Re: Your Baby can Read Dvds
Posted 5/20/2009 8:31:53 AM by Hofstra26


Posted by GoldenRod

IMHO, it teaches them bad habits and/or just sight memory, so they aren't reading, and may possibly slow them down with "real" reading, where they actually comprehend the words. This system seems to teach DC to recognize the picture of a word. Instead of knowing that a picture of a horse is "horse", they "read" the picture of the word. They learn that the 5 letters together make a picture.

Just keep reading books to DC, and let them see the pages when you're reading. You can run your finger under the words as you're reading.

What I think helped a lot with DS is having the Closed Captioning on the TV. He started correcting the captioning very early... Chat Icon Chat Icon

The DVR also helped. "I want to watch Sesame Street!" Sorry, we don't have it recorded. "Yes we do, it's right there!" Chat Icon Chat Icon



I am a teacher........sight memory is the first stage in the reading process. It's not a bad habit, it's how a child learns to read. When I taught Kindergarten last year to get them "reading" we actually read them the same book EVERY day for a week. By the end of the week the kids are able to "read" the story back to you and not because they learned the words but because they have memorized the story from hearing it so much and because they slowly learn to use the pictures to help them along as they recall and "read" the story to you. Also, it's vital as they learn to read to show them a picture with the word. They are able to make connections and learn and remember new words. That is why we label EVERYTHING in the classroom from the buckets of toys to the chalkboard to the bookcase to the chairs. Emerging readers don't read the words, they read the pictures to tell a story. Slowly they are able to make the connections between the word and the picture that corresponds.

I don't know much about this program to say if it's decent or not however, you are incorrect in saying sight memory of pictures causes bad reading habits. Quite the opposite, it helps to develop readers.
Chat Icon

EDIT - Running your finger under the word as you read is also not the best way to get a child reading. You aren't making any connections for them and a word out of context or with nothing to associate it with means nothing to them.

With young children the BEST thing to do with every book you read them is to take a picture walk first. Let them tell you what they think the story will be about by looking at the cover pictures. Let them help you to prepare to read to them by asking them to go through each page and tell you the story by the pictures. Kids read by pictures first and by words later. If you ever watch a young child read they spend most of their time staring at the pictures as they "read" to you. It's also very important they learn to read and use pictures because as they do begin to read words it's important that they know how to use the pictures to help them to figure out an unknown word if they get stuck as they really are reading.
Print Post      Close Window