Which would you want?

Forum Opinion Poll
LR4 5 5.05%
Range Rover Sport 30 30.30%
BMW X5 29 29.29%
Acura MDX 35 35.35%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

UPDATE!!!Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

Posted By Message

robynfs
12/6/10!!

Member since 9/05

4947 total posts

Name:

UPDATE!!!Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

UPDATE 10/28
Just wanted to update you all. I saw the car post and it reminded me.

We just put in the order for the 2011 BMW X5. I just felt like it was the best decision for my family. The LR's/RR's are great, fun cars but we are buying this one and plan to have for about 6-7 years and the BMW just has a much better maintenance plan and a better history regarding reliability!

Thanks for all the feedback! We are picking it up at the BMW factory in S.Carolina in about 4 weeks
_____________________________________________________________

I have to make a decision really by this weekend. I have driven almost every SUV out there and we are just torn!

I am between the following:

LR4
Range Rover Sport
BMW X5
Acura MDX (DH doesn't love this one...but I like it so it stays on my list)

They all drive great, have beautiful interiors, are safe etc. As far as cost the Range Rover and BMW are the most expensive. Then is the LR4 about 10k less and then the Acura which is close to the LR4...just a few grand less.

We are unsure if we are leasing or buying, but either way see this as a max 5 year car.

Just looking for opinions..thanks!

Message edited 2010-10-28 09:36:21.010000.

Posted 8/24/10 11:20 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KittyGags
LIF Adult

Member since 7/09

5614 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV!

With no budget in mind, I pick the BMW. I have a 3 series now and we had the X3 before it and they're just awesome cars/trucks. LOVE.

I love the RR Sport too but people complain about them.

I love the LR4 which is probably the cheapest of them all...so if this is most in line with your budget I'd do this one.

I am not a fan of the MDX.

Posted 8/24/10 11:24 AM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV!

out of all those I would pick the X5

I sat in all of them and I prefered my SUV (ML350) to all and the X5 was the next one I would have gotten

I found the land rover and the range rover to not be so roomy in the front- which I hated - and they also tend to have electric issues

Message edited 2010-08-24 11:26:57.657000.

Posted 8/24/10 11:26 AM
 

robynfs
12/6/10!!

Member since 9/05

4947 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV!

Posted by Beth

out of all those I would pick the X5

I sat in all of them and I prefered my SUV (ML350) to all and the X5 was the next one I would have gotten

I found the land rover and the range rover to not be so roomy in the front- which I hated - and they also tend to have electric issues



I drove the ML350 and I really liked it. But then the guy had us drive the 550 and I couldn't go back to the 350...I am also used to driving a very fast car right now. The price grew really quickly with all the additions etc.

I appreciate your opinion and definitely need to sit in the LR and RR again to remember the feel.

Message edited 2010-08-24 11:33:13.953000.

Posted 8/24/10 11:32 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV!

I would pick the Range Rover bc I like the way it looks best and I feel like I don't see them as often as the others Chat Icon

Granted I have no insight into how any of these are..did you look up consumer reports? Sit in all of them? That might help you Chat Icon

Posted 8/24/10 11:33 AM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

Posted by robynfs

[



I drove the ML350 and I really liked it. But then the guy had us drive the 550 and I couldn't go back to the 350...I am also used to driving a very fast car right now. The price grew really quickly with all the additions etc.

I appreciate your opinion and definitely need to sit in the LR and RR again to remember the feel.

wow...how much faster is the 550?...I find myself speeding already on the highway in mine

I got then middle ML350- I had the base model the first time and I could not be happier with it

I went from the C230 sports seden to the ML with no issues- I prefer a SUV to a car any day

Posted 8/24/10 11:41 AM
 

luvmytwins
pretty princesses

Member since 7/09

1424 total posts

Name:
Nancy

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

I have the X5 and love it! Its a great car. We lease it for 3 years. FM me if you have any questions.

Posted 8/24/10 11:58 AM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

I have the MDX and I LOVE it just love it. I would save a little bit of $ if I were you and get the MDX. I have driven the X5 , it's drives nice but honestly I am not crazy about the way it looks. I really don't like the range rover.

I don't know what the LR4 is. the mercedes truck , 350 I think, Is a BEAUTIFUL truck. I've never driven it tho so I'm not sure.

Did you check consumer reports? I'm not sure how the others are rated but the MDX does well

Message edited 2010-08-24 12:09:20.087000.

Posted 8/24/10 12:06 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

Definitely the BMW X5.

Posted 8/24/10 12:08 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

Looking only at Consumer Reports, I'd go with the Acura MDX. It has the most front seat comfort & the largest third row - without sacrificing on fuel economy.

BUT DH would want the 5.5L, V8...so it's a cr@p shootChat Icon

Let me know if you want the consumer reports stuff.

Posted 8/24/10 12:35 PM
 

KimberlyScott
Graceyn=My World <3

Member since 10/08

4173 total posts

Name:
Kimberly

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

I'm a previous Land Rover owner. I owned a 02 Discovery SE7 and while I LOVED it, my pocketbook didn't.

Since mine is a bit older, I had issues with repairs bc a lot of mechanics didnt unterstand the British engineering so I had to bring it to the dealer or a "specialist". I spent about $3k in repairs not including the scheduled maintenance and I owned the car 3 years.

Just a heads up, Land Rover might be better engineered now. Good Luck

PS ....Don't get one with a sunroof, they leak!! All of them!!

Posted 8/24/10 1:10 PM
 

laurenandmike619
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/10

857 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

I have a BMW 328i so I'm partial but I have to say that for YEARS I have worshipped the X5. It's just absolutely beautiful and such a well made car. That's where my vote goes!!

