Mental Illness in America
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
|
Mental Illness in America So many people are quick to say that stricter gun control is what is needed but I feel we are still ignoring the giant elephant in the room. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 10:09 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Mental Illness in America I've been saying for years that the cuts to mental health care are affecting us as a society in a negative way. It's great and such a wonderful thing to believe that we can save every person, that we have come "so far" with treatment plans and medications. That intensive therapy and day treatment programs and community based group homes are enough. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 11:25 AM
|
|
|
Mental Illness in America I agree with this. Unfortunately, I think part of the problem is that a lot of parents don't want to admit when their child has a mental problem. Whether it be developmental delays, personality disorders, autism, etc. They like to think that their child is perfect and don't want to come to terms with the fact that unfortunately their child does need medical help. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 11:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by tara73 I've been saying for years that the cuts to mental health care are affecting us as a society in a negative way. It's great and such a wonderful thing to believe that we can save every person, that we have come "so far" with treatment plans and medications. That intensive therapy and day treatment programs and community based group homes are enough. The fact is, they're not. Some people need to be put into long term care in a hospital setting. Sad, but true. There are people who can not function in society. They lash out and become violent and dangerous to themselves and others. They're not just "harmless" people who have an illness, they're ticking time bombs. We can't save everyone. We don't have the knowledge, understanding or ability on how the mind truly works. It's a novel concept to keep certain people out in society under the guise of "freedom" and "human rights" but there exists a segment of the population who simply do not belong out of institutions. We should not have to wait until they start committing felonies to get them treatment. Jail shouldn't be the only option available. There needs to be a safe place for them to be able to function and thrive while getting the treatment they need. But, if they can't thrive in that safe place, if they are routinely non compliant with meds, if they are unable to gain control over their illness and not have violent outbursts then they simply do not belong in the general population, not only for the public's safety but for their own too. Further, we need to push insurers to pay for appropriate mental health treatment and continue to educate people to remove stigmas surrounding it. Help parents like the author in the above to get their children appropriate treatment BEFORE they get to the point of no return (criminality). Continued cuts to mental health budgets don't serve any good to society. We can't continue to let these children become violent criminals and clog up jails. We're failing our mentally ill population. Beautifully said. I work as a guidance counselor in a middle school and it is very disheartening to see sick kids but the reality is these sick kids can turn into dangerous adults and something needs to be done. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 11:35 AM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America AGREED! |
|
Posted 12/16/12 11:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by tara73 I've been saying for years that the cuts to mental health care are affecting us as a society in a negative way. It's great and such a wonderful thing to believe that we can save every person, that we have come "so far" with treatment plans and medications. That intensive therapy and day treatment programs and community based group homes are enough. The fact is, they're not. Some people need to be put into long term care in a hospital setting. Sad, but true. There are people who can not function in society. They lash out and become violent and dangerous to themselves and others. They're not just "harmless" people who have an illness, they're ticking time bombs. We can't save everyone. We don't have the knowledge, understanding or ability on how the mind truly works. It's a novel concept to keep certain people out in society under the guise of "freedom" and "human rights" but there exists a segment of the population who simply do not belong out of institutions. We should not have to wait until they start committing felonies to get them treatment. Jail shouldn't be the only option available. There needs to be a safe place for them to be able to function and thrive while getting the treatment they need. But, if they can't thrive in that safe place, if they are routinely non compliant with meds, if they are unable to gain control over their illness and not have violent outbursts then they simply do not belong in the general population, not only for the public's safety but for their own too. Further, we need to push insurers to pay for appropriate mental health treatment and continue to educate people to remove stigmas surrounding it. Help parents like the author in the above to get their children appropriate treatment BEFORE they get to the point of no return (criminality). Continued cuts to mental health budgets don't serve any good to society. We can't continue to let these children become violent criminals and clog up jails. We're failing our mentally ill population. I agree. I am a social worker, and there are many clients in the community who cannot be served by the resources that are available. They are a drain on already over-burdened systems, and helping professionals. By keeping people like this in the community, also takes away from providing quality services to people who need help, but are not as much of a burden. I know at least one person who has ended up in the media over the years and I 100% feel that everyone did all they could to try to help this person, but short of locking him up and throwing away the key, they were a ticking time bomb. This person's parents were also begging for help, but there were no resources to turn to, outside of forcing them to take their meds, which honestly, does not really exist in this day and age. