Did you walk in and instantly fall in love with your first home?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes, it was love at first sight and no other would do. 25 47.17%
Eh, not really, it took us a while to warm up to it. 8 15.09%
Nope, but we saw the potential and love it now that we've done the work. 12 22.64%
Other, just because.... 8 15.09%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

We saw a home in the neighborhood in which we really want to live. While the house is not ideal, it would work for us and we think we could get it at a good price. There is a lot of potential in this house, despite the fact that we'd have to do a fair amount of updating (removing wall paper, refinishing floors, updating the original, circa 1950--seriously, 1950--kitchen).

The problem is that neither one of us are having the "this is it!" feeling that we think we should have. I don't know if there's any one thing that's nagging us about it. The other homes for sale in the neighborhood are either out of our price range or we've been able to outright knock them off our list. We don't have a feeling that we'd be settling either. We may just be feeling this way b/c this would potentially be the first house for which we make an active offer.

Does anyone really have that "this is it" sense? Maybe we're being too naive about this. Don't know, but would love opinions.

Disclaimer--looked for similar posts and couldn't find any coming up on search, so apologies if this has appeared before /recently.

TIA for your responses.

Posted 6/30/09 6:48 PM
 
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Long Island Weddings

jteach
2 and through

Member since 9/07

3939 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Some people might not agree with me but this is how I feel on this subject.


A house is probably the biggest investment you will EVER make. Your house will be where you make so many family memories, and your house will cause you to write out a FAT check every month for the next 30 years of your life.

I would never be able to feel comfortable making that kind of investment and not LOVING the house.

We were so excited to start house hunting and we saw a bunch of houses that were okay, and could be made to be nicer, and in nice neighborhoods, but I wasn't excited and paying all that money on something that I wasn't over the moon for just did not make sense.

We walked into one house that at first we eren't sure if we could afford but automatically dh and I fell in love, we knew that this was OUR house.

We are in contract for the house now and I am so happy that I did not choose one of the ones that were just OK.

Hope this makes sense and maybe helps you decide.

Good luckChat Icon

Posted 6/30/09 7:23 PM
 

bride07
Ava Rose you are an angel!!!

Member since 3/09

6115 total posts

Name:

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?


It sounds like you are buying a fixer upper that has great potential. If that is the case- then NO you probably wouldnlt have that "this is it feeling" right away. But what is great about what your are considering is you can MAKE IT YOUR OWN. We are considering buying a house that needs work. I would rather get to create my own dream kitchen & bath. Sounds like it could def become your DREAM home once you fix it up!


Good luck house hunting

P.S That is what we did with our current apartment that we live in NYC. It was a great apartment with good amount of space. It was a total mess when we bought it and we renovated everything and have a new bathroom, kitchen, hardwood floors, lighting etc. So we never had the feeling initially- but knew that it had great potential. Now everyone loves our aprtment and we get tons of compliments b.c of all the work we did to it. : ) Hopefully we can sell it so we can move out to Long Island soon. : )

Message edited 2009-06-30 19:31:05.780000.

Posted 6/30/09 7:25 PM
 

rkoenke
my little piggys

Member since 3/08

4315 total posts

Name:
rachel

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Not me! all that matters to me is that it has good bones.
It had all the bedrooms that we wanted (3 at the time)
bathrooms (2)
den
living room
dining room
basement
attic
hardwood in some rooms.

that's all we wanted. none of the rooms are tiny, except maybe the bathrooms, but we don't care about that...

we ripped out sheetrock, wallpaper, flooring, windows, doors, appliances, fans, did electric work... and pavers!! new heating system with four zones...

we did everything that we wanted (could afford to do) to make it ours.

in my next house search, i am not looking for "perfect" meaning everything completely re-done... kitchen would be nice to have done, anything else, i want to do it myself (well Dh and myself).
i want to rip out all the landscaping and do it MYSELF. paint, plumb, electric... i want to do it all . . . ourselves! this way, i know what i have, when it was replaced, how old it is, yada yada... this is important to me, no surprises. but, i have been told that i am not the ordinary person. most people want done/ complete, don't have to do anything... not me.

Chat Icon
PS- i drove past our times often and say "NO WAY! IT'S UGLY!" well, that was five years ago and i think we turned it into a pretty home.

Message edited 2009-06-30 19:53:14.050000.

Posted 6/30/09 7:51 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Posted by Cpt2007

We saw a home in the neighborhood in which we really want to live. While the house is not ideal, it would work for us and we think we could get it at a good price. There is a lot of potential in this house, despite the fact that we'd have to do a fair amount of updating (removing wall paper, refinishing floors, updating the original, circa 1950--seriously, 1950--kitchen).



