Who won debate #2

Forum Opinion Poll
McCain 21 20.39%
Obama 50 48.54%
Tom Brokaw 28 27.18%
Other 4 3.88%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Who won?????

Posted 10/7/08 10:37 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

bella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1871 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

I'd call it a draw....again....although Brokaw had some good lines!

Posted 10/7/08 10:41 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

def Tom!

Posted 10/7/08 10:41 PM
 

Jessica
I'm a mommy :)

Member since 1/06

7322 total posts

Name:
~Jess~

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

def Tom!


hell yeah!

Posted 10/7/08 10:43 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Brokaw hands down.

I do think that McCain did better overall, but not sure how the message will carry for either.

Posted 10/7/08 10:45 PM
 

Jessica
I'm a mommy :)

Member since 1/06

7322 total posts

Name:
~Jess~

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

I would call a candidate a winner at a debate if they swing an undecided voter to their side...

I think they both did an ok job. But I do not think this debate swayed any of the undecided. They both keep saying the same thing.

Posted 10/7/08 10:45 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

BROKEN-JAW!!!! Chat Icon

Posted 10/7/08 10:46 PM
 

MrsRivera
2 under 2...whew!!

Member since 2/07

9876 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

I think Brokaw took this one Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Honestly, though, I was disappointed tonight. I really wanted to hear something different than what we've BEEN hearing from both of them.

Posted 10/7/08 10:50 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Tom Brokaw is holding his own here...maybe he should have runChat Icon

Posted 10/7/08 10:52 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Hells to the YEAH Beyotches...


External Image

Posted 10/7/08 10:52 PM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Hells to the YEAH Beyotches...


External Image



HOT!!!!

Posted 10/7/08 10:53 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Message edited 2011-11-21 22:01:25.293000.

Posted 10/7/08 10:55 PM
 

dandr10199
Grace is growing up too fast!

Member since 10/05

11561 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin

again, Rob's Nana



AWESOME!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Rob's Nana won!

Posted 10/7/08 10:57 PM
 

Lanabean
Yoginis

Member since 11/05

9202 total posts

Name:
Lana

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Here's something I found online:
For Obama, by contrast, the format proved to be an unexpected blessing. His height and his physical fluidity made him a much more commanding stage presence than his rival. In the debate's first half, on the economy and domestic issues, he was "a message machine," in the assessment of one old Bill Clinton hand. "He made contact with the middle class in every answer he could. He had a strategy. He raked McCain on tax cuts for the wealthy, he related to average people, he knew how much gasoline costs, how much teachers make. He was emotionally congruent with the moment. He did contrast without being bilious." (ny magazine)

here's me being random:
Now, did anyone notice how Obama referred to a teacher as "her"...I didn't like that. I know it's probably irrelevant, but I was like: HIM OR HER! I like Obama; I'm just being picky. I get nervous when McCain speaks. The tripping over the words kills me. And he sort of looks like Dr. Evil. Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/08 10:53 AM
 

alisonggg
Cutie

Member since 3/06

4749 total posts

Name:
a

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

I think everyone lost mostly because of the format.... Personally I didn't like how they didn't have time to refute the claims that were made against them. To me it seemed like whoever spoke last could say whatever they wanted, true or not, and it had no chance to be adressed.

Posted 10/8/08 10:58 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

There are a few ways to look at this. In terms of issues that resonate with me and my perspective as someone who has been following the race and knows a good deal of what is true and what is BS based on fact-checking, I would say Obama won because he stands for the same things I do, and because I think he did "win" several points.

However I voted for McCain in the poll. I think if someone is a swing voter and doesn't know all of the facts and doesn't have passions about issues either way but wants to connect with a candidate, I think McCain did a better job of showing his passion. I think Obama showed more clear-headedness and intelligence, but I think people will respond more to McCain's speaking style in that forum. In times of crisis, people are looking for someone to trust, and I think as we saw very clearly in 2000, people often respond better to someone familiar than to someone who operates on a more intellectual level.

ETA: I don't think either candidate had a slam dunk in terms of preventing something clear and convincing to the swing voter who does not already know some of the truths and details about the different tax plans, health plans, foreign policy plans, etc. There was so much flying back and forth, and if you take it all on face value they are both going to A) solve all of our problems while simultaneously B) ruining our country.

Message edited 2008-10-08 11:03:18.033000.