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 11:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by BeachGrl I agree with this. Unfortunately, I think part of the problem is that a lot of parents don't want to admit when their child has a mental problem. Whether it be developmental delays, personality disorders, autism, etc. They like to think that their child is perfect and don't want to come to terms with the fact that unfortunately their child does need medical help. I think there should be a law in place to force people to get their kids medical help, regardless of how hard it is for the parent to admit their child is sick or whatever. Too many parents and family members turn their head the other way to avoid facing the truth bc it's hard for them. Also, there needs to be a way we can make sure these patients are taking their medication every day, and the right way. It's easy for a dr to just write a prescription out, and send it home with the patient or family, but how do we know they're really going to take their medication? I believe there are already laws in place for this, but they are super hard to enforce, especially with client rights. Also hospitals are quick to discharge back to the community once the person stabilizes (or says the right things). As I stated in my last post, there are not really a lot of resources available for the severe mentally ill, drug addicts and the like. I have known many parents to beg for help, but there's no where to turn to. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 11:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America I completely agree. Mental health cuts and lack of access to treatment is a national crisis. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 12:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by tara73 I've been saying for years that the cuts to mental health care are affecting us as a society in a negative way. It's great and such a wonderful thing to believe that we can save every person, that we have come "so far" with treatment plans and medications. That intensive therapy and day treatment programs and community based group homes are enough. The fact is, they're not. Some people need to be put into long term care in a hospital setting. Sad, but true. There are people who can not function in society. They lash out and become violent and dangerous to themselves and others. They're not just "harmless" people who have an illness, they're ticking time bombs. We can't save everyone. We don't have the knowledge, understanding or ability on how the mind truly works. It's a novel concept to keep certain people out in society under the guise of "freedom" and "human rights" but there exists a segment of the population who simply do not belong out of institutions. We should not have to wait until they start committing felonies to get them treatment. Jail shouldn't be the only option available. There needs to be a safe place for them to be able to function and thrive while getting the treatment they need. But, if they can't thrive in that safe place, if they are routinely non compliant with meds, if they are unable to gain control over their illness and not have violent outbursts then they simply do not belong in the general population, not only for the public's safety but for their own too. Further, we need to push insurers to pay for appropriate mental health treatment and continue to educate people to remove stigmas surrounding it. Help parents like the author in the above to get their children appropriate treatment BEFORE they get to the point of no return (criminality). Continued cuts to mental health budgets don't serve any good to society. We can't continue to let these children become violent criminals and clog up jails. We're failing our mentally ill population. Totally agree with you (and this whole thread). DH and i have been saying this all weekend. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 12:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee Posted by BeachGrl I agree with this. Unfortunately, I think part of the problem is that a lot of parents don't want to admit when their child has a mental problem. Whether it be developmental delays, personality disorders, autism, etc. They like to think that their child is perfect and don't want to come to terms with the fact that unfortunately their child does need medical help. I think there should be a law in place to force people to get their kids medical help, regardless of how hard it is for the parent to admit their child is sick or whatever. Too many parents and family members turn their head the other way to avoid facing the truth bc it's hard for them. Also, there needs to be a way we can make sure these patients are taking their medication every day, and the right way. It's easy for a dr to just write a prescription out, and send it home with the patient or family, but how do we know they're really going to take their medication? I believe there are already laws in place for this, but they are super hard to enforce, especially with client rights. Also hospitals are quick to discharge back to the community once the person stabilizes (or says the right things). As I stated in my last post, there are not really a lot of resources available for the severe mentally ill, drug addicts and the like. I have known many parents to beg for help, but there's no where to turn to. That's really sad, I hope things can change for the future
|
|
Posted 12/16/12 1:24 PM
|
|
|
Mental Illness in America This story sounds just like what a family member is dealing with on a daily basis with her child. Sadly she has been trying to get help for the kid, and everyone attributes it to a strict mom/child acting out scenario. Its so much more than that, its scary. I worry for the family's safety often. I agree there needs to be more mental health help in this country. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 2:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Then why did Adam Lanza's mother have an assault rifle and hand guns in the house? I agree that mental illness in America needs to be addressed and the stigma removed as well as funding for resources but what bothers me so much about this article is the fact that had the family known of a tendencies for violent outbursts, why the H E L L were there any guns in a home where he lived? |
