle of the night screaming fit.)

If you want to take this further, write a formal complaint to the landlord / management company that this tenant's screaming at all hours of the day and night are affecting your right to live in your apartment peacefully. They will also have to investigate and follow up. If she's disturbing you, then she is most likely disturbing others in your building.

Hopefully this lady can get the help she needs !
I too have a psycho living below me, so I kind of know what you are going thru.

Message edited 2010-03-30 11:27:11.883000.

Posted 3/30/10 11:24 AM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

I would without a doubt call CPS. The reason is yes, there *may* be nothing but simple poor communication happening in that household, and that would be plain old unfortunate, but no harm, no foul.

However, there *may* be something much more serious going on. CPS can appraise the conditions IN the home which you are not privvy to. There might be PPD or other illness, there may be some kind of neglect, or far more dire conditions at work...

I generally mind my own beeswax in MOST matters. But where there are children involved who CANNOT advocate for themselves, I think we all share the burden of advocating FOR them. And I am so so so sick of reading about children being abused and hurt these days, and neighbors who hear the commotion and do NOTHING, that I'd do anything to prevent just one kid from being hurt.

And I felt that way before DS was born too; I watched my mother go APESH*T on people who belittled their kids in public, she would not tolerate it, and say what you will, I believe she was doing the right thing.

A call to CPS will not hurt those children and may in fact, help.

Posted 3/30/10 11:25 AM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by MST9106

Posted by Mssissy

Posted by nrthshgrl

From your old post, I would call CPS. I would explain that you're not sure if they're the right people to call but you suspect your neighber is dealing with PPD & are concerned about the children. I would ask if they have any suggestions if they can't help.

While she's a screaming lunatic now, she is clearly overwhelmed & may need that push to see medical help.

I realize this is extreme but it's not normal. I come from a family of screamers too but given she just had a baby a week or two ago, it sounds like post partum.



I agree with this.

There is no harm in calling someone.
You're concerned for the kids. Since neither you or I are professionals in dealing with this, I would let them determine if she being abusive.

I know I would feel better if they are being investigated. Because god for bid something happened to one of those kids and I didn't callChat Icon

Chat Icon
Good Luck...I'm sure it's not easy



T, OMG I am so sorry you're going through this!Chat Icon And those poor kids...my goshChat Icon I would definitely call CPS and talk to them anonymously about what can be done...how they can help her!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Thank you . The worst past is that we LOVE our new place, the area is great, neighbors are really nice, overall we are happy here, but we haven't been able to fully enjoy our new place bc we've been dealing with this Chat Icon We've been so patient, saying hi , how are you and always smiling when we see them.
But it's become just too much....

Posted 3/30/10 11:28 AM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

I really don't think the cops or CPS will do anything about yelling and you could be making a big mess. It's hard to even prove yelling. If I saw bruises or scratches or other signs of physical abuse, I would call the cops stat.

Posted 3/30/10 11:49 AM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

I would not approach the neighbor myself. I wouldn't want to make it my business, and she could be unstable.

I would either call the cops when she's screaming early in the morning or late at night and make a noise complaint and let them come and check it out, or if I suspected physical abuse, I would call Child Protective Services. Either way, they are impartial professionals, and can make a determination as to whether or not they should step in (even if "step in" just means showing up on the doorstep - maybe it would be a wake-up call for the mother).

*The only reason I wouldn't call CPS just for the constant yelling (even though I do consider it psychological abuse), is because if that's all that's going on, they can't prove it. Without evidence, they can't do anything.

Posted 3/30/10 2:13 PM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by JessInCA

*The only reason I wouldn't call CPS just for the constant yelling (even though I do consider it psychological abuse), is because if that's all that's going on, they can't prove it. Without evidence, they can't do anything.



They can probably help her though by obtaining some sort of evaluation for therapy, maybe some extra help for her to receive services...something. I believe CPS should also be used as a preventative measure...

Posted 3/30/10 2:34 PM
 

PattyCake
LIF Adult

Member since 2/07

1007 total posts

Name:
Hope

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

I would call Child Protective Services.

Posted 3/30/10 2:38 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by nrthshgrl

From your old post, I would call CPS. I would explain that you're not sure if they're the right people to call but you suspect your neighber is dealing with PPD & are concerned about the children. I would ask if they have any suggestions if they can't help.

While she's a screaming lunatic now, she is clearly overwhelmed & may need that push to see medical help.

I realize this is extreme but it's not normal. I come from a family of screamers too but given she just had a baby a week or two ago, it sounds like post partum.



all of this.

Posted 3/30/10 2:40 PM
 

Chai77
Brighter days ahead

Member since 4/07

7364 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

I think you should call CPS as a concerned neighbor. You do NOT have to give your name, you can make an anonymous report. The hotline number is 1-800-342-3720. Just tell them what you have observed and they will decide if it warrants an investigation.

It may actually turn out to be a good thing, that mom may get the help that she needs.

Edited to say- - Some other posters suggested not to call CPS unless there was evidence of physical abuse. This is not true. Cases of psychological/emotional abuse and neglect are very serious and should be reported. CPS will take such cases. They interview the child and others to substantiate the allegations.

Message edited 2010-03-30 14:54:15.800000.

Posted 3/30/10 2:49 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Posted by MrsRbk

Posted by nrthshgrl

From your old post, I would call CPS. I would explain that you're not sure if they're the right people to call but you suspect your neighber is dealing with PPD & are concerned about the children. I would ask if they have any suggestions if they can't help.

While she's a screaming lunatic now, she is clearly overwhelmed & may need that push to see medical help.

I realize this is extreme but it's not normal. I come from a family of screamers too but given she just had a baby a week or two ago, it sounds like post partum.



I remember that post and also responded that it sounds like she is dealing with some severe PPD. I'd be inclined to say it's NOT abuse given the circumstances (new baby, other children at home, etc....) having dealt with PPD myself, I really think this woman needs medical help and quick.

I agree with Barbara's suggestion above.



ITA with calling CPS.

I have to say just because she may have PPD doesn't make it not abusive behavior.

Posted 3/30/10 2:50 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: how would you handle the situation? (UPDATED with a link)

Just wanted to add that I would not be calling the police with this as a "noise complaint"... I think it will be given the LOWEST priority possibility if dealt with in that manner, and if there were something amiss they'd have to call CPS anyway. So I think an anonymous call to CPS is the way to go.

Posted 3/30/10 3:01 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How would YOU handle this situation.... (sorry so long) KGools 1/7/07 5 Families Helping Families ™
Looking for advise on how to handle the situation with DH smdl 3/5/07 8 Bereavement Support Group
How would you handle - SIL situation pugmama 10/29/06 14 Parenting