YES...another Oprah Q
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
YES...another Oprah Q So i am watching Oprah.. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:26 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q I don't know if I agree. I was watching the show on and off today. I do like the idea of losing your license/permit if you drop out. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q I don't think that is a good idea. I think the idea of criminalizing dropping out is not going to solve the problem. Honestly, I have been in schools (did an internship in one) that I would have been tempted to drop out of due to not feeling safe and the overwhelming presence of gangs and drugs. Message edited 2006-04-11 19:36:12.443000. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q I am not watching the show - but I don't think it is a good idea. What about the families that have certain circumstances where the child might need to work. Maybe because they had a death in the family or someone in the family has a disability. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by mommy2Alex I don't know if I agree. I was watching the show on and off today. I do like the idea of losing your license/permit if you drop out. It was sad how many kids are dropping out. Scary too! The 1 HS had 1 in 3 kids dropping out see THAT i do not agree with... If they are allowed to drop out but can't have a car or a work permit... WHAT THE HELL are they going to do all day? Sit around... If my kid was allowed to drop out....TO WORK HIS/HER ARSE would go! |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Hmmm, I'm going to have to think about this one. It's such a huge problem and something has to be done however I don't think making it illegal is going to properly address the issue. Perhaps more time should be spent looking into why these kids are dropping out and work with them more to keep them in school. Not sure if I'm making sense. What I'm trying to say is, forcing a kid to stay in school so they're not breaking the law is not going to do them any good, they won't learn and grow that way..addressing the underlying issues is the way to go. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Omg, are you all watching now. Teenagers in other countries know more American history than our teenagers. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by Jessica Omg, are you all watching now. Teenagers in other countries know more American history than our teenagers. yup watching |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by Redhead Posted by mommy2Alex I don't know if I agree. I was watching the show on and off today. I do like the idea of losing your license/permit if you drop out. It was sad how many kids are dropping out. Scary too! The 1 HS had 1 in 3 kids dropping out see THAT i do not agree with... If they are allowed to drop out but can't have a car or a work permit... WHAT THE HELL are they going to do all day? Sit around... If my kid was allowed to drop out....TO WORK HIS/HER ARSE would go! I tend to feel the same way. I'm not watching the show though so I don't have the whole picture. If my kid wanted to drop out of school just becaue they're lazy, they'd be in for a rude awakening. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by Redhead Posted by mommy2Alex I don't know if I agree. I was watching the show on and off today. I do like the idea of losing your license/permit if you drop out. It was sad how many kids are dropping out. Scary too! The 1 HS had 1 in 3 kids dropping out see THAT i do not agree with... If they are allowed to drop out but can't have a car or a work permit... WHAT THE HELL are they going to do all day? Sit around... If my kid was allowed to drop out....TO WORK HIS/HER ARSE would go! I think that's the point-- the fact that they cannot work or drive, takes away their ability to sustain a life without an education. It will force a kid to say--well, I guess I'll just finish HS, then I'll work full time at wherever-- the epidemic that this will cause is that the corporate work force of the future will be under-educated, or non-existent, threatening the US's strength and power. I agree that is is harsh-- but, I would be curious to see how it increases the graduation rate in Indiana. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by randella Posted by Redhead Posted by mommy2Alex I don't know if I agree. I was watching the show on and off today. I do like the idea of losing your license/permit if you drop out. It was sad how many kids are dropping out. Scary too! The 1 HS had 1 in 3 kids dropping out see THAT i do not agree with... If they are allowed to drop out but can't have a car or a work permit... WHAT THE HELL are they going to do all day? Sit around... If my kid was allowed to drop out....TO WORK HIS/HER ARSE would go! I think that's the point-- the fact that they cannot work or drive, takes away their ability to sustain a life without an education. It will force a kid to say--well, I guess I'll just finish HS, then I'll work full time at wherever-- the epidemic that this will cause is that the corporate work force of the future will be under-educated, or non-existent, threatening the US's strength and power. I agree that is is harsh-- but, I would be curious to see how it increases the graduation rate in Indiana. But they can sustain life....Via parent. Yes a socal life might be hard... but being a grub isn't exactly unappealing to some.... IMO it makes it easier for them to just be bums |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by Redhead But they can sustain life....Via parent. Yes a socal life might be hard... but being a grub isn't exactly unappealing to some.... IMO it makes it easier for them to just be bums but they won't be able to drive-- that certainly takes away a lot of a teenager's freedom. It's a harsh punishment from the government-- and this is only for kids over 16-- if you are under 16 it is illegal to drop out of HS anyway. I bet that kids will either be deterred from dropping out, or some may head back to school in order to get these freedoms back. Either way-- it is really frightening how far the US has slipped in education. The thing that I find strange is that I feel that parents really put more pressure on kids to succeeed, take on a lot and really prep for college-- perhaps this is not all over- but I feel like kids today are taking on more than they ever have. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q This is a tough one. I think some kids have good reason to drop out. There was a high school near where we lived in Brooklyn that didn't have enough textbooks, had a crappy, crappy building, fights all the time, stabbings, etc. I could see why a kid wouldn't want to be there. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 7:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by MsG This is a tough one. I think some kids have good reason to drop out. There was a high school near where we lived in Brooklyn that didn't have enough textbooks, had a crappy, crappy building, fights all the time, stabbings, etc. I could see why a kid wouldn't want to be there. That's a whole other problem! The condition of some of the schools they showed was really horrific. More money clearly needs to go into education-- |