|
Posted 12/16/12 2:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by CookiePuss Then why did Adam Lanza's mother have an assault rifle and hand guns in the house? I agree that mental illness in America needs to be addressed and the stigma removed as well as funding for resources but what bothers me so much about this article is the fact that had the family known of a tendencies for violent outbursts, why the H E L L were there any guns in a home where he lived? Oh I TOTALLY agree! Furthermore, this wasnt about health insurance and how they couldnt afford to get help for their son. C'mon now. I am leaving it at that bc we could go into so much more about how financially wealthy this family was. This was a case of parenting. The parents knew way before Friday that he needed help. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 3:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by BeachGrl Also, there needs to be a way we can make sure these patients are taking their medication every day, and the right way. It's easy for a dr to just write a prescription out, and send it home with the patient or family, but how do we know they're really going to take their medication? They do have this in place in various states. The poor caseworker visits this lunatic to ensure he's taking his meds, and gets murdered. There will never ever be a handle on mental illness in this country. It is too widespread. (CBS/AP) DADE CITY, Fla. - Stephanie Ross, a 25-year-old health care caseworker who visited a client at his home alone, was stabbed to death by her patient Monday, police say. Ross reportedly knew there was something that made her "very uncomfortable" about the 53-year-old man, even previously writing in his file that two people should visit him in the future. Yet Ross still traveled alone to Lucious Smith's apartment the morning of December 10th, and police said the ex-con with a history of violence inexplicably chased her down the street, stabbing her to death with a butcher knife. Ross' death is not the first time an in-home visit by a health care professional has turned deadly. In fact, some states have added safeguards to prevent attacks, such as pairing them up with another worker for home visits or assigning a police escort, but the additional measures are sometimes too costly for states and private companies. "It may be if the risk is too high you don't send two people out, you ask the client to come in or meet in a different place or postpone the visit," Tracy Whitaker, of the National Association of Social Workers, told The Associated Press. "Unfortunately, the money gets found after there's a tragedy." Smith was being held without bail at the Pasco County jail on a first-degree murder charge. It is unclear whether he has an attorney. Ross became a service coordinator for Maryland-based Integra Health Management in September and wanted to help people with chronic illnesses, the company said in a statement. She had been on the job for about a month when she first visited Smith in Dade City, a small city about 30 miles north of Tampa It is unclear why Ross went on the visit by herself Monday, even after she had made a note that she felt "very uncomfortable" with Smith. Although Smith's illness has not been released, it is known that Smith had previous trouble with the law. Authorities had received "50 or 60 calls" about him since 2006, ranging from trespassing to battery to drunken, disorderly behavior, Dade City police officer Brian Uppercue told The Associated Press. Neighbors said he argued with nearly everyone around him and was banned from a nearby convenience store. Smith spent seven years in prison for aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and was released in 2005. After the attack, Ross was driven to the hospital by a motorist who saw her lying on the street bleeding. She died a shortly afterwards. According to an eyewitness, Smith sat outside his apartment after the stabbing and a few minutes later, police arrived. "We knew right away that he was involved," Uppercue said. Dee Brown, Integra's chief operating officer called the incident an "especially tragic loss." "We take the safety and well-being of our employees very seriously and are committed to assuring ongoing compliance with existing safety practices and incorporation of measures that might further reduce avoidable risk to our employees," Brown said in a statement. link to story |
|
Posted 12/16/12 3:13 PM
|
|
|
Mental Illness in America I'm a little confused by this article. I definitely was moved by the mother's plight- but she makes it sound like it is jail or nothing. Is that really true? My neighbor has a son with down's (adult- maybe 30's) and he lives in a facility and comes home for some of the weekends. I'm not making any comparisons- just that I know that he lives in an in-patient place where he is monitored 24/7. The child in the article imo should not be living at home. Is what she is saying really true? That there is literally no assistance for her to get her son into some sort of home? Or does she just not want to do something like that? I wonder if this article going so viral will help her get more help. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 3:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America
|
|