Posted 8/24/10 8:46 PM
 

LisaW
Time for me to FLY!

Member since 5/05

13199 total posts

Name:
Did I ever tell you that I hate people?

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

We were looking at the same group of SUVs and wound up with the Lexus GX460

I liked the RR a lot, but as a pp said I heard it had electrical issues- I also heard the LR had issues too (can't remember exactly what they were)

I also looked at the ML350, and like you, once I saw the 550- forget it!

Never cared for the Acura, but that may be bc of the salesperson LOL- I looked at it years ago and thought the interior was a bit chintzy although that might have changed

That being said, the X5 is a good car, it was a little smaller than I wanted, but my brother has the X3 and loves it, so I would pick that out of your choices

good luck
Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-08-24 21:21:12.223000.

Posted 8/24/10 9:19 PM
 

robynfs
12/6/10!!

Member since 9/05

4947 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

Thanks for all the input...I really appreciate the help. I'll let you know what we decide.

Oh on a side note, we did a lot research on the LR and RR and the electrical issues are no longer a problem since they were bought buy xx...can't remember Chat Icon They also said the newer line since the Discovery, so the last 5-6 years does not have the same issues.

We will see!! Thanks again! Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/10 10:22 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

The LR4 is nicer than the Sport imho

The Acura costs too much for what you get in the end.

Did you look at the Audi options?

Posted 8/25/10 10:24 AM
 

luckyinlove
I love my baby girls!

Member since 12/06

2441 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

I would go with the X5 or the MDX. All Land Rovers need crazy repairs that are costly. If you are leasing, LR's are a good deal, but I would never buy one bc once they go off warranty, you are screwed. I used to work for them and I heard tons of complaints!

Posted 8/25/10 11:34 AM
 

Barbiegrl
So in love with my little man!

Member since 8/09

2618 total posts

Name:
Barbara

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

I have the LR2 this is my second one. The 1st one I leased for 2 years and now I bought the new one I have. So far no electrical problems or anything like that. The only thing I can find wrong with the car is that I've cracked the windshield in both cars. I drive a lot, over 70 miles per day, so I really use the car but I found it weird that both cracked. And I know its an expensive windshield. I loveeeeeeeeeee Land Rover! The LR4 is gorgeous I really love that one! But there is nothing like a Range Rover Sport Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-08-25 11:39:56.493000.

Posted 8/25/10 11:36 AM
 

Kaitlyn747
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/10

399 total posts

Name:
Kaitlyn

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

IMHO..

You are missing the Audi Q5.

That IS my next car. I have driven both the BMW and Q5...and the Q5, TO ME, is superior.

If you havent driven it yet, do.

Posted 8/25/10 12:01 PM
 

KimberlyScott
Graceyn=My World <3

Member since 10/08

4173 total posts

Name:
Kimberly

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

Posted by Barbiegrl

I have the LR2 this is my second one. The 1st one I leased for 2 years and now I bought the new one I have. So far no electrical problems or anything like that. The only thing I can find wrong with the car is that I've cracked the windshield in both cars. I drive a lot, over 70 miles per day, so I really use the car but I found it weird that both cracked. And I know its an expensive windshield. I loveeeeeeeeeee Land Rover! The LR4 is gorgeous I really love that one! But there is nothing like a Range Rover Sport Chat Icon




This happened to me too! Replaced the windshield 2x and it's $$ since they are heated.

Head gaskets may be an issue too.

Posted 8/25/10 12:08 PM
 

Reese1106
Family of 4! :o)

Member since 8/06

6655 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

Definitely the X5!

Posted 8/25/10 12:16 PM
 

mrsboss
my little love

Member since 12/09

5054 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

DH has a Range rover sport - he likes it, not loves it. I like driving it, I think alot of the features are frivolous however. I also think it rides alot rougher than the MDX which I loved. I recently drove the Lexus RX and LX, and felt they drove so smooth and beautifully. I guess you need to decide what you are really looking for? Good luck.

Posted 8/25/10 5:26 PM
 

robynfs
12/6/10!!

Member since 9/05

4947 total posts

Name:

Re: Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

Just wanted to update you all. I saw the car post and it reminded me.

We just put in the order for the 2011 BMW X5. I just felt like it was the most practical decision for my family. The LR's are great, fun cars but we are buying this one and plan to have for about 6-7 years and the BMW just has a much better maintenance plan and a better history regarding reliability!

Thanks for all the feedback! We are picking it up at the BMW factory in S.Carolina in about 4 weeks Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/10 9:33 AM
 

Sunday
In love with a boy named Luca

Member since 6/09

1799 total posts

Name:
`

Re: UPDATE!!!Please help me decide on an SUV! (WITH POLL)

Good choice! We have had a 335 for the last 3 years (sooo not good for a family) and I also just ordered an x5 which should arrive in about 6 weeks or so. I'm super excited. What color did u get? I got deep sea blue with beige interior. Do u know about the tracking system on the website? My order was just placed but I tracked my last one and it was so fun. You can see the steps as it,s built in germany, gets on the ship, gets to the american port, etc. kind of dumb, lol, but fun.

Message edited 2010-10-28 10:30:03.970000.

Posted 10/28/10 10:28 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
At what point would you decide to leave your job BabyAvocado 10/12/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
How to decide... luvsun27 10/11/05 10 Adoption
Help me decide on a halloween costume for Ava Dani00518 9/29/05 16 Parenting
Please help me decide on a pic.. Denisemang 9/26/05 31 Parenting
help me decide on Condo!! MrsR 6/20/05 2 Home
question-if you decide to put your closing costs into your mortgage, raken40 5/24/05 0 Home