|
Posted 4/11/06 8:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by randella Posted by MsG This is a tough one. I think some kids have good reason to drop out. There was a high school near where we lived in Brooklyn that didn't have enough textbooks, had a crappy, crappy building, fights all the time, stabbings, etc. I could see why a kid wouldn't want to be there. That's a whole other problem! The condition of some of the schools they showed was really horrific. More money clearly needs to go into education-- true.... but i still think that a diploma is worth staying... |
|
Posted 4/11/06 8:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q First of all, I know Oprah means well, but I think she has her nose in somethign she does not fully understand. And, not for nothing, I think a big problem is stemming from home these days. Yes we have problems with our public schools, but kids dropping out is somethign that stems from home and the fact that there is obviously not a strong enough influence from home to keep them in school. |
|
Posted 4/11/06 8:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q That was some show. Very scary! |
|
Posted 4/11/06 9:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q I didn't see it, but I am very disturbed by drop out rates. And you can't blame one party- parents, the kid and the school all have a role. In NYC the drop out rate is ridiculous, and a lot of it has to do with a lack of support for kids who struggle. It's also very un-pc to refer city kids for special ed services, and as a result we have lots of kids in regular classes who aren't getting the support they need, whether it be for academic or emotional issues. |
|
Posted 4/12/06 7:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by Redhead Posted by Jessica Omg, are you all watching now. Teenagers in other countries know more American history than our teenagers. yup watching pretty sad I dont think it should be illegal. If they want to be a drop out and have nO LIFE that is their choice. I have many students who want to drop out and they have NO IDEA what their life will be in store for them. They think that they can make a living working in a shop for $10 an hour. Boy will that be a big slap in the face. Let them figure out the hard way. Im so tired of trying to get kids to do the right thing in HS. They DO NOT want to hear it. These kids these days, have a different frame of thinking
|
|
Posted 4/12/06 8:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by prncssrachel First of all, I know Oprah means well, but I think she has her nose in somethign she does not fully understand. And, not for nothing, I think a big problem is stemming from home these days. Yes we have problems with our public schools, but kids dropping out is somethign that stems from home and the fact that there is obviously not a strong enough influence from home to keep them in school. Very well said. My mom would have kicked my A$$ out of the house if I wanted to quit school. Her theory if I was big enough to make those types of decisions then I was big enough to live on my own and support myself. |
|
Posted 4/12/06 8:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q I agree. Illinois just passed a tough law saying you will lose your license and work permit if you are under 18 - unless it is for mitigating circumstances, illness etc. I saw part of Oprah's show yesterday and I have to agree with her and the Gates - this is a crisis. We are severely losing ground with other countries and at this rate may not remain the world power we are. The video she showed that had students from other countries who knew more about US history then our students did, was sooo sad. Other countries are worlds ahead of us in math, science, engineering, R&D already. For the most part, their students work harder then ours do and prioritize school more. |
|
Posted 4/12/06 9:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by prncssrachel First of all, I know Oprah means well, but I think she has her nose in somethign she does not fully understand. And, not for nothing, I think a big problem is stemming from home these days. Yes we have problems with our public schools, but kids dropping out is somethign that stems from home and the fact that there is obviously not a strong enough influence from home to keep them in school. so well said!!! I agree 10000%!! Just spend a week in a public school and you can tell right away which parent's value education and which don't. It becomes clear very quickly!! |
|
Posted 4/12/06 10:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q I saw this last night and was talking to DH about it on the train this morning. It's all very disturbing. I think that the blame falls three ways - equally. |
|
Posted 4/12/06 10:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Ang...I have to disagree in a few senses. |
|
Posted 4/12/06 10:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: YES...another Oprah Q Posted by Diane Ang...I have to disagree in a few senses. Yes, our kids are falling apart, but with this new "No Child Left Behind", we are not getting the FUNDING to provie better services for these children. I am a HS teacher, and kids these days just DONT CARE, and tell me to go F my self and other teachers, they have NO respect for teachers, other students, or themselves, so how am I supposed to teach a student who has such a poor attitude and just doenst care. I think a lot has to do with the PARENTS. Im in a district that not many parents have a good education, so the quality of a good education is not importanat to theri child, which is pretty sad. Thanks for posting this - I really would like to understand this issue so much more. I was on the fence about #3 because I think teachers get too much of the blame - and unfairly. I agree that parents have to step up. Teachers aren't babysitters and the education should not stop at school. Plus I agree - the disrespect that kids show teachers is disgusting. I really want to learn from this. |
|
Posted 4/12/06 10:28 AM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Night by Elie Weisel: Does anyone know when Oprah Goes to Auschwitz will air? | AtomicMom | 2/27/06 | 0 | StoryBoard |
| Ewww, Oprah, Americans and debt! | MissJones | 2/24/06 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Oprah | danielleandscott | 2/23/06 | 35 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Anyone watch Oprah today? | Shanti | 2/21/06 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Anyone watching Oprah??? | mommy2Alex | 2/17/06 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Oprah | luvsbob4603 | 2/16/06 | 3 | Families Helping Families ™ |