DH and i saw a house exactly like you described - except we both got the "this is it!" feeling.

unfortunately the owners were completely unrealistic and unwilling to come down in price. with all the updates it needed we would have been overpaying by about 50K.

in the end we went with a house that we really, really loved, and the more we think about it the more we love it and can't wait to make it our own.

Posted 6/30/09 8:07 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

I absolutely knew this house was the one when we walked into it. I can't explain it, but it's like when we walked into the house, it just felt right. Almost like it had been waiting for us. That sounds SO hokey, but I swear that's how it felt and still does feel. Like this house was built for us. There was only two other owners, the original owner and the one who sold it to us after living here for 50 years. I like to think it really was put here for usChat Icon

Posted 6/30/09 8:16 PM
 

JJN4
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

1109 total posts

Name:

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Posted by olliesmama

Some people might not agree with me but this is how I feel on this subject.


A house is probably the biggest investment you will EVER make. Your house will be where you make so many family memories, and your house will cause you to write out a FAT check every month for the next 30 years of your life.

I would never be able to feel comfortable making that kind of investment and not LOVING the house.

We were so excited to start house hunting and we saw a bunch of houses that were okay, and could be made to be nicer, and in nice neighborhoods, but I wasn't excited and paying all that money on something that I wasn't over the moon for just did not make sense.

We walked into one house that at first we eren't sure if we could afford but automatically dh and I fell in love, we knew that this was OUR house.

We are in contract for the house now and I am so happy that I did not choose one of the ones that were just OK.

Hope this makes sense and maybe helps you decide.

Good luckChat Icon



ITA!

Posted 6/30/09 8:23 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

we are buying the biggest fixer upper (but within reason) and honestly after 7 months (i think) of looking we kinda knew it was the one. We saw soo much damn potential it was sickening. By putting the work in yourself and hiring the people you want you are controlling the quality. I have seen FAR too many move in houses that we looked at and laughed because we know the stuff was S H I T.

Posted 6/30/09 8:27 PM
 

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

We went strictly, and I mean strictly - by location (oh, and basement).

It was love at first sight.

I don't think you need that "it" feeling though... Chat Icon If it has everything you want and it's a fixer-upper, it's hard to get that feeling.

Posted 6/30/09 8:39 PM
 

Megs4
LIF Adult

Member since 11/08

1619 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

I wanted to pick the "nope but we saw the potential and love it now" but I am the "other" because the answer is "nope but we saw the potential and hope we will love it or make a profit when we are ready to leave."

When we saw our house we saw it had GREAT potential, and we got to know and really care about the sweet old lady selling it, and she really wanted us to buy it so it definitely added to the experience at the time. Our story took a turn after that, but that is neither here nor there.

We have already done a lot of work and are starting to love the house. But we have a long list of things we still want to do. We never doubt whether or not it was the right house for us to get at this time, but I still don't LOVE it, per se.

Posted 6/30/09 10:34 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

We felt it was IT when we saw our house. We had one thing about it though that we didn't like. And there were many things we wanted that were just not realistic for the area/houses available.

We paid high, and put a lot of work into our house. Put a lot of love in it, you name it we did it.

Here we are 6 years later and we hate it. The things that bothered us are bothering us to the point where we sort of regret buying it. But there wasn't much on the market and it was GREAT house for the area. But it isn't a great house for us now.

What's my point? Even if you have the feeling of it being the ONE, you never know how your feelings may change in time. I dont know what you should make of what I am saying....just telling my story.

Posted 6/30/09 10:35 PM
 

CoutureMaMa
nicholas is one!!

Member since 9/07

6081 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Posted by bride07


It sounds like you are buying a fixer upper that has great potential. If that is the case- then NO you probably wouldnlt have that "this is it feeling" right away. But what is great about what your are considering is you can MAKE IT YOUR OWN. We are considering buying a house that needs work. I would rather get to create my own dream kitchen & bath. Sounds like it could def become your DREAM home once you fix it up!


Good luck house hunting

P.S That is what we did with our current apartment that we live in NYC. It was a great apartment with good amount of space. It was a total mess when we bought it and we renovated everything and have a new bathroom, kitchen, hardwood floors, lighting etc. So we never had the feeling initially- but knew that it had great potential. Now everyone loves our aprtment and we get tons of compliments b.c of all the work we did to it. : ) Hopefully we can sell it so we can move out to Long Island soon. : )



ITA! this is what we just did. bought a house in a great area for so cheap! that needs a lot of work. a second floor, total gut! but in the end it will be what we always dreamed of. so no when i saw it i said lets go this isnt what i want . but then when i thought if the price and potential and area; i was like how can we pass this up. so follow your heart but weigh out everything...

