Your Baby can Read Dvds

Posted By Message

nadia
My two Girls=)

Member since 7/07

1421 total posts

Name:

Your Baby can Read Dvds

Does it actually work? Is it worth it to buy it for DD who is 17 months old? Any advice..thanks ladies.

Posted 5/19/09 11:16 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

There were some discussions about this a few weeks ago. There are some books about teaching babies to read and many of them look better to me but I'm not going to use them until his age is a little bit more appropriate. He has enough to learn as he grows!

Posted 5/20/09 12:16 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

IMHO, it teaches them bad habits and/or just sight memory, so they aren't reading, and may possibly slow them down with "real" reading, where they actually comprehend the words. This system seems to teach DC to recognize the picture of a word. Instead of knowing that a picture of a horse is "horse", they "read" the picture of the word. They learn that the 5 letters together make a picture.

Just keep reading books to DC, and let them see the pages when you're reading. You can run your finger under the words as you're reading.

What I think helped a lot with DS is having the Closed Captioning on the TV. He started correcting the captioning very early... Chat Icon Chat Icon

The DVR also helped. "I want to watch Sesame Street!" Sorry, we don't have it recorded. "Yes we do, it's right there!" Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/20/09 7:44 AM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

My Mother has a PhD in reading and I asked her about these DVDs. She said it does teach children sight reading, which is actually the first stage of reading. Children learn to recognize the word by sight and then start to recognize letter groups correlating them to sounds which help them to build upon larger words. She said learning these letter groups is actually a much better way to learn than phonics.

I asked her if I should get the DVDs and she said it couldn't hurt, but reading to my son, using simple books could be just as, if not more effective because it involves the interaction of a parent.

When we were growing up all my mother did was read to us a lot and many of us were reading before kindergarten.

Posted 5/20/09 7:56 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

Posted by GoldenRod

IMHO, it teaches them bad habits and/or just sight memory, so they aren't reading, and may possibly slow them down with "real" reading, where they actually comprehend the words. This system seems to teach DC to recognize the picture of a word. Instead of knowing that a picture of a horse is "horse", they "read" the picture of the word. They learn that the 5 letters together make a picture.

Just keep reading books to DC, and let them see the pages when you're reading. You can run your finger under the words as you're reading.

What I think helped a lot with DS is having the Closed Captioning on the TV. He started correcting the captioning very early... Chat Icon Chat Icon

The DVR also helped. "I want to watch Sesame Street!" Sorry, we don't have it recorded. "Yes we do, it's right there!" Chat Icon Chat Icon



I am a teacher........sight memory is the first stage in the reading process. It's not a bad habit, it's how a child learns to read. When I taught Kindergarten last year to get them "reading" we actually read them the same book EVERY day for a week. By the end of the week the kids are able to "read" the story back to you and not because they learned the words but because they have memorized the story from hearing it so much and because they slowly learn to use the pictures to help them along as they recall and "read" the story to you. Also, it's vital as they learn to read to show them a picture with the word. They are able to make connections and learn and remember new words. That is why we label EVERYTHING in the classroom from the buckets of toys to the chalkboard to the bookcase to the chairs. Emerging readers don't read the words, they read the pictures to tell a story. Slowly they are able to make the connections between the word and the picture that corresponds.

I don't know much about this program to say if it's decent or not however, you are incorrect in saying sight memory of pictures causes bad reading habits. Quite the opposite, it helps to develop readers.
Chat Icon

EDIT - Running your finger under the word as you read is also not the best way to get a child reading. You aren't making any connections for them and a word out of context or with nothing to associate it with means nothing to them.

With young children the BEST thing to do with every book you read them is to take a picture walk first. Let them tell you what they think the story will be about by looking at the cover pictures. Let them help you to prepare to read to them by asking them to go through each page and tell you the story by the pictures. Kids read by pictures first and by words later. If you ever watch a young child read they spend most of their time staring at the pictures as they "read" to you. It's also very important they learn to read and use pictures because as they do begin to read words it's important that they know how to use the pictures to help them to figure out an unknown word if they get stuck as they really are reading.

Message edited 2009-05-20 08:42:43.827000.

