Antibiotic for ear infections

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes 31 83.78%
No 4 10.81%
Other 2 5.41%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Antibiotic for ear infections

Posted By Message

NewLeaf2012
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

2741 total posts

Name:
....

Antibiotic for ear infections

Does your pedi always give antibiotics for ear infections? Does it depend on how bad it is or if there is a fever with it? Yes, no, other.
Please explain...Chat Icon

Posted 3/2/12 5:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

My ped only gives it when it reaches a certain point. They try to let it heal first. I was told most ear infections will heal on their own. Ds has been on meds twice (he's 4) and dd once (she's 2).

Posted 3/2/12 5:38 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

No ours doesn't. DD#1 had a minor infection and no fever. We were told if she is in more pain, or gets a fever we could call and they would call in antibiotics for us. But she wasn't in a lot of pain and motrin took all the pain away. It was totally clear when we went back in 10 days for a check.

DD#2 on the other hand - is not in pain but does get double severe bulging ear infections. Since they are what they classify as severe infections she does get the antibiotics right away.

The current school of thought is that many ear infections are viral so antibiotics don't work. I believe under 1 they usually give them - or if the child has a severe one or is in a lot of pain. Otherwise they say it is better to wait a few days and see if it resolves without meds.

Posted 3/2/12 5:47 PM
 

NewLeaf2012
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

2741 total posts

Name:
....

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

Posted by Lillykat

No ours doesn't. DD#1 had a minor infection and no fever. We were told if she is in more pain, or gets a fever we could call and they would call in antibiotics for us. But she wasn't in a lot of pain and motrin took all the pain away. It was totally clear when we went back in 10 days for a check.

DD#2 on the other hand - is not in pain but does get double severe bulging ear infections. Since they are what they classify as severe infections she does get the antibiotics right away.

The current school of thought is that many ear infections are viral so antibiotics don't work. I believe under 1 they usually give them - or if the child has a severe one or is in a lot of pain. Otherwise they say it is better to wait a few days and see if it resolves without meds.




That is what I thought about them too.. My son was diagnosed with an ear infection n Tuesday. Didn't know he had one. No fever and he was pulling on the other ear! They put him on an antibiotic right away. 2 days later they checked the ear again and it was almost cleared up. He only had one dose of antibiotic. He has no fever and is acting normal. The last ear infection cleared up on its own. He was prescribed an antibiotic but only got 1-2 doses before he stopped taking it. He was spitting it out or throwing it up.. He has oral sensitivities.

Posted 3/2/12 6:08 PM
 

ChilisWife
God Bless America

Member since 5/05

3572 total posts

Name:
A.K.

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

My understanding is that the cause of the ear infection may be viral (like a cold that causes excess fluid to build up in the ear), but for there to be an "infection" it means that there is now bacteria in the ear and to prevent it from multiplying and to go away you need the antibiotics. My doctors are not prescription happy at all, but they always give me one for ear infections. Plus, it can be very painful for the child and even if it goes away by itself in a week, I'd prefer they only be hurting for a day!

Posted 3/2/12 6:52 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

Posted by NewLeaf2012

That is what I thought about them too.. My son was diagnosed with an ear infection n Tuesday. Didn't know he had one. No fever and he was pulling on the other ear! They put him on an antibiotic right away. 2 days later they checked the ear again and it was almost cleared up. He only had one dose of antibiotic. He has no fever and is acting normal. The last ear infection cleared up on its own. He was prescribed an antibiotic but only got 1-2 doses before he stopped taking it. He was spitting it out or throwing it up.. He has oral sensitivities.



See taking the antibiotic for 1-2 days is not good. Also too many antibiotics can cause resistance to them. If he is not in pain and is getting better soon then he might not need them.

There are some peds who rush to give them. We are on our second practice and neither one rushed - they discussed it fully with me - DD#2 gets them automatically because she gets severe ones that they worry her ear drum will burst - but my feeling is if there is no pain and it is mild then I would rather wait it out then rush to put them on antibiotics and have resistance issues.

Posted by ChilisWife

My understanding is that the cause of the ear infection may be viral (like a cold that causes excess fluid to build up in the ear), but for there to be an "infection" it means that there is now bacteria in the ear and to prevent it from multiplying and to go away you need the antibiotics. My doctors are not prescription happy at all, but they always give me one for ear infections. Plus, it can be very painful for the child and even if it goes away by itself in a week, I'd prefer they only be hurting for a day!



Well I can tell you that my DD and several people I know who had minor infections all cleared up without meds. But usually if the child is in pain they do give meds. So it really depends on the degree of pain. I know at Columbia and Cornell they don't rush to give them unless they are needed. I know my ped doesn't want my girls to be in pain. My younger DD btw is never bothered when she had bulging eardrums and severe ones. She won't even take motrin but she does get antibiotics because it is a severe infection. With DD#1 though we could completely control the pain with motrin so she was in no pain. I know that they have the script waiting to call in if I call them and say she needs it.

Here is one of several articles I found that I have seen over the years in the NYTs on this subject.

This was just one article I know I have seen others.

http://health.nytimes.com/health/guides/disease/ear-infection-acute/treatment.html

Posted 3/2/12 8:19 PM
 

NewLeaf2012
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

2741 total posts

Name:
....