Posted 6/30/09 11:09 PM
 

jerseygirl
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/08

808 total posts

Name:

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

We looked for close to 2 years to find a house. We actually put a bid in for another house that I thought was "the one" but the sellers wouldn't budge. Fast forward about 2 weeks, and when I walked into this house I just knew it was the one. Now when I even think about that other house I'm so glad we didn't get it. So...2 years is a very long time to search..but we are very happy that we did. It just happened to work out for us.

Posted 6/30/09 11:43 PM
 

evenedan
Need a little sunshine

Member since 9/05

3843 total posts

Name:
D

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

When we first saw our house, we loved and hated it, if that makes any sense. We loved the neighborhood, the charming street and the layout of the house. (The layout was very important to me because I wanted big, open rooms and all bedrooms upstairs.) But I hated the condition it was in. BEYOND DISGUSTING. OVERWHELMINGLY DISGUSTING! We left the house feeling physically ill that a human being could live in such filth, but at the same time we kept talking about how much we loved the "bones" of the house. We went back a few more times and got some estimates on what it would cost to renovate it. We also looked at every house for sale in Nassau County, but kept coming back to our beloved dump.

We decided to make an offer. The condition of the place worked to our advantage and we got a good price.

It came down to these factors...

The layout was perfect.

We love the area.

Everything in our price range needed updating, so why be deterred by a bathroom that looked like it was in a prison or a carpeted kitchen that had 8 layers of filth caked all over it? We factored in the cost of renovations into our offer and got the house for a price MUCH lower than anything else in the area.

We are in the process of renovating now, but already LOVE the place and feel so thrilled with our decision! The house is going to be FANTASTIC! Some day.

So, I guess we did have a "this is it" feeling, but it was mixed with a heavy dose of "are we crazy?" If the issues you have with your house are cosmetic—wallpaper, dated kitchen etc.—I wouldn't let that get in the way. Focus on the location and the layout.

Good luck with your decision!

Message edited 2009-07-01 01:32:32.457000.

Posted 7/1/09 1:29 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

I think potential is more important than being "the one". SIL had her "dream house" built, but didn't plan for the future, just what she felt she needed at the moment. Over the years, she's had several complaints about the house.

Needs and wants change. What could be "the one" today, may not be what you need in 1 year, or 5 years. If you don't have the ability to modify the house, you may wind up resenting it.

Our house was "OK" when we bought it. Great neighborhood, good SD, had what we needed at the time, but also had enough of a yard so we could expand. Now that we've totally redone almost the entire house, it is currently "the one". I designed the layout myself, and I hope I took into account most of what we'll encounter over the next 20-30 years, but if not, hopefully I can modify the house again.

Posted 7/1/09 7:56 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

we knew immediately that we would make an offer, in fact we made our offer within a minute of entering the house before seeing every room.
Not because we loved everything about it but because we knew it was an excellent buy & either we'd make it what we wanted or sell it.
Our house was unlivable when we bought it, it had broken pipes, limited electrical system, no heating system the day we looked at it, but yet we knew it was a great house.
It wasn't that wedding dress feeling, if you know what I mean.
We compromised a good bit on our "must have list" but we also got things we never thought we'd get with our budget. 5 years later we are still improving the house and I'm so glad we bought it.

Posted 7/1/09 8:09 AM
 

TreAnt427
-

Member since 8/06

8652 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Our house was not by any means "beautiful" when we saw it. But we saw the potential and it was the first house that I could "picture" us living in. I knew this was the house I had to have for many reasons. The deal almost didn't go through and we even looked at other houses while still in the process of buying. I was heart broken looking at other houses b/c everyone we saw couldn't compare to ours. Everything worked out in the end and I'm so glad it did!

Posted 7/1/09 8:12 AM
 

rkoenke
my little piggys

Member since 3/08

4315 total posts

Name:
rachel

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Posted by evenedan

but kept coming back to our beloved dump.
]

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/1/09 8:32 AM
 

rkoenke
my little piggys

Member since 3/08

4315 total posts

Name:
rachel

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Posted by GoldenRod

I think potential is more important than being "the one". SIL had her "dream house" built, but didn't plan for the future, just what she felt she needed at the moment. Over the years, she's had several complaints about the house.

Needs and wants change. What could be "the one" today, may not be what you need in 1 year, or 5 years. If you don't have the ability to modify the house, you may wind up resenting it.

Our house was "OK" when we bought it. Great neighborhood, good SD, had what we needed at the time, but also had enough of a yard so we could expand. Now that we've totally redone almost the entire house, it is currently "the one". I designed the layout myself, and I hope I took into account most of what we'll encounter over the next 20-30 years, but if not, hopefully I can modify the house again.




