Re: Ok, so someone has to do it...DEBATE
Posted 10/8/2008 11:29:49 AM by Phyl


Posted by JenniferEver


Posted by Phyl


Posted by JenniferEver

There are a few ways to look at this. In terms of issues that resonate with me and my perspective as someone who has been following the race and knows a good deal of what is true and what is BS based on fact-checking, I would say Obama won because he stands for the same things I do, and because I think he did "win" several points.

However I voted for McCain in the poll. I think if someone is a swing voter and doesn't know all of the facts and doesn't have passions about issues either way but wants to connect with a candidate, I think McCain did a better job of showing his passion. I think Obama showed more clear-headedness and intelligence, but I think people will respond more to McCain's speaking style in that forum. In times of crisis, people are looking for someone to trust, and I think as we saw very clearly in 2000, people often respond better to someone familiar than to someone who operates on a more intellectual level.

ETA: I don't think either candidate had a slam dunk in terms of preventing something clear and convincing to the swing voter who does not already know some of the truths and details about the different tax plans, health plans, foreign policy plans, etc. There was so much flying back and forth, and if you take it all on face value they are both going to A) solve all of our problems while simultaneously B) ruining our country.


So are you saying if someone were to vote for McCain they are not intelligent?



Yeah that's exactly what I'm saying!

No, I'm saying that the feeling people get from Obama is that he's an intellectual..he's "elitist" he's "aloof", McCain resonates with people on a more gut level. The same is true in a really exagerrated way if you look at Palin vs. Biden at the debate. It doesn't matter whom you agree with, it's clear that they were connecting to the American People on different levels. I'm saying that a large portion of swing voters who are not typically engaged in the political process are more likely to trust and vote for someone who connects with them on that gut level. I don't think people respond well in this climate (for a reason I can't understand) to shows of superior intelligence the way they respond, for example, to the story of a POW or a mom of 5. This isn't to say that McCain is not capable of relating to people on an intellectual level, or that Obama can't connect with real people (after all he's the son of a single mom who went on to be President of the HArvard law Review and a US Senator, and perhaps, President of the United States), but that the way the campaigns are going, and form what I've been hearing on TV and in the news, and what I have observed in debates, Obama/Biden are showing an intellectual viewpoint, and McCain/Palin are connecting with voters on a less intellectual and more emotional ground. McCain and Palin, for better or worse, true or false, come across as more normal, everyday americans. You hear it all the time in the "wasila Main Street" and "aloof elitists" comments on cable news.


I know what you are saying. Chat Icon
I just tend to hate the negative views that are always blanketed toward Republicans.
Print Post      Close Window