Posted 5/20/09 8:31 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

Posted by Hofstra26

I am a teacher........sight memory is the first stage in the reading process. It's not a bad habit, it's how a child learns to read. When I taught Kindergarten last year to get them "reading" we actually read them the same book EVERY day for a week. By the end of the week the kids are able to "read" the story back to you and not because they learned the words but because they have memorized the story from hearing it so much and because they slowly learn to use the pictures to help them along as they recall and "read" the story to you. Also, it's vital as they learn to read to show them a picture with the word. They are able to make connections and learn and remember new words. That is why we label EVERYTHING in the classroom from the buckets of toys to the chalkboard to the bookcase to the chairs. Emerging readers don't read the words, they read the pictures to tell a story. Slowly they are able to make the connections between the word and the picture that corresponds.

I don't know much about this program to say if it's decent or not however, you are incorrect in saying sight memory of pictures causes bad reading habits. Quite the opposite, it helps to develop readers.
Chat Icon

EDIT - Running your finger under the word as you read is also not the best way to get a child reading. You aren't making any connections for them and a word out of context or with nothing to associate it with means nothing to them.

With young children the BEST thing to do with every book you read them is to take a picture walk first. Let them tell you what they think the story will be about by looking at the cover pictures. Let them help you to prepare to read to them by asking them to go through each page and tell you the story by the pictures. Kids read by pictures first and by words later. If you ever watch a young child read they spend most of their time staring at the pictures as they "read" to you. It's also very important they learn to read and use pictures because as they do begin to read words it's important that they know how to use the pictures to help them to figure out an unknown word if they get stuck as they really are reading.



I'm only going by my DS. I guess he is different than every other child. For us, DS never sight-read. We never read the same story repeatedly. He never liked that. He reads a different book every day, since we started reading. He comprehended words much earlier than other DC his age. He is currently 6yo, and reading at roughly a 6th grade level, maybe higher.

I guess I'm saying that every child is different, and sight reading isn't what we use, and it isn't what DS used. I used the methods that I described above, and in DS's particular case, he is at a higher reading level than his classmates who used more traditional methods (sight reading). Correlation doesn't make causation, so it's very possible that DS is just unique, and the typical methods work for the typical child. For *MY* DS, though, I *am* correct. Chat Icon

Reading to your child every day is never a bad thing, no matter what methods you prefer.... Chat Icon

Posted 5/20/09 8:53 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

Posted by GoldenRod


Reading to your child every day is never a bad thing, no matter what methods you prefer.... Chat Icon



This is true!! You can never go wrong reading to your child every day. Chat Icon

Posted 5/20/09 8:59 AM
 

nadia
My two Girls=)

Member since 7/07

1421 total posts

Name:

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by GoldenRod


Reading to your child every day is never a bad thing, no matter what methods you prefer.... Chat Icon



This is true!! You can never go wrong reading to your child every day. Chat Icon


I do read to her every night, the problem is that she tries to turn the pages before I'm finish actually reading the page or she just doesn't seem to be paying attention. She tries to get down from the bed or couch and wants to start walking around. Any recommendations.

Posted 5/20/09 9:58 AM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

Posted by nadia

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by GoldenRod


Reading to your child every day is never a bad thing, no matter what methods you prefer.... Chat Icon



This is true!! You can never go wrong reading to your child every day. Chat Icon


I do read to her every night, the problem is that she tries to turn the pages before I'm finish actually reading the page or she just doesn't seem to be paying attention. She tries to get down from the bed or couch and wants to start walking around. Any recommendations.



I think this is totally normal. She will grow out of it. I continue to read the story when Ale would do this. Now she sits quietly. Don't force DD to sit with you -- it is supposed to be enjoyable so you don't want to make it stressful. Eventually she'll get it.

Posted 5/20/09 10:07 AM
 

Tine73

Member since 3/06

22093 total posts

Name:
*********

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

My Dad bought this program for DD. I haven't watched the DVD's yet, we have only read the books and she loves them.

Posted 5/20/09 10:34 AM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds

um bump

Posted 6/26/09 11:08 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
My baby got hurt and my boss kinda made me feel guilty for calling in sick. Am I wrong? Kinda long. munchkinbugs 5/19/09 48 Parenting
good friend just had a baby and I want to do something for her and her DH jes81276 5/19/09 1 Parenting
How do you dress a 2month old boy for a wedding? Where can you get a suit for a baby? Bridex100 5/19/09 10 Parenting
How often should i feel the baby move? UPDATED MrsBurtch525 5/19/09 11 Pregnancy
Anyone buy "Your Baby Can Read"? dvds JenBenMen 1/3/09 6 Parenting
Want to get ready to read to the baby (belly) Ang-Rich 12/7/06 15 Pregnancy