Posted 12/16/12 3:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America I work with the mentally ill and all I know is it isn't going to get better. Funds from the state keep getting cut and it is only going to get worse. It is sad. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 3:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by lynnd126 I'm a little confused by this article. I definitely was moved by the mother's plight- but she makes it sound like it is jail or nothing. Is that really true? My neighbor has a son with down's (adult- maybe 30's) and he lives in a facility and comes home for some of the weekends. I'm not making any comparisons- just that I know that he lives in an in-patient place where he is monitored 24/7. The child in the article imo should not be living at home. Is what she is saying really true? That there is literally no assistance for her to get her son into some sort of home? Or does she just not want to do something like that? I wonder if this article going so viral will help her get more help. It's been awhile since I worked in the field but at that time, I don't think it has gotten better, there is very little as far as resources. 10 years ago in NYC there was a pysh ward, Spofford, or Central booking as a first resource and after that, not much else unless you were willing to walk away and leave your child in the care of the foster system. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 3:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Is there still such a thing as forcibly institutionalized someone who is clearly mentally ill? I now take mental illness very seriously after what had recently happened to me. My father in law is clearly VERY mentally ill and long story short 2 months ago he attacked me and my children while my husband was at work. After the shock wore off and i went to the cops, they pretty much laughed in my face and didnt take what he did, or his threats seriously. Ive been living with fear and PTSD since fearing he would keep his promise . He has a history of breaking into my house and Im scared one day he will get his hands on a gun which I am sure he is capable of getting ( because he has before) and more then willing to use. The ONLY thing we can think of doing (since the police wont take us seriously) is getting my husband to get him insitutionalized but for the life of me, I cannot find any info on how to go about it. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 3:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America I don't work with kids anymore (thank goodness) but did for about a year, in a residential treatment facility, and it's not a place you want to send a kid to, even if they have major problems. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 3:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America I don't want to repeat everything that has already been said because so much of it is true. I do work with children with special needs. My current job allows me to work mainly with high functioning, relatively low-risk children. However I've worked in the past with children with far more difficult conditions and behaviors. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 3:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by mrsboss Posted by BeachGrl Also, there needs to be a way we can make sure these patients are taking their medication every day, and the right way. It's easy for a dr to just write a prescription out, and send it home with the patient or family, but how do we know they're really going to take their medication? They do have this in place in various states. The poor caseworker visits this lunatic to ensure he's taking his meds, and gets murdered. There will never ever be a handle on mental illness in this country. It is too widespread. (CBS/AP) DADE CITY, Fla. - Stephanie Ross, a 25-year-old health care caseworker who visited a client at his home alone, was stabbed to death by her patient Monday, police say. Ross reportedly knew there was something that made her "very uncomfortable" about the 53-year-old man, even previously writing in his file that two people should visit him in the future. Yet Ross still traveled alone to Lucious Smith's apartment the morning of December 10th, and police said the ex-con with a history of violence inexplicably chased her down the street, stabbing her to death with a butcher knife. Ross' death is not the first time an in-home visit by a health care professional has turned deadly. In fact, some states have added safeguards to prevent attacks, such as pairing them up with another worker for home visits or assigning a police escort, but the additional measures are sometimes too costly for states and private companies. "It may be if the risk is too high you don't send two people out, you ask the client to come in or meet in a different place or postpone the visit," Tracy Whitaker, of the National Association of Social Workers, told The Associated Press. "Unfortunately, the money gets found after there's a tragedy." Smith was being held without bail at the Pasco County jail on a first-degree murder charge. It is unclear whether he has an attorney. Ross became a service coordinator for Maryland-based Integra Health Management in September and wanted to help people with chronic illnesses, the company said in a statement. She had been on the job for about a month when she first visited Smith in Dade City, a small city about 30 miles north of Tampa It is unclear why Ross went on the visit by herself Monday, even after she had made a note that she felt "very uncomfortable" with Smith. Although Smith's illness has not been released, it is known that Smith had previous trouble with the law. Authorities had received "50 or 60 calls" about him since 2006, ranging from trespassing to battery to drunken, disorderly behavior, Dade City police officer Brian Uppercue told The Associated Press. Neighbors said he argued with nearly everyone around him and was banned from a nearby convenience store. Smith spent seven years in prison for aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and was released in 2005. After the attack, Ross was driven to the hospital by a motorist who saw her lying on the street bleeding. She died a shortly afterwards. According to an eyewitness, Smith sat outside his apartment after the stabbing and a few minutes later, police arrived. "We knew right away that he was involved," Uppercue said. Dee Brown, Integra's chief operating officer called the incident an "especially tragic loss." "We take the safety and well-being of our employees very seriously and are committed to assuring ongoing compliance with existing safety practices and incorporation of measures that might further reduce avoidable risk to our employees," Brown said in a statement. link to story Oh my goodness!! How terrible!!