Oooh! i have to agree. we have a great den... requirement of my husband when buying. it turns out that a den is great for adults, but now we have two kids. all their toys are in there, they are constantly in there laughing, screaming, playing, punching, hitting, biting, yelling... we realize how nice it would be to have a den, and some room that they can play in and watch their TV and sort out their differences themselves. . . so, although the den idea was perfect at the time, guess what? it isn't so perfect now!
Chat Icon

Posted 7/1/09 8:35 AM
 

cindy104
This is my "Baby"

Member since 6/08

1522 total posts

Name:
Cindy

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Posted by jerseygirl

We looked for close to 2 years to find a house. We actually put a bid in for another house that I thought was "the one" but the sellers wouldn't budge. Fast forward about 2 weeks, and when I walked into this house I just knew it was the one. Now when I even think about that other house I'm so glad we didn't get it. So...2 years is a very long time to search..but we are very happy that we did. It just happened to work out for us.




This was pretty much the same for us too....we searched 2 years and there was one other house before this one that we though was "the one". We had a contract drawn up, inspection done, everything ready and all we had to do was sign. We backed out b/c we just had this really unsettled feeling about it....that there was better out there. Not to mention we were still looking as we went through this process with this one house! So that right there showed that we weren't completely satisfied.
Low and behold, within a week or two we found a house that we loved every single thing about. Location, updates, style, price, etc.
We knew THIS was the one. We backed out of the other deal and jumped on this one.
We are so happy we didn't get the other one. This house is "the one" and we're so happy with our purchase!
It just so happens that the other house finally sold too and someone bought if for only $500 less then we bought our house for and it was much smaller and not as nice as an area as we're in now!
(p.s. - and we got more land and cheaper taxes too!)

Posted 7/1/09 9:03 AM
 

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

We didn't get the "this is the house" feeling and that is because we bought the ugly house on the block. But we are glad we did. We have great neighbors that treat us very well, good schools, good neighborhood and the house is starting to become a Home to us now. Our home. I think back and look at pics of the house when we first started and we have come so far since we bought 2 yrs ago. We are making the house ours and we wouldn't have it any other way. I liked that we were able to do what we wanted done in the house. Of course there has been a lot of cursing over the last 2 yrs and a lot of things we didn't think we were going to have to fix but now we are or will. But in the end, we will be able to say, "We did this and we are very proud of ourselves". It was a long road, so be prepared if you buy a fixer upper. It can be challenging at times, upsetting at times, cost more money at times, take a lot longer than what you thought it was going to take you, but in the end, we made it ours. (just being honest with our experience so far) Lots of luck with your decision. Chat Icon

Posted 7/1/09 9:07 AM
 

Nik211
my little monkey<3

Member since 5/08

3303 total posts

Name:
Nik

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

i look for potential - we've made 6 offers already - so for us there isn't "the one" b/c we thought every house we put an offer on was "the one" and we still have no house Chat Icon but that is b/c we look at a homes bones and we can see all the potential and things that we could do with it....also the neighborhood/location is a HUGE factor....i rather buy an ugly house in the best area than buy a house with all the bells and whistles that is somewhere less desireable...

i think that the people living in the house make it a home - but that doesn't mean i'm not really picky....all 6 houses we put an offer on were Chat Icon Chat Icon and we didn't get any of them Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-07-01 09:13:28.373000.

Posted 7/1/09 9:12 AM
 

HopingtobeaMOMin09
LIF Toddler

Member since 1/09

495 total posts

Name:
J

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

We definitely wanted our house from the first moment we saw it. It is definitely a fixer upper, but we loved the location and the potential it has...now we are just waiting to close so we can get to work!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/1/09 9:48 AM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

Not love at first sight for me, but DH saw the potential and convinced me. So glad he did! Now that we've fixed it up we're totally in love. Chat Icon

Posted 7/1/09 9:51 AM
 

LaPetiteSirène
:)

Member since 8/06

5196 total posts

Name:

Re: How many of you just knew that your first home was the "one"?

The house we bought needed a ton of work but I immediately saw the potential and fell in love with it.

Posted 7/1/09 9:56 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
First time home buyer programs? SweetTooth 7/7/06 12 Home
Besides saving money what is your first step in buying a home? LuckyMe 6/30/06 7 Home
What is the first thing you do when you get home from work? MrsPornStar 6/21/06 70 Families Helping Families ™
Breaks for First Time Home Buyers MrsA 6/2/06 4 Home
I got my first offer on my co-op - home equity question DjPiLL 9/14/05 19 Home
so whats the first thing everyone did when they got the keys to their new home Bebalina 9/12/05 46 Home