Posted 10/8/08 11:00 AM
 

Phyl
R.I.P. Sweet Mia &hearts;

Member since 5/06

28918 total posts

Name:
The Mystical Azzhorse! ™

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Posted by JenniferEver

There are a few ways to look at this. In terms of issues that resonate with me and my perspective as someone who has been following the race and knows a good deal of what is true and what is BS based on fact-checking, I would say Obama won because he stands for the same things I do, and because I think he did "win" several points.

However I voted for McCain in the poll. I think if someone is a swing voter and doesn't know all of the facts and doesn't have passions about issues either way but wants to connect with a candidate, I think McCain did a better job of showing his passion. I think Obama showed more clear-headedness and intelligence, but I think people will respond more to McCain's speaking style in that forum. In times of crisis, people are looking for someone to trust, and I think as we saw very clearly in 2000, people often respond better to someone familiar than to someone who operates on a more intellectual level.

ETA: I don't think either candidate had a slam dunk in terms of preventing something clear and convincing to the swing voter who does not already know some of the truths and details about the different tax plans, health plans, foreign policy plans, etc. There was so much flying back and forth, and if you take it all on face value they are both going to A) solve all of our problems while simultaneously B) ruining our country.


So are you saying if someone were to vote for McCain they are not intelligent?

Posted 10/8/08 11:04 AM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

It was a draw IMO. Neither one shined, neither flopped. They both got their points across well.

Posted 10/8/08 11:09 AM
 

Phyl
R.I.P. Sweet Mia &hearts;

Member since 5/06

28918 total posts

Name:
The Mystical Azzhorse! ™

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Posted by cjik

It was a draw IMO. Neither one shined, neither flopped. They both got their points across well.


I agree. The whole thing didn't wow me!

Posted 10/8/08 11:10 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Posted by Phyl

Posted by JenniferEver

There are a few ways to look at this. In terms of issues that resonate with me and my perspective as someone who has been following the race and knows a good deal of what is true and what is BS based on fact-checking, I would say Obama won because he stands for the same things I do, and because I think he did "win" several points.

However I voted for McCain in the poll. I think if someone is a swing voter and doesn't know all of the facts and doesn't have passions about issues either way but wants to connect with a candidate, I think McCain did a better job of showing his passion. I think Obama showed more clear-headedness and intelligence, but I think people will respond more to McCain's speaking style in that forum. In times of crisis, people are looking for someone to trust, and I think as we saw very clearly in 2000, people often respond better to someone familiar than to someone who operates on a more intellectual level.

ETA: I don't think either candidate had a slam dunk in terms of preventing something clear and convincing to the swing voter who does not already know some of the truths and details about the different tax plans, health plans, foreign policy plans, etc. There was so much flying back and forth, and if you take it all on face value they are both going to A) solve all of our problems while simultaneously B) ruining our country.


So are you saying if someone were to vote for McCain they are not intelligent?



Yeah that's exactly what I'm saying!

No, I'm saying that the feeling people get from Obama is that he's an intellectual..he's "elitist" he's "aloof", McCain resonates with people on a more gut level. The same is true in a really exagerrated way if you look at Palin vs. Biden at the debate. It doesn't matter whom you agree with, it's clear that they were connecting to the American People on different levels. I'm saying that a large portion of swing voters who are not typically engaged in the political process are more likely to trust and vote for someone who connects with them on that gut level. I don't think people respond well in this climate (for a reason I can't understand) to shows of superior intelligence the way they respond, for example, to the story of a POW or a mom of 5. This isn't to say that McCain is not capable of relating to people on an intellectual level, or that Obama can't connect with real people (after all he's the son of a single mom who went on to be President of the HArvard law Review and a US Senator, and perhaps, President of the United States), but that the way the campaigns are going, and form what I've been hearing on TV and in the news, and what I have observed in debates, Obama/Biden are showing an intellectual viewpoint, and McCain/Palin are connecting with voters on a less intellectual and more emotional ground. McCain and Palin, for better or worse, true or false, come across as more normal, everyday americans. You hear it all the time in the "wasila Main Street" and "aloof elitists" comments on cable news.