|
|
Posted 12/16/12 4:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America As a mental health professional working with children and adolescents I would have to agree that the system is deterioriating. I work for an agency and we have to meet with 27-30 clients a week to meet the productivity numbers for the agency, otherwise our job is in jeopardy. The agency makes money based on the number of clients seen each week along with the insurance being billed to the agency. The demands are very high (progress notes/treatment plans) along with making sure clients attend their appointments. It is about quantity over quality. I meet with my client 1x a week for 30-45mins which is not enough. I have had clients that I know are already lost not just to the system but beyond the help we can provide them those clients are either hospitalized or in juvenile detention. It is very frustrating and that is why many social workers burn out and leave their jobs. Not a lot of resources not just for clients but for mental health professionals. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 5:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America How is it that special needs children are being crossed with children with mental illness? Two entirely different issues. Just bc someone has down syndrome and is placed in a residentail facility does not mean they have mental illness. Clearly, Adam Lanza was not a child with just a special need. They named all kinds of mental illnesses that went along with his DX. Yet, his parents still chose to have a house full of guns and take him to shooting ranges. Sounds like a plan. Message edited 2012-12-16 17:38:07.577000. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 5:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Mental Illness in America Posted by PrincessP How is it that special needs children are being crossed with children with mental illness? Two entirely different issues. Just bc someone has down syndrome and is placed in a residentail facility does not mean they have mental illness. Clearly, Adam Lanza was not a child with just a special need. They named all kinds of mental illnesses that went along with his DX. Yet, his parents still chose to have a house full of guns and take him to shooting ranges. Sounds like a plan. I think the two get lumped together for a few reasons. The main ones as I understand them are: 1) The umbrella term 'mental health' refers to both disabilities/special needs as well as mental illness. 2) Mental illness and special needs are VERY often comorbid - it is very, very common for a person with special needs (such as Autism Spectrum) to also have diagnosed or undiagnosed depression, OCD, etc. My master's thesis was actually about the higher risk and comorbidity of Autism Spectrum Disorders and mental illnesses. Of course having one does not always mean a person will have the other, but they do often go hand in hand and it could be useful to address both issues in conjunction. ETA: I just want to add, from what we currently know, I 100% agree that there should not have been guns in the home where this man lived. Message edited 2012-12-16 17:42:04.317000. |
|
Posted 12/16/12 5:41 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NAMI Walks-Do you know someone with mental illness? | rose825 | 5/10/07 | 9 | Charity |
| Do you know anyone with a mental illness/disorder? | dm24angel | 7/26/05 | 79 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| One in Five affected by mental illness- Join NAMI Walks for the Minds of America | rose825 | 5/12/08 | 1 | Charity |
| Mental illness- NAMI spinoff | rose825 | 5/10/07 | 28 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Mental Illness | BellaCosa | 2/9/07 | 3 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Mental illness: Depression | 05mommy09 | 10/1/06 | 35 | Families Helping Families ™ |










