Do you think AI has gone too far?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes 37 61.67%
No 23 38.33%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

American Idol... Too Far?

Posted By Message

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

American Idol... Too Far?

I've seen it several times so far today on different news shows or talk shows that American Idol might've gone too far in "making fun" of people the past two nights. What do you all think? Are people just looking for another thing to complain about or do you really think they've taken the "judging" a bit too far?

Posted 1/18/07 4:37 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Bebalina
<3

Member since 6/05

2922 total posts

Name:
N

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

yes they are but i will say i was Chat Icon Chat Icon big time when the guy said "simon i dont look like a monkey" Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/07 4:40 PM
 

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

Posted by Bebalina

yes they are but i will say i was Chat Icon Chat Icon big time when the guy said "simon i dont look like a monkey" Chat Icon



I know what you mean Chat Icon . But I definitely think they've gone too far. They're always reminding people that it's a singing contest yet here they are telling this poor boy that he looks like a jungle animal. I was shocked (in between laughing)

Posted 1/18/07 4:41 PM
 

JennChris
life moves fast

Member since 5/05

4225 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

They have agreed to go in front of those judges and be on TV.. they get what they get... If they don't want to take the chance of being insulted, don't go on the show.

Posted 1/18/07 4:43 PM
 

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

Posted by JennChris

They have agreed to go in front of those judges and be on TV.. they get what they get... If they don't want to take the chance of being insulted, don't go on the show.



Do you think some of the people trying out "all there" mentally to know the difference??

Message edited 2007-01-18 16:44:04.427000.

Posted 1/18/07 4:43 PM
 

JennChris
life moves fast

Member since 5/05

4225 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

Posted by CoopersMom01

Posted by JennChris

They have agreed to go in front of those judges and be on TV.. they get what they get... If they don't want to take the chance of being insulted, don't go on the show.



Do you think some of the people trying out "all there" mentally to know the difference??


judging by some of the people on there last night probably not Chat Icon ... but it's not the shows responsibility to be careful of someones feelings

Message edited 2007-01-18 16:45:23.850000.

Posted 1/18/07 4:45 PM
 

trnity44
I hope you stay beautiful baby

Member since 5/05

8356 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

I was just talking about this with some co-workers today. Sometimes I feel sooooo bad for the people that the judges make fun of. I'm sure some of the people know that they are not good and just doing it to make it on tv- but other times, I think there are people who have no idea that they are bad! When the judges make fun of them, and they get upset- I feel soooo bad! I think that sometimes the judges need to be a little nicer.

I have a theory though- I'm thinking that maybe they hire actors to be really really bad and its planned ahead of time that the judges make fun of them in a horrible way!

Posted 1/18/07 4:45 PM
 

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

Posted by JennChris

Posted by CoopersMom01

Posted by JennChris

They have agreed to go in front of those judges and be on TV.. they get what they get... If they don't want to take the chance of being insulted, don't go on the show.



Do you think some of the people trying out "all there" mentally to know the difference??


judging by some of the people on there last night probably not Chat Icon ... but it's not the shows responsibility to be careful of someones feelings



Chat Icon Chat Icon True! I was saying this earlier though. Those people go thru a pre-judging before they get in the room with Paula, Randy, and Simon. Now I know it makes for "good tv", but if I were one of them, I'd be sooooo ****** that those pre-judges were wasting my time with people who clearly have zero talent! Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/07 4:47 PM
 

Jillybean28
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

1018 total posts

Name:
Jill

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

I always start watching the show after they have picked the top 20. I don't find any enjoyment out of watching people's dreams get killed. Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/07 5:32 PM
 

MikesWife
Wanting...........

Member since 1/06

6887 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

If they have a comment to say about your singing, then fine, it IS a singing contest and you can tell them all you want that they have a fat *** chance and to find another dream, but to disrespect someone over their appearance is completely unacceptable IMO.

Posted 1/18/07 5:52 PM
 

partyof6
b nice like u want ur kidz 2

Member since 7/06

7752 total posts

Name:
jeannine

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

I was saying last night...one day they are going to hurt someone by what they say and someone is going to kill themselves.

I felt so bad for those people.

Posted 1/18/07 5:55 PM
 

jenny
L O V E

Member since 4/06

2784 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

I think last night they went too far. I actually felt guilty that I was laughing.

I am sure the people they were making fun of get enough torture in their daily lives and they don't need to see it aired on national television.

Posted 1/18/07 6:06 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

no, these people go in of their own free will. they have seen the show and must know what to expect. i have no sympathy for that.

Posted 1/18/07 6:08 PM
 

june262004
But I love the Snow!

Member since 5/05

15379 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

people set them selves up for it and its funny as he!!

Posted 1/18/07 6:08 PM
 

luvsbob4603
To a healthy 2013

Member since 5/05

21840 total posts

Name:
To a brand new year to a healthier me

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

I agree last night also remember when they put through the girl who was very tall and simon said i quote' you just put through a giraffe' yes i admit i did not watch AI last year,but i said i was going to watch it this year and man was it funny as hell lastnight! people need to realize this is what they are paid to do and yes they will critize you if you do not have the talent they are looking for, is it Wrong? in my opinion yes but it would not be AI if they did not do what they do.

Posted 1/18/07 6:22 PM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

Posted by lastchance1222

I was saying last night...one day they are going to hurt someone by what they say and someone is going to kill themselves.

I felt so bad for those people.



I especially felt bad for the one kid whose co-workers encouraged him to try out. The one who sang unchained melody.

I said to DH, either his coworkers are cruel or completely clueless.

I think AI goes to far in letting some of these people through. I said in another post I really think some of them are mentally ill and the producers need to make sure they are NOT put on TV.

I must admit I still watched both episodes, but I really don't like the show much until it's Hollywood time.

Posted 1/18/07 6:26 PM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

I'm on the fence about this. I mean, if these people THINK that they are good enough, which they obviously aren't, then I think they deserve what they are getting.

They know what this competition is about and I just can't feel bad for these people that put themselves in this position when they are so horrible.

Granted, they shouldn't make fun of the way they look, that's not what it's about, but the singing? Come on, the judges are only saying what everyone else in America is thinking.

Posted 1/18/07 6:40 PM
 

LaPetiteSirène
:)

Member since 8/06

5196 total posts

Name:

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

I felt so bad for those guys who were obviously being made fun of but had no clue. I don't think they were mentally all there and were taken advantage of.

Posted 1/18/07 6:50 PM
 

SweetT
LIF Adult

Member since 4/06

1305 total posts

Name:
Ali

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

I have to say, yes, I felt bad for some of the people but at the same time, those people were pretty rude and almost picking arguments with Simon and Randy. TO THE POINT THEY SHOULD HAVE BEEN ESCORTED OUT. I got scared at one point!

Posted 1/18/07 7:17 PM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: American Idol... Too Far?

Posted by LaPetiteSirène

I felt so bad for those guys who were obviously being made fun of but had no clue. I don't think they were mentally all there and were taken advantage of.



like an above poster says, they sign there lives away. when i was on tv, i had to sign my life away also. not knowing whats going to happen is kinda an odd feeling to you see what happens.

Posted 1/18/07 7:25 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
American Idol tonight.... reggie 3/21/06 15 Families Helping Families ™
Who's getting kicked off American Idol tonight!! mrswask 3/15/06 92 Families Helping Families ™
american Idol... reggie 3/14/06 499 Families Helping Families ™
american idol time reggie 3/9/06 119 Families Helping Families ™
American Idol bklyngirl 3/8/06 84 Families Helping Families ™
american idol reggie 3/7/06 97 Families Helping Families ™