Posted 10/8/08 11:11 AM
 

azoodie

Member since 8/05

8377 total posts

Name:
Team SEXY BACK

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

I definitely don't think Tom won at all. Those two were walking all over him Chat Icon

Poor Tom Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/08 11:11 AM
 

Phyl
R.I.P. Sweet Mia &hearts;

Member since 5/06

28918 total posts

Name:
The Mystical Azzhorse! ™

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by Phyl

Posted by JenniferEver

There are a few ways to look at this. In terms of issues that resonate with me and my perspective as someone who has been following the race and knows a good deal of what is true and what is BS based on fact-checking, I would say Obama won because he stands for the same things I do, and because I think he did "win" several points.

However I voted for McCain in the poll. I think if someone is a swing voter and doesn't know all of the facts and doesn't have passions about issues either way but wants to connect with a candidate, I think McCain did a better job of showing his passion. I think Obama showed more clear-headedness and intelligence, but I think people will respond more to McCain's speaking style in that forum. In times of crisis, people are looking for someone to trust, and I think as we saw very clearly in 2000, people often respond better to someone familiar than to someone who operates on a more intellectual level.

ETA: I don't think either candidate had a slam dunk in terms of preventing something clear and convincing to the swing voter who does not already know some of the truths and details about the different tax plans, health plans, foreign policy plans, etc. There was so much flying back and forth, and if you take it all on face value they are both going to A) solve all of our problems while simultaneously B) ruining our country.


So are you saying if someone were to vote for McCain they are not intelligent?



Yeah that's exactly what I'm saying!

No, I'm saying that the feeling people get from Obama is that he's an intellectual..he's "elitist" he's "aloof", McCain resonates with people on a more gut level. The same is true in a really exagerrated way if you look at Palin vs. Biden at the debate. It doesn't matter whom you agree with, it's clear that they were connecting to the American People on different levels. I'm saying that a large portion of swing voters who are not typically engaged in the political process are more likely to trust and vote for someone who connects with them on that gut level. I don't think people respond well in this climate (for a reason I can't understand) to shows of superior intelligence the way they respond, for example, to the story of a POW or a mom of 5. This isn't to say that McCain is not capable of relating to people on an intellectual level, or that Obama can't connect with real people (after all he's the son of a single mom who went on to be President of the HArvard law Review and a US Senator, and perhaps, President of the United States), but that the way the campaigns are going, and form what I've been hearing on TV and in the news, and what I have observed in debates, Obama/Biden are showing an intellectual viewpoint, and McCain/Palin are connecting with voters on a less intellectual and more emotional ground. McCain and Palin, for better or worse, true or false, come across as more normal, everyday americans. You hear it all the time in the "wasila Main Street" and "aloof elitists" comments on cable news.


I know what you are saying. Chat Icon
I just tend to hate the negative views that are always blanketed toward Republicans.

Message edited 2008-10-08 11:35:49.137000.

Posted 10/8/08 11:29 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Phyl won. Thats my final opinion.

Posted 10/8/08 11:31 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Posted by Phyl

I know what you are saying. I just tend to hate the negative views that are always blanketed toward Republicans.Chat Icon



It wasn't intended as negative. I actually voted that McCain won because I think he related to the avg person more. But I also believe that if given time to really explore the issues in more than soundbites, the average person would find voting for Obama to be in her best interest. But clearly that's my opinion.

ETA: I think we can sum it up this way. Obama won on content (IMO< which is going to be my opinion b/c I'm an Obama supporter), and McCain won on style, which may be more important to some voters.

Message edited 2008-10-08 11:34:08.420000.

Posted 10/8/08 11:31 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE

Actually, it is my opinion that it was more like a town meeting than a true debate. they did not go back and forth in discussion - rather they said what is, what they would do and what the other WASN'T doing. That is not debate in my book.

Posted 10/8/08 11:32 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Is the moderator biased? Can that sway the questioning/direction of the debate? justbeachy 10/2/08 41 Families Helping Families ™
Let's get some heated debate going to move this afternoon along-8 teenager who beat up a girl CrankyPants 4/11/08 7 Families Helping Families ™
Thought it deserved it's own thread - Creating "new" breeds debate - very long. Something new for us to fight over TheWhiteRabbit 1/10/08 58 Pets
Pls. help me settle a debate over debt & bankruptcy Mommy2Boys 7/13/07 11 Families Helping Families ™
I'm bringin' it here!!! The Maggie Gyllenhall breastfeeding debate. curliegirl 6/6/07 77 Celebrities & Entertainment
The big debate.. WHAT to watch and what to DVR Jen2999 1/22/07 11 Families Helping Families ™