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

Posted by Lillykat

Posted by NewLeaf2012

That is what I thought about them too.. My son was diagnosed with an ear infection n Tuesday. Didn't know he had one. No fever and he was pulling on the other ear! They put him on an antibiotic right away. 2 days later they checked the ear again and it was almost cleared up. He only had one dose of antibiotic. He has no fever and is acting normal. The last ear infection cleared up on its own. He was prescribed an antibiotic but only got 1-2 doses before he stopped taking it. He was spitting it out or throwing it up.. He has oral sensitivities.



See taking the antibiotic for 1-2 days is not good. Also too many antibiotics can cause resistance to them. If he is not in pain and is getting better soon then he might not need them.

There are some peds who rush to give them. We are on our second practice and neither one rushed - they discussed it fully with me - DD#2 gets them automatically because she gets severe ones that they worry her ear drum will burst - but my feeling is if there is no pain and it is mild then I would rather wait it out then rush to put them on antibiotics and have resistance issues.

Posted by ChilisWife

My understanding is that the cause of the ear infection may be viral (like a cold that causes excess fluid to build up in the ear), but for there to be an "infection" it means that there is now bacteria in the ear and to prevent it from multiplying and to go away you need the antibiotics. My doctors are not prescription happy at all, but they always give me one for ear infections. Plus, it can be very painful for the child and even if it goes away by itself in a week, I'd prefer they only be hurting for a day!



Well I can tell you that my DD and several people I know who had minor infections all cleared up without meds. But usually if the child is in pain they do give meds. So it really depends on the degree of pain. I know at Columbia and Cornell they don't rush to give them unless they are needed. I know my ped doesn't want my girls to be in pain. My younger DD btw is never bothered when she had bulging eardrums and severe ones. She won't even take motrin but she does get antibiotics because it is a severe infection. With DD#1 though we could completely control the pain with motrin so she was in no pain. I know that they have the script waiting to call in if I call them and say she needs it.

Here is one of several articles I found that I have seen over the years in the NYTs on this subject.

This was just one article I know I have seen others.

http://health.nytimes.com/health/guides/disease/ear-infection-acute/treatment.html



thanks for the info... The first ear infection was bad. I knew he had one. I didn't stop giving him the meds, he refused to take them because of his sensory issues. It was gritty and he spit it out. I probably got more of it on the floor then in him. They said if he wasn't in a lot pain and had no fever, then it would probably clear up on its own. It did... This time around he had no symptoms of the infection. And after 2 days it was almost gone. That leads me to think it never needed an antibiotic. I don't want him to become resistant to antibiotics in case he gets something worse and needs it.. DS has always had fluid issues in one ear but it never turned into anything. And the other ear is the one that gets infected. Go figure. I appreciate all of the info. I just want to do what is best for him..

Posted 3/2/12 10:33 PM
 

NewLeaf2012
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

2741 total posts

Name:
....

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

Most of the people with kids I know IRL don't get antibiotics for ear infections. Unless it is severe or there is a fever over 101.. I guess it depends on the dr and parent. Some ear infections may not respond to antibiotics because it is viral. I am just confused with what to do.

Posted 3/3/12 2:02 PM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

Some are "ear aches", which we get no meds.

DS has had 2 ear "infections" with hig temps. So he has gotten antibiotics with both.

Posted 3/3/12 2:20 PM
 

NewLeaf2012
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

2741 total posts

Name:
....

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

Posted by munchkinbugs

Some are "ear aches", which we get no meds.

DS has had 2 ear "infections" with hig temps. So he has gotten antibiotics with both.



I would definitely want an antibiotic if he had a high fever... That IMO warrants one. This one had no fever, not much pain. I didn't even know he had one until we went to the dr for something else... He is like me and doesn't tolerate antibiotics very well. Poor kid! Today he threw up after I finally got him to eat and tried another dose.. I put a call into the pedi and am waiting for a call back.

Posted 3/3/12 5:52 PM
 

mnmsoinlove
Mommy to 2 sweet girls!

Member since 3/09

8585 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

My dd has chronic ear infections that won't even go away with most antibiotics so at this point the ent will prescribe strong antibiotics. I hate it, even after putting tubes we are still doing antibiotics Chat Icon

Posted 3/3/12 8:35 PM
 

NewLeaf2012
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

2741 total posts

Name:
....

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

Posted by mnmsoinlove

My dd has chronic ear infections that won't even go away with most antibiotics so at this point the ent will prescribe strong antibiotics. I hate it, even after putting tubes we are still doing antibiotics Chat Icon



Sorry to hear that... Do they do antibiotic ear drops instead of regular antibiotics?

Posted 3/4/12 12:14 AM
 

Lucky
Growing up fast!

Member since 4/07

12683 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: Antibiotic for ear infections

The couple of times my DD has had ear infections, they were painful for her so he has always given antibiotics. My DD always has fluid in her ears and for the most part it never poses a problem; when she complains then we know that she needs something.

Posted 3/4/12 8:15 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What is the antibiotic stronger than Amoxicillin for ear infections? CEFZIL cgdg61606 2/13/09 6 Parenting
Antibiotic ear drops v. oral meds for infection? ChilisWife 1/22/11 2 Parenting
Question about chronic colds/ear infections and rectal temperature... Candy Girl 11/11/09 6 Parenting
Chronic Ear Infections and Dairy being a contributing factor to it? LJSMommy 6/29/09 3 Parenting
Green Gook coming out of eyes and ear infections? Tine73 12/17/08 4 Parenting
Ear INfections.... Anybody up please?????? mommy2devin 10/11/08 